Government | Totality of Evidence https://totalityofevidence.com COVID-19 pandemic timeline and research resource links Thu, 06 Mar 2025 08:25:24 +0000 en-AU hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.2 https://totalityofevidence.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/TE-favicon-150x150.png Government | Totality of Evidence https://totalityofevidence.com 32 32 Dr Aaron Kheriaty https://totalityofevidence.com/dr-aaron-kheriaty/ Thu, 06 Feb 2025 06:56:28 +0000 https://totalityofevidence.com/?p=30966 Dr Aaron Kheriaty earned his MD degree from Georgetown University, and completed residency training in psychiatry at the University of California Irvine. He was a Professor of Psychiatry in the School of Medicine at the University of California Irvine and…

The post Dr Aaron Kheriaty first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
Dr Aaron Kheriaty earned his MD degree from Georgetown University, and completed residency training in psychiatry at the University of California Irvine. He was a Professor of Psychiatry in the School of Medicine at the University of California Irvine and the Director of the Medical Ethics Program at UCI Health before he was fired in December 2021, following his challenging of their vaccine mandates on the grounds of natural immunity and informed consent. – [BIO]

On November 1, 2022 Dr Aaron Kheriaty released his book The New Abnormal: The Rise of the Biomedical Security State which “which details how the COVID pandemic paved the way for the implementation of a totalitarian one world government, where human rights and freedoms will no longer exist.” Warning: “The coronavirus pandemic conferred enormous power on certain government officials. They have no intention of giving it up.”

The New Abnormal: The Rise of the Biomedical Security State
The New Abnormal: The Rise of the Biomedical Security State by Aaron Kheriaty – BOOK, AMAZON

Kheriaty became chief of medical ethics at the Unity Project and fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center.

Dr. Aaron Kheriaty Official:

  • Aaron Kheriaty website – HERE,
    • Published Articles – HERE
    • Interviews – HERE
  • Twitter/ X – HERE
  • Human Flourishing Substack – HERE
  • Senior Brownstone Institute Counselor – ARTICLES

I began this page more than a year ago, it has been in my drafts. I will catalogue below my bookmarks for Dr Kheriaty. This will be but a snapshot of interviews and articles by another of the ethical freedom warrior doctors and scientists that were raised to “awakened” public awareness due to the COVID-19 pandemic measures.

Links in reverse chronological order

Content below will be continuously added to

2025

February 5, 2025 – Brownstone Institute: Court Filings Reveal More Government Lies about Censorship by Aaron Kheriaty – READ, source The Federalist by Joy Pullmann – READ

  • Missouri [v Biden] plaintiffs include the states of Missouri and Louisiana, Health Freedom Louisiana co-director Jill Hines and Gateway Pundit founder Jim Hoft, and internationally recognized research scientists and medical doctors Martin Kulldorff, Aaron Kheriaty, and Jay Bhattacharya, a Stanford University medical professor who is now President Trump’s nominee to lead the National Institutes of Health.”
  • “Pullman goes on to explain how the government’s response is characteristic of repeated patterns meant to evade legal responsibility and cover up unconstitutional abuses of government power:..”
  • “The pattern goes beyond just blocking access to information and includes efforts to vilify any critics of the regime. CISA, a little-known agency that I have written about several times here in relation to our case, coordinated these efforts to silence and slander anyone who opposed the government’s actions. Furthermore, not only was the government censoring its critics, but it was also engaged in age-old propaganda techniques to “flood the zone” of public discussion with lies and falsehoods (propaganda is always the flip side of censorship):…”
  • “As I have described previously, in an attempt to hide its fingerprints the government suborned quasi-private entities, like the Stanford Internet Observatory, to conduct its censorship work. I describe them as “quasi-private” (i.e., really public) because they are government-organized, government-funded through grants, and staffed by former government officials….”
  • The truth about government censorship continues to emerge for those willing to examine the evidence. Regardless of the final legal outcome in our case, we are succeeding through the discovery process in shedding much-needed light on the government’s operations. Armed with this information, Americans can decide whether this is the kind of regime they want to live under.”

2024

December 27, 2024 – Human Flourishing Substack: Government Censorship on Covid Began Before Lockdowns – New documents from America First Legal demonstrate that CISA was censoring covid narratives even earlier than previously thought – READ

December 19, 2024 – America First Legal: America First Legal’s Lawsuit Against CISA Further Exposes Deep State Reliance on the Censorship Industrial Complex to Monitor Social Media Narratives on COVID-19 – READ, CREDIT

October 4, 2024 – Brownstone Institute: Homeschooling Gave Medicine a Blueprint by Aaron Kheriaty – READ

  • “… our medical institutions—from hospitals and licensing boards to medical schools and professional societies—are failing us. The complex of problems in many of these institutions makes reform or repair, in the short term at least, impractical and perhaps impossible. Too many vested financial or other interests will not readily relinquish their territory….
  • Still, I want to suggest here a rough blueprint for a way forward….We need to plant seeds that might not fully germinate in our lifetimes, thinking in 50- to 100-year increments….In 1973, just over fifty years ago, there were 13,000 homeschoolers; today there are 5 million.” [How many of these are driven by forced public “medical” intervention?]

September 12, 2024 – Human Flourishing Substack: Why We Are Sick– How monopolized, industrialized, managerialist medicine is harming us and how we can remedy our ills. – READ

  • “Whether the influence of big pharma that profits from sickness, compromised public health agencies controlled by the very industries they are supposed to regulate, a biosecurity state that tends to jump from one declared health emergency to the next, medicine is now in danger of causing more sickness than it heals.” [Has it ever healed, or does it push diagnoses into remission and/or simply quash/mask symptoms, and not address the underlying cause? ]

July 29, 2024 – Brownstone Institute: Missouri v. Biden/Kennedy v. Biden Update – by Aaron Kheriaty – READ, Substack – READ

  • “…back in 2023 the District Court combined (enjoined) our Missouri v. Biden case against government censorship with a similar case, Kennedy v. Biden, filed in the same court by plaintiffs Robert F. Kennedy, Jr, Children’s Health Defense (Kennedy’s nonprofit advocacy group), and Connie Sampognaro. This means Kennedy and his co-plaintiffs can utilize all our case’s documents on discovery; and for our purposes, he is considered, as it were, a co-plaintiff.
  • …In documents we’ve obtained on discovery, Kennedy was named several times, and specifically identified posts of his were targeted for censorship by government officials. If he does not have standing to bring the case then nobody does, and government censorship can proceed without any citizens having any legal recourse.”

February 9, 2024 – America First Legal: America First Legal Files Brief at Supreme Court on Behalf of Representative Jim Jordan and 44 Members of Congress About the Federal Government’s Unconstitutional Censorship of Free Speech on Social Media – READ

  • Murthy v. Missouri – is ” the landmark case regarding the government’s unconstitutional censorship of free speech on social media.”
  • “During initial discovery in Missouri v. Biden, the plaintiffs note on Dec. 23, Twitter claimed it had communicated with just 11 federal officials about online censorship efforts. Yet after tycoon Elon Musk bought Twitter months later, the company then revised that number upward to 84 federal officials.” – REF

2023

October 25, 2023 – The Kennedy Beacon Podcast w/ John Leake Episode 01: Doctor Aaron Kheriaty Talks Censorship & Supreme Court Lawsuit – WATCH

  • John Leake talks with Aaron Kheriaty, MD about the landmark Missouri vs. Biden case.

October 25, 2023 – Substack: Supreme Court Agrees to Hear Missouri v. Biden – READ, Courageous Discourse – CREDIT

  • Dr. Aaron Kheriaty and his co-plaintiffs are leading us out of censorship darkness. “Bravo to Dr. Aaron Kheriaty and his fellow plaintiffs for taking their landmark free speech case against the President known as “Joe Biden” to the U.S. Supreme Court. ” –REF
  • The plaintiffs are: The State of Missouri, the State of Louisiana, Dr. Aaron Kheriaty, Dr. Martin Kulldorff, Jim Hoft, Dr. Jayanta Bhattacharya, and Jill Hines.

October 2, 2023 – The Sun New York: Meet the Physician Who Stepped Forward To Tackle the Leviathan of Government Censorship – The scope and breadth of the Biden administration’s anti-‘disinformation’ campaign is unlike anything that we’ve seen in the past, Aaron Kheriaty suggests – READ

June 1, 2023 – Brownstone Institute: The Deplatforming of the “Disinformation Dozen”: More Coverage [Part 4] by Tracy Beanz – READ, Substack – READ

May 29, 2023 – Brownstone Institute: The Struggle for Free Speech: More Reporting on Missouri v. Biden from Tracy Beanz – by Aaron Kheriaty – READ

  • “Literally 3 days after Biden took office [January 21, 2021], the government’s censorship operation was flying. The White House immediately launched a pressure campaign on social media platforms to suppress supposed “COVID misinformation.””
  • The Surgeon General [Dr Vivek Murthy] launched his signature “disinformation” initiative at a Virality Project event at the Stanford Internet Observatory.
  • Biden himself publicly pressured platforms on July 16, 2021

May 28, 2023 – Brownstone Institute: The Censors are Exposed: Major Update to Missouri v. Biden from Tracy Beanz – by Aaron Kheriaty – READ

  • May 24, 2023 – Tracy Beanz – Missouri v. Biden – “a virtual handbook to government censorship based on what limited discovery has been provided so far.” – Mega THREAD

May 16, 2023 – Ask Dr. Drew: Multiple Assassination Attempts Against Anti-WHO Politicians As Pandemic Treaty Deadline Approaches w/ Dr. Meryl Nass & Dr. Aaron Kheriaty – WATCH

March 30, 2023 – Aaron responds to Tweet: “The U.S. Senate has just voted 68-23 to end the COVID-19 “national emergency” that has been in place since 2020.” – “Better late than never” – TWEET

March 21, 2023 – Aaron Kheriaty on Twitter: “BREAKING: Important update in our Missouri v. Biden case. The judge denied government defendants’ motion to dismiss the case”… – TWEET, THREAD, The CASE, SUBSTACK

February 5, 2023 – Dr Mercola: The New Abnormal: The Rise of the Biomedical Security State- Interview with Dr. Aaron Kheriaty – WATCH, LISTEN

January 27, 2023 – The Hill: Federal judge blocks California misinformation law – READ

  • “A federal judge has temporarily blocked a California law intended to prevent doctors from spreading COVID-19 misinformation or disinformation to patients, finding that it is “unconstitutionally vague.” “
  • A group of five doctors and two nonprofit advocacy groups sued in November after California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) signed Assembly Bill 2098 into law the month before.
    • California-based doctors — Aaron Kheriaty Tracy Hoeg, Ram Duriseti, Pete Mazolewski and Azadeh Khatibi filed a lawsuit against Newsom and other officials, including the president and members of the Medical Board of California to block Newson’s California Assembly Bill 2098. – REF

January 14, 2023 – UncoverDC: The 6 Most Shocking Recent Revelations of Government Censorship by Tracy Beanz – in-depth coverage of the landmark Missouri v. Biden censorship case… READ, CREDIT

  • 1. CISA considers your thoughts “Cognitive Infrastructure”
  • 2. Rob Flaherty coerced Facebook to ban and censor the vaccine injured, despite acknowledging their posts were true and didn’t break the Terms of Service.
    • “Rob Flaherty is the White House Director of Digital Strategy and a senior advisor to President Joe Biden.”
  • 3. Flaherty wanted Facebook to take more action in censoring the encrypted chat program “WhatsApp”
  • 4. Flaherty wanted to know what Facebook was doing to censor vaccine claims that were “dubious” but not false
  • 5. Joe Biden was inadvertently swept up in the censorship algorithm the White House forced Instagram to implement
  • 6. The office of First Lady Jill Biden was also involved in censoring Americans on Twitter

January 3, 2023 – American Though Leaders – Technocratic Medicine – Dr Aaron Kheriaty: Self-Spreading Vaccines, Transhumanist Ideology, and Government Gag Orders–The New Technocracy Threatening Hippocratic Medicine and the Nuremberg Code – WATCH, EXCERPT

  • Chief Nerd: Dr. Aaron Kheriaty Explains the Complicated History of the Nuremberg Code “this legal concept of Crimes Against Humanity” – EXCERPT
  • For 12 years the Nazi requiem governed under Article 48 of the Weimar constitution which “allowed the German president to declare a state of emergency in Germany in times of national danger and to rule as a dictator for short periods of time. After the Reichstag Fire of 1933, Hitler would rely upon the precedent of Article 48 to pass the Enabling Act, which gave him truly unlimited dictatorial powers” – WATCH

2022

December 15, 2022 – Compact Magazine: Dr. Fauci’s Amnesia by Aaron Kheriaty – READ

  • Last week, The New York Times published a guest essay in praise of Dr. Anthony Fauci, written by Dr. Anthony Fauci! titled Anthony Fauci: A Message to the Next Generation of Scientists – ARCHIVE

December 9, 2022 – CHD | Friday Roundtable: The New Abnormal With Aaron Kheriaty, M.D. – WATCH

November 30, 2022 – Brownstone Institute: The Evil of Coerced Medicine – READ

  • “…I argued publicly in the pages of the Wall Street Journal in June 2021 that university vaccine mandates violated foundational principles of medical ethics, including the principle of informed consent….Although the minimal conditions for justifying vaccine mandates were never close to being met, institutions embraced these misguided policies with little meaningful public discussion and no debate.”

November 19, 2022 – Brownstone Institute: Technocracy and Totalitarianism by Aaron Kheriaty – READ, CREDIT

  • Scientism is the philosophical claim—which cannot be proven scientifically—that science is the only valid form of knowledge. Anyone who begins a sentence with the phrase, “Science says . . . ” is likely in the grip of scientism.”

November 1, 2022 – “One year ago today, @UCIrvineSOM placed me on unpaid suspension after I challenged the UC vaccine mandate in federal court. They fired me the following month. Today I published this book.” – TWEET

  • “In the space of a few weeks in early 2020, Americans witnessed the imposition of previously unimagined social controls by the biomedical security state—the unelected technocrats who suddenly enjoyed nearly absolute power to incarcerate, isolate, and medicate the entire population.”
The New Abnormal: The Rise of the Biomedical Security State
The New Abnormal: The Rise of the Biomedical Security State
by Aaron Kheriaty – BOOK, AMAZON

October 29, 2022 – Bannons War Room: Dr Aaron Kheriaty On The Biomedical Security State Pushed By Governments Following The Pandemic – EXCERPT

October 28, 2022 – Brownstone Institute: Kheriaty vs. University of California – READ,

  • The Daily Wire: This Doctor Witnessed The Worst Of COVID And Still Refused The Jab. So UC Irvine Fired Him. – “I was given no opportunity to contact my patients, students, residents, or colleagues and let them know I would suddenly disappear.” – READ
  • “Shortly after I published the Wall Street Journal piece arguing that university vaccine mandates were unethical, the University of California, my employer, promulgated its vaccine mandate.

October 27, 2022 – Washington Times: Vaccine propaganda and coercion – Institutions embraced these misguided policies with little public discussion and no debate – by Dr Aaron Kheriaty – READ, CREDIT

October 22, 2022 – Brownstone Institute: The Quarantine of Healthy Populations by Aaron Kheriaty – READ

  • Lockdowns were never part of conventional public health measures
  • The full significance of what transpired in 2020 may have escaped our attention.”

October 19, 2022 – Daily Wire: This Doctor Witnessed The Worst Of COVID And Still Refused The Jab. So UC Irvine Fired Him. – ARCHIVE

September 22, 2022 – Brownstone Institute: Uncovering the Army of Federal Censors by Aaron Kheriaty – READ

  • …the executive branch of the federal government has been colluding with social media to censor any content on social media platforms — Twitter, YouTube (owned by Google), and LinkedIn (owned by Microsoft), Facebook and Instagram (both owned by Meta) — any content that questions, challenges, or contradicts the government’s covid policies.”

September 1, 2022 – New Civil Liberties Alliance | Press Release: NCLA Suit Uncovers Army of Federal Bureaucrats Coercing Social-Media Companies to Censor Speech – ARCHIVE

  • “The New Civil Liberties Alliance, the Attorney General of Missouri, and the Attorney General of Louisiana, have filed a lawsuit that blows the lid off a sprawling federal censorship regime that will shock the conscience of Americans. The joint statement on discovery disputes in the lawsuit, State of Missouri ex rel. Schmitt, et al. v. Joseph R. Biden, Jr., et al., reveals scores of federal officials across at least eleven federal agencies have secretly communicated with social-media platforms to censor and suppress private speech federal officials disfavor. This unlawful enterprise has been wildly successful.”

August 15, 2022 – Human Flourishing Substack: Checkmate – READ

  • The CDC finally comes around to acknowledge what I’ve been saying for a year about natural immunity. The University of California’s unjust vaccine mandate no longer has any legal ground to stand on.

June 27, 2022 – California Senate Committee on Business, Professions, and Economic Development – Dr. Aaron Kheriaty’s testimony in opposition to Assembly Bill 2098 – WATCH, READ, CREDIT,

  • “The Senate gave our side a total of 3 minutes to testify, which [Attorney Laura Powell ] and I had to share between us. Democracy!” – the Bill passed!
  • California Plotting to Punish Medical Dissent – Bill 2098 “sponsored by Senator Pan—who has been in Pharma’s back pocket for years and the source of much legislative health policy mischief in my home state —would give the medical board the authority to punish any physicians who challenge the safety and efficacy of covid vaccines.”  – READ

May 11, 2022 – American Though Leaders: Dr. Aaron Kheriaty on the Rise of the Biomedical Security State: The Merger of Public Health, Surveillance Tech, and Policing Power – WATCH, transcript ARCHIVE

  • Discussed is the “egregious violations of medical ethics” Dr Kheriaty has seen over the course of the pandemic and the deadly consequences of these policies. Among working-age Americans, there’s been an unprecedented 40 percent rise in all-cause mortality—most of which is not due to COVID-19.

This welding of public health with digital technologies of surveillance and control and the police powers of the state allows for intrusions on our privacy, on our bodily autonomy that are unprecedented in history.

…I think this biomedical security state apparatus that has been put in place during the pandemic will remain in place and will be redeployed for other purposes…

Dr Aaron Kheriaty

May 5, 2022 – US District Courts: Missouri v. Biden (3:22-cv-01213) was filed in District Court, W.D. Louisiana – – DOCUMENTS, Court Listener – READ

  • “The complaint alleged that the US Government was not only threatening and coercing social media companies to censor Americans on social media, but they were also working with social media companies to accomplish that goal.” – REF
  • Kheriaty is a plaintiff in the Missouri v. Biden case, filed by the attorneys general of Missouri and Louisiana, in which they argue that the Biden administration is colluding with Big Tech to illegally censor Americans. Dr. Jay Bhattacharya and Martin Kulldorff, Ph.D., — two authors of the Great Barrington Declaration, an early critique of lockdowns and school closures — have also joined the case. – REF
  • “Since it was initially filed, it has taken quite a trip through the court system. The complaint has been amended three times, with the most recent amendment being to transform the case into a class suit—this due to the overwhelming evidence of broad harm to the constitutional rights of all Americans.” – REF

April 9, 2022 – Epoch Times | American Thought Leaders: Dr. Aaron Kheriaty on the Rise of the Biomedical Security State: The Merger of Public Health, Surveillance Tech, and Policing Powers – WATCH

  • New ‘Biomedical Security State’ Will Be Deployed to Tackle Other ‘Crises’ -(paywall) WATCH, EXCREPT

“This vaccine passport system gives unprecedented level of surveillance, monitoring. and control to many different institutions, not just the government…That’s going to be used for other purposes…. Right, there is going to be another public health crisis. There are social issues already in play that over the last year have been redefined as public health issues. Climate change would be one obvious example… I think this same infrastructure is probably going to be deployed to again try to control [the] movements of the populations.”

Dr Kheriaty

March 2, 2022 – Tucker Carlson Today: Dr Kheriaty on Vax Mandates – WATCH, EXCERPT, READ

February 24, 2022 – Planet Lockdown Series: Aaron Kheriaty, MD – WATCH,

January 24, 2022 – US Senator Ron Johnson : COVID-19: A Second Opinion (5 hours) – WATCH, FULL,

  • Dr Aaron Kheriaty Testimony @1h50min “Thank you, Senator, for that introduction, for this opportunity to speak” … – TIMESTAMP, TRANSCRIPT

January 13, 2022 – The Highwire Episode 250: GAME, SET, MATCH – FULL, “Natural Immunity is our way out of the Pandemic” – EXCERPT, BACKUP

  • “NBA superstar, Jonathan Isaac, has been on the frontlines of pro-athletes pushing back on Covid-19 vaccine mandates, and doctors are joining his team. Former UCI Director of Medical Ethics, Dr. Aaron Kheriaty, who has also been in the limelight for refusing to get vaccinated, joins Isaac on The HighWire for a deep dive into why they are defending their natural immunity to Covid.”

January 2, 2022 – LA Times: UC Irvine fires physician who refused to get vaccinated, claiming ‘natural immunity’ – READ

2021

November 1, 2021 – Book Release: The New Abnormal: The Rise of the Biomedical Security StateTWEET

September 9, 2021 – Fox News: California professor sues over vaccine mandate, says he has natural immunity – By Emma Colton – WATCH

July 5, 2021 – The Federalist: How College COVID Vaccine Mandates Put Students In Danger co-authored by Aaron Kheriaty, along with Risch, McCullough et al – ARCHIVE

  • “More than 520 of America’s 5,300 colleges and universities, approximately 10 percent, have announced students must be fully vaccinated against COVID before they return for fall classes.”
  • [Note. By 2021 the media had already shortened COVID-19 to simply coronavirus disease i.e. COVID – pay attention to the language!]

June 14, 2021 – Wall Street Journal | Opinion: University Vaccine Mandates Violate Medical Ethics – College students aren’t guinea pigs. – By Aaron Kheriaty and Gerard V. Bradley – READ, CREDIT [The article that got Aaron fired!]

  • Public declaration that “university vaccine mandates violated foundational principles of medical ethics, including the principle of informed consent.” – REF
  • “Shortly after I published [this] Wall Street Journal piece arguing that university vaccine mandates were unethical, the University of California, my employer, promulgated its vaccine mandate. I decided then it was time to put a stake in the ground: I filed lawsuit in federal court challenging the constitutionality of the university’s vaccine mandate on behalf of COVID-recovered individuals [i.e. naturally immune]. It was already clear from many robust studies that natural immunity following infection was superior to vaccine-mediated immunity in terms of efficacy and duration of immunity.” – REF, REF2
  • “At [this] time I was an unlikely candidate to challenge the prevailing vaccination policies. I was deeply embedded in the academic medical establishment, where I had spent my entire career. In my capacity as a psychiatric consultant on the medical wards and in the emergency department, I had suited up in PPE (personal protective equipment) to see hundreds of hospitalized COVID patients, witnessing the worst that this illness can do. Nobody needed to explain to me how bad this virus could be for some individuals, especially the elderly with co-occurring medical conditions who were at significant risk of bad outcomes when infected.” – REF2
  • “I had worked every day for over a year to develop and advance the university’s and state’s pandemic mitigation measures. But as the prevailing COVID policies unfolded, I became increasingly concerned, and eventually disillusioned. Our one-size-fits-all coercive mandates failed to take account of individualized risks and benefits, particularly age-stratified risks, which are central to the practice of good medicine. We ignored foundational principles of public health, like transparency and the health of the entire population. With little resistance we abandoned foundational ethical principles.” – REF

May 31, 2021 – America Out Loud: The McCullough Report podcast: Monkeypox? Are We Going Bananas? – LISTEN, READ, TRANSCRIPT

2020

July 2020 – Aaaon “contracts the virus” – considers himself as having COVID-19 – REF

  • “I contracted the virus in July 2020, and despite my efforts to self-isolate, passed it to my wife and five children. Living and breathing COVID for a year, I eagerly awaited a safe and effective vaccine for those that were still not immune to this virus. I happily served on the Orange County COVID-19 Vaccine Task Force, and I advocated in the Los Angeles Times that the elderly and sick be prioritized for vaccination, and that the poor, disabled, and underserved be given ready access to vaccines.”

1976

The year Aaron Kheriaty was born

1976 – Ivan Illich publishes his prophetic book, Medical Nemesis : The Expropriation of HealthREAD

  • The book “opens with the startling claim, “The medical establishment has become a major threat to health.”
  • “The book explores the epidemic of iatrogenic disease—that is, illnesses caused by medical interventions—which has only worsened in the nearly half century since this book was published….
  • Illich’s basic thesis was that some systems, including our healthcare system, improve outcomes only until they expand to a certain industrialized size, monopolized scope, and level of technological power. Once this threshold is reached, without intending to do so, these systems paradoxically cannot help but inflict harm and undermine their stated aims. Illich diagnosed “the disease of medical progress” in its early stages; I believe this disease has now [2024] reached its advanced stage.” – REF

The post Dr Aaron Kheriaty first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
Kash Patel https://totalityofevidence.com/kash-patel/ Sun, 02 Feb 2025 08:16:13 +0000 https://totalityofevidence.com/?p=41282 Kashyap ‘Kash’ Patel is an American lawyer, born to legal immigrant parents. He is a former federal prosecutor, former chief of staff for the Department of Defence and Deputy Director of National Intelligence during Trump’s 45th administration. He is the…

The post Kash Patel first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
Kashyap ‘Kash’ Patel is an American lawyer, born to legal immigrant parents. He is a former federal prosecutor, former chief of staff for the Department of Defence and Deputy Director of National Intelligence during Trump’s 45th administration. He is the author of several books including the “long awaited” Government Gangsters, written for the purpose of helping to expose the gangsters and teach and inform American’s, and the world, of the true existence of a “deep state” or shadow government – something the Wikipedia gatekeepers label a “conspiracy theory”. [BIO]

Fast forward to 2025, and President Donald Trump, for the 47th administration, picked Kash to head up the US Federal Bureau of Investigation, The FBI.

[I started putting together this page in 2023, but only now in early 2025, I feel compelled to launch it, while the Senate is still deciding whether to confirm Kash as President Trump’s cabinet pick for FBI director]

Kash’s overall message
An informed public, who takes action at a local level, positive change is possible.

During Trump’s first administration, together with congressman Rep. Devin Nunes, Kash exposed the “Russia, Russia, Russia” collusion hoax and Hillary Clinton’s funding of the deep-fake Steel Dossier, which the FBI blindly accepted and used as justification to surveil, under the power FISA, the sitting President of the United States, namely Donald Trump, and any American in his circle.

In mid 2021, Kash started a non-profit called “Fight with Kash” to help “fund lawsuits for all Americans who have been defamed and deplatformed by the media and big tech”, to help Americans legally fight the corrupt system, and to support them financially as they stand up against the deep state – such recipients of the foundations funding were FBI whistleblowers.

If this was a movie script, it would get rejected… because it is so unbelievable!

As someone, who prior to 2020 didn’t follow politics, through listening to many of Kash’s interviews, although I am not American, I have learnt so much about the American political and corruption landscape. Below I have captured some of Kash’s interviews, though you can find many from his website.

Screencapture of Kash Patel’s Wikipedia page Feb 2, 2025 – source

Content about Kash Patel on Wikipedia is controlled information, as shown by the Padlock, and highlighted by smearing him as a “conspiracy theorist”! Check for yourself from the wealth of links below.

Kash’s official links:

  • Kash only has one social media account, on Trump’s Truth Social – @Kash – HERE
  • Fight with Kash – VIDEOS
  • The Kash Foundation – HERE
  • Books – Government Gangsters – HERE
  • Kash’s Corner on Epoch Times – HERE

Links in reverse chronological order

This page will continuously be updated

2025

February 20, 2025 – FBI Director Kash Patel’s Swearing in Ceremony by US AG Pam Bondi and Kash’s speech – WATCH, BACKUP

  • Kash Patel Speaks During Swearing in Ceremony, Says “There Will be Accountability Within the FBI and Outside of the FBI” Starting IMMEDIATELY – TRANSCRIPT

February 20, 2025 – RSBN: United States Senate Nominates Kash Patel to be Director of the FBI – Final Confirmation Vote 51 to 47- WATCH, EXCERPT

  • Gateway Pundit: Senate Confirms Kash Patel as FBI Director – RINOs Murkowski, Collins Vote “NO” – McConnell Votes “YES” – Senate broke the filibuster on Kash Patel’s nomination in a 51-47 voteREAD

February 20, 2025, White House Press Briefing expects Kash Patel’s nomination – and overview of President Trump’s first 30 days in officeWATCH, YouTube, READ

February 1, 2025 – Daily Mail UK: Prince Andrew could face FBI investigation over Jeffrey Epstein as new boss promises to ‘do everything’ to expose links to paedophile – READ, Gateway Pundit – CREDIT

  • “Mr. Patel pledged: ‘Child sex trafficking has no place in the US. I will do everything, if confirmed as FBI director, to make sure the American public knows the full weight of what happened. He agreed to a senator’s demands to open up records ‘of who flew on Epstein’s plane and who helped him build an international human trafficking, sex trafficking ring’.” – REF

January 31, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: FBI Is Still Stalling and Refuses to Turn Over the Seth Rich Records – The Information Could Take Down Democrat Party for a Generation [Kash is a threat to Dems!] – READ

January 31, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: BREAKING: HUGE SCALP: Trump Fires Head of FBI Washington Field Office David Sundberg – Cans More Than 20 Heads of FBI Field Offices – READ, NBC – READ

January 30, 2025 – CNN: Senior FBI leaders ordered to retire, resign or be fired by Monday – READ

  • Gateway Pundit: All Six FBI Executive Assistant Directors and 25 Special Agents in Charge Out at FBI According to FBI Whistleblower – CREDIT
  • “…While Kash Patel was sitting before a Senate committee for his confirmation, a purge of FBI agents who “just followed orders” were told to resign or be fired including 6 of 7 executive assistant directors and 25 out of 56 Special Agents in Charge…” – TWEET

January 30, 2025 – US Senate Committee on the Judiciary: Kash Patel’s confirmation hearing for the position of FBI Director held Thursday Jan 30, 2025 – WATCH, BACKUP, Official WATCH, Gateway Pundit – READ, WATCH

  • C-SPAN: FBI Director Nominee Kash Patel Testifies at Confirmation Hearing, Part 1 – WATCH, Part 2 – WATCH
  • ALSO held on Thursday
    • HHS Sec. Nominee Robert F. Kennedy (RFK) Jr. Testifies at Confirmation Hearing- WATCH , BACKUP
    • Director of Nat’l Intelligence Nominee Tulsi Gabbard Testifies at Confirmation Hearing – WATCH, BACKUP
  • Kash Fires Warning Shot at Pelosi – READ
  • Debating the Word ‘We’ with Adam Schiff – READ
  • Epic response to Senator Amy Klobuchar sly questioning – READ
  • Democrat Senator Dick Durbin brings up J6 Pardons and implies Patel is racist! – READ

January 24, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: JUST IN: Senate Judiciary Committee Sets Kash Patel’s FBI Director Confirmation Hearing for Next Week – READ

January 20, 2025 – C-SPAN: Elon Musk, Kash Patel and Others Speak at Inaugural Parade Pre-Program – WATCH

January 20, 2025 – Kash Patel speaks to crowd during Trump’s Inauguration Day – WATCH

January 16, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: Rep. James Comer Reveals He Had a Long Discussion with Kash Patel in Bold Plan to Dismantle the Deep StateREAD, TWEET

2024

December 11, 2024 – Mel K Show: ICYMI Government Gangsters Last Stand? The People Are Wide Awake –WATCH

December 2, 2024 – Bannons War Room: Episode 4095: Kash Patel Appointed To Clean Up The FBI – WATCH

November 30, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: GOOD NEWS! Trump Officially Nominates Kash Patel For FBI Director – READ

  • President Trump announcement on Truth Social – TRUTH

November 24, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Kash Patel Displays Why He Is the Best Pick for FBI Chief – Explains How Americans Can Regain Trust in Chris Wray’s Rogue Law Enforcement Agency (VIDEO) – READ

November 7, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Kash Patel Announces Massive Declassification Will Occur Under Trump’s Administration from Epstein Files to ‘Diddy List’ and More – READ, TWEET

September 10, 2024 – Bannons War Room Hosted by Kash Patel: Nunes Exposes How The Intelligence State Has Fabricated Hoaxes Against President Trump Since 2016 – WATCH

September 7, 2023 – X22 Report: Kash Patel – [KH] Acting Resident,Trump Getting Intelligence From Other Places,Think 3D Chess – WATCH, October Surprise? – EXCERPT, TWEET

  • Gateway Pundit: Kash Patel Believes Kamala Harris Will Be Installed as President Before Election – READ

September 3, 2024 – Shawn Ryan Show Ep #128: Kash Patel – Donald Trump’s FBI Director Nominee – WATCH

July 8, 2024 – Try That in a Small Town Podcast: Episode 11: Kash Patel on Working for Trump, Counterterrorism, and love for Jason Aldean’s music – revealing the untold stories behind the headlines – WATCH, READ

June 22, 2024 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel Drops BLOCKBUSTER: Paul Ryan’s Chief of Staff Held Crucial Evidence Since 2016 – WATCH

May 23, 2024 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel: President Trump Experiencing Historic Surge In Nevada – WATCH

May 18, 2023 – C-SPAN | FBI Employees and Others Testify Before Weaponization Committee – WATCH

May 17, 2024 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel-The Constitutional Guillotine: The End Of The Deep State – WATCH

  • The Constitutional Guillotine: The End of the Deep State Kash Patel, Former National Security Prosecutor and Deputy Director of National Intelligence – READ

April 5, 2024 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel: “The Deep State Is Going Deep State” – WATCH

March 24, 2024 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel On Moscow Terrorist Attack- “President Biden Has Not Prioritized Intelligence Collection Against Any Form Of Terrorism Around The World” – WATCH

February 23, 2024 – Kash’s Full 2024 CPAC Speech – WATCH, BACKUP

February 23, 2024 – Bannons War Room Live at CPAC: Government Gangsters: THE MOVIE launch – TRAILER, WATCH, WATCH

February 23, 2024 – C-SPAN: Kash Patel Speaks at Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) – THEME: “Where Globalism Goes to Die.” – WATCH

  • Kash Patel, chief of staff to the acting defense secretary during the Trump administration, spoke about American politics and support for former President Donald Trump during the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC).

February 15, 2024 – Mel K Show: Fighting the Fifth Column: Nothing Can Stop What Is Coming w/ Kash – WATCH

February 8, 2024 – Bannons War Room:Kash Patel: “We Finally Found A Constitutional Court That Is Willing To Follow The Law” – WATCH

February 7, 2024 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel: “There Should Be No More Money To Ukraine Until America Is Secure” – WATCH

February 6, 2024 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel: “The Only Person That Can Fix The Southern Border Is The President” – WATCH

February 5, 2024 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel: “We Need President Trump’s Policies To Take On The CCP” – WATCH

January 18, 2024 – Kimberly Guilfoyle Ep 91: HISTORY IN IOWA – AND DONALD TRUMP IS JUST GETTING STARTED – Live with Kash Patel and Joe Kent – WATCH

2023

December 20, 2023 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel Dissects The Disinformation Campaign In Colorado – WATCH

December 14, 2023 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel Discusses How Congress Can Fund The Defense Department And Pull Out Section 702 From FISA – WATCH

December 14, 2023 – Laura Roomer | Loomer Unleashed EP16: China Attacks US Infrastructure as GOP Caves to Deep State on FISA Funding: Special Guest Kash Patel – WATCH

December 8, 2023 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel: Tens Of Thousands Of Americans Surveilled Illegally Under Section 702 In America – WATCH

November 23, 2023 – Royce White | Call Me Crazy Ep # 134: Former Deputy Director of National Intelligence Kash Patel – WATCH

November 18, 2023 – Bannons War Room : Kash Patel: “The January 6th Truth Has Entered The American Bloodstream” – WATCH

  • Kash Patel Calls Out Government Gangster “Andrew Weissmann” Live On Show – EXCERPT

November 14, 2023 – Bannons War Room | Episode 3175: The Government Kickback Program On The CR – Patel on Andrew Weissman – WATCH

November 2, 2023 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel: Biden’s Middle East Intelligence Failure Was “Intentional”, Jack Smith’s Bluff Exposed – WATCH

November 1, 2023 – C-SPAN: Former President Trump 14th Amendment Hearing in Colorado, Day 3, Part 3 – Kash Patel and Katrina Pierson testify – WATCH

October 19, 2023 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel Explains How Iranian Agents Have Infiltrated Biden Regime, Accessed Classified Secrets – WATCH

October 13, 2023 – Epoch Times | American Thought Leaders: Kash Patel on the Israel–Hamas War, the Defense–Industrial Complex, and Strategies to Curb the Deep State – WATCH

October 8, 2023 – Gateway Pundit: How Did the Biden Administration Miss WORLD WAR III? by Kash Patel – READ

October 6, 2023 – One America News w/ Chanel Rion: Kash Patel: ‘Deep State’ Will Turn On Democrats – WATCH

September 26, 2023 – Bannons War Room : “The First Person That Have Been In The Seat Is Hunter Biden”: Patel On Biden Crime Family Hearing – WATCH

October 12, 2023 – Epoch Times | American Thought Leaders: [CLIP] Kash Patel on Strategies to Curb the Deep State – WATCH, FULL

August 2, 2023 – Bannons War Room : Episode 2923: The Hunt For Trump; Impeachment Inquiries Are Imminent – WATCH, Kash – EXCERPT

  • Judge Presiding Over Jack Smith’s Case Previously Recused Self Over Connections To Democratic Leader – EXCERPT
  • DoJ Refused To Prosecute James Comey On Election Interference, Yet Targets President Trump – EXCERPT

July 27, 2023 – Bannons War Room : Episode 2909: The Disgust In Washington; Justice Department Debasing Themselves – WATCH, Kash: Hinter Biden, it’s all interconnected – EXCERPT

June 22, 2023 – Bannons War Room | Episode 2825: The Spineless Actions Of Congress – Durham – WATCH, Kash Patel – EXCERPT

  • Kash Patel And Jeff Clark Critique Durham’s Weak And Disappointing Report That Exposed Nothing New – EXCERPT
  • Durham proves Trump was unlawfully surveilled, illegally for years, the FBI lied to a federal court and more people should have gone to prison…more people now know this as a fact. From Durhams biggest champion to now biggest critic.

June 10, 2023 – Citizen Free Press – Kash Patel breaks down the case re Jack Smith’s Trump document case – WATCH

  • It’s simple, what charges have they levied base on what laws – Espionage act opposes the Presidential Records act, the latter supersedes the former. – TWEET

May 19, 2023 – The Sean Morgan Report: Exposing Government Gangsters with Kash Patel and Praying Medic – WATCH

  • Kash Patel about the latest in the Durham Report aftermath, the whistleblower testimony, and other breaking news. Next, Dave Hayes aka Praying Medic gives us his analysis of the Kari Lake trial and breaking twitter file revelations.

May 15, 2023 – Real Americas Voice: Kash Patel joins Just the News, No Noise With His Reaction To The Durham Report – WATCH, Durham’s Report Affirms the Existence of America’s Two Tiered Justice System – EXCERPT

  • Special Counsel John Durham released his final report today investigating the origins of the Russia Collusion Hoax – Kash Patel says Durham’s report affirms the existence of the two-tiered justice system in America
  • Kash Patel says the fake news is being forced to report that President Trump is innocent as a result of the Durham report & they are “injecting that into the media narrative for the first time to an audience that has never really heard that.” – TWEET

May 13, 2023 – 51 intelligence official signing letter that Hunter’s laptop was Russian disinformation – “Since it’s inception in 1947, the CIA has a LEGAL mandate to never interfere domestically, especially with partisan politics…”As Kash says, this is the exact definition of election rigging. – TWEET

May 4, 2023 – Breitbart News: Exclusive — Kash Patel Suing Defense Department for ‘Obstructing’ Release of His Book that Exposes Deep State – READ, Just The News – READ, @Kash on TRUTH

  • “Kash Patel has filed a lawsuit against the Defense Department for allegedly stopping him from publishing unclassified information in his upcoming book, “Government Gangsters: The Deep State, the Truth, and the Battle for Our Democracy.”…the review process normally lasts three months, but he has been waiting for approval since October (more than 6 months)

April 30, 2023 – Epoch Times | Kash’s Corner: Kash Patel on Tucker Carlson’s Departure From Fox News – WATCH

March 27, 2023 – Mel K Show: Government Gangsters Exposing Themselves Everywhere – WATCH

March 22, 2023 – NY Post: Ex-House ‘Russiagate’ investigator Kash Patel sues Politico over impeachment lies by Miranda Devine – READ

  • “Watch out, Adam Schiff, Alexander Vinman, Fiona Hill and assorted other Russia/Ukraine hoaxers. Kash Patel is coming for you in a courtroom in Virginia.”…Patel “filed a $23 million defamation action against Politico for falsely claiming he misrepresented himself as a Ukraine expert and fed lies to Donald Trump about Ukraine — which ultimately led to the then-president’s impeachment.

March 21, 2023 – Fox Business | Kudlow: This will backfire on the left – Kash Patel weighs in on the impact of a Trump indictment – WATCH

March 14, 2023 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel: J6 Report Reveals Intel Withheld from Intelligence Agency, The Truth of J6 – WATCH

March 8, 2023 – Timcast: KASH PATEL CALLS ON TUCKER TO RELEASE FOOTAGE OF UNDERCOVER FEDS on Jan 6 – WATCH, TWEET

  • “Ray Epps was on FBI’s most wanted list one day, and the next day he was off. There are only two ways that happens: you die, or you are an informant. Jill Sanborn, the head of the FBI counterintelligence division, in charge of all these investigations, testified under oath when Senator Cruz asked her flat out, were there federal agents involved with January 6th? And she said, Senator, I can’t answer that now. If the answer was definitively no, she would have said, no, absolutely not.”

February 17, 2023 – TRIGGERED Ep. 7 w/ Donald Trump Jr.: Kash Patel On Collusion Lies, Big Tech Corruption, and Alien Encounters – WATCH

February 17, 2023 – Epoch Times | Kash’s Corner: Kash Patel: Here’s How Jim Jordan Can Set a Trap to Expose Collusion Between Big Tech and Intelligence Agencies – WATCH

February 17, 2023 – Center For Renewing America: Combatting Over-Classification and Weaponized Intelligence by Kash Patel, Troup Hemenway – READ

  • I. Introduction – “On January 6, 2017, then-Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) Director James Comey briefed President-elect Donald Trump on a summary of salacious and uncorroborated material compiled by former British spy Christopher Steele. The now-infamous “Steele Dossier,” impermissibly funded by the Democratic National Committee (DNC) and the Hillary Clinton campaign, was a cornerstone of the years-long “Russia collusion” conspiracy theory—a baseless, left-wing fever dream that nonetheless deeply damaged the Trump presidency at its outset. As just one of the costs, the energy and resources the new Administration had to devote to rebutting the Russia hoax were considerable, and the effort blunted its ability to turn the rudders of the administrative state quickly.”
  • Although the Clinton campaign and its allies were effective at peddling Steele’s allegations and related Trump-Russia stories to a willing leftist media, it was their laundering of opposition “research” through the intelligence community that provided a veneer of legitimacy to patently ludicrous and fabricated claims.  Perhaps most shockingly, congressional investigators determined—and the Department of Justice (DOJ) Inspector General (IG) later confirmed—that the Steele Dossier formed an essential component of four Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) warrants used to spy on the Trump campaign.  The DOJ IG later identified 17 significant errors or omissions in the FISA applications.  Unfortunately, the Steele Dossier is not an aberration….”
  • II. Background and History – 3 basic levels of classification… which “These standards are so general as to be nearly useless—and grossly understate the complexity of contemporary classification markings,…”
    • (1) “Top Secret” information, if released, would cause “exceptionally grave damage” to national security; 
    • (2) “Secret” information, if released, would cause “serious damage” to national security; 
    • (3) and “Confidential” information, if released, would cause “damage” to national security.  
  • III. The Weaponization of Classification
    IV. Solutions
    V. Conclusion

January 28, 2023 – X22 Report: Kash Patel – D’s Are In The Process Of Removing Biden, The Patriots Have The Leverage To Get It All – WATCH

January 16, 2023 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel: D.C. Law Firms Run The Administrative State, “Worse Than The Lobbyists” – its not a coincidence where the Government Gangsters are hired before and after government appointments – the corruption is not just nested in the lobbying industry. “The Administrative State is the Biggest Problem Facing America, not the Democratic Party” – WATCH

  • “The target is, and has always been, taking out the deep state” not Joe Biden
  • June 16, 2022 – White House counsel Dana Remus is leaving the administration – READ, after mid-term elections – READ, She leaves her post to man-hunt for Biden’s documents she helped move to Penn Biden Center [?] – READ, READ
  • This investigation began before the election, we are only being told now. …running the operation to get rid of Joe Biden
  • January 13, 2023 – CBS News: Longtime Democratic lawyer Bob Bauer is serving as the personal attorney for President Biden in the classified documents matter now before a Justice Department special counsel, the White House confirmed Friday – READ, Robert Bauer, Michael Sussmann and Marc Elias, all former attorneys at Perkins Coie – PDF, Bauer left in 2018 – READ
  • Maggie Tamposi Goodlander, a former White House aide and the wife of national security adviser Jake Sullivan – READ, Context @5min – WATCH
  • January 10, 2023 – U.S. attorney reviewing documents marked classified from Joe Biden’s vice presidency found at Biden think tank – The classified material was identified by personal attorneys for Mr. Biden on Nov. 2, just before the midterm elections… – READ
  • “It all goes back to Russiagate, and the subset of that goes back to UkraineKash you’ve nailed it.” – Steve Bannon

January 13, 2023 – Bannons War room: Patel: Garland’s Biden Special Counsel Should Be First Subpoena Of Government Weaponization Subcommittee – WATCH

  • “There’s two parts to this scandal. The act itself and then there’s the cover up.” Steve Bannon
  • Every body else is focused on the distractions…the CCP has leverage over our sitting commander and chief, Joe Biden, because he and his son have been on the payroll of the CCP for a decade…before getting to Ukraine. Joe Biden had these top secret, compartment clearance documents “out in the wild”

January 12, 2023 – Bannons War Room: Kash Patel Forewarns Against The Government Gangster Appointed As Special Counsel For Biden’s Leaked Documents, Hur needs to be subpoenaed – WATCH

  • Remember Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein appointed Robert Mueller, who is the best friend of former FBI Director James Comey, to be special counsel to investigate ties between Donald Trump’s 2016 presidential campaign and Russia.
  • Now Attorney General Merrick Garland appoints Robert K. Hur as Special counsel, Hur is Rod Rosenstein’s #1 lawyer, who helped block Russiagate subpoenas, and argued against the release of Nunes Memo – which is why Kash disagrees with Hur being appointed to this Special Counsel role.
  • Hur was instrumental in authorising the subpoena for Kash Patel’s personal records in 2017 – info only released a few weeks ago – how could Garland legitimately choose Hur?

2022

December 26, 2022 – Mel K Show at America Fest: We the People Demand the Whole Truth – WATCH

  • Show the repeated pattern of misconduct and them breaking the rules – the Twitter Files is not surprising
  • There’s too much information coming too fast and purposeful distractions …”America is sick of it, people want justice”
  • This was going on before the 2016 election!

December 24, 2022 – X22 Report: Kash Patel-The FBI Colluded To Overthrow The US Government,The House Has The Ability To Get It All – WATCH

December 23, 2022 – Epoch Times | Kash’s Corner: DOJ Exposed for Subpoenaing My Records in 2017, AG Rosenstein Lies; FBI’s $3.4 Million Payment to Twitter Just Tip of the Iceberg – WATCH, TRANSCRIPT

  • “It was recently revealed that in Nov. 2017, the Department of Justice (DOJ) and the FBI issued a grand jury subpoena to Google for Kash Patel’s personal records, emails, and credit card information. “And I wasn’t the only one. We’ve confirmed at least one other senior congressional staffer was subpoenaed,” says Kash Patel.
    At the time, Patel was senior counsel and chief investigator for the House Intelligence Committee’s Russiagate investigation under then-Chairman Devin Nunes….”
  • “If you send out a subpoena to investigate a member of Congress and/or his staff, the Attorney General must sign off on that. That means Rod Rosenstein himself…had to have personally signed off on it,” says Patel. Attorney General Jeff Sessions had recused himself and vested authority in Rosenstein.
  • Two months later, in a closed-door meeting in January 2018, Rosenstein threatened to subpoena the records of Devin Nunes and his staff, Patel says. He would later deny issuing such a threat when asked by Rep. Jim Jordan under oath.”

November 11, 2022 – X22 Report: Kash Patel-Red Wave Worked, The Only Way To Shutdown The [DS],Put It On Full Blast For The World To See – WATCH

October 3, 2022 – Epoch Times | Kash’s Corner: Sussmann Case Exposed Sweeping Evidence of Abuse; Durham Should Bring Future Cases Outside of DC – WATCH, ARCHIVE

  • “The acquittal of ex-Clinton campaign lawyer Michael Sussmann was “a straight-up case of jury nullification … which basically says we don’t care what the facts are, we’re going to find you not guilty anyway,” argues Kash Patel. The jury’s short deliberation time means “they didn’t really look at the evidence.””

August 29, 2022 – Tucker Carlson Show via Gateway Pundit: Kash Patel: Entire Raid on Mar-a-Lago Was to Prevent Disclosure of Declassified Russiagate Documents that implicate the FBI! – WATCH

  • Most of the search warrant affidavit is redacted, but Kash Patel’s name is not redacted. American citizens names in search warrants are supposed to be redacted! The DOJ intentionally lifted redaction on just Kash’s name for political reasons. – REF
  • At this time 40% of Russiagate documents have yet to be publicly released – documents which President Trump declassified – Kash believes this raid was to prevent this disclosure.
  • August 26, 2022 – Peter Strzok “Never great to see your unredacted name in a search warrant affidav…Get a great F’ing criminal defense lawyer- you’re going to need it” – TWEET Note Kash is the reason Strzok et al got fired!
  • August 26, 2022 – Newsweek: Kash Patel Rages Over Being Named in Trump Affidavit: ‘Brown Lives Matter’ – READ

August 11, 2022 – Real Americas Voice | Charile Kirk Show: Kash Patel on the High Ranking Officials that KNEW about Mar-a-Lago Raid – WATCH

  • Damage control coming from the DOJ and who potentially knew about the raid on Trump’s home. “Every single thing they have done is intentional, it’s planned out, you cannot conduct a raid quietly with 30 guys.”

July 30, 2022 – Epoch Times | Kash’s Corner: J6 Disinfo Tactics: Liz Cheney Has Effectively Exonerated Trump for Charges of Insurrection – WATCH, ARCHIVE

  • Whistleblowers have recently come forward alleging widespread misconduct within the FBI and DOJ and a cover-up of the Hunter Biden laptop story, according to a letter from Sen. Chuck Grassley demanding answers and accountability.

July 23, 2022 – Epoch Times | Kash’s Corner: Government Documents Shatter ‘Insurrection’ Narrative – ARCHIVE

  • In the days leading up to Jan. 6, 2021, President Donald Trump authorized up to 20,000 National Guard, but official government documents show Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, Washington mayor Muriel Bowser, and the D.C. Capitol Police each declined the offer.

July 15, 2022 – Real Americas Voice | Charile Kirk Show: What’s The Latest On The Durham Investigation? – WATCH

June 29, 2022 – Fox News via The Gateway Pundit : Kash Patel Destroys J-6 Committee’s Star Witness Cassidy Hutchinson in 3 Minutes – WATCH

  • Kash was in the room when President Donald Trump authorised up to 20,000 troops to guard The Capitol on Jan 6, 2021, and any activity related to it. Kash testified this before the J6 “unselect” committee.

June 24, 2022 – Mel K Show: Trump DOD Insider & Justice Warrior Kash Patel On Reclaiming Truth & Justice – WATCH

June 23, 2022 -The Devin Nunes Podcast Returns with Kash Patel – Only on Truth Social – WATCH

June 23, 2022 – Mary Grace Media: Kash Patel on RussiaGate, 2A, SCOTUS and other national concerns – WATCH

June 4, 2022 – Newsmax |The Chris Salcedo Show: Kash Patel explains how Michael Sussmann told him under oath that he went to the FBI on behalf of the Hillary Clinton campaign – WATCH

May 27, 2022 – X22 Report: Kash Patel – Convictions Coming, More Indictments Coming, We Caught Them All – WATCH

  • Children’s Book by Kash: The Plot Against The King – HERE

May 20, 2022 – Epoch Times | Kash’s Corner: Inside the Michael Sussmann Trial—Kash Patel Talks ‘October Surprise’; Fusion GPS Employee Testimony; Rodney Joffe – WATCH, ARCHIVE

May 4, 2022 – Mel K Show: Trump DOD Insider & Justice Warrior Kash Patel On Current Events – WATCH

April 9, 2022 – Epoch Times | Kash’s Corner: Durham Hits Clinton Campaign with ‘Joint Venture Conspiracy’; Sussmann Defense ‘in Shambles’ – WATCH, ARCHIVE

  • “What I find most striking about this pleading is John Durham’s use of the joint venture/conspiracy exception to [Rule] 404(b).”

March 31, 2022 – Mel K Show: Trump DOD Insider & Justice Warrior Kash Patel On Current Events – WATCH

February 8, 2022 – Epoch Times | Kash’s Corner: Exclusive Interview with Former President Donald Trump – ARCHIVE

2021

October 30, 2021 – Epoch Times | Kash’s Corner Part 2: Kash Patel and Ric Grenell the former Acting Director of National Intelligence Part 1: Russia, NATO, and Building Serbia-Kosovo Peace – READ, ARCHIVE

October 18, 2021 – Tucker Carlson Tonight: Tucker: Anyone who thinks Russia is biggest threat is national security threat – w/ Republican Rep. Devin Nunes and former Trump official, Kash Patel. Kash Patel Crushes Deep State Stooge Christopher Steele – WATCH, ARCHIVE

Kash Patel and Devin Nunes on Tucker Carlson Tonight – WATCH
  • The Hillary Clinton Campaign for President paid a British Spy called Christopher Steel to produce a document now known as the Fake and False Steele Dossier, Steele still stands by all of it! And no one has ever seen the alleged “pee tape”.
  • October 14, 2021: ‘Out of the Shadows: The Man Behind the Steele Dossier’ – George Stephanopoulos sits down with former MI6 spy Christopher Steele for an exclusive interview. His first since the publication of the series of intelligence report known as the Steele dossier – TRAILER

September 16, 2021 – Newsmax w/ Greg Kelly: Kash Patel speaks out on Ashli Babbitt shot on January 6, 2021 – re Babbitt’s shooter, who’s name is unknown, is exonerated after internal probe –WATCH, ARCHIVE,

  • Fight with Kash – Kash Patel Legal Offensive Trust – ARCHIVE – “I know firsthand that the Fake News propaganda machine is working overtime to put American patriots on the defensive.””My name is Kash Patel. As a former career national security official and senior Trump advisor, I know firsthand that the Fake News propaganda machine is working overtime to put American patriots on the defensive. …You see, among many others, WaPo, CNN, Politico, and the NYT falsely and viciously smeared me after I discovered and exposed their Russian Collusion hoax. Twitter has greenlit an account falsly impersonating me to remain in operation….I’m done playing defense. It’s time to go on the offensive! That’s why I’m fighting back.”- CREDIT

April 22, 2021 – The Federalist: Deep State Mouthpiece Retaliates Against Staffer Who Uncovered Russia Collusion Hoax by Mollie Hemingway – READ, ARCHIVE, BACKUP

  • “A frequent media mouthpiece [David Ignatius] for the intelligence community who published the classified leak that launched the Russia collusion hoax is retaliating against the senior government official [Kash Patel] who debunked it.”
  • “Ignatius quietly and briefly admits that “Patel sometimes hit pay dirt,” citing his report on the FBI’s abuse of its application to spy on the Trump campaign, later vindicated by the Department of Justice Inspector General’s report and the guilty plea a former FBI lawyer filed for falsifying information used to apply for warrants.”

April 22, 2021 – The Washington Post | Opinion by David Ignatius Opinion: “How Kash Patel rose from obscure Hill staffer to key operative in Trump’s battle with the intelligence community” – ARCHIVE

2020

August 20, 2020 – Washington Post: Ex-FBI lawyer admits to falsifying document in probe of Trump’s campaign – ARCHIVE

  • “…former FBI lawyer [Kevin Clinesmith] pleaded guilty Wednesday to altering an email that one of his colleagues relied on as he sought a court’s blessing [FISA Warrant] to surveil a former Trump campaign adviser during the bureau’s 2016 investigation of Russia’s election interference.”

2018

February 2, 2018 – House Intelligence Committee released the controversial document, which alleges surveillance abuses by the FBI -“Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act Abuses at the Department of Justice and the Federal Bureau of Investigation” known as the “Nunes Memo” – PDF, READ, WIKI, The Atlantic – READ, BBC – READ, Time Magazine – READ, Politico – READ

  • House Intelligence Committee, chaired by Republican Representative Devin Nunes, “released a four-page memo alleging surveillance abuses by the FBI. Earlier this week, Republicans on the committee voted to make the document public. The classified document has drawn criticism from Democratic lawmakers, who argue it is misleading, as well as from law enforcement officials. In a rare statement, the FBI warned against the document’s release, saying it had “grave concerns” about its accuracy. Despite pushback from officials, the White House approved the release of the memo Friday,” Jan 18, 2018
  • “1) The “dossier” compiled by Christopher Steele (Steele dossier) on behalf of the Democratic National Committee (DNC) and the Hillary Clinton campaign formed an essential part of the Carter Page FISA application. Steele was a longtime FBI source who was paid over $160,000 by the DNC and Clinton campaign, via the law firm Perkins Coie and research firm Fusion GPS, to obtain derogatory information on Donald Trump’s ties to Russia.” ETC…..

January 2018 – Kash Patel lead author of House Intelligence Committee report recounting abuses by the FBI in its application for electronic surveillance of former Trump campaign aide Carter Page. – READ, NY Times – READ

2017

2017 – Kash Patel joined the House Intelligence Committee – REF

  • Kash “spearheaded then-Chairman Nunes’s efforts to challenge allegations that the Trump team had improper contact with Russian officials during the 2016 presidential campaign” – REF
  • In May 2017, for example, intelligence officials say Patel was involved in delivering subpoenas to the CIA, FBI and NSA asking whether Obama administration officials had ever requested “unmasking” of the names of Trump campaign officials who were picked up in communications intercepts. Democrats criticized the unusual direct requests to the agencies.” – REF
  • “Patel made another surprising foray in July 2017, when he showed up in London at the office of former MI6 officer Christopher Steele, who the previous year had provided the FBI with reports (financed in part by the Clinton campaign) on Trump’s alleged Russia links.”

The post Kash Patel first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
TGA Regulation Timeline https://totalityofevidence.com/tga-regulation-timeline/ Wed, 03 Apr 2024 06:58:19 +0000 https://totalityofevidence.com/?p=48321 This page plots the timeline of events that led up to the TGA’s reform allowing for a genetically modified synthetic gene sequence encapsulated by a synthetic lipid to be considered a “vaccine” and plugged into a relatively newly formed regulatory…

The post TGA Regulation Timeline first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
This page plots the timeline of events that led up to the TGA’s reform allowing for a genetically modified synthetic gene sequence encapsulated by a synthetic lipid to be considered a “vaccine” and plugged into a relatively newly formed regulatory pathway. A regulator, who’s role is to protect it’s people, but is funded by the sponsor, allowed a gene technology product, referred to as COVID-19 mRNA vaccines, to enter the newly legislated provisional registration pathway, which in record time, worked its way to full registration which now by default is somehow considered a vaccine platform. How on earth did we get here, that is what I’m attempting to plot.

Since 2022 the TGA, just like the WHO and FDA, have updated their website and deleted many pages, which makes it difficult to locate information, so be aware many links below are web archived pages. You’d think public health were trying to make it difficult for the public to find vaccine information!

There is no legal definition for “vaccine”

  • IMPORTANT: No where in Therapeutic Goods Act or Regulations is there a definition for what constitutes a “vaccine” product, as such there is no legal definition. Yet the regulations call for an Advisory Committee on Vaccines (ACV)!
    • According to the regulations “vaccines” fall under the category of “Biological Medicine“, but not the blood/tissue product type of Biological.
    • The regulations have a definition for “gene therapy” products, yet mRNA “vaccines” some how escaped that category, yet fit the definition perfectly.
    • It appears if a sponsor refers to their product as a “vaccine” then it is considered a vaccine by the regulator!
    • It appears if the mRNA code encodes for an antigen protein, that is all that is needed for it to be considered a “vaccine”, if it encodes a human derived protein it will likely be considered a “drug”. It’s all in the code (as far as I can work out! – Totally shocking!)

To fully understand the TGA we need to also look at the history of the Department of Health in Australia, of which the TGA falls under.

Snapshot of the history of the TGA from 1937 to 2000 – PDF

Australian Register for Therapeutic Goods (ARTG) – HERE, ARCHIVE

Read more for youreself:

  • History of TGA – PDF
  • History of Clinical Trials regulation Australia – HERE

Brief History of TGA

1911- Commonwealth Vaccine Depot (CVD) was established

1916 – CVD became Commonwealth Serum Laboratories (CSL) during war time to provide a source of anti-toxins and other biological agents, it took over manufacture of smallpox vaccine. [1, 5]

  • CSL is privatised in 1991, sold in 1994 to private investors for $299 million [2] now worth $145 billion [3]
  • 1956 CSL mass produced polio vaccine [6]

1921 – Department of Health was established [4]

1937 – Therapeutic Substances Act 1937 giving Minister of Health drug control powers

1953 – Therapeutic Substances Act 1953 administered by Dept of Health

1953 – National Biological Standards Laboratory (NBSL) established to monitor imported products

1989 – Therapeutic Goods Act 1989 – HERE

1989 – Therapeutics Goods Administration (TGA) was created as a Division of the Department of Health equivalent

1990 – Therapeutic Goods Regulations 1990 – HERE

2001 – Office of Gene Technology Regulator (OGTR) established out of Act and Regulation – MORE

TGA: Definition of Gene Therapy

Therapeutic Goods Regulations definition of “gene therapy” as of March 7, 2024
“gene therapy means the in vivo transfer of DNA or RNA into the cells of human recipients”
(nothing is stated about integrations into DNA) – source, PDF

Documents and links below help provide a thread of understanding of the local and global regulatory web and “justification” for consolidation, which they call “harmonisation”. It all sounds good to streamline the regulation of the same product around the world, until you realise the decisions are distantly related to “health” but closely controlled or influenced by those who profit.

Listed in reverse chronological order

This timeline is a work in progress, content will be added as time permits

2024

January 17, 2024 – The European lobby Kangaroo Group, hosted a lunch in the European Parliament with Members with BioNTech and Moderna as key speakers, to discuss the forthcoming revision of “European Commission’s proposal for a reform of the EU General Pharmaceutical Legislation (GPL)”. EU- ARCHIVE, KG – ARCHIVE, PDF, CREDIT

  • Their objective to effecttively change the definition of gene therapy, underwhich their COVID-19 mRNA vaccines are classified, and to create a “definition of Platform Technologies, as well as a clear demarcation between Gene Therapies Medicinal Products that alter human genomes, and those that do not (e.g. mRNA).”
  • [If it is happening in the EU, it’s likely happening with all regulators]

2023

February 24, 2023 TGA – Priority Review pathway for biologicals: feasibility, potential eligibility criteria and determination process – submissions – READ, Priority review – WEB, Priority Review of Biologicals – READ, Application Process – READ

  • [It’s unclear when the Priority Review legislation was updated as the TGA no longer add dates to their web pages, like they’re trying to hide something, at the very least make it harder to track their changes.]
  • Consultation opened March 28, 2022 – REA

2022

August 1, 2022 – Journal of Law and Medicine: A new priority pathway for biologicals in Australia: contextualising and evaluating the proposed reforms by Rudge et al – READ, READ

  • Examines recent reforms to the regulatory framework for biologicals contained in the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989 (Cth) in the context of the “New Frontier” of reform envisioned in a report completed by the Commonwealth Government in 2021….identifies several potential shortcomings of the proposed reforms and reports on the current lack of data on the processes of expedited approvals in Australia more generally.

July 4, 2022 – TGA Advanced Therapies: Report on ‘Cell, Gene and Tissue Regulatory Framework in Australia – A stakeholder engagement report on Advanced Therapies prepared for the Therapeutic Goods Administration – READ, Report – PDF, ARCHIVE

  • In November 2021 the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) commissioned Medical Technologies and Pharmaceuticals Growth Centre (MTP Connect) to conduct a stakeholder review of the regulatory framework for gene, cell and tissue therapies in Australia.

May 23, 2022 – ARCS Annual Conference 2022: Regulation of cell and gene therapies in Australia – Presentation – PDF

  • Biological Medicines (prescription medicines) – vaccines (that do not contain viable human cells)
  • February to April 2022 – TGA initiated a public consultation – support the introduction of a new Priority Review pathway for biologicals
    • Consideration for priority – the biological is to be used for treatment, prevention [AKA VACCINE!] or diagnosis of a life threatening disease or seriously debilitating condition (as described by the TGA)

January 10, 2022 – TGA – New catagory appears called Advanced Therapies, under which gene therapies suddenly appears! – ARCHIVE, READ, Quitely added to the website with NO press release or statement – ARCHIVE, unable to find regulatory change around this time – READ

2021

June 4, 2021 – June 4, 2021 – Legislation: Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code) Instrument 2021ARCHIVE – It is now “legal” or permissible to advertise COVID-19 vaccines “safe” in Australia – TIMELINE

  • Australia’s Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code is amemded to be able to claim COVID-19 vaccines as “safe” – (Dr Philip Altman) – REF [As I am not a legal person it is unclear which instrument brought this advertising permission into effect, it appears to be June 4, 2021 set off the snowball]
June 4, 2021 – Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code) Instrument 2021source
  • June 4, 2021 – Dept Health: Therapeutic Goods (Restricted Representations – COVID-19 Vaccines) Permission 2021 – Skerritt’s letter – (now Repealed) READ, no early ARCHIVE
  • June 7, 2021 – Dept Health: New regulatory arrangements support businesses and health professionals to communicate and incentivise COVID-19 vaccinationREAD, ARCHIVE,
  • September 23, 2021 – Legislation change: Therapeutic Goods (Restricted Representations – COVID-19 Vaccines) Permission (No. 4) 2021 READ , ARCHIVE
    • Authority: This instrument is made under section 42DK of the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989
    • “In recognition of the importance of responsible communications regarding the COVID-19 vaccination program, the TGA has issued a subsequent legal permission (the 2021 permission) that allows advertisers such as health professionals, participating vaccination sites, corporate entities, media outlets and others to develop their own materials to communicate publicly about COVID-19 vaccines subject to the conditions below.” – REF
COVID-19 vaccines made exempt of Advertising code, provides the authority TO MAKE SAFETY claims –
Legislation: Therapeutic Goods (Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code) Instrument 2021 –READ
  • November 8, 2021 – TGA: Communicating about COVID-19 vaccines – ARCHIVE
    • The following guidance explains how parties can lawfully provide communications about COVID-19 vaccines to support the Government’s COVID-19 vaccine roll-out.
  • November 29, 2021 – Legislation: Therapeutic Goods (Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code) Instrument 2021 – ARCHIVE
  • July 1, 2022 – The Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code (the Code) is the cornerstone of the therapeutic goods advertising regulatory framework – ARCHIVE
    • “From 1 July 2022, advertisers must ensure their advertisements comply with the Therapeutic Goods (Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code) Instrument 2021 (2021 Advertising Code).”

April 21, 2021 – Monash Uni: Monash supports Australia’s first mRNA vaccine facilityARCHIVE

  • The Victorian government has announced it will put $50 million towards the first domestic production of mRNA COVID-19 vaccines, such as Pfizer and Moderna…
  • Experts from Monash University’s Biomedicine Discovery Institute will also work on the project, including mRNA specialists from the fields of biotechnology, infectious disease, immunity and cancer.
  • The proven scalability and comparative low-cost vaccine manufacturing potential of mRNA vaccines and nanomedicines secures them as the critical technology platform for vaccines and medicines of the future.
  • Increasingly, mRNA nanomedicine can also be used in the treatment of cancer, rare diseases, cellular engineering and protein-replacement therapy, so this investment will help accelerate mRNA projects and develop new treatments to save lives.

2019

November 21, 2019 : Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP) for new and emerging technologies: Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products (ATMPs) Presentation – ARCHIVE, PDF

September 27, 2019 – TGA business plan 2019-20 ARCHIVE, PDF

TGA Business Plan 2019-2020 – PDF, SOURCE
  • “The Business Plan sets out our product regulation, regulatory reform, international engagement and regulatory compliance agenda for 2019-20 and the steps we will take to achieve our vision.”

Better health and wellbeing for all Australians through regulatory excellence

TGA Vision statement

  • Our priorities are derived from:…TGA International Engagement Strategy 2016-2020 – READ (which began in 2013)
  • TGA “proactively responding to innovations in therapeutic goods, which may require updates to regulation all identifiable opportunities for international work sharing and harmonisation.”
  • “The TGA annual budget is approximately $165 million and we operate predominantly on a cost recovery basis. The regulatory costs are recovered through fees and charges levied on sponsors and manufacturers of therapeutic goods…” – REF
TGA actively aligning with international regulators – source
  • The Australia-Canada-Singapore-Switzerland (ACSS) Consortium‘s work sharing pilot on New Chemical Entities is a unique global collaboration between regulatory authorities and the pharmaceutical industry.

August 12, 2019 – Dept Health: Australian Health Management Plan for Pandemic Influenza (AHMPPI) – READ, ARCHIVE, PDF

  • AHMPPI, the national government health sector pandemic influenza plan, outlines the agreed arrangements between the Australian Government and State and Territory Governments for the management of an influenza pandemic. This agreement was ignored a few months later when another respriatory virus pandemic was declared in 2020!
  • The previous version of this plan was 2008, which conincidentally a year later the 2009 H1N1 pandemic was declared. The Australian govt did successfully utilised the plan that year.

June 2019 – TGA Annual performance statistics report: July 2018 to June 2019 – “provides detailed statistical information on our performance to our stakeholders.” – ARCHIVE, (2016-2019) – ARCHIVE

  • “At 30 June 2019 there were 88,788 therapeutic goods on the ARTG, including 31,987 new products added during the reporting period. All therapeutic goods registered on the ARTG can be lawfully manufactured and supplied in Australia and include prescription medicines, over-the-counter medicines, complementary medicines, biologicals, and medical devices.” [curiously no mention of vaccines, which are a separate category called biological medicines, separate from bioligicals]
    • Thus 36% of all registered products listed on ARTG were added in one financial year!

February 8, 2019 – Prescription medicine major variation: discretionary power to reduce fees in exceptional circumstances – ARCHIVE

  • The sponsors fee reduction is only intended for safety related changes in certain circumstances.

2018

December 2018 – TGA release a promotional video below, … they’re “looking out for you.” – WATCH, ARCHIVE

August 2, 2018 -TGA: Priority review pathway: prescription medicines- Information on the priority review pathway for the registration of novel prescription medicinesREAD

June 29, 2018 – TGA Advertising Code opens up definition for a “serious form of a disease” “to be anything deemed “medically accepted” as a serious disease or a diagnostic test available” – TIMELINE

March 29, 2018 – Provisional Registration added to TGA legislation – TIMELINE

  • “On March 29, 2018 the Australian government added a Provisional Registration (PR) amendment  to the Therapeutic Goods Act (1989), of which the TGA Secretary now has overriding power to send a product application through the registration process with only preliminary clinical data.”

March 23, 2018 – TGA: Completing a designation or determination extension application form in TGA Business Services – A step-by-step guide for agents and sponsors who wish to apply for an extension of a previously approved provisional determination – ARCHIVE, SOURCE

March 21, 2018 – TGA: Australian Regulatory Guidelines for Prescription Medicines (ARGPM) -UPDATE: Implementation of a Provisional approval pathway for the time limited registration of eligible prescription medicines now avaliable – ARCHIVE

March 20, 2018 – TGA announce time-limited provisional registration pathway is now available – ARCHIVE, TIMELINE

  • ” The provisional approval pathway allows sponsors to apply for time-limited provisional registration on the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods (ARTG)
  • “As part of the Government’s response to the Review of Medicines and Medical Devices Regulation (MMDR review), we are implementing a pathway for the provisional registration of prescription medicines. Approval through the provisional pathway will be on the basis of preliminary clinical data where there is the potential for a substantial benefit to Australian patients.
  • The provisional approval pathway allows sponsors to apply for time-limited provisional registration on the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods (ARTG). It provides access to certain promising new medicines where we assess that the benefit of early availability of the medicine outweighs the risk inherent in the fact that additional data are still required.”

March 6, 2018 – TGA legislations change sets up for government to advertise “vaccines” on TV in the interest of public health –TIMELINE

January 2, 2018 – TGA announce Comparable overseas regulators (CORs) for prescription medicines – Criteria, COR report-based process and work-sharing – ARCHIVE, SOURCE

  • “In response to the Medicines and Medical Devices Review (MMDR) we are reforming the way we collaborate with comparable overseas regulators” – and “implementing a formal process for work-sharing with CORs on prescription medicines applications.”
  • Under this process, multiple regulators would be able to work simultaneously on different parts of a dossier submitted for evaluation in each jurisdiction. A joint evaluation report would then be provided to each agency to allow independent decision-making.”
  • They began with re-assessing generic medicines – Nov 2017 ACSS Consortium and the Generic Medicines Work-Sharing Trial presentation – ARCHIVE

2017

June 26, 2017 – TGA: Priority review pathway for the registration of novel prescription medicines for Australian patients, providing “faster assessment of vital and life-saving prescription medicines” – ARCHIVE, ARCHIVE

  • The very pathway all COVID-19 vaccine entered to gain regulatory handshake
  • Sponsors lodge their application first for TGA Secretary to determine whether the medicine/vaccine is eligible for registration via the Priority review pathway, once approved it enters the provisional pathway.

March 2017 – TGA: Expert Panel Review of Medicines and Medical Devices Regulation 2016 – Streamlining Statutory TGA advisory committees – ARCHIVE

  • Efficiencies will be achieved through reducing the number of statutory advisory committees that provide independent expert advice to the TGA. – i.e. Advisory Committee for Vaccines (ACV) funded by the sponsor “cost arrangement” – TIMELINE

January 2, 2017

2016

September 15, 2016 – TGA: Australian Government Response to the Review of Medicines and Medical Devices Regulation – The case for reform presented by the Expert Panel – ARCHIVE, Reforms proposed – ARCHIVE

  • “The Expert Panel identified several significant trends in the regulation of medicines and medical devices internationally. In particular,…allowing earlier access to medicines … through the development of provisional approval pathways” There are “benefits of harmonising international regulatory frameworks”.
  • “TGA has a strong reputation as a regulator both domestically and internationally, and benchmarks well against comparable overseas regulators. However, …there are opportunities for reform and improvement in the regulation of therapeutic goods.”
  • “…allowing for greater flexibility in approval pathways …(including greater use of overseas assessment reports and provisional approvals in certain circumstances) would expedite access to market without compromising the safety, quality and efficacy or performance of medicines and medical devices.” [Bold claim!]
  • “The Panel also identified areas of regulation where a more risk-based approach could be adopted to more appropriately align regulation with the risk posed by regulated products” [Do you sense they are suggesting vaccines here, which are believed to be, by default of their name, safe and effective” ?]

May 2016 – The Australian Government Response to the Review of Medicines and Medical Devices Regulation – PDF, ARCHIVE

  • Recommendation 10 – Provisional: “Subject to the provision of clear advice to consumers and health practitioners that the medicine has been granted provisional approval and the implications of that for the consumer/health practitioner”
    • [Was it made clear th the pubic and health practitioners that the COVID-19 vaccines in Australia were “Provisional” when released in 2021?]

2015

November 2015 – Australian Goverment establishes Medical Technologies and Pharmaceuticals Growth Centre (MTP Connect) – as part of the $248 million Industry Growth Centres Initiative, an alleged independent, not-for-profit organisation – ARCHIVE , Gov- ARCHIVE, Factsheet – PDF

  • MTP Connect Chair, Dr Bronwyn Evans – was from 2009-2012, the Chair of the Medical Technology Association of Australia (MTAA), a national peak industry body representing companies in the medical technology industry…for a healthier Australia..and “also play a vital role in providing healthcare professionals with essential education and training” – of non-pharmaceutical products. REF

July 31, 2015 – Review of Medicines and Medical Devices Regulation: Recommendations to the Minister for Health on the Regulatory Frameworks for Medicines, Medical Devices, Complementary Medicines and Advertising of Therapeutic Goods – Stage TWO Review report – PDF, PDF, ARCHIVE

  • “The rapid pace of innovation and change in the health sector confers both benefits and risks. The Government’s deregulation agenda is based on the core principle that well-designed regulation has a role in achieving the greatest net benefit for the Australian community….positioning Australia to effectively respond to emerging opportunities for, and manage challenges to the health and safety of the public”

March 31, 2015 – Expert Panel Stage ONE Review report and discussion papers – PDF, ARCHIVE

2015 – TGA Acronyms & Glossary – Definitions – ARCHIVE, READ

  • Active Ingredient
  • Anticeptic
  • Bacterial endotoxin limit 
  • Bioburden
  • Biological
  • Biological Medicine (vaccine)
  • Cochrane review
  • Common Technical Document (CTD) format – An internationally agreed set of specifications for a submission dossier….
  • Disease
  • Drug – See medicine (Section 3(1) of TG Act
  • Genetically Modified Organism (GMO)
  • Homoeopathic preparation   
  • Informed consent
    • “In relation to treatment or proposed treatment, means consent freely given by a person on the basis of information concerning the potential risks and benefits of the treatment that was sufficient information to allow the person to make an informed decision whether to consent to the treatment”
  • Medicine
  • (no definition for “Gene Therapy” but can be found in the TG Regulations)
  • (no definition for vaccine, can’t be found anywhere!)
  • Medical Device – READ
  • New chemical entity (NCE) – could be anything!
  • Placebo
    • “An inactive substance or treatment that supposedly has no treatment value. It is given to participants in clinical trials as a control against which to compare the effects of the test substance. In practice, placebos may also have positive or negative effects on trial participants.” 
  • Control
    • “In clinical trials comparing two or more interventions, a control is a person in the comparison group that does not receive the medicine or treatment under evaluation. Instead that person receives a placebo, no intervention, usual care or another form of care. In case-control studies, a control is a person in the comparison group without the disease or outcome of interest.”
  • Therapeutic goods     

2015 – Legislation Australian Immunisation Register Act 2015 – NEED MORE INFO

  • recognised vaccination provider within the meaning of the Australian Immunisation Register Act 2015 – REF

2014

October 28, 2014 – Dept. Health: Expert Review of Medicines and Medical Devices Regulation announced – ARCHIVE, Web page ARCHVIES

  • Media Release: Health Minister Peter Dutton and Assistant Minister for Health Fiona Nash announced they had appointed an Expert Panel Review of Medicines and Medical Device Regulation – PDF
    • We need a modern regulatory framework to ensure Australians can access the latest treatments in a timely manner,” Dutton
  • The scope of the Review is set out in the Terms of Reference, review report due March 31, 2015 – PDF
  • The Review panel experts are Emeritus Professor Lloyd Sansom AO (chair), Professor John Horvath AO, Mr Will Delaat AM

June 5, 2014 – The Health Ministerial Advisory Council – ARCHIVE

  • Health Ministerial Advisory Council (Health MAC) has been established to provide advice to the Health Ministers about opportunities to reduce regulatory and red tape burden within the Health portfolio. Health MAC falls within the Deregulation Branch, Best Practice Regulation and Deregulation Division of the Department of Health.
    • Chair: Hon Peter Dutton MP, Minister for Health and Minister for Sport
    • Deputy Chair: Senator the Hon Fiona Nash, Assistant Minister for Health

April 22, 2014 – Dept Health: Regulation and Red Tape Reduction – The deregulation agenda – ARCHIVE

  • Deregulation Unit within the Department’s Best Practice Regulation and Deregulation Division has been established to promote regulatory performance across the Health portfolio

March 19, 2014 – Abbott government as part the 2014 Autumn Repeal Day: The Australian Government Guide to Regulation – Cutting Red Tape, for the Australian Public Service involved in policy making, Honourable Josh Frydenberg MP, Parliamentary Secretary to the Prime Minister – READ, PDF, WEB

  • It is no mandatory that every government policy proposal designed to introduce or abolish regulation must now be accompanied by an Australian Government Regulation Impact Statement (RIS)
  • Australian Government has a plan to cut $1 billion in red tape every year. Regulation is “Any rule endorsed by government where there is an expectation of compliance”.

2013

International regulatory cooperation takes hold – “harmonisation” – regulatory assessment becomes consolidated

July 2013 – TGA International Engagement Strategy 2013-2015 (it begins) – Version 1.0 July 2013 – ARCHIVE, updated versions ARCHIVE, SOURCE

  • “The therapeutic goods industry is becoming increasingly globalised and the TGA must be able to assure public confidence in products no matter where they are produced. As this is occurring, international regulators are demonstrating a greater willingness to develop partnerships and share information, skills and experience to ensure more informed and consistent decisions about the quality, safety and efficacy of therapeutic products.”
  • “The major return on this investment is a reduction in duplication of effort in pre and post market evaluation of therapeutic goods, leading to a more efficient and effective regulatory system.” – i.e. to drive harmonisation
  • The strategy will be reviewed periodically and amended as necessary in response to the changing international environment…
  • The development of the joint Australia and New Zealand Therapeutic Products Agency (ANZTPA) [which eventually failed and was disbanded]

2011

May 31, 2011 – TGA – Biologicals legislation commenced following a recommendation from Commonwealth, State and Territory health ministers to improve the regulation of human tissues and cell-based therapies. – REF Providing the regulatory framework for biologicals

  • What is regulated as a biological – Human derived – ARCHIVE
  • Different to blood and tissued – ARCHIVE
  • Don’d confuse “biological” with “biological medicine”, the latter is where “vaccine” is placed.
  • First introduced in May 2011, the regulatory framework for biologicals provides the legislative basis for the regulation of human tissue and cell-derived products as well as live animal cell, tissues or organs that are supplied, in or exported from, Australia (TGA, 2017, 2021b). For those therapeutic goods, regulated by the TGA, and which are produced by genetic manipulation (GM), the TGA is required to seek advice from Office of the Gene Technology Regulator (OGTR) (TGA, 2004) – PDF

2010

November 1, 2010 – TGA introduced a streamlined submission process for prescription medicine applications that require the evaluation of non-clinical, clinical and/or bioequivalence information (category 1 and category 2 submissions). – REF

  • Jan 17, 2011 – Transition information about the streamlined submission process – ARCHIVE
  • To support sponsors in meeting the regulatory requirements under the streamlined submission process, a regulatory framework of legislative instruments has been created.

2009

The year the TGA introduced Business process reforms which included – AusPAR and PI/CMI

December 2009 – The first Australian Public Assessment Report (AusPAR) was published – a Publication of a regulatory decisions – REF, Australian Public Assessment Record (AusPAR) – ARCHIVE updated 2014 – READ

  • The AusPAR project, part of the Prescription medicines business process reform project (BPR program) – “is increasing the transparency of the prescription medicine regulatory process by publicly releasing (since December 2009), Australian Public Assessment Records (AusPAR) for new products of major variations to existing products.” –REF
  • “AusPAR provides information about the evaluation of a prescription medicine and the considerations that led the TGA to approve or not approve an application”
  • “The TGA works with international counterparts in order to reduce the worldwide regulatory burden and increase the global uniformity of data requirements. Thus, wherever possible, the TGA’s requirements are the same as those of other major regulatory agencies.” [Thus FDA, EMA and UK medical agency important to take note of]

November 2009 – PI/CMI project launched – ARCHIVE

  • “Since November 2009, the PI/CMI project provided via the TGA website “a single trusted source for product information (PI) and consumer medicine information (CMI)” to provide consumers and health professionals “enhanced access to prescription medicine information.” – REF,

April 2009 – The Industry Working Group (IWG) has provided advice and assistance on the range of business process reforms. Under the terms of reference, members of the working group are not representatives of individual sponsors, but bring specific expertise to the working group.” – REF

2009 – Streamlined Submission Process project (prescription medicines) “In early 2009, the TGA commenced a significant program of business process reforms (BPR program) for the regulation of prescription medicines in Australia” – REF

  • “The key elements of the BPR program were identified during an industry consultation workshop held on 17 December 2007 which brought together representative of the TGA, Medicines Australia, and the Department of Health and Ageing. These initiatives are part of the Australian Government’s broader regulatory reform agenda.” – ARCHIVE
  • There are three projects within the BPR program: –REF
    • Streamlined submission process project – ARCHIVE
    • PI/CMI project – ARCHIVE
    • AusPAR project (Dec 2009) – REF, AusPAR – ARCHIVE

2008

2008 – Department of Health and Ageing: Australian Health Management Plan for Pandemic Influenza (AHMPPI) 2008 – READ, REF,

  • This plan was used the following year in the 2009 pandemic which ended up being “mild” – READ

2007

December 17, 2007 – TGA holds an industry consultation workshop – REF

  • The key elements of the 2009 business process reforms (BPR program) “were identified during an industry consultation workshop held on 17 December 2007 which brought together representative of the TGA, Medicines Australia, and the Department of Health and Ageing.”

November 2007 – Biosecurity and Emergency Response: The National Health Security Act 2007 and the National Health Security Agreement – Dept Health 2007-08 Annual Report – PDF

  • To improve the identification and response capacities of health authorities to national and international public health events, such as an influenza pandemic.
  • N5H1 vaccines added to National Medical Stockpile
  • Implemented outcomes of Oct 2006 National Pandemic Influenza Exercise — Exercise Cumpston’ 06READ
  • Commenced revision of the Australian Health Management Plan for Pandemic Influenza (2003) to ensure that the plan is based on the latest evidence. (See 2008)

2006

October 2006 – Therapeutic Goods Administration and Biologics and Genetic Therapies Directorate (BGTD) of Health Canada – Parallel Review Pilot Project – ARCHIVE

  • The project will involve the two agencies reviewing one or more submissions in parallel with an aim to enhance cooperation between regulators in various jurisdictions around the world.”
  • November 8, 2006 – Health Canada:
Health Canada “Vaccines are Biologics” – source,
This reference led me here…ARCHIVE

October 16-19, 2006 – Exercise Cumpston’ 06 : Australia holds Australia’s largest ever health exercise and was one of the first major exercises on pandemic influenza conducted in any country – REPORT, READ, TIMELINE

July 10, 2006 – “On July 10, 2006, Health Canada issued a Notice of Compliance to Merck Frosst Canada Ltd. for the vaccine product GardasilTMARCHIVE

2005

2005 – “Australia had been in the pandemic “ALERT” phase since 2005 following the emergence of the avian influenza A(H5N1) virus infection in humans.” REF

2004

August 19-20, 2004 – The 9th National Public Health Association of Australia Inc (PHAA) Immunisation & 1st PHAA Asia-Pacific Vaccine Preventable Diseases Conference: ‘Immunisation at the crossroads: Challenges and Strategies‘ –READ, REF, PHA is an advocacy group – ARCHIVE

  • PHAA Vaccines in Public Health Short Course before the conference!
  • 1998 the 6th conference Immunisation Beyond 2000 – HERE

January 2004 – Dept Health & Ageing: Protecting Australia against Communicable Disease: Everybody’s BusinessPDF (Referenced by Halton)

  • “Influenza virus is a continuing global threat because it can spread easily and evolve rapidly to elude our prevention and treatment strategies.” [i.e. flu vaccines]

2003

November 5, 2003 – WHO Global Training Network (GTN) course on vaccine regulation for National Control Authorities – ARCHIVE

  • “The Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) is one of the accredited training centres around the world that contributes to the WHO Global Training Network (GTN). The GTN was developed in 1996 as a means of providing educational resources to staff of vaccine production facilities and regulatory agencies responsible for control of vaccines.”

October 2003 – The Australian Action Plan for Pandemic Influenza was endorsed by the National Public Health Partnership and the Australian Health Ministers’ Advisory Council – Dept Health Annual Report 2003-04 – by Secretary of Department of Health and Ageing, Jane Halton ARCHIVE, REF

  • The 2003-04 outbreak of avian influenza H5N1 (bird ’flu) in Asia “was the second time in as many years that an unknown and highly contagious disease had posed a major international threat, the previous one being SARS” (a coronavirus)
  • So Australia compiles an influenza plan (not a respiratory virus pandemic plan) to provide direction for the Australian, State and Territory governments and emergency services in the event of an influenza pandemic.
  • “Influenza pandemics result from a major change in the structure of the influenza virus and are expected to occur about every 30 years. Experts predict that future pandemics are likely, if not inevitable.”
    • [They got their wish 6 years later, following the May 2009 definition change for what constitutes a pandemic, except there was pushback in Europe
  • “The expectation of 50 years ago that humanity would soon wipe out infectious disease, has been replaced with the knowledge that we will probably never win the ‘arms race’ against ever-changing microbes and viruses” writes Jane Halton [1953 Salk polio vaccine was released], now in makes sense why she headed the organisation that would save the world with 100-day vaccines for Disease X!
    • Jane Halton became head of CEPI when it launched in 2017, in time for 2020 pandemic!

June 4, 2003 – TGA Laboratories (TGAL) are designated by the World Health Organization (WHO) as a WHO Collaborating Centre ARCHIVE, ARCHIVE2

  • WHO Collaborating Centre for Quality Assurance of Vaccines and other Biologicals and
  • WHO Collaborating Centre for Drug Quality Assurance
  • WHO Vaccine Self Sufficiency Program in the Western Pacific Region – REF

2002

January 29, 2002 – TGA Media Release: TGA sweeps Internet for false claims – ARCHIVE

  • Australian Internet Sweep Day, coordinated by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC), is part of an international evaluation of web sites, aimed at protecting consumers and promoting fair trading in the global market. Linked through the International Marketing Service Network (IMSN) of of consumer protection authorities.

May 2002 – NCIRS: Vaccine preventable diseases and vaccination coverage in Australia 1999 to 2000PDF, SOURCE, CREDIT

2000

November 26-28, 2002 – WHO/IVR: Ethical considerations arising from vaccine trials conducted in paediatric populations with high disease burden in developing countries – PDF

  • “Each year, millions of children in developing countries suffer from infectious diseases. Of these, more than 2.7 million children under five (WHO 2001 estimate) die from diseases that are potentially preventable by vaccines. In light of these unacceptable rates of morbidity and mortality, the development or improvement of vaccines to meet the needs of children in developing countries continues to be one of the highest priorities, with the attendant requirement for an increasing number of trials to evaluate new vaccines.”
    • [This is an important claim which is parroted by WHO yet supply without citation]
  • A cautious approach is appropriate in the conduct of vaccine trials among children in any circumstances because of their particular vulnerability in view of their inability to give informed consent and their sometimes greater potential to adverse reaction to vaccines.”

July 14, 2000 – Australian Children’s Hospital at Westmead and Children’s Medical Research Institute joint initiative: Gene Therapy Research Unit – ARCHIVE, REF

1998

January 1998 – TGA commenced an orphan drug programARCHIVE, PDF

  • The “program aimed at encouraging sponsors of prescription medicines for treatment of rare diseases to register and market these medicines in Australia. Because these medicines are for a very limited number of patients, they are less likely to be commercially attractive to sponsors than medicines with a larger market. If the sponsor can substantiate that a medicine meets orphan drug criteria, the TGA will waive the cost of evaluating the medicine.”
  • [Think ivermectin for COVID-19!]

1997

1997 – National Centre for Immunisation Research and Surveillance (NCIRS) of Vaccine Preventable Diseases was established by the National Centre for Disease Control, Commonwealth Department of Health and Aged Care as an initiative under the Seven Point Plan for the “Immunise Australia” program. – (lots of ref) ARCHIVE, Research – ARCHIVES, Vaccine trials – ARCHIVE

  • NCIRS has provided editorial and scientific support for the production of the Australian Immunisation Handbook and provided support to the Australian Technical Advisory Group on Immunisation (ATAGI)
  • NCIRS 2002 report: Vaccine preventable diseases and vaccination coverage in Australia, 1999 to 2000 PDF
  • NCIRS 2001 edition: Immunisation – Myths & Realities. Responding to arguments against immunisation – a guide for providers (first pub. October 1994) – PDF
    • Look at charts on pg 10 & 11, and compare the dates on the Y-axis to comparable graphs found, and the Y-axis units – HERE, this is how they “debunk”.

February 1997 – Australian Government Immunise Australia Program: Population Health Division: The Seven Point PlanARCHIVE

  • The Seven Point Plan was approved by Cabinet and launched by the Minister for Health and Family Services, the Hon Dr Michael Wooldridge, in February 1997
    • Initiatives (incentives) for Parents.
    • A bigger role for General Practitioners.
    • Monitoring & Evaluation of Immunisation Targets.
    • Immunisation Days.
    • Measles Eradication.
    • Education and Research.
    • School Entry Requirements

1995

October 1, 1995 – Therapeutic Goods Regulations – Definitions antiseptic, fungicide, viricide etc added – PDF, READ

1992

August 18, 1999 – Therapeutic Goods Administration Laboratories Branch – The TGA laboratories (TGL)were first occupied in the spring of 1992. – REF, ARCHIVE

  • “TGAL is responsible for evaluating the chemistry, quality control and manufacturing data submitted by the manufacturer in support of: vaccines, cytokines, blood products, hormones and enzymes, other biological medicines, monoclonal antibodies”
  • Laboratory Information Bulletin Vol. 6, no. 1 (September 1994) – ARCHIVE, SOURCE

1989

1989 – The Therapeutic Goods Act 1989 came into effect in 1991 giving the Commonwealth more clearly defined regulatory authority. – READ Followed by the Therapeutic Goods Regulations 1990READ

  • The Therapeutics Goods Administration (TGA) was created as a Division of the (then) Department of Community Services and Health – history – READ
  • The legislation was to streamline Commonwealth and State legislation and to allow the Government to charge fees to industry to meet the costs of therapeutic goods regulation – REF

1983

1983 – A New Pandemic emerges HIV/AIDS- Much of the world’s optimism about the state of health was shattered by a new, mysterious pandemic, HIV/AIDS. In Australia, the virus was first identified in a patient in Sydney in 1983 – REF

1981

1981 – WHO: World Health Day with the ‘Health for all by the year 2000‘ – REF

1966

1966 – Therapeutic Goods Act (1966) – READ, CREDIT

  • Therapeutic Goods Regulations (1970) – READ
  • This Act and Regulations held until the big overhaul happened in 1989.

1953

1953 – Therapeutics Substances Act (1953) passed – READ, CREDIT

  • The regulations were not enacted until 1956 , after the polio vaccine Cutter incident debacle in the USA – READ

1937

1937 – The Federal Health Council (1925) is expanded to become the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) with State and Federal representatives, now to include members of the medical establishment – REF

1937 – The Commonwealth Government passed a Therapeutic Substances Act in 1937, giving the Minister for
Health power to control the importation and exportation of substances which were declared in the Gazette
to be therapeutic substances. – (more history) – REF

1936

1936 – Therapeutics Substances Act (1936) signed, followed then by 1937, neither Act were proclaimed because of WWII – TGA History – REF

1926

1926 – Australia hosted the first League of Nations’ international conference on health – REF

  • The delegates discussed early warning systems for epidemics and quarantine issues, as well as various medical problems… then the Great Depression hit followed by World War II, after which the World Health Organisation is formed, under the umbrella of the United Nations

1925

1925 – Federal Health Council to promote Federal-State cooperation established following a Royal Commission Commonwealth health system – REF

1921

March 1921 – The Commonwealth Department of Health was established – ARCHIVE

  • “The panicked response to the 1919 influenza pandemic was a catalyst for founding the Commonwealth Department of Health in March 1921 .
  • Other factors included recommendations from the State Premiers, the British Medical Association of Australia (the forerunner of the Australian Medical Association) and a blunt appeal to the Prime Minister, Billy Hughes, by Dr Victor Heiser from the Rockefeller Foundation’s International Health Board. Heiser told Hughes that Australia would be considered backward until it acquired a national health department.
  • Rockefeller Foundation provided the “Government the financial incentives of temporary expertise in industrial hygiene, public health engineering and administration, as well as training scholarships” – REF
  • Billy Hughes would go on to become Minister for Health and Repatriation – REF

Department of Health went through many structural changes – HISTORY

1919

1919 – “Spanish influenza” was brought to Australia by returning servicemen. “The epidemic killed 12,000 Australians. It caused widespread panic. Troops were quarantined before being reunited with their families. Public meeting places such as hotels and theatres were closed, and masks had to be worn on the streets. The authorities’
response to the crisis was chaotic, with police being stationed along State borders to try to prevent the disease from spreading. – REF, HISTORY

  • The panicked response to the 1919 influenza pandemic was a catalyst for founding the Commonwealth Department of Health in March 1921 – REF

1919 – The first international flight to Australia by Ross and Keith Smith, pointed to the need for improved quarantine and health services – REF

1916

1916 – Australia work with the Rockefeller-funded International Health Board to extend its hookworm eradication campaign to Australia – REF

1916 – WWI prompted the establishment in 1916 of the government Commonwealth Serum Laboratories to provide a source of anti-toxins and other biological agents, should overseas, supplies become scarce… – REF

1909

1909 – The Federal Quarantine Service within the Department of Trade and Customs is established – REF

  • Commonwealth quarantine officers became part of an informal network of health officials and doctors operating at all levels around the country. It’s members started the public health movement leading to the Department of Health
  • In 1900, life expectancy for men was 52 and 55 for women – REF
  • In 1984 the quarantine responsibilities of the Department of Health,which was once its very nucleus, were transferred to the Department of Primary Industry – REF

1901

January 1, 1901 – Birth of the Commonwealth of Australia – TIMELINE

The post TGA Regulation Timeline first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
Doug Brodie’s Collective Works https://totalityofevidence.com/doug-brodies-collective-works/ Fri, 08 Mar 2024 09:47:55 +0000 https://totalityofevidence.com/?p=47068 Doug Brodie’s has been writing open letters to UK government officials regarding the COVID-19 pandemic response, the climate change hoax and more, these letters have been made public via several platforms, I found them via Joel Smalley‘s Dead Man Talking…

The post Doug Brodie’s Collective Works first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
Doug Brodie’s has been writing open letters to UK government officials regarding the COVID-19 pandemic response, the climate change hoax and more, these letters have been made public via several platforms, I found them via Joel Smalley‘s Dead Man Talking Substack. They are valuable pieces of writing in my opinion, and my own research has led me to concur with Doug’s writings and rants, the work that I have laboured over capturing through out this website, Totality of Evidence. But Doug’s work is scattered and needs a collective home, so I hope this page will serve that role.

Mr Brodie says a lot of what I’d like to say, but is expressly more articulate than I could ever be. So I will highlight his work here to make it (reverse) chronologically accessible to everyone, and hopefully it will inspire people to join the campaign in waking up the hypnotised through sharing these letters or writing their own – or simply direct them to this page!

As I was placing the last of Doug’s letter in this page I came across the following comment by Joel Smalley. It seems I’m not the only one who Doug’s letters have resonated with more than many, after all they inspired me to create this page.

There seems to be a theme developing. It’s funny how so many of us keep arriving independently at the same place at the same time from different paths.

I TOTALLY agree with that…

One of the things my mum [Joel’s mum] told me yesterday is that I should write a book. I don’t think I have the aptitude for that. I certainly don’t have the inclination. But if Doug Brodie were to put his letters together in an epistolary novel, it would be worth a read.”

Joel Smalley comments on Doug’s installment on Jan 14, 2023

I’ve had friends say the same to me about writing a book, that is not my thing either, so links below will serve as a home for Dougs collective works until that book comes out (if it ever does).

Open letters in reverse chronological order

Continuously updated as time permits

2024

March 6, 2024 – Net Zero climate change broadside – READ

2023

June 10, 2023 – Rishi Sunak’s Recent Net Zero Back-Pedalling: What It Really Means – READ

April 12, 2023 – The Undemocratic Tyranny of Modern Government – ERAD

March 9, 2023 – COVID, Climate Change, Agenda 2030 and The Great Reset, the Ukraine War, Online Censorship and “safety”, 15-Minute Cities and More – Doug Brodie’s Campaigning Swan Song – READ

March 2, 2023 – The undemocratic tyranny of Net Zero – READ

February 25, 2023 – We are being horribly abused by lies, false propaganda and suppression of the truth – READ

January 14, 2023 – Why do so few of the general public smell a rat? – READ

  • …that we are stuck in an abusive relationship with our treasonous, lying politicians who act as puppets to their globalist overlords,…”

2022

December 3, 2022 – “First degree premeditated mass murder crimes against humanity and genocide”- Another chapter in the epistolary novel by Doug Brodie, focussed on the COVID “pandemic” – PART 1, Conclusions – PART 2

  • Doug notes the title’s words were spoken by the late Dr Vladimir Zelenko
  • I never thought I would see such naked premeditated evil in my lifetime. Unless we can stop it, whatever they are planning to spring on us will probably happen before the US and UK elections due in 2024 when the presiding incumbents must expect to get swept away. People need to take time out to pay attention to what is going on, otherwise there is little hope of resisting these dystopian plans. …We need people power. We need people to join the campaigns!”
  • Not our Future campaign – PLEDGE WATCH , READ
  • Neil Oliver gets this, as he sets out in his must-watch November 27, 2022 monologue “The Government should be afraid because they’re behaving unforgivably” – WATCH

November 10, 2022 – The Powers That Be who rule our lives are inveterate liars – Economic collapse, hyperinflation, climate change scam, COVID scam, mass democide, pharmaceutical fraud, digital ID, CBDCs. It’s all there and points in one direction – READ

  • “The Powers That Be (TPTB) showed their true colours during the Covid “plandemic” through their proven lies, fearmongering psy-ops, false propaganda, censoring, cancelling of dissidents, coercions such as the vaccine mandate of “no jab, no job” and turning a collective blind eye to the horrendous Covid vaccine injuries. All this for a virus similar to flu with a median Infection Fatality Rate of 0.035% for the under-60s including the chronically unwell and with safe and effective early Covid treatments deliberately and cruelly banned. The median age of death in the UK from the not-so-deadly virus has always been above UK life expectancy, currently running at an astonishing 86 versus life expectancy of about 80 years.”
    • Neil Oliver GB News: “We are expected to forget those promising to fix the disaster, caused it” – WATCH
    • Mark Steyn GB News: “These are deeply weird times. And the fact that the American and British media cover them as perfectly normal only adds to the weirdness.’ – WATCH

September 1, 2022 – The Other Big Con – Net Zero Climate Change – A rant by Doug Brodie of Nairn – READ

  • “I am sick and tired of being continuously oppressed and abused by unaccountable, misanthropic WEF/UN/WHO/Big Money tyrants and their puppet politicians. -(Them-guys/gals –IMAGE)
  • “To everyone who has disparaged me as a “climate change crank” for daring to speak out against the so-called climate consensus, I say: “Today’s chaos shows that I was right all along and you were wrong for failing to question the obviously-flawed climate cult narrative”…” -(Told you so –IMAGE)
  • This email is as usual based on facts and information you are unlikely to see in the biased MSM (excluding GB News) and will hopefully lead more people to share my conclusion that the fairy tale “climate change Emperor” is not dressed in a suit of fine clothes but is actually stark naked.  

August 18, 2022 – Follow-up open letter to my MP, complicit by his silence – READ

  • “With the rollout of another round of Covid boosters imminent, I feel compelled to update you with information vital to your wellbeing that you are unlikely to see in the corrupt mainstream media (MSM)…

July 30, 2022 – An open letter to my MP, culpable by commission and omission – 20 questions – READ

  • “This rebuttal of the official establishment narrative will hopefully help more family and friends to understand how they are being lied to and abused by the government….we are living in the middle of a complex, mass murder global conspiracy being bizarrely played out with massive collateral damages over a respiratory virus which for nearly everyone is no more dangerous than ordinary flu. [March 2023 the CDC confirm it’s but a flu – TIMELINE]

July 12, 2022 – 21st Century crimes against humanity by Doug Brodie – READ

  • Guest writer shares his diligent research and well-referenced opinions on COVID and climate change agendas.

The post Doug Brodie’s Collective Works first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
Artificial Intelligence (AI) https://totalityofevidence.com/artificial-intelligence-ai/ Thu, 29 Feb 2024 05:32:44 +0000 https://totalityofevidence.com/?p=46316 Artificial Intelligence (AI) or Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) technology has been brewing for quite a while, and used successfully in many applications, but in 2022 the new era of AI was no longer hidden. This page is a timeline that…

The post Artificial Intelligence (AI) first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
Artificial Intelligence (AI) or Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) technology has been brewing for quite a while, and used successfully in many applications, but in 2022 the new era of AI was no longer hidden. This page is a timeline that traces back through some AI milestones, and will be updated with current information as time permits.

At the 2023 World Economic Forum annual meeting in Davos, the guests were introduced to just how far AI technology had advanced, with the promotion of ChatGPT , a chatbot powered by Artificial Intelligence. AI is highly useful and can be applied to almost any modern technology application, BUT it can be programmed to be biased and CONTROL the information or outcomes, all of which has far reaching consequences for our freedoms.

Some noteworthy new era AI technology milestones:

  • Nov 30, 2022 – OpenAI launched chatbot called ChatGPT
  • Feb 6, 2023 – Google launched chatbot called Bard (later rebrands Gemini)
  • Dec 6, 2023 – Google launched Gemini to the public

Other notes:

  • “Artificial Intelligence” at Wikipedia is padlock-protected content! – HERE
  • AI powers transhumanism merger of man and machine, Joe Allen reports – HERE

This page will collect but a snapshot of AI content, it is helping me to understand what is going on, maybe it will for your too. I adding content about Sam Altman‘s history leading up to his Universal Basic Income inspired Worldcoin, iris Orb scanner, digital ID company as well.

Links in reverse chronological order

This content is continuously being updated

2025

February 6, 2025 – News.com.au: AUSTRALIA: Federal mandatory sentences for terror offences, displaying hate symbols in new hate crimes law pass – READ, The Highwire – CREDIT [Problem, Reaction, Government “Solution” – HERE]

  • CNN:Australia introduces mandatory jail time for hate crimes following surge in antisemitism – READ

February 4, 2025 – CNN: Google erases promise not ot use AI technology for weapons or surveillance – READ, READ, The Highwire – CREDIT

  • “Google’s updated, public AI ethics policy removes its promise that it won’t use the technology to pursue applications for weapons and surveillance” – Wayback Machine captures previous – ARCHIVE

January 21, 2025 – PRESS CONVERNECE: President Trump—Flanked By Larry Ellison, Sam Altman, & Masayoshi Son—Announces Project Stargate, a major new AI initiative – WATCH, Celia Faber – CREDIT, TIMELINE

  • The Inventor of the mRNA Technology, Dr. Robert Malone, Reacts to “Project StarGate” — “I am Blown away…” – “The logic of what Mr Ellison is promoting here is grossly naive” – WATCH, TWEET
  • Greg Reese – A.I. Grid and mRNA Shots Announced on Trump’s 2nd Day in Office – TWEET
  • Bannons War Room Ep 4214: The Rise Of AI Instead Of DEI – WATCH,
    Noor Bin Ladin: “Apparently Now Just Like Bill Gates, Larry Ellison Is A Doctor” – EXCERPT
    Joe Allen Breaks Down The Horrific Implications Of Stargate AI – EXCERPT
  • Jefferery Jaxen: Oracle’s Larry Ellison Pitches mRNA Cancer Jabs During Trump’s First Presser as President – Public Recoils – READ
  • Dr Malone: AI, mRNA, Cancer Vaccines and “Stargate” – Reality check. Curb your enthusiasm, and beware of grifters – READ

January 21, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: President Trump Launches $500 Billion AI Initiative ‘Project Stargate’ – READ

  • “Project Stargate,” a monumental $500 billion investment in artificial intelligence (AI) infrastructure. – a joint collaborative effort with industry titans OpenAI, SoftBank Group Corp., and Oracle Corp., aiming to establish state-of-the-art data centers and related infrastructure projects across the nation.

2024

January 15, 2025 – Tucker Carlson: Mother of Likely Murdered OpenAI Whistleblower Reveals All, Calls for Investigation of Sam Altman – WATCH

  • Suchir Balaji worked as an engineer for Sam Altman building AI, until he decided that Altman was committing crimes. Balaji became a whistleblower, and soon after was found dead in his apartment. California authorities claim it was suicide. Crime scene photos clearly show a murder. Balaji’s mother, Poornima Ramarao, tells the most shocking story we’ve heard in a long time.”
  • “In October [2024], the New York Times published an interview with Mr Balaji in which he alleged that OpenAI had violated US copyright law while developing its popular ChatGPT online chatbot.” – REF
  • December 13, 2024 – BBC: OpenAI whistleblower found dead in San Francisco apartment – READ, Tech Crunch – READ, Mercury News – READ
  • Reports by MSN – READ, IB Times – READ

April 3, 2024 – Technocracy News: Trilateral Commissioner Larry Summers, OpenAI Board Member, Says All Labor Will Be ReplacedREAD, OpenAI’s NEW SHOCKING Statement On AI – WATCH, Leo Hohmann – “…gets scant attention from corporate mainstream media” – READ

  • “With the immediate release of my The Genesis of Modern Globalization (1978-1979), the first in a series of three, Professor Antony Sutton and I [Patrick Wood] lay out all of the details of the Trilateral Commission’s early plans to take over the world.”
  • Larry Summers recently became a member of OpenAI’s board of directors. He has membership in the Trilateral Commission (TC), the Council on Foreign Relations, has previously served in the Clinton and Obama administrations, and former US Treasury Secretary
  • Summer’s “friendship” with Jeffrey Epstein started before he became Harvard University President, both served on TC together. Epstein donated $30M to Harvard (2003 article).
  • “Summers will undoubtedly get on board with Altman’s plan for Universal Basic Income (UBI), a concept of historic Technocracy from the 1930s. UBI is a stipend paid to all who have no useful purpose in life.”

March 24, 2024 – Fortune Magazine: Larry Summers, now an OpenAI board member, thinks AI could replace ‘almost all’ forms of labor. Just don’t expect a ‘productivity miracle’ anytime soon – READ, ARCHIVE, Fox News: AI threatenes US job growth – READ

“If one takes a view over the next generation, this could be the biggest thing that has happened in economic history since the Industrial Revolution… This offers the prospect of not replacing some forms of human labor, but almost all forms of human labor.

Larry Summers to Fortune’s Innovation Forum in Hong Kong

February 29, 2024 – Public Substack: Google CEO Pledged To Use AI To Counter “Fake News,” Racism, And Populism After Trump Victory – but Google’s bias has been on public display since August 2017… – READ

February 28, 2024 – The Economist: Is Google’s Gemini chatbot woke by accident, or by design? “It all STARTED with black Vikings and Asian Nazis” – READ, The Guardian – READ, NBC News- READ

February 27, 2024 – Mel K with Google Whistleblower Zach Vorhies – The Truth About Google: Seeing Beyond the Grand Illusion – WATCH

  • Google’s Gemini is erasing history and “white” image bias! – EXCERPT

February 22, 2024 – CNBC: Google pauses Gemini AI image generator after it created inaccurate historical pictures – READ, Reuters – READ

February 8, 2024 – The Highwire Ep 358: THE DAWN OF AUGMENTED HUMANITY – WATCH, FULL

  • “With Elon Musk announcing the first human has had his Neuralink device implanted in their brain, we do a deep dive into the history of implantable technology. From its CIA and military roots to the current developers whose shocking admissions should cause us all to pause

February 8, 2024 – Reuters: Google rebrands Bard chatbot as Gemini, rolls out paid subscription – READ

  • U.S. customers can subscribe for $19.99 a month to access Gemini Advanced, which includes a more powerful Ultra 1.0 AI model, with two terabytes of cloud storage – called Google One AI Premium plan

January 16, 2024 – Vaccine Confidence Project (VCP): Generative artificial intelligence can have a role in combating vaccine hesitancy (paper) by Heidi Larson etal – READ, VCP – TIMELINE

January 15, 2024 – Reuters: Microsoft offers $20 consumer AI subscription to Copilot Pro to boost business – READ

January 9, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: AI Justice: England and Wales Authorize Judges To Use Artificial Intelligence To Produce Rulings – now the implications for our civil liberties are impossible to dismiss – READ

2023

December 7, 2023 – The Verge: Google’s Bard chatbot is getting way better thanks to [being powered by] Gemini Pro – READ

December 7, 2023 – The Verge: Google launches Gemini, the AI model it hopes will take down GPT-4 – a year into the AI era brought on by ChatGPT, [Google is] finally making a big move – READ

  • Gemini is Google’s latest large language model, which Pichai first teased at the I/O developer conference in June 2023, but is now launching to the public
  • Google’s DeepMind CEO Demis Hassabis “it’s a huge leap forward in an AI model that will ultimately affect practically all of Google’s products

December 6, 2023 – Google Blog: Introducing Gemini: our largest and most capable AI model – READ

  • Gemini 1.0 is now rolling out across a range of products and platforms – READ
  • A new era of AI at Google, the Gemini era sasy Google CEO Sundar Pichai
  • There are: Gemini Nano, Gemini Pro, Gemini Ultra

November 22, 2023- Fortune magazine: Larry Summers, who more and more thinks ‘ChatGPT is coming for the cognitive class,’ just joined OpenAI’s board to seal Sam Altman’s triumphant comeback – ARCHIVE

November 22, 2023 – Reuters: Sam Altman to return as OpenAI CEO after his tumultuous ouster – READ

  • He then “bought in new Directors who would be more amenable to his plans to conquer the world….Enter Larry Summers, member of the Trilateral Commission and new member of OpenAI’s Board of Directors!” – REF

November 19, 2023 – Guardian: Sam Altman ‘was working on new venture’ before sacking from OpenAI – READ

  • The Verge: New CEO is Twitch co-founder Emmett Shear, the 3rd in just a few days – READ

November 18, 2023 – The Verge: Sam Altman fired as CEO of OpenAI -President and co-founder Greg Brockman has also quit – READ, Sputnick International – READ, What happened? – READ, CNN: internal investigation found that Altman was not always truthful with the board – READ

November 17, 2023 – OpenAI: OpenAI announces leadership transition – READ

August 8, 2023 – The Street: OpenAI CEO Sam Altman’s latest venture under fire for privacy concerns – Altman is not content with changing the internet. He wants to change the world – READ, CREDIT

  • Sam Altman “another tech entrepreneur intent on ushering in a new era of civilization…he’s interested in the creation and implementation of artificial intelligence.” Working on “artificial general intelligence (AGI), or AI that is generally smarter than humans.” OpenAI mission is “to build and deploy AGI in order to benefit all of humanity”!
  • “He has another venture, one that ties together AI and cryptocurrency in a new firm with lofty goals and privacy risks possibly more severe than those posed by his AI models: Worldcoin.” The idea of Worldcoin is twofold:
    • First, the company wanted to find a way to verify humanity in a world that is already teeming with AI bots. It’s achieving this through a piece of tech called the Orb, which scans people’s irises and converts those scans into a string of numeric code. 
    • Second, in a world that is already threatened by explosive AI-driven job loss, Worldcoin is intent on providing universal basic income to its users. …the company’s goal is to scan every human on Earth
  • WorldCoin.org launched June 2021 with footnote “Tools for Humanity Corp” – ARCHIVES, ARCHIVE
    • Tools for Humanity are “building tools for Worldcoin and beyond” and are “Founded in 2019 by Alex Blania (CEO) and Sam Altman (Chairman).” – READ

August 3, 2023 – Time Magazine: What to Know About Worldcoin and the Controversy Around It – READ

August 2, 2023 – Kenya Press Release – TWEET, Kenya became the first country to suspend Worldcoin’s activities and its government launched a multi-agency investigation into the project’s practices – Time Magazine – READ, CREDIT

July 31, 2023 – Robert Malone Substack: A Conversation with Chat GPT re Population Control- and the lies an AI will tell to protect US Government policy – READ

July 24, 2023 – Reuters: OpenAI’s Sam Altman launches Worldcoin crypto project – READ, Worldcoin’s cryptocurrency token (WLD) – READ, CREDIT – CoinMarketCap – GRAPH

  • “The project’s core offering is its World ID, which the company describes as a “digital passport” to prove that its holder is a real human, not an AI bot. To get a World ID, a customer signs up to do an in-person iris scan using Worldcoin’s ‘orb’, a silver ball approximately the size of a bowling ball. Once the orb’s iris scan verifies the person is a real human, it creates a World ID.”

May 17, 2023 – CBS News: Sen. Richard Blumenthal kicked off a Senate hearing on artificial intelligence with introductory remarks generated by AI. He said the words used in the recording were created by ChatGPT and the audio came from an AI voice-cloning software – WATCH at Judiciary Subcommittee on Privacy, Technology and the Law

March 27, 2023 – Summit News: ChatGPT Jokes About Jesus Being ‘Nailed to a Board’, Refuses to Crack Joke About Muhammad – Another example of woke bias revealed – ARCHIVE

March 31, 2023 – Independent: ChatGPT now banned in Italy – READ, CREDIT

February 13, 2023 – CNET: AI Is Speeding Us Toward Intelligent Computers and the Singularity, Says John Hennessy, a Silicon Valley pioneer and former Stanford president, says AI progress is “stunning.” – READ

  • The “singularity” — that ordinary humans will someday be overtaken by artificially intelligent machines or cognitively enhanced biological intelligence, or both — has moved from the realm of science fiction to serious debate.” – REF

February 12, 2023 – Daily Mail: The nine shocking replies that highlight ‘woke’ ChatGPT’s inherent bias — including struggling to define a woman, praising Democrats but not Republicans and saying nukes are less dangerous than racism – READ, Daily Mail – READ

February 10, 2023 – Reuters: Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates: ChatGPT ‘will change our world’ – “Until now, artificial intelligence could read and write, but could not understand the content…” – READ

February 8, 2023 – The Verge: Microsoft’s ChatGPT-powered Bing is open for everyone to try starting today – READ

February 7, 2023 – The Verge: It’s official: Google is working on a ChatGPT competitor named Bard READ

  • “Google is working on a competitor to OpenAI’s chatbot ChatGPT. The ‘experimental conversational AI service’ is called Bard and is only being tested by a limited group”

February 6, 2023 – Google blog: An important next step on our AI journey – Introducing Bard to early testers- READ, DiscloseTV – READ, The Verge – READ, CNET – READ

  • Two years ago we unveiled next-generation language and conversation capabilities powered by our Language Model for Dialogue Applications (or LaMDA for short). Bard is an experimental conversational AI service, powered by LaMDA. Today opening it up to trusted testers ahead of making it more widely available to the public in the coming weeks.
  • “Bard seeks to combine the breadth of the world’s knowledge with the power, intelligence and creativity of our large language models. It draws on information from the web to provide fresh, high-quality responses.”

February 8, 2023 – NY Times: Microsoft integrated powerful A.I. technology into its search engine Bing READ

  • NY Times: Bing Won’t Stop Declaring Its Love for Me – READ

January 28, 2023 – NY Post: How woke ChatGPT’s ‘built-in ideological bias’ could do more harm than good – political bias – READ

  • “OpenAI hasn’t denied any of the allegations of bias, but Sam Altman, the company’s CEO and ChatGPT co-creator, explained on Twitter that what seems like censorship “is in fact us trying to stop it from making up random facts.”

January 25, 2023 – NY Post: ChatGPT could make these jobs obsolete: ‘The wolf is at the door’ – READ

  • Some of the jobs sectors most vulnerable to the fast-learning, ever-evolving technology could include Education , Finance, Software engineering, Journalism and Graphic design

January 23, 2023 – CNBC: Microsoft announces new multibillion-dollar investment in ChatGPT-maker OpenAI – READ, NY Post “making a “multiyear, multibillion dollar investment” – READ, WSJ – READ,
MS already invested $1B in July 2019

January 20, 2023 – J of Social Sciences: The Political Biases of ChatGPT by David Rozado – READ, Extended analysis – READ

January 19, 2023 – Axios: ChatGPT is the talk of Davos – ARCHIVE

  • “Forget crypto and blockchain: The tech conversation at this year’s World Economic Forum in Davos is all about the rise of artificial intelligence, particularly the text-generator ChatGPT”
  • “Concerns range from the inevitable flood of AI-generated misinformation to the biases baked into systems that have been trained on real-world data that’s filled with stereotypes and dominated by rich countries.”

January 5, 2023 – WSJ: ChatGPT Creator Is Talking to Investors About Selling Shares at $29 Billion Valuation – Tender offer at that valuation would make OpenAI one of the most valuable U.S. startups – READ, CREDIT

2022

December 22, 2022 – Cnet: ChatGPT Caused ‘Code Red’ at Google, Report Says – ChatGPT can deliver direct answers quickly, not pages of endless links. That’s reportedly scaring Google – READ, NY Times – READ, CREDIT

December 9, 2022 – The Verge: ChatGPT proves AI is finally mainstream – and things are only going to get weirder –READ

December 6, 2022 – The Telegraph: Meet ChatGPT, the scarily intelligent robot who can do your job better than you – OpenAI’s chatbot proves the gap between computers and humans is rapidly narrowing – READ

December 5, 2022 – David Rozado Substack: The political orientation of the ChatGPT AI system –Applying Political Typology Quizes to a state-of-the-art AI Language model – READ

  • By administering 15 political orientation tests to ChatGPT … answers to their questions as manifesting a preference for left-leaning viewpoints.

November 30, 2022 – Sam Altman X: OpenAI launch ChatGPT – TWEET, and reach 1 million users in 5 days – TWEET, ARCHIVE,

  • Zero Hedge: apparently the legacy news outlets were slow to report on the decade’s biggest tech story – READ

November 30, 2022 – OpenAI: Introducing ChatGPT: Optimizing Language Models for Dialogue – We are excited to introduce ChatGPT to get users’ feedback and learn about its strengths and weaknesses – READ, ARCHIVE

  • “We’ve trained a model called ChatGPT which interacts in a conversational way. The dialogue format makes it possible for ChatGPT to answer followup questions, admit its mistakes, challenge incorrect premises, and reject inappropriate requests.”
  • ChatGPT can currently be accessed for free here: https://chat.openai.com/chat

October 31, 2022 – Worldcoin Whitepaper: Worldcoin Foundation was “established as the non-profit steward of the Worldcoin protocol, supporting and growing the ecosystem until it becomes self-sufficient” – ARCHIVE, WIRED- CREDIT

  • ” To both trial its technology and scale its user base, Worldcoin conducted initial field tests across 27 countries—from Norway and Chile, to Kenya and Sudan. A team of independent contractors, called Orb Operators, who were paid a commission for each iris scanned, notched up hundreds of thousands of signups. 14 of the trial nations are classified as developing, per WorldBank.” – REF

Worldcoin Whitepaper: A New Identity and Financial Network – Introducing Worldcoin – ARCHIVE

  • “Worldcoin was founded with the mission of creating a globally-inclusive identity and financial network, owned by the majority of humanity. If successful, Worldcoin could considerably increase economic opportunity, scale a reliable solution for distinguishing humans from AI online while preserving privacy, enable global democratic processes, and show a potential path to AI-funded UBI [Universal Basic Income]….“Proof of personhood” is one of the core ideas behind Worldcoin:
  • Proof of Personhood (PoP) – “For high-stakes use cases such as global UBI, the democratic governance of AI and the Worldcoin project, a highly secure and inclusive PoP mechanism to prevent multiple registrations is needed.” – ARCHIVE
    • Iris biometrics outperform other biometric modalities … [and is] several orders of magnitude more accurate than the current state of the art in face recognition. Moreover, the structure of the iris exhibits remarkable stability over time”..”the iris is hard to modify”. [Think protocol for Digital ID/CBDC]
    • “Based on the conclusion that the only path to verify uniqueness on a global scale is iris biometrics, Tools for Humanity built a custom biometric device, called the Orb. This device issues an AI-safe PoP credential called World ID” Fig3
“Iris biometrics stands out as the most reliable and accurate method for verification of humanness and uniqueness on a global scale” – source
World ID Proof of Personhood digital wallet for Gov ID – source

April 2, 2022 – MIT Tech Review: Deception, exploited workers, and cash handouts: How Worldcoin recruited its first half a million test users – he startup promises a fairly-distributed, cryptocurrency-based universal basic income. So far all it’s done is build a biometric database from the bodies of the poor – READ, CREDIT

  • “Our investigation revealed wide gaps between Worldcoin’s public messaging, which focused on protecting privacy, and what users experienced. We found that the company’s representatives used deceptive marketing practices, collected more personal data than it acknowledged, and failed to obtain meaningful informed consent

2021

October 22, 2021 – Edward Snowden Tweet: Warns about the ORB iris scan connected to Worldcoin – TWEET, CREDIT

This looks like it produces a global (hash) database of people’s iris scans (for “fairness”), and waves away the implications by saying “we deleted the scans!”

Yeah, but you save the *hashes* produced by the scans. Hashes that match *future* scans.

Don’t catalogue eyeballs.

Edward Snowden TWEET

October 22, 2021 – Biz Journal | Silicon Valley Business Journal: The Funded: Sam Altman new $1B startup is aiming for global adoption of its new cryptocurrency – READ WorldCoin.

  • “How does one deliver cryptocurrency to the masses? By handing out free digital cash to anyone who gets their eyeballs scanned with a silver orb. That’s the premise of Worldcoin, a new startup from Sam Altman, the former president of startup accelerator Y Combinator.”
  • “The San Francisco company, legally known as Tools for Humanity Corp., has developed an ethereum-based cryptocurrency … It’s aiming to have 1 billion users of its digital money by 2023″

October 21, 2021 – CNBC: Silicon Valley entrepreneur Sam Altman wants to scan your eyes in exchange for free cryptocurrency – READ , Sam Altman introduce Worldcoin – TWEET, Worldcoin launched out of “stealth” on Oct 21, 2021, Altman’s other company. Origins of Worldcoin – READ, Tools for Humanity the scanning ORB for “Verifying proof of humanness in the age of AI” – READ

  • Tech millionaire Sam Altman’s new start-up Worldcoin uses orb-shaped devices to scan people’s eyes in exchange for free cryptocurrency!… “Worldcoin promises to hand out free cryptocurrency to people who verify their accounts by taking an iris scan”
  • A metallic orbs that scan people’s eyes – Iris scan “It’s the most secure and privacy-preserving way we found to prove everyone in the world is unique.” said Blania,
  • Worldcoin aim [bit didn’t] to hit 1 billion users by 2023, with 100K users globally at this date – “free money” lures in the unsuspecting. Less than 3% population are crypto users.
  • Worldcoin CEO Alex Blania hinted Worldcoin could be used as “infrastructure” for a universal basic income one day.
WorldCoin – Iris ID scan, Digital Passport, Crypto Universal Basic Income infrastructure –source

June 30, 2021 – The Verge: GitHub and OpenAI launch a new AI tool called Copilot that autocompletes code snippets – Copilot is a virtual coder working alongside a human coder – READ

  • “This project is the first major result of Microsoft’s $1 billion investment into OpenAI, the research firm now led by Y Combinator president Sam Altman. Since Altman took the reins, OpenAI has pivoted from a nonprofit status to a “capped-profit” model, took on the Microsoft investment, and started licensing its GPT-3 text-generation algorithm.”
  • GPT-3 is OpenAI’s flagship language-generating algorithm, which can generate text sometimes indistinguishable to human writing.”

June 29, 2021 – Bloomberg: Sam Altman Wants to Scan Your Eyeball in Exchange for Cryptocurrency, the first report of Worldcoin and the Orb iris scanner after after Bloomberg uncovered details of it and inquired – READ, ARCHIVE, CREDIT

  • Former President of Silicon Valley accelerator Y Combinator, Sam Altman (36 yrs old) is one of three founders of the company Worldcoin, said he conceived Worldcoin idea in late 2019. “The head of the venture is Alexander Blania, 27, a former student of theoretical physics at the California Institute of Technology and the Max Planck Society.” Also Max Novendstern
  • “Worldcoin company is backed by Andreessen Horowitz, the venture capital arm of Coinbase Global Inc., LinkedIn founder Reid Hoffman and Day One Ventures. It recently raised about $25 million from investors”.
  • The intention was to use cryptocurrency to spread money around equitably, inspired by the trendy economic theory known as universal basic income. Altman was the first investor in Worldcoin but said he has no role in day-to-day operations and mainly serves as an adviser to the company when needed.” [UBI is an historic Technocracy concept from 1932]

“I’ve been very interested in things like universal basic income and what’s going to happen to global wealth redistribution and how we can do that better,” …“Is there a way we can use technology to do that at global scale?”

Sam Altman
  • “According to Blania, iris-scanning is an essential part of the plan because it can prevent people from trying to register multiple times to defraud the system. He’s also aware of the privacy implications of handing over biometric information to a tiny startup and said Worldcoin will make the process as transparent as possible so user scan see how the data is used.
  • Blania said the iris scan will produce a unique numerical code for each person and that the image is then deleted and never stored.” [The very point Ed Snowden warns about, a tracking hash code – TWEET]

“So many people around the world don’t have access to financial systems yet,” … “Crypto has the opportunity to get us there.”

Alexander Blania [start with the developing countries as they do with “health”. See more Digital ID]

2020

December 3, 2020 – WhiteHouse | Infrastructure & Technology (Trump): Executive Order on Promoting the Use of Trustworthy Artificial Intelligence in the Federal Government – ARCHIVE

2019

August 14, 2019 – Project Veritas: Google “Machine Learning Fairness” Whistleblower [Zach Vorhies] Goes Public, says: “burden lifted off of my soul” – WATCH, ARCHIVE, The Highwire Ep 149 – WATCH

July 22, 2019- The Verge: Microsoft invests $1 billion in OpenAI to pursue holy grail of artificial intelligence – READ

  • “OpenAI, a San Francisco-based research lab founded by Silicon Valley luminaries, including Elon Musk and Sam Altman, that’s dedicated to creating artificial general intelligence (AGI).
  • The investment will make Microsoft the “exclusive” provider of cloud computing services to OpenAI, and the two companies will work together to develop new technologies”

July 22, 2019 – Microsoft: OpenAI forms exclusive computing partnership with Microsoft to build new Azure AI supercomputing technologies – $1 billion from MicrosoftREAD

  • OpenAI’s mission is to ensure that artificial general intelligence benefits all of humanity. The OpenAI Charter describes the principles that guide it as it executes on this mission.

June 13, 2019 – House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence: open hearing on the national security challenges of artificial intelligence (AI), manipulated media, and “deepfake” technology and other types of AI-generated synthetic data – WATCH

March 11, 2019 – OpenAI LP, a new “capped-profit” company announced – ARCHIVE

  • Going forward (in this post and elsewhere), “OpenAI” refers to OpenAI LP (which now employs most of our staff), and the original entity is referred to as “OpenAI Nonprofit.”
  • In order to increase the ability to raise capital while still serving our mission, and no pre-existing legal structure we know of strikes the right balance. Our solution is to create OpenAI LP as a hybrid of a for-profit and nonprofit—which we are calling a “capped-profit” company.

March 8, 2019 – Irish Tech News: Sam Altman to step down as President of Y Combinator and become Chairman OpenAI – READ

February 14, 2019 – OpenAI: Better Language Models and Their Implications – READ, Language Models are Unsupervised Multitask LearnersPDF GPT’s are “Learners” where their model is “primed” with “inputs”.

  • GPT-2 (a successor to GPT) is a large transformer-based language model with 1.5 billion parameters, trained on a dataset of 8 million web pages. GPT-2 is trained with a simple objective: predict the next word, given all of the previous words within some text.”
  • Many millions of people were involved in creating the data that GPT-2 was trained on – PDF

February 12, 2019 – US Department of Defense (DoD): Transforming the DoD through AI- Joint Artificial Intelligence Center (JAIC) – ARCHIVE, now Digital and Artificial Intelligence Office (CDAO) – READ

  • Summary of DoD 2018 AI Strategy (Feb 12, 2019) – PDF

February 11, 2019 – Whitehouse: Executive Order 13859 On Maintaining American Leadership in Artificial Intelligence – ARCHIVE, REF

2019 – Tools For Humanity Corporation is launched with co-founders Alex Blania, CEO and Sam Altman, Chairman, and HQ in Germany and USA – It is engaged in building tools for blockchain and economic systems – READ. A project on the go for years before – ARCHIVE

  • By 2021 it launches Worldcoin, a decentralized digital cryptocurrency. The Company distributes free cryptocurrency in exchange for people allowing their eyes to be scanned using their “ORB“, which begins as a volleyball-sized chrome sphere. –REF
  • “built to ensure a more just economic system” ..”We are currently building tools for the Worldcoin project” – Website first live Jan 2023 – ARCHIVE, Not until April 2024 is additional content added to the website!

2018

April 9, 2018 – OpenAI Charter is released – ARCHIVE

  • “This document reflects the strategy we’ve refined over the past two years, including feedback from many people internal and external to OpenAI. The timeline to AGI remains uncertain, but our charter will guide us in acting in the best interests of humanity throughout its development.”

2017

December 12, 2017 Subcommittee on Communications, Technology, Innovation, and the Internet: “Digital Decision-Making: The Building Blocks of Machine Learning and Artificial Intelligence” – READ

May 6, 2017 – OpenAI: Robots that LearnREAD, other research – HERE,

  • “We’ve created a robotics system, trained entirely in simulation and deployment on a physical robot, which can learn a new task after seeing [with a vision system] it done one”

January 29, 2017 -Sam Altman Blog: “Time to Take a Stand” READ, ARCHIVE.

  • “There are many actions from [Trump’s] first week that are objectionable….unsubstantiated conspiracy theories (like the 3 million illegal votes)” [in an election he won!]
  • “The tech community is powerful. Large tech companies in particular have enormous power and are held in high regard. We need to hear from the CEOs clearly and unequivocally….” (re Travel Ban, Atlantic – READ)
    • Silicon Valley “respond” – The Guardian – READ, WoP – READ,
  • Altman links to a website called “Track Trump” which he is a co-founded – ARCHIVE, Track Trump first archived Jan 22, 2017, tracking his first 100 days – ARCHIVE, READ, and comparison to Obama – ARCHIVE

2016

November 30, 2016 – US Senate Committee on Commerce, Science & Transportation: Commerce Announces First Artificial Intelligence Hearing –The Dawn of Artificial Intelligence WATCH, ARCHIVE, Press Release – READ, Testimony – ARCHIVE

  • Mr. Greg Brockman, Cofounder and Chief Technology Officer, OpenAI – Testimony transcript – PDF

October 13, 2016 – White House Frontiers Conference #FutureofAI – ARCHIVE, Obama Speaks – READ

  • discussions with leading experts on harnessing the potential of AI, including data science, machine learning, automation, and robotics to engage and benefit all Americans

AI represents one of history’s biggest advances, on par with books and steam engines

Andrew McAfee, co-director of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Initiative on the Digital Economy

October 12, 2016 – Whitehouse (Obama): The Administration’s Report on the Future of Artificial IntelligenceARCHIVE,

  • The White House Future of Artificial Intelligence initiative held 4 Public Workshops on Artificial Intelligence in addition to requests for information (RFI) in June 2016 and the following White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) reports were released:
    • Preparing for the Future of Artificial Intelligence which surveys the current state of AI, and “focuses on the opportunities, considerations, and challenges of Artificial Intelligence (AI)” – Report – PDF
    • A companion National Artificial Intelligence Research and Development Strategic Plan was also released, “laying out a strategic plan for Federally-funded research and development in AI” – Plan – PDF

October 3, 2016 – Purdue University: Artificial Intelligence: Dawn or Doom Conference – WATCH

  • Professor Jennifer Neville talked about the history and future of artificial intelligence and about machine dialog systems called “Chatbots.” Professor Neville focuses her research on machine learning and data mining.

September 6, 2016 – Medium: Public Input and Next Steps on the Future of Artificial Intelligence – ARCHIVE, (watch videos of AI workshops within)

August 29, 2016 – OpenAI: Infrastructure for Deep LearningREAD

  • Deep learning is an empirical science, and the quality of a group’s infrastructure is a multiplier on progress. Fortunately, today’s open-source ecosystem makes it possible for anyone to build great deep learning infrastructure.
  • Our infrastructure aims to maximize the productivity of deep learning researchers, allowing them to focus on the science

June 21, 2016 – Sam Altman Blog – “Trump” , Sam even mentioned Hitler – READ, ARCHIVE, CREDIT (see Jan 29, 2017)

  • “Trump is right about the problem, but horribly wrong about the solution”…I understand why other people in the technology industry aren’t saying much. In an ordinary election it’s reasonable for people in the business world to remain publicly neutral. But this is not an ordinary election.” [Time] to start speaking up”.
  • At this time Trump was destined to be announced as the Republican candidate for President in 2016 – READ, with record Primary and Caucus voting numbers – READ (I was wondering what was happening with Trump just before Sam’s post)

June 1, 2016 – Tech Crunch: Y Combinator announces basic income pilot experiment in Oakland [i.e. Universal Basic Income] – READ, Y Combinator – READ, CREDIT

  • “Our goal will be to prepare for the longer-term study by working on our methods — how to pay people, how to collect data, how to randomly choose a sample, etc.”
  • January 27, 2016 – Y Combinator Research: The Basic Income Project recruitment – ARCHIVE
  • The “lack of affordable housing, and a potential labor crisis [are] brought on by technological advancements like artificial intelligence and automation” so Y Combinator president Sam Altman is launched the “new initiative to try and create political solutions” and for a vision for guaranteed basic income to survive

May 3, 2016 – Whitehouse (Obama): Preparing for the Future of Artificial Intelligence initiative – announcing a new series of workshops and an inter-agency working group to learn more about the benefits and risks of artificial intelligence – ARCHIVE (workshops listed within May-July 2016)

  • “AI’s influence on the world is growing. The rate of progress we have seen will have broad implications for fields ranging from healthcare to image- and voice-recognition
  • A new National Science and Technology Council (NSTC) Subcommittee on Machine Learning and Artificial Intelligence” met for first time May 2016 – PDF

April 27, 2016 – OpenAI Gym Beta – READ, READ, GYM – HERE, Gym was released in Aug 2016 – REF

  • Gym is a toolkit for developing and comparing reinforcement learning algorithms. It supports teaching agents everything from walking to playing games like Pong or Pinball
  • Reinforcement learning (RL) is the subfield of machine learning concerned with decision making and motor control. It studies how an agent can learn how to achieve goals in a complex, uncertain environment.

2015

December 11, 2015 – Introducing OpenAI – OpenAI is a non-profit artificial intelligence research company… – ARCHIVE, OpenAI’s timeline til March 2019 launch – ARCHIVE, About – READ

  • Artificial general intelligence (AGI) will be the most significant technology ever created by humans” – REF
  • “We publish at top machine learning conferences, open-source software tools for accelerating AI research, and release blog posts to communicate our research.” (2017)
  • “OpenAI’s research director is Ilya Sutskever, one of the world experts in machine learning. Our CTO is Greg Brockman, formerly the CTO of Stripe. The group’s other founding members are world-class research engineers and scientists: Trevor Blackwell, Vicki Cheung, Andrej Karpathy, Durk Kingma, John Schulman, Pamela Vagata, and Wojciech Zaremba. Pieter Abbeel, Yoshua Bengio, Alan Kay, Sergey Levine, and Vishal Sikka are advisors to the group. OpenAI’s co-chairs are Sam Altman and Elon Musk.” – REF
  • “Sam, Greg, Elon, Reid Hoffman, Jessica Livingston, Peter Thiel, Amazon Web Services (AWS), Infosys, and YC Research are donating to support OpenAI. In total, these funders have committed $1 billion
  • Individuals and companies sponsoring OpenAI:
    • Sam Altman
      Greg Brockman
      Reid Hoffman
      Jessica Livingston
      Elon Musk
      Peter Thiel

2014

March 18, 2014 – Vox: Y Combinator’s New Head Startup Whisperer Sam Altman Is Quite a Talker – Meet the guy taking the reins of the influential startup program Y Combinator from its long time leader, Paul Graham – READ Sam was president of the firm from 2014 to 2019.

  • Y Combinator has turned out 630 companies from its biannual classes, including three that are valued in multiple billions of dollars: Dropbox, Airbnb and Stripe. (and Coinbase)
  • “Under Altman, Y Combinator planned experiments on universal basic income that have faced some delays and complications” – REF
  • Stripe was Altman’s first-ever angel investment, and he remains closely involved in the company.” – REF

2012

March 9, 2012 – All Things D: Loopt’s Sam Altman on Why He Sold to Green Dot for $43.4M – READ, CREDIT

  • “After Loopt, Altman helped Green Dot launch a mobile banking product, then split time between helping out at Y Combinator and some explorations into energy startups”

2008

June 10, 2008 – Apple’s WWDC 2008: Sam Altman Loopt shows off new app for the iPhone – WATCH, CREDIT

2005

September 2005 – LOOPT began: Sam Altman at aged 19, dropped out of Stanford as a sophomore computer science major and started Loopt which “transforms your mobile phone into a social compass” AKA a tracking service – ARCHIVE, WIKIPEDIA, History, Launched in 2006 – ARCHIVE, Sold 2012, Bloomberg – CREDIT

  • The start up received received initial funding from Y Combinator and initial $5 million from Sequoia Capital and New Enterprise Associates [$17M in total]. They initially moved into “Sequoia’s incubation space where they shared office space with the YouTube team…” – REF
  • Board of directors include NEA’s Patrick Chung, a Canadian? who also heads genetic databank 23andMe. He is a Harvard graduate, went to Oxford University and previously worked for McKinsey & Company (who are used by United Nations and WEF)- ARCHIVE, Other Loopt Board members – ARCHIVE
  • “Altman rose from being the 19-year-old founder of a middling social network called Loopt to becoming a startup kingmaker at Y Combinator. He was president of the firm from 2014 to 2019, during which some of the accelerator’s companies, including  Airbnb Inc., Dropbox Inc. and Stripe Inc., became some of the most valuable startups in America.”
  • While at Stanford, Altman worked in their AI lab – REF
  • Dorm mate Blake Ross [FB, Mozilla] told Sam about Y Combinator – REF

The post Artificial Intelligence (AI) first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
Climate Change cont… https://totalityofevidence.com/climate-change-cont/ Sun, 04 Feb 2024 01:31:23 +0000 https://totalityofevidence.com/?p=44864 This page is a continuation from Climate Change – PAGE 1 This page will continue collecting information regarding the man-made Climate Change narrative. Some useful resources are below: The “population control” link to the climate narrative is becoming more obvious…

The post Climate Change cont… first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
This page is a continuation from Climate ChangePAGE 1

This page will continue collecting information regarding the man-made Climate Change narrative. Some useful resources are below:

  • Climate Change on Trial podcast re Mann v Steyn – HERE
  • Timeline of Failed Climate Predictions (search by eg Al Gore, IPCC etc) – HERE
  • Watts Up With That (climate news and analysis) – HERE
  • Climate View News – Tracking the Climate Changers (by Jim Peel) – HERE

The “population control” link to the climate narrative is becoming more obvious and they have many means of making this their reality – Food wars, land grabs, legal euthanasia, sterilisation…

Links in reverse chronological order

2025

[Watch the Narrative shift from Jan 2025 – Since Artificial Intelligence requires more power than “green energy” can produce, “fossil fuels” will be required to power this new frontier! Mr Global has to now shape the narrative to allow the emitting of CO2! They can’t hold Trump back from his “drill baby drill” energy dominance agenda, so they have to re-direct the fossil fuel narrative, or Mr Global will MI$$ out! – IMO]

March 5, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: Biden Regime and John Podesta Gave BILLIONS to Environmental Charity Led by Democrats that Was Founded Only 5 Months Earlier and Received $7 BillionREAD

  • Former Vice President Kamala Harris handed over a taxpayer-funded government check for $7 billion to Climate United Fund in April 2024 [after submitting a 49-page plan]….”Climate United Fund, a non-profit organization, had only been incorporated in Delaware since November 30, 2023, just five months earlier”… the “Climate United Fund does not appear in the IRS’s charities database, and has no federal filings”
  • Feb 3, 2024 – Daily Caller: You’ll Never Guess Who Biden Just Picked to Replace John Kerry as Top Climate Diplomat – John Podesta – READ, Politico – READ
  • March 5, 2025 – NY Post: “$375B EPA slush fund handled by John Podesta [ex Hillary Clinton campaign manager] gave billions to charities founded only months earlier.” – SOURCE
  • [Remember the Wiki Leaks John Podesta Emails? – READ]

March 3, 2025 – Bloomberg via Watts up with That: The “Clean Energy” Collapse: Hedge Fund Manager Declares the Obvious – READ

  • “It’s finally happening. After years of government subsidies, media cheerleading, and financial markets propping up a house of cards, a hedge fund manager has come forward to say what many of us have known all along: the so-called clean energy sector is “dead for now.”” Nishant Gupta, founder and chief investment officer at London-based Kanou Capital LLP
  • “This marks a turning point—when even those inside the financial world, who have long played along with the green energy narrative, admit that the numbers simply don’t add up.”

March 3, 2025 – Global Research: 1900 Scientists Say ‘Climate Change Not Caused by CO2’ – The Real Environment Movement Was Hijacked READ, Dr Merly Nass – CREDIT, More BOOKS

  • CLINTEL – World Climate Declaration – There is no climate emergencyREAD
  • “The World Climate Declaration (WCD) has brought a large variety of competent scientists together from all over the world*. The considerable knowledge and experience of this group is indispensable in reaching a balanced, dispassionate and competent view of climate change.”
    • Natural as well as anthropogenic factors cause warming
    • Warming is far slower than predicted
    • Climate policy relies on inadequate model
    • CO2 is plant food, the basis of all life on Earth
    • Global warming has not increased natural disasters
    • Climate policy must respect scientific and economic realities
Climate CO2 Hoax – How Bankers Hijacked the Environment Movement – by Mark Keenan, a former scientist at the UK Government Dept. of Energy and Climate Change, and at United Nations Environment.” – “many scientists dispute with the UN-promoted man-made climate change theory” – BOOK
Transcending the Climate Change Deception – Toward Real Sustainability – “This book demolishes the UN-promoted climate change hysteria and provides evidence and testimony from renowned and distinguished climate scientists that the climate does not change due to carbon emission or methane” – BOOK
Demonic Economics and the Tricks of the Bankers
Demonic Economics and the Tricks of the Bankers (Published April 2023) – BOOK

February 16, 2025 – Robert Malone Substack: Global Warming and Air Pollution – I guess “The Science” ™ isn’t so settled after all. – READ

  • The year 2023 was so much warmer than expected…
  • “The Washington Post story hypes these new studies that suggest a counter narrative to CO2 causing global warming as just accounting for the last two years of increased global temperatures (on average). But this is not actually what these new papers show.”
  • AI has calculated that over half a trillion dollars of tax payer money has been spent on the Climate “problem” since it was identified. …”a problem that mainstream scientists now admit most likely isn’t caused by all the “usual suspects.””!!!

February 15, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: BREAKING NEWS! Trump Unleashes the Oil Battle: Reverses Biden’s Ban and opening over 625 million acres for oil and gas drilling and exploration! – READ, WATCH

February 14, 2025 – Breitbart New: Trump by Executive Order Establishes National Energy Dominance Council – Secretary of the Interior Doug Burgum will chair the council, while Energy Secretary Chris Wright will be the vice chairman – READ, Gateway Pundit – CREDIT, TWEET

  • “During Trump’s first term, he made America energy independent. Now he is moving to make America energy dominant. This is the key to a thriving economy. This is the key to bringing down inflation. This will make life more affordable for millions of Americans” – REF
  • “The Council will advise President Trump on strategies to achieve energy dominance by improving the processes for permitting, production, generation, distribution, regulation, and transportation across all forms of American energy”

“This is a big deal. We have more energy than any other country, and now we’re unleashing it, to put it nicely,”

Trump said ahead of signing the order. 

February 7, 2025 – CNN: How a ‘cow fart’ vaccine could help tackle climate changeREAD

  • Climate Depot: Morano on Fox on the absurdity of climate inspired ‘cow fart vaccine’ – Warns Bill Gates pushing lab-grown meat & eating bugs – WATCH

February 1, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: California’s Obsession with Electric Vehicles (EVs) Is Turning Neighborhoods Into Minefields – READ, EV Magazine – READ

  • Damaged lithium ion batteries found in electric vehicles from fire-damaged areas in Califorina pose a unique cleanup challenge and expose “critical gaps in disaster response & environmental safety protocols”…”adding a layer of complexity to an already daunting task.”
  • “The situation in Los Angeles serves as a wake-up call for other regions with high EV adoption rates. It demonstrates the need to improve infrastructure and protocols to handle EV batteries in various scenarios, from everyday recycling to disaster response. As the world transitions to cleaner transportation, addressing these challenges will be crucial to ensuring that unforeseen consequences do not overshadow the environmental benefits of EVs in times of crisis.” ! – REF
  • November 18, 2019 – California EPA: California Lithium-ion Car Battery Recycling Advisory Group | Meeting #1 – WATCH

January 31, 2025 – Politico: USDA ordered to scrub climate change from websites – READ, Gateway Pundit- CREDIT

  • Reminder: “On December 3, 2024, Project Veritas released a video showing a top EPA advisor telling the undercover reporter that they are funneling billions to Climate Organizations as an ‘Insurance Policy’ against President Trump…“We’re Throwing Gold Bars off the Titanic…”-TWEET, REF
  • “Well, as an insurance policy against unsettled science, President Trump has issued an order to the USDA, telling them that they are to remove all climate change “propaganda from their websites “no later than close of business day on Friday (31st).”” –REF
  • January 29, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: USDA Inspector General Physically Removed by Security After Refusing to Comply with Her Firing …”Fong was responsible for audits, evaluations, investigations, and law enforcement efforts relating to USDA’s programs and operations. But she ultimately failed in this mission.” – READ

January 29, 2025 – Federal Highway Administration | Press Release: Sean Duffy Sworn In as Secretary of U.S. Department of Transportation and Takes Immediate Action to Make Cars More Affordable – READ, Gateway Pundit: Sledgehammer taken to Biden’s ‘De Facto EV Mandate’ – First Act in Office – CREDIT

  • US Dept of Transport memorandum Fixing the Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) Standards program – PDF
  • March 21, 2024 – Western Journal: Trump Campaign Blasts Biden’s New ‘Extreme Electric Vehicle Mandate,’ Promises ‘Day One’ Reversal – READ

January 20, 2025 – By Executive Order on the Day of his Inauguration, President Trump WITHDRAWS from the Paris Climate Treaty, saving over a trillion dollars – WATCH

2024

December 2024 – via Wide Awak Media: Award-winning journalist Alex Newman delivers a PERFECT 90 second summary of the climate scam – WATCH

December 4, 20224 – Project Veritas: BREAKING: @EPA Advisor Admits ‘Insurance Policy’ Against Trump is Funneling Billions to Climate Organizations, “We’re Throwing Gold Bars off the Titanic” “It was an insurance policy against Trump winning.” – TWEET

November 15, 2024 – IntelliNews: President of Azerbaijan roasts the West for double standards as COP29 goes off the rails – READ, BACKUP, Climate Depot – READ

  • “Emissions are currently at an all-time high and the UN warns that with current policies, the world is on track to see a “catastrophic” 3.1C increase in temperatures by the 2050 deadline, according to United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) climate models.” [models that have never got it right – WATCH]
    • “Concentrations of CO2, methane and nitrous oxide climbed to record levels in the global atmosphere in 2023, contributing ever more to the climate crisis. This is according to scientists from the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).” – READ

November 11, 2024 – COP29 Opens in Baku with Breakthrough on Global Carbon Markets – READ, COP20 official – WEB

  • Parties reach consensus on standards for the creation of carbon credits under Article 6.4 of the Paris Agreement, in sign of early momentum.
  • [Carbon Credits are new trillion dollar commodity market for the elites, charging “polluters” (i.e. tax payers) who still need energy. This is not about helping the environment – WATCH, ARCHIVE]

November 11-22, 2024 – The 29th session of the Conference of the Parties of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (COP29)- OFFICIAL, UN Official – HERE

September 15, 2024 -News.com.au: Shrinking island, vanishing polar bears — the climate scare stories that turn out to be falseREAD

  • “The one constant: a fixation on scaring the public, which has in turn shaped bad climate policies”
    • 2015

September 15, 2024 – The Delingpod: A James Delingpole Podcast w/ guest Jacob Nordangård from Sweden – research into the history of the Rockefellers and climate change – WATCH

  • “The Rockefeller family is one of the richest in the world. Yet, why would the family that made the world dependent on oil fund environmental and climate research since the 1950s, help shape climate policy measures since the 1980s, and supported climate activism since the 1990s?”
  • Dec 13, 2019 – “The same day that Greta Thunberg was appointed Person of the Year by Time Magazine, the English edition of Rockefeller – Controlling the Game was released.” – by Jacob Nordangård – “the impact of Rockefeller philanthropy on public policy”- ARCHIVE, blog ARCHIVE, July 2024 new book edition released – READ
  • April 30, 2019 – Columbia Journalism School (CJR) hosts Rockefeller Family-supported town hall called Covering Climate Change – READ, WATCH, Jacob’s blog – CREDIT
Rockefeller – Controlling the Game by Jacob Nordangård 2024 edition
Rockefeller – Controlling the Game by Jacob Nordangård, now updated July 10, 2024 by Skyhorse publishing – READ, AMAZON, ARCHIVE

September 9, 2024 – Wide Awake Media: WHO Director-General demands a transformation of global food systems—away from meat-eating and traditional agriculture—under the guise of combatting “climate change” – WATCH

“Our food systems are harming the health of people and planet. Food systems contribute to over 30% of greenhouse gas emissions, and account for almost one third of the global burden of disease.”

Transforming food systems is therefore essential, by shifting towards healthier, diversified and more plant based diets.”

Tedros – WHO Director General

  • WHO: “Transforming food systems” – document SEARCH
    • The phrase “transforming food systems” first entered WHO in 2021 –
  • April 23, 2019 – WHO: International Forum on Food Safety and Trade – READ
  • July 12, 2021 – WHO: UN report: Pandemic year marked by spike in world hunger…must act now for 2030 turnaround – READ
    • “They go on to warn of a “critical juncture,” even as they pin fresh hopes on increased diplomatic momentum. “This year offers a unique opportunity for advancing food security and nutrition through transforming food systems with the upcoming UN Food Systems Summit, the Nutrition for Growth Summit and the COP26 on climate change.” “The outcome of these events,” the five add, “will go on to shape the […] second half of the UN Decade of Action on Nutrition” – a global policy commitment yet to hit its stride.”
  • June 7, 2019 first-ever World Food Safety Day – REF
  • June 16, 2019 – The state of food security and nutrition in the world 2019 – READ, ARCHIVES
  • September 15, 2017 – FAO: THE STATE OF FOOD SECURITY AND NUTRITION IN THE WORLD – How close are we to #ZeroHunger? – Sustainable Development Goal 2 (SDG 2)- ARCHIVE
    • “The concurrence of conflict and climate-related natural disasters is likely to increase with climate change, as climate change not only threatens food insecurity and malnutrition, but can also contribute to further downward deterioration into conflict, protracted crisis and continued fragility.”

July 7, 2024 – 42nd Annual Meeting of Doctors for Disaster Preparedness: Climate Change is a Myth and A Cloud Thermostat Controls the Earth’s Climate, Not Greenhouse gasses – John F. Clauser, PhD “Retired experimental and theoretical physicist, 2022 Physics Nobel Laureate, Climate Change Denier” – WATCH, SOURCE

  • Using Weather Balloon Data to Test Assumptions of Computer Climate Models – Dr Michael Connolly – WATCH
  • Scientific challenges of the “detection and attribution of global warming” – presented by Dr Willie Soon of Center for Environmental Research and Earth Sciences (ceres-science.com) – WATCH
  • How COVID-19 Public Health Policies Neglected “the Disease, the Patient, and the Physician.” presentation by Dr Ronan Connolly – WATCH

June 26, 2024 – NY Times -The Vanishing Pacific Islands that Failed to Vanish – Low-lying tropical island nations were expected to be early victims of rising seas. But research tells a surprising story: Many islands are stable. Some have even grown.- READ, ARCHIVE

  • Craig Kelly told parliament years ago the islands were not sinking, but growing – READ, TWEET
  • Of the 1000s of islands looked at via aerial footage over time…”By and large, though, their area hadn’t shrunk. In some cases, it was the opposite: They grew. The seas rose, and the islands expanded with them.”
Time Magazine Our Sinking Planet June 24,2019 – cover image of Antonio Guterres, UN Secretary-General. –source, READ

June 19, 2024 – Senator Gerard Rennick: Australias Bureau of Meteorology (BOM) “homogenised” weather records are called the ACORN series – homogenisation is to “analyse change over time”. They now surreptitiously update record sets using versions with decimal points – small incremental updates – WATCH

June 3, 2024 – CHD: Carbon Offsets Are a ‘Scam’ — Here’s Why – READ, ORIGINAL

  • Corporate giants purchase “climate offsets” to claim and market products deceivingly as carbon neutral, “net zero” products.
  • Thousands of world’s largest companies publicly declared goals of net zero by ~2030, and most plan to get there by purchasing carbon credits as “emission reductions”… but the schemes fail to deliver the promised emissions reductions, or even are causing harm. Consumer beware!
  • “The global offsets market is huge, worth more than $2 billion and expected to grow to $10 billion or more by 2030 …Under standards set by the 2015 Paris climate treaty, one carbon credit represents the reduction of 1 metric tonne (about 1.1 U.S. ton) of carbon dioxide or the equivalent climate-heating potential of other greenhouse gases, such as methane….many government regulators worldwide…let regulated polluters buy carbon credits to meet some of their legally required emissions reductions. But like Apple, companies can also buy credits voluntarily, to bolster their net-zero claims.”
  • Dr Shiva proposes it will be a trillion dollar trading market – WATCH

April 11, 2024 – The Honest Story of Climate Change: Part I: Weighed down by fear and intimidation By Guus Berkhout & Kees de Lange – PART 1, PART 2

In Part I, we urge politicians, climate researchers and journalists to stop fearmongering and stop citing results of flawed climate models. Our leaders must tell citizens the honest story.

April 22, 2024 – Toby Rogers Substack: This really is World War III – READ

  • Last week, Michael E. Mann spoke at the EcoHeath Alliance: Green Planet One Health Benefit 2024 – $50,000 for premium ticket “on the evening of April 18, 2024 as we bring together some of the brightest minds in the fields of conservation and public health to celebrate the ways we can work together to protect the health of humans, animals, and the environment.” – READ, ARCHIVE
    • “So a leader in the global warming movement [Man] spoke at an event to raise money for the organization [EHA] that just murdered 7 million people and the campaign [WHO OneHealth] that intends to launch new pandemics in perpetuity to enrich the biowarfare industrial complex….Peter Hotez reposted all of this information on Twitter, I imagine in solidarity with all of the exciting genociding going on” [Yep!]
    • “…we are witnessing a convergence between the global warming movement, the biowarfare industrial complex, and the WHO pandemic treaty grifters”

April 16, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: A Year’s Worth of Rain Causes Massive Flooding in Dubai — Cloud Seeding Operation (confirmed) was Carried Out in the Last 24 Hours – READ TWEET, Weather modification

  • downpour resulted in over 120 millimetres (4.75 inches) of rain, overwhelming the city’s infrastructure caused massive disruptions.

April 15, 2024 – Mel K Show: Geoengineering: The True Danger to Our Planet w/ Dane Wigington – WATCH, Geoengineering Watch – WEB

  • Extrapolated as much as much as 40-60 million tons of particulate matter being dumped into world sky’s annually – EXCERPT
  • Tennessee Governor Bill Lee has now signed legislation into law that bans any form of climate engineering operations over the State of Tennessee – READ, WATCH
    • HB 2063 (March 18, 2024): “bill to prohibit the intentional injection, release, or dispersion, by any means, of chemicals, chemical compounds, substances, or apparatus within the borders of this state into the atmosphere with the express purpose of affecting temperature, weather, or the intensity of the sunlight”. – ARCHIVE, READ
  • The Environment’s “Immune System, it’s natural resilience “is now broken” largely by climate engineering activities. It’s decimated the ozone layer, and contaminated the planet’s soils, water and plants, esp. plankton (down 90% in Atlantic ocean) etc…- EXCERPT
  • “You can fit 100,000 nano-particles across the width of a single human hair… their absorbed into virtually everything…” – EXCERPT
  • Impact of satellites – every rocket launch tears a massive hole in the ozone layer – EXCERPT
  • Destroying the atmosphere has caused ~50 feedback loops triggered, “so now we have this cascading effect of planetary life-support sytem collapse”…now they have Project Lucy-Alamo for microwaving the atmosphere to undo the negative effects of methane that their tech caused in the first place which is on top of burning of carbon fuels (i.e. 100 Million barrels of oil per day) …but “The Left” has been trained not to address geoengineering piece of the climate issue – EXCERPT

April 7, 2024 – Climate Change Dispatch: Study: Net Coastal Change Of 13,000+ Islands Expanded 155 Sq. Miles Since 2000 “contrary to initial assumptions.” – READ, International Journal of Digital Earth – STUDY, Senator Rennick – CREDIT

March 21, 2024 – Climate: The Movie (The Cold Truth) – Official WATCH, READ, BACKUP, BACKUP, Interview with Tom Nelson – WATCH, Substack – READ, movie script – HERE, CREDIT

Climate: The Movie (The Cold Truth)

Written and directed by MARTIN DURKIN, produced by TOM NELSON – Official website – HERE

March 14, 2024 – The Highwire Episode 363: EYE ON THE SKY – FULL, UNPACKING CLIMATE ENGINEERING WITH JIM LEE weather modification with climate engineering expert Jim Lee –WATCH

  • Climate View News website by Jim Lee – geoengineering, pollution, privacy concerns, and propaganda – HERE
  • Mapping the lengthy history of weather modification, aviation pollution and more

March 13, 2024 – The Answer to Population Control. Hidden in plain sight – by Jesse Friedman – READ

March 10, 2024- Corbett Report: The Climate Death Cult’s Mask is Slipping – READ

  • Newly released (propaganda-masquerading-as-science) study based on only 328 breath samples from 104 volunteers, sounds alarm that “minuscule (and statistically meaningless)” human breathing contributes to climate change! Oh and farts too!
  • “With every story like this, the would-be controllers of humanity are telling you something about who they are and what they have planned for you.” [more media fart-fodder]

“human life is no longer something to be treasured, but something to be measured in carbon and then reduced.”

James Corbett reporting on “Carbon Eugenics” (2009)
  • 2018 The Guardian – the environmental carbon toll of “children” – so couples volunteer for sterilisation – READ

March 6, 2024 – Net Zero climate change broadside by Doug Brodie a letter- READ, follow up from 2022 Big Con –READ

  • Letter to Sir Edward Mountain MSP who is Convener of Net Zero, Energy and Transport of the Scottish Government regarding his forthcoming “Let’s Talk Energy Summit”

February 29, 2024 – The Highwire Ep 361 : Judith Curry, PhD.: IN THE EYE OF THE ‘CLIMATE CHANGE’ STORM – WATCH, FULL

February 28, 2024 – Popular Science: Plastic makers lied about recycling for decades – The plastic industry “knowingly misled the public about the feasibility of plastic recycling”, while internally dismissing it as technically and economically unviable READ, CREDIT, The Guardian on “they lied” – READ

  • In 1950’s single use plastics began to explode (profitable), Consumer backlash occurred in 80-90s to the waste – plastic pollution. The industry convinced the public that recycling was the solution! “As a result, worldwide plastic production rose from 2 million tonnes to 120 million tonnes annually from 1950 and 1990″
    • 1997 Ad from American Plastics Council promoting the benefits of plastics – WATCH
  • 2022 – OECD report only 9% of plastics are ever recycles, the rest of the waste goes to landfill, burned or mismanaged – READ
  • Center for Climate Integrity: Excerpts of key documents cited in The Fraud of Plastic Recycling (historical images) – PDF

February 7, 2024 – Epoch Times | Cross Roads: Journalist Alex Newman Explains Why the “Human-Induced Climate Change” Narrative is Finally Crumbling – EXCERPT

  • Climate Emergency no longer “settled science” – “Three new peer-reviewed papers, published in major prestigious scientific journals… completely undermine the alleged scientific consensus on man-made global warming.”

February 3, 2024 – The Heartland Institute | Climate Change Roundtable Ep 96: Climate Trial of the Century, Mann vs. Steyn Week 3 – Guest: Ann McElhinney of Unreported Story Society – WATCH, READ,

  • Climate “hockey stick” inventor Michael Mann claims he was defamed in 2012 blog by writer and broadcaster Mark Steyn
  • third week …Mann rested his case. And now the defense has begun to make its devastating case against the nasty serial litigator in the Climate Trial of the Century. The hockey stick itself is being broken into pieces in public. [see 2009 below for Hockey stick, climategate]
  • More Climate Change on Trial daily podcast where actors re-enact court transcripts – HERE
  • “Mann is perhaps best known for producing the Hockey Stick graph alleging the global temperatures were basically stable for 1500 years until human industrial activity led to an ongoing spike in temperatures.” Steyn claims the graph is fraudulent
  • March 3, 2025 – via Watts up with That: BREAKING: A Victory for Free Speech: Mark Steyn’s $1 Million Judgment [declared unconstitutional—too excessive] Slashed to $5,000 in Landmark Climate CaseREAD
    • Re: 12-year legal saga that began with Steyn’s July 13, 2012 blog post criticizing Mann’s iconic “hockey stick” graph, a cornerstone of climate change narratives” – previous ARTICLES

February 2, 2024 – Jeremy Cordeaux Podcast Adelaide | The Court of Public Opinion: Climate Realities & Misconceptions: Prof. Ian Plimer Sets the Record Straight – WATCH, READ

January 31, 2024 – Brian Sussman Show ep 229: The Hoax: an interview with Dr. Neil Frank, former Director, National Hurricane Center – WATCH, FB, EXCERPT

  • We’ve had major hurricanes throughout our records“. i.e. 1893 two major hurricanes made landfall in US
  • Context: October 30, 2023 – Ep 14 – The latest “news” says hurricanes are now “intensified” by boiling ocean temperatures. – Is it True? – WATCH

January 30, 2024 – Statista: Carbon dioxide emissions in China 1960-2022 – China released 11.4 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions in 2022, making it by far the world’s largest polluter that year. – READ, Dr Shiva (Nov2018) – EXCERPT

  • 2014 article “China’s peaking year of 2030 means that it would peak at about 10 tonnes per capita (compared to the present level of around 7 tonnes per capita)” – REF
China’s CO2 emissions – source

January 19, 2024 – WEF Davos 2024 – World Economic Forum (WEF) called on one billion people to “stop eating meat” to combat climate change , Siemens AG Chairman Jim Hagemann – READ, CREDIT

January 16, 2024 – Daily Sceptic: Arctic Sea Ice Soars to Highest Level for 21 Years – READ, CREDIT

January 13, 2024 – Politico: John Kerry to step down as Biden climate envoy – The veteran diplomat helped craft the 2015 Paris climate agreement, and more recently led the U.S. team at COP28 in Dubai – now plans to help Biden’s re-election campaign. – READ , NY Times – READ, first reported Axios – ARCHIVE, CREDIT

…I got news for you, no one politician anywhere in the world can undo what is happening now [with climate agenda], the market place is doing this…
…The only challenge is will we get there [net zero] in time to meet the challenges of the scientists to avoid the worse consequences of this crisis”John Kerry at WEF Davos 2024

January 12, 2024 – The Highwire Ep 354: THE REAL CAUSE OF CLIMATE CHANGE – could it be THE SUN solar flares? – EXCERPT, FULL

  • CHINA & INDIA are biggest importers of coal – what The Highwire missed is that this was already accepted by the United Nations in the Paris Agreement – Dr Shiva pointed this scam out in 2018 – WATCH
    • China allowed to go from 11B Tons CO2 to 22B by 2030, while the west has to decrease to ZERO

January 10, 2024 – Tucker Carlson on X: Ep. 62 If fossil fuels come from fossils, why have scientists found them on one of Saturn’s moons? A lot of what you’ve heard about energy is false. Dr. Willie Soon explains – WATCH

  • Vigilant News: Astrophysicist Drops a Nuclear Bomb on the Entire Climate Change Narrative – READ

2023 and earlier…

For timeline before 2024 click HERE or see some data points below.

The original timeline page is so long that I am unable to edit it, so I am placing additional data points below until a fix is found

2015

September 1, 2015 – “A Disgrace to the Profession” by Mark Steyn – BOOK, Book Review – CREDIT

  • “The “hockey stick” graph of global temperatures is the single most influential icon in the global-warming debate, promoted by the UN’s transnational climate bureaucracy, featured in Al Gore’s Oscar-winning movie, used by governments around the world to sell the Kyoto Accord to their citizens, and shown to impressionable schoolchildren from kindergarten to graduation”. BUT….
A Disgrace to the Profession – BOOK

2012

July 13, 2012 – Open Market Blog of Competitive Enterprise Institute: The Other Scandal In Unhappy Valley (listed in Global Warming) – ARCHIVE

  • So it turns out that Penn State has covered up wrongdoing by one of its employees to avoid bad publicity…it’s time that we revisit the Michael Mann affair, particularly given how much we’ve also learned about his and others’ hockey-stick deceptions since.
  • Mann “has molested and tortured data in the service of politicized science that could have dire economic consequences for the nation and planet.

May 17, 2012 – PJ Media: The Death of the Hockey Stick? The iconic symbol of the global warming panic may have taken a hit from which it will never recover- ARCHIVE

  • November 23, 2009 – Climategate: When Scientists Become Politicians – ARCHIVE

2010

July 1, 2010 – Research at Penn State University: “Investigation” complete of Penn State climate scientist Michael Mann by Penn State University – ARCHIVE, Final Report on Michael Mann – PDF

  • Meaning Penn State undertook its “own investigation, independently of one that had been launched by the National Academy of Sciences (NAS)” – SOURCE
  • A panel of leading scholars [tenured professors of Penn State] has cleared [Penn State Professor Michael Mann] a well-known Penn State climate scientist of research misconduct, following a four-month internal investigation by the University.
  • June 4, 2010 -The Pennsylvania State University: RA-1O Final Investigation Report Involving Dr. Michael E, MannPDF REPORT, CREDIT

2007

2007 – IPCC: Climate Change 2007: Working Group I: The Physical Science Basis – FAQ 3.1 How are Temperatures on Earth Changing? – ARCHIVE, CREDIT

  • The IPCC zero point is 14 C
IPCC 2007 use 14 degrees celsius as global mean temperature
Historical global mean temperature has now been adjusted dowon to 14 degrees C – this is the ZERO Point – source

2004

November 9, 2004 – Washington Post: Study Says Polar Bears Could Face Extinction – READ

  • Bu 2010 – “campaigners just stopped talking about polar bears”…”Why? Because after years of misrepresentation, it finally became impossible for them to ignore a mountain of evidence showing that the global polar bear population has increased substantially from around 12,000 in the 1960s to around 26,000 in the present day. (The main reason? People are hunting a lot less polar bears). ” – CREDIT

1992

15 degrees Celsius is still used by NASA as Average global temperature (until ~1997 when they suddenly changed it to 14!)

January 12, 1992 – The Daily Gazette | The Associate Press: Eruption may have slowed global warming – READ, CREDIT

  • “On average, the world’s annual temperature is about 15 degrees Celsius, or 59 degrees Farenheit. Hansen and Wilson noted in their analysis that the 1991 readings are mearly identical with 1981 and 1988.”

1981

August 28,1981 – Science Vol 231, No 4511: Climate Impact of Increasing Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide by James Hansen et al – ARCHIVE, PDF, CREDIT

  • Hansen reveals the average global temperature in this paper “The mean surface temperature is Ts ~ 288 K“.
  • “Two hundred and eighty-eight K, or 288 Kelvin, is the same as 15 degrees Celsius.  A report in the Schenectady-based Daily Gazette indicates that Hansen and his colleague Helene Wilson used this value at least as late as 1992.  Thus, Hansen consistently used 15 degrees Celsius as the baseline average for several years.” – REF

The post Climate Change cont… first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
One World, One Health Agenda https://totalityofevidence.com/one-world-one-health-agenda/ Mon, 29 Jan 2024 07:24:11 +0000 https://totalityofevidence.com/?p=44561 This page will track the formation and development of the Wildlife Conservation Society’s (WCS) One World, One Health™ agenda which has morphed into a United Nations Quadripartite push between the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), World…

The post One World, One Health Agenda first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
This page will track the formation and development of the Wildlife Conservation Society’s (WCS) One World, One Health™ agenda which has morphed into a United Nations Quadripartite push between the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), World Health Organization (WHO), the World Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH) and recently the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP).

In January 2022, the World Health Organisation takes a “paradigm shift” and adopts the “One Health” approach stating “Engagement in One Health is growing”. In their words One Health is “an integrated, unifying approach that aims to sustainably balance and optimize the health of people, animals and ecosystems. It recognizes that the health of humans, domestic and wild animals, plants, and the wider environment (including ecosystems) are closely linked and interdependent.” – WEB

What does OneHealth mean for our sovereignty?

The System loves the vaccine passport because as soon as they can impose it they’re going to turn it into your money …your vaccine wallet…vaccine passport is the excuse to bring [social credit score model] in.

This is primarily about control, this is not about your health. If it was about your health they would have done things right during COVID…they want to do more of the bad stuff…

There’s something called OneHealth which enables the director general of the WHO to declare emergencies that are not health emergencies. They can be climate emergencies, or ecosystem emergencies, or gun violence emergencies…anyway you can call health of humans, animals or ecosystems, or plants…they can then impose rules on us for.

Dr Meryl Nass, March 8, 2024

The OneHealth Agenda timeline

The agenda seems to trace back to a September 2002 article in Foreign Affairs magazine written by the head of the WCS, justifying why the conservation movement needs to lead a global response in connecting the “triangle of wildlife health, domestic animal health, and human health.” The following year his Society coined the term “One Health”.

  • One World One Health -website ARCHIVE
  • One Health Commission website – HERE, History – HERE
  • One Health Global Network “Milestones” – HERE
  • One Health Commission – HERE
    • March 2017 – “One Health links human, animal, and ecosystem health into a model for solving today’s health problems.“- WATCH, CREDIT
  • The International Journal of Infectious Diseases (IJID) One Health (OH), an open access, peer-reviewed journal published monthly online by the International Society for Infectious Diseases (ISID) – READ, see 2007
  • EcoHealth Journal – Public Health Official journal of EcoHealth Alliance – (One Health) – READ
  • Australian Govenment: Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research on One Health – READ, SEARCH, AIRPOH w/ Canada – HERE
  • World Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH) – One Health – HERE
“One Health” concept has morphed over the years from Wildlife Conservation Society proposal (2007) to United Nations Quadriparties Agenda (2021)! – source, source

Australia hosted the First International OneHealth Congress in 2011

Links in reverse chronological order

2025

January 16, 2025 – The Defender: U.S. Launches ‘One Health’ Plan Prompting Concerns About Global Power Play – READ

  • “The U.S. last week introduced a national framework for One Health to help the country prepare for “the next potential threat” to public health. Critics argue the plan will expand government surveillance and crisis-driven health policies”
  • Meryl Nass Substack: US government implemented its One Health Framework last week
    And I watched every boring minute of the announcement – “IMHO, this project is simply an effort to create an alternate governance structure:” – SLIDES – CREDIT

January 10, 2024 – CC Newsroom: U.S. Government Releases First National One Health Plan to Protect People, Animals, and Our Environment from Shared Health Threats – READ, ARCHIVE, CREDIT

  • The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), and the Department of the Interior (DOI) today released the first-ever National One Health Framework to Address Zoonotic Diseases and Advance Public Health Preparedness in the United StatesPDF, CDC One Health Coordination – READ
  • “In developing this framework, the U.S. government is helping to ensure that the groundwork is laid for effective disease response in the future so that we can be better prepared for the next potential threat.”
US National One Health Framework – PDF
  • Responding to COVID-19 with the One Health Approach – “The COVID-19 pandemic led to the creation of new One Health coordination activities across the US government.” – REF

2024

December 3-6, 2024 (scheduled) – ProMED: 20th International Congress on Infectious Diseases (ICID) 2024 | Cape Town, South Africa – features an expanded range of sessions by bringing the One Health aspect to the world of clinical infectious diseases and microbiology. Looking through the One Health lens – READ, ARCHIVE

  • “The recent COVID-19 pandemic highlights the importance of the need for continued research, innovation, and funding in the field of infectious diseases” [of course it does!]. ProMED and SARS-CoV-2 – READ

September 20-23, 2024 (scheduled) – World One Health Conference, Cape Town, South Africa – READ, CREDIT


April 17, 2024 – Meryl Nass: US Government bribes 100 countries to agree to the global biosecurity agenda, and openly reveals that One Health will be used to control food, economic development and climate – READ

  • Whitehouse REPORT: US Government Global Health Security Strategy 2024 (April 2024) – PDF, ARCHIVE
    • “…because health security, economic security, climate security, and national security are all related.”

…they really are using the “health” hook to wrap up the food supply, economic development, plants and animals…into one neat “thing” they plan to control in the name of preventing zoonotic disease spillover. [Disease X]

They aren’t even trying to hide it anymore

Dr Meryl Nass

March 8, 2024 – The Kim Iversen Show: This Doctor Proved They’ve Been Doing Biowarefare For Decades. Now They’re Censoring Her – WATCH

  • Dr Meryl Nass explains how WHO vaccine passports will become a digital wallet together interlinked with the pandemic treaty/IHR and OneHealth – it threaten us all – EXCERPT

The System loves the vaccine passport because as soon as they can impose it they’re going to turn it into your money …your vaccine wallet…vaccine passport is the excuse to bring [social credit score model] in.

This is primarily about control, this is not about your health. If it was about your health they would have done things right during COVID…they want to do more of the bad stuff…

There’s something called OneHealth which enables the director general of the WHO to declare emergencies that are not health emergencies. They can be climate emergencies, or ecosystem emergencies, or gun violence emergencies…anyway you can call health of humans, animals or ecosystems, or plants…they can then impose rules on us for.

Dr Meryl Nass

February 8, 2024 – A Midwestern Doctor Substack: Why The Bioweapons Research Industry Is A Danger to Society and what the WHO is doing to protect this grift now that the public is wising up to it. – One Health etc – READ

  • “…fears have been used to create the justification we need to perform an endless amount of bioweapons research to “prevent” the next pandemic.
  • “Since the public is gradually becoming aware of what COVID cartel has done to us, they are switching to far more totalitarian methods to ensure they can continue their grift. We are at a pivotal moment to stop that, and that is why this series was written.
  • “…given how easy experts are to buy off (as we all saw throughout the pandemic), it was clear to any seasoned observer that One Health was simply an attempt to merge the war on infectious diseases with the war on future environmental catastrophe and have “One Health” usurp the ability of the common people to speak out against it—as under the incredibly broad definition of “One Health,” almost every aspect of our lives was something which could be regulated under it (e.g., you can’t live here because it might increase the chance of you coming in contact with a wild animal that could spark a pandemic)….most of “One Health” is a series of deceptive promises wrapped in doublespeak which simply serve the billionaire class and do anything but promote health” – REF

January 28, 2024 – Meryl Nass Substack: “One Health” has an earlier pedigree than I knew. The false narratives emanating from One health had already been created by 2004, and one author of this drivel now works at EcoHealth Alliance – READ, inspired data point TIMELINE

  • William H. Foege, a Fellow at the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation gave the Keynote Speech: “One World, One Health, Could We Muddle Through?” – REF

2023

May 17, 2023 – CHD | The Defender: ‘Sinister Forces at Play’ in WHO’s Global One Health Agenda – READ

  • “…the World Health Organization appears to have used the COVID-19 crisis as a catalyst for an about-turn on its previously more altruistic and democratic approach.”

May 8, 2023 – CHD | The Defender : One Health: A Plan to ‘Surveil and Control Every Aspect of Life on Earth’? – READ

  • Experts who spoke with The Defender suggested One Health has more to do with a biosecurity agenda, a global surveillance system, vaccine passports and restrictions on human behavior than it has to do with protecting human health.

May 1, 2023 – The Defender: ‘One Health’ — The Global Takeover of Everything? – READ

  • Under the One Health agenda, the World Health Organization would have power to make decisions relating to diet, agriculture and livestock farming, environmental pollution, movement of populations and much more. Taxpayers would fund the scheme — corporations would profit.”

April 27, 2023 – The Defender: ‘One Health’: What Is It, Who’s Promoting It — and Why? – READ

  • The “One Health” concept has been gaining traction among public health policymakers in recent years — but questions remain about what One Health really means, who’s behind the concept and whether what started out as a sound idea has since been hijacked by individuals or groups that see it as a means to expand their power.

2022

December 6, 2022 – Meryl Nass Substack: One Health: what is it and why is it important? One Health is being embedded into the WHO’s International Health Regulations (IHRs) and Pandemic Treaty/AccordREAD

The One Health Umbrella – source

2022 – FAO: Rome: One Health Joint Plan of Action (2022-2026) – Working Together for the Health of Humans, Animals, Plants and the EnvironmentPDF, READ, READ

June 3, 2022 – World Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH) – launch One Health page – READ, ARCHIVE

  • “The COVID-19 pandemic, a human public health crisis resulting from a virus of potential animal origin, underlined the validity of the One Health concept in understanding and confronting global health risks.” – REF
    • [Except this statement is misleading and deceptive as it is most likely the SARS-CoV-2 virus came from a lab in Wuhan as a result of gain-of-function research techniques, and was covered up by the very people helping to push “One Health” genetic surveillance and vaccine countermeasure “research” – virus origins TIMELINE
    • Maybe the emerging “bird flu” – avian influenza is the same
  • WOAH Terrestrial Animal Health Code! – HERE, SOURCE
  • WOAH Manual of Diagnostic Tests and Vaccines for Terrestrial Animals: Chapter 3.3.4. Avian Influenza – PDF, SOURCE
“One Health” approach summarises a concept “that human, animal and plant health are interdependent and bound to the health of the ecosystems in which they exist”- source

January 30, 2022 – WHO: On World NTD Day, WHO releases key document to guide a paradigm shift towards One Health – ARCHIVE

  • The “Road Map” Document: Ending the neglect to attain the sustainable development goals. One health: approach for action against neglected tropical diseases 2021-2030ARCHIVE
  • In an “efforts to control and eliminate neglected tropical diseases (NTDs)”. [It will move to Disease X soon enough]
One Health Approach for action against neglected tropical diseases 2021–2030 – PDF

2021

December 2021 – Global One Health Community: The Quadripartite (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), World Health Organization (WHO), and the World Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH)) welcomed the newly formed operational definition of One Health from their advisory panel, the One Health High Level Expert Panel (OHHLEP) – READ

One Health is an integrated, unifying approach that aims to sustainably balance and optimize the health of people, animals and ecosystems.

It recognizes the health of humans, domestic and wild animals, plants, and the wider environment (including ecosystems) are closely linked and inter-dependent.

The approach mobilizes multiple sectors, disciplines and communities at varying levels of society to work together to foster well-being and tackle threats to health and ecosystems, while addressing the collective need for clean water, energy and air, safe and nutritious food, taking action on climate change, and contributing to sustainable development.

Definition of One Health, developed by the One Health High Level Expert Panel (OHHLEP), PDF

September 6, 2021 – Indo Pacific Health Security: Australian expert appointed to One Health High Level Expert Advisory Panel – Professor John Mackenzie, a member of the Centre’s Technical Reference Group, – READ, Members- HERE

  • The panel was established jointly by the UN Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO), the World Organization for Animal Health, the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the World Health Organization (WHO) Launched May 2021

February 2021 : The Tripartite organisations FAO, WHO and WOAH, who had been together for 27 years (since 1994?), called on the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) to join their effort “reaffirming the importance of the environmental dimension of the One Health collaboration.” – PDF

  • UNEP agreed to jointly develop a strategy and action plan to prevent future pandemics through the One Health approach ->
  • Rome 2022: One Health Joint Plan of Action (2022-2026) – Working Together for the Health of Humans, Animals, Plants and the Environment – PDF

2020

March 23, 2020 – How ProMED Crowdsourced the Arrival of Covid-19 and SARS – READ [One Health surveillance]

  • Marjorie Pollack, a physician, epidemiologist and deputy editor of ProMED got email alert from China

March 11, 2020 – Scientific American: How China’s “Bat Woman” Hunted Down Viruses from SARS to the New Coronavirus – READ

  • Once potential pathogens are mapped out, scientists and public health officials can regularly check for possible infections by analyzing blood and swab samples from livestock, wild animals that are farmed and traded, and high-risk human populations…This approach, known as “One Health,” says Peter Daszak

2017

December 5-7, 2017 – CDC: Prioritizing Zoonoses for Global Health Capacity BuildingThemes from One Health Zoonotic Disease Workshops in 7 Countries, 2014–2016 – PDF, ARCHIVE, CREDIT

  • The workshop was held December 5-7, 2017, at the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office ofthe Assistant Secretary for Preparedness and,Response (ASPR) headquarters in Washington, DC
  • “Fourteen CDC-trained OHZDP workshop facilitators were used for the 7 workshops and represented interdisciplinary backgrounds with expertise in zoonoses. A total of 21 in-country facilitators were trained at 5 of the 7 workshops,…”
  • “Early detection of zoonotic pathogens through enhanced laboratory capacity and surveillance at the animal–human interface is a crucial step toward controlling and preventing zoonoses”
    • Moving interdisciplinary science forward: integrating participatory modelling with mathematical modelling of zoonotic disease in Africa. Grant et al. Infect Dis Poverty. 2016; 5:17. – ARCHIVE (United Nations)
    • This work, Dynamic Drivers of Disease in Africa Consortium, NERC project no. NE-J001570-1, was funded with support from the Ecosystem Services for Poverty Alleviation (ESPA) programme. The ESPA programme is funded by the Department for International Development (DFID), the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) and the Natural Environment Research Council (NERC).”

August 23, 2017 – Zoonotic Disease Prioritization – ARCHIVE

  • “In 2017, CDC, USDA, and DOI organized a One Health Zoonotic Disease Prioritization (OHZDP) workshop to further joint efforts to address zoonotic disease challenges in the United States. Participants in the workshop identified eight zoonotic diseases of greatest national concern…” – REF

March 2017 – Research Gate: Roadmap to a One Health Agenda 2030 – READ, SOURCE

2016

November 3, 2016 – One Health Commission PRESS RELEASE: GLOBAL “ONE HEALTH DAY” PLANNED BY THREE INTERNATIONAL ONE HEALTH GROUPS – READ, They’ve designated November 3, “One Health Day” – READ, CREDIT

  • One Health Day is celebrated through One Health educational and awareness events held around the world.

2011

March 1, 2011 – CDC launch their One Health website – ARCHIVE

February 14-16, 2011 – 1st International One Health Congress: Human Health, Animal Health, the Environment and Global Survival in Melbourne, Australia – to Showcase the One Health concept globally, to open debate to the wider international scientific and policy making community – ARCHIVE, REF, WEB, Report – PDF

  • Focus on outcomes needed to effectively manage growing risks to global health & make global policy recommendations and organizational changes, using underlying science, to drive real and profound change.
  • Co-Chaired by Professor John Mackenzie, who happens to have been on WHO emergency committee who decided SARS-CoV-2 was a PHEIC – READ, TIMELINE, in 2021 australia appoints him head of One Health advisory panel! – READ
  • “Professor Peter Doherty’s keynote speech dealt with the growing evidence of negative impact of human behavior on the health of the world and the likely risk to humankind.” – REF
  • Published EcoHealth Journal: 2011, Volume 7, Supplement – “One Health – Ecology & Health – Public Health Official journal of EcoHealth Alliance”: 1st International One Health CongressREAD
  • One Health case studies, from all continentsThere is clearly a “One Health movement” starting out there” – REF

2010

July 2010 – United Nations and World Bank Fifth Global Progress Report: Animal and Pandemic Influenza; A framework for Sustaining Momentum – The adoption of “One Health approaches” is one of the three suggested mainstreams of the “framework for sustaining momentum”REF

May 2010 – Stone Mountain meeting (Atlanta, Georgia): Operationalizing One Health: a Policy Perspective -taking stock and shaping an implementation roadmap, One Health working groups are set up, with 3-year time operational objectives. – REF

April 21, 2010 – UNited Nations: Hanoi Declaration Sets Global Framework for Avian Influenza, Pandemic Readiness, Proposes National Steps to Detect Animal-Human Transmission, Control Outbreaks – READ

March 16 -17, 2010 – Shifting from Emergency Response to Prevention of Pandemic Disease Threats at Source, Chatham HouseREF, no archive – HERE

2008

October 2008 – 6th International Ministerial Conference on Avian and Pandemic Influenza at Sharm-el-Sheikh – READOne Health becomes a political reality and a recommended approach

  • “In 2008, the three major international organizations charged with animal health and human health—FAO, OIE and WHO—collaborated with UNICEF, the UN System for Influenza Coordinator, and the World Bank to develop a joint strategic framework in response to the evolving risk of emerging and re-emerging infectious diseases.
  • The document communicating this framework, ‘Contributing to One World, One Health—A Strategic Framework for Reducing Risks of Infectious Diseases at the Animal-Human-Ecosystems Interface,’ was officially released” – ARCHIVE
    • The ‘One World, One Health’ concept, which establishes a more interdisciplinary and cross-sectoral approach to preventing epidemic or epizootic disease and for maintaining ecosystem integrity, is a trademark of the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS).REF

2007

December 2007 – International Ministerial Conference on Avian and Pandemic Influenza (IMCAPI) of New Delhi – REF

  • Promoting One Health could be the natural extension of the Global Response to Avian Influenza (GRAI).” it is set in stone the next year!

October 2-4, 2007 – Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS): One World-One Health: Brazil 2007 Symposium- Healthy Ecosystems, Livestock and Human Livelihoods: An Innovative Public-Private PartnershipARCHIVE, Agenda – ARCHIVE

Welcome by Robert Cook – source
And this is how “conservations” gets involved in human health – SLIDE
  • Building upon the successful model of our previous One World – One Health symposia in New York, Bangkok and Beijing, we are now introducing this multidisciplinary approach to health and livelihoods to Brazil.
    • William Karesh, linking disease to population, land, conservation.
    • One World – One Health – One Surveillance System (aka ProMED mail) – READ, SLIDES
      • Program for Monitoring Emerging Diseases (ProMED) is the global electronic reporting system for outbreaks of emerging infectious diseases & toxins. It is a program of the International Society for Infectious DiseasesARCHIVE, History ISID – READ
      • ProMED and One Health today – HERE
  • Wildlife Conservation Society Announces One World One Health Research Projects Funded by Cargill a global food company

2005

November 30, 2005 – The Lancet: Potential of cooperation between human and animal health to strengthen health systems – Zinsstag et al – READ

  • The WHO ministerial summit held in Mexico City, Mexico, on Nov 16–20, 2004, recognised the pivotal role of strengthened health systems in achieving the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) in an equity-effective manner
  • US epidemiologist Calvin Schwabe coined the term “one medicine”, to focus attention on the similarity between human and veterinary health interests – Historical roots of the “one medicine”

2005 – WCS: Conservation and Development Interventions at the Wildlife/Livestock Interface: Implications for Wildlife, Livestock and Human Health – by Osofsky, Karesh et al – READ

2004

This page will track the formation and development of the Wildlife Conservation Society’s (WCS) One World, One Health™ agenda which has morphed into a United Nations Quadripartite push between the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), World Health Organization (WHO), the World Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH) and recently the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP).

In January 2022, the World Health Organisation takes a “paradigm shift” and adopts the “One Health” approach stating “Engagement in One Health is growing”. In their words One Health is “an integrated, unifying approach that aims to sustainably balance and optimize the health of people, animals and ecosystems. It recognizes that the health of humans, domestic and wild animals, plants, and the wider environment (including ecosystems) are closely linked and interdependent.” – WEB

What does OneHealth mean for our sovereignty?

The System loves the vaccine passport because as soon as they can impose it they’re going to turn it into your money …your vaccine wallet…vaccine passport is the excuse to bring [social credit score model] in.

This is primarily about control, this is not about your health. If it was about your health they would have done things right during COVID…they want to do more of the bad stuff…

There’s something called OneHealth which enables the director general of the WHO to declare emergencies that are not health emergencies. They can be climate emergencies, or ecosystem emergencies, or gun violence emergencies…anyway you can call health of humans, animals or ecosystems, or plants…they can then impose rules on us for.Dr Meryl Nass, March 8, 2024

The OneHealth Agenda timeline

The agenda seems to trace back to a September 2002 article in Foreign Affairs magazine written by the head of the WCS, justifying why the conservation movement needs to lead a global response in connecting the “triangle of wildlife health, domestic animal health, and human health.” The following year his Society coined the term “One Health”.

  • One World One Health -website ARCHIVE
  • One Health Commission website – HERE, History – HERE
  • One Health Global Network “Milestones” – HERE
  • One Health Commission – HERE
    • March 2017 – “One Health links human, animal, and ecosystem health into a model for solving today’s health problems.“- WATCH, CREDIT
  • The International Journal of Infectious Diseases (IJID) One Health (OH), an open access, peer-reviewed journal published monthly online by the International Society for Infectious Diseases (ISID) – READ, see 2007
  • EcoHealth Journal – Public Health Official journal of EcoHealth Alliance – (One Health) – READ
  • Australian Govenment: Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research on One Health – READ, SEARCH, AIRPOH w/ Canada – HERE
  • World Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH) – One Health – HERE
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is one-health-transition-900x322.jpg

“One Health” concept has morphed over the years from Wildlife Conservation Society proposal (2007) to United Nations Quadriparties Agenda (2021)! – source, source

Australia hosted the First International OneHealth Congress in 2011

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is congresses-900x150.jpg

source

Links in reverse chronological order

2025

January 16, 2025 – The Defender: U.S. Launches ‘One Health’ Plan Prompting Concerns About Global Power Play – READ

  • “The U.S. last week introduced a national framework for One Health to help the country prepare for “the next potential threat” to public health. Critics argue the plan will expand government surveillance and crisis-driven health policies”
  • Meryl Nass Substack: US government implemented its One Health Framework last week
    And I watched every boring minute of the announcement – “IMHO, this project is simply an effort to create an alternate governance structure:” – SLIDES – CREDIT

January 10, 2024 – CC Newsroom: U.S. Government Releases First National One Health Plan to Protect People, Animals, and Our Environment from Shared Health Threats – READ, ARCHIVE, CREDIT

  • The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), and the Department of the Interior (DOI) today released the first-ever National One Health Framework to Address Zoonotic Diseases and Advance Public Health Preparedness in the United StatesPDF, CDC One Health Coordination – READ
  • “In developing this framework, the U.S. government is helping to ensure that the groundwork is laid for effective disease response in the future so that we can be better prepared for the next potential threat.”
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is OneHealth-Framework-2025.jpg

US National One Health Framework – PDF

  • Responding to COVID-19 with the One Health Approach – “The COVID-19 pandemic led to the creation of new One Health coordination activities across the US government.” – REF

2024

December 3-6, 2024 (scheduled) – ProMED: 20th International Congress on Infectious Diseases (ICID) 2024 | Cape Town, South Africa – features an expanded range of sessions by bringing the One Health aspect to the world of clinical infectious diseases and microbiology. Looking through the One Health lens – READ, ARCHIVE

  • “The recent COVID-19 pandemic highlights the importance of the need for continued research, innovation, and funding in the field of infectious diseases” [of course it does!]. ProMED and SARS-CoV-2 – READ

September 20-23, 2024 (scheduled) – World One Health Conference, Cape Town, South Africa – READ, CREDIT


April 17, 2024 – Meryl Nass: US Government bribes 100 countries to agree to the global biosecurity agenda, and openly reveals that One Health will be used to control food, economic development and climate – READ

  • Whitehouse REPORT: US Government Global Health Security Strategy 2024 (April 2024) – PDF, ARCHIVE
    • “…because health security, economic security, climate security, and national security are all related.”

…they really are using the “health” hook to wrap up the food supply, economic development, plants and animals…into one neat “thing” they plan to control in the name of preventing zoonotic disease spillover. [Disease X]

They aren’t even trying to hide it anymoreDr Meryl Nass

March 8, 2024 – The Kim Iversen Show: This Doctor Proved They’ve Been Doing Biowarefare For Decades. Now They’re Censoring Her – WATCH

  • Dr Meryl Nass explains how WHO vaccine passports will become a digital wallet together interlinked with the pandemic treaty/IHR and OneHealth – it threaten us all – EXCERPT

The System loves the vaccine passport because as soon as they can impose it they’re going to turn it into your money …your vaccine wallet…vaccine passport is the excuse to bring [social credit score model] in.

This is primarily about control, this is not about your health. If it was about your health they would have done things right during COVID…they want to do more of the bad stuff…

There’s something called OneHealth which enables the director general of the WHO to declare emergencies that are not health emergencies. They can be climate emergencies, or ecosystem emergencies, or gun violence emergencies…anyway you can call health of humans, animals or ecosystems, or plants…they can then impose rules on us for.Dr Meryl Nass

February 8, 2024 – A Midwestern Doctor Substack: Why The Bioweapons Research Industry Is A Danger to Society and what the WHO is doing to protect this grift now that the public is wising up to it. – One Health etc – READ

  • “…fears have been used to create the justification we need to perform an endless amount of bioweapons research to “prevent” the next pandemic.
  • “Since the public is gradually becoming aware of what COVID cartel has done to us, they are switching to far more totalitarian methods to ensure they can continue their grift. We are at a pivotal moment to stop that, and that is why this series was written.
  • “…given how easy experts are to buy off (as we all saw throughout the pandemic), it was clear to any seasoned observer that One Health was simply an attempt to merge the war on infectious diseases with the war on future environmental catastrophe and have “One Health” usurp the ability of the common people to speak out against it—as under the incredibly broad definition of “One Health,” almost every aspect of our lives was something which could be regulated under it (e.g., you can’t live here because it might increase the chance of you coming in contact with a wild animal that could spark a pandemic)….most of “One Health” is a series of deceptive promises wrapped in doublespeak which simply serve the billionaire class and do anything but promote health” – REF

January 28, 2024 – Meryl Nass Substack: “One Health” has an earlier pedigree than I knew. The false narratives emanating from One health had already been created by 2004, and one author of this drivel now works at EcoHealth Alliance – READ, inspired data point TIMELINE

  • William H. Foege, a Fellow at the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation gave the Keynote Speech: “One World, One Health, Could We Muddle Through?” – REF

2023

May 17, 2023 – CHD | The Defender: ‘Sinister Forces at Play’ in WHO’s Global One Health Agenda – READ

  • “…the World Health Organization appears to have used the COVID-19 crisis as a catalyst for an about-turn on its previously more altruistic and democratic approach.”

May 8, 2023 – CHD | The Defender : One Health: A Plan to ‘Surveil and Control Every Aspect of Life on Earth’? – READ

  • Experts who spoke with The Defender suggested One Health has more to do with a biosecurity agenda, a global surveillance system, vaccine passports and restrictions on human behavior than it has to do with protecting human health.

May 1, 2023 – The Defender: ‘One Health’ — The Global Takeover of Everything? – READ

  • Under the One Health agenda, the World Health Organization would have power to make decisions relating to diet, agriculture and livestock farming, environmental pollution, movement of populations and much more. Taxpayers would fund the scheme — corporations would profit.”

April 27, 2023 – The Defender: ‘One Health’: What Is It, Who’s Promoting It — and Why? – READ

  • The “One Health” concept has been gaining traction among public health policymakers in recent years — but questions remain about what One Health really means, who’s behind the concept and whether what started out as a sound idea has since been hijacked by individuals or groups that see it as a means to expand their power.

2022

December 6, 2022 – Meryl Nass Substack: One Health: what is it and why is it important? One Health is being embedded into the WHO’s International Health Regulations (IHRs) and Pandemic Treaty/AccordREAD

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is one-health-umbrella.webp

The One Health Umbrella – source

2022 – FAO: Rome: One Health Joint Plan of Action (2022-2026) – Working Together for the Health of Humans, Animals, Plants and the EnvironmentPDF, READ, READ

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is one-health-action-plan.jpg

PDF

June 3, 2022 – World Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH) – launch One Health page – READ, ARCHIVE

  • “The COVID-19 pandemic, a human public health crisis resulting from a virus of potential animal origin, underlined the validity of the One Health concept in understanding and confronting global health risks.” – REF
    • [Except this statement is misleading and deceptive as it is most likely the SARS-CoV-2 virus came from a lab in Wuhan as a result of gain-of-function research techniques, and was covered up by the very people helping to push “One Health” genetic surveillance and vaccine countermeasure “research” – virus origins TIMELINE
    • Maybe the emerging “bird flu” – avian influenza is the same
  • WOAH Terrestrial Animal Health Code! – HERE, SOURCE
  • WOAH Manual of Diagnostic Tests and Vaccines for Terrestrial Animals: Chapter 3.3.4. Avian Influenza – PDF, SOURCE
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is one-health-500x494.jpg

“One Health” approach summarises a concept “that human, animal and plant health are interdependent and bound to the health of the ecosystems in which they exist”- source

January 30, 2022 – WHO: On World NTD Day, WHO releases key document to guide a paradigm shift towards One Health – ARCHIVE

  • The “Road Map” Document: Ending the neglect to attain the sustainable development goals. One health: approach for action against neglected tropical diseases 2021-2030ARCHIVE
  • In an “efforts to control and eliminate neglected tropical diseases (NTDs)”. [It will move to Disease X soon enough]
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is One-Health-2022.jpg

One Health Approach for action against neglected tropical diseases 2021–2030 – PDF

2021

December 2021 – Global One Health Community: The Quadripartite (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), World Health Organization (WHO), and the World Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH)) welcomed the newly formed operational definition of One Health from their advisory panel, the One Health High Level Expert Panel (OHHLEP) – READ

One Health is an integrated, unifying approach that aims to sustainably balance and optimize the health of people, animals and ecosystems.

It recognizes the health of humans, domestic and wild animals, plants, and the wider environment (including ecosystems) are closely linked and inter-dependent.

The approach mobilizes multiple sectors, disciplines and communities at varying levels of society to work together to foster well-being and tackle threats to health and ecosystems, while addressing the collective need for clean water, energy and air, safe and nutritious food, taking action on climate change, and contributing to sustainable development.Definition of One Health, developed by the One Health High Level Expert Panel (OHHLEP), PDF

September 6, 2021 – Indo Pacific Health Security: Australian expert appointed to One Health High Level Expert Advisory Panel – Professor John Mackenzie, a member of the Centre’s Technical Reference Group, – READ, Members- HERE

  • The panel was established jointly by the UN Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO), the World Organization for Animal Health, the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the World Health Organization (WHO) Launched May 2021

February 2021 : The Tripartite organisations FAO, WHO and WOAH, who had been together for 27 years (since 1994?), called on the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) to join their effort “reaffirming the importance of the environmental dimension of the One Health collaboration.” – PDF

  • UNEP agreed to jointly develop a strategy and action plan to prevent future pandemics through the One Health approach ->
  • Rome 2022: One Health Joint Plan of Action (2022-2026) – Working Together for the Health of Humans, Animals, Plants and the Environment – PDF

2020

March 23, 2020 – How ProMED Crowdsourced the Arrival of Covid-19 and SARS – READ [One Health surveillance]

  • Marjorie Pollack, a physician, epidemiologist and deputy editor of ProMED got email alert from China

March 11, 2020 – Scientific American: How China’s “Bat Woman” Hunted Down Viruses from SARS to the New Coronavirus – READ

  • Once potential pathogens are mapped out, scientists and public health officials can regularly check for possible infections by analyzing blood and swab samples from livestock, wild animals that are farmed and traded, and high-risk human populations…This approach, known as “One Health,” says Peter Daszak

2017

December 5-7, 2017 – CDC: Prioritizing Zoonoses for Global Health Capacity BuildingThemes from One Health Zoonotic Disease Workshops in 7 Countries, 2014–2016 – PDF, ARCHIVE, CREDIT

  • The workshop was held December 5-7, 2017, at the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office ofthe Assistant Secretary for Preparedness and,Response (ASPR) headquarters in Washington, DC
  • “Fourteen CDC-trained OHZDP workshop facilitators were used for the 7 workshops and represented interdisciplinary backgrounds with expertise in zoonoses. A total of 21 in-country facilitators were trained at 5 of the 7 workshops,…”
  • “Early detection of zoonotic pathogens through enhanced laboratory capacity and surveillance at the animal–human interface is a crucial step toward controlling and preventing zoonoses”
    • Moving interdisciplinary science forward: integrating participatory modelling with mathematical modelling of zoonotic disease in Africa. Grant et al. Infect Dis Poverty. 2016; 5:17. – ARCHIVE (United Nations)
    • This work, Dynamic Drivers of Disease in Africa Consortium, NERC project no. NE-J001570-1, was funded with support from the Ecosystem Services for Poverty Alleviation (ESPA) programme. The ESPA programme is funded by the Department for International Development (DFID), the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) and the Natural Environment Research Council (NERC).”

August 23, 2017 – Zoonotic Disease Prioritization – ARCHIVE

  • “In 2017, CDC, USDA, and DOI organized a One Health Zoonotic Disease Prioritization (OHZDP)workshop to further joint efforts to address zoonotic disease challenges in the United States. Participants in the workshop identified eight zoonotic diseases of greatest national concern…” – REF

March 2017 – Research Gate: Roadmap to a One Health Agenda 2030 – READ, SOURCE

2016

November 3, 2016 – One Health Commission PRESS RELEASE: GLOBAL “ONE HEALTH DAY” PLANNED BY THREE INTERNATIONAL ONE HEALTH GROUPS – READ, They’ve designated November 3, “One Health Day” – READ, CREDIT

  • One Health Day is celebrated through One Health educational and awareness events held around the world.

2011

March 1, 2011 – CDC launch their One Health website – ARCHIVE

February 14-16, 2011 – 1st International One Health Congress: Human Health, Animal Health, the Environment and Global Survival in Melbourne, Australia – to Showcase the One Health concept globally, to open debate to the wider international scientific and policy making community – ARCHIVE, REF, WEB, Report – PDF

  • Focus on outcomes needed to effectively manage growing risks to global health & make global policy recommendations and organizational changes, using underlying science, to drive real and profound change.
  • Co-Chaired by Professor John Mackenzie, who happens to have been on WHO emergency committee who decided SARS-CoV-2 was a PHEIC – READ, TIMELINE, in 2021 australia appoints him head of One Health advisory panel! – READ
  • “Professor Peter Doherty’s keynote speech dealt with the growing evidence of negative impact of human behavior on the health of the world and the likely risk to humankind.” – REF
  • Published EcoHealth Journal: 2011, Volume 7, Supplement – “One Health – Ecology & Health – Public Health Official journal of EcoHealth Alliance”: 1st International One Health CongressREAD
  • One Health case studies, from all continentsThere is clearly a “One Health movement” starting out there” – REF

2010

July 2010 – United Nations and World Bank Fifth Global Progress Report: Animal and Pandemic Influenza; A framework for Sustaining Momentum – The adoption of “One Health approaches” is one of the three suggested mainstreams of the “framework for sustaining momentum”REF

May 2010 – Stone Mountain meeting (Atlanta, Georgia): Operationalizing One Health: a Policy Perspective -taking stock and shaping an implementation roadmap, One Health working groups are set up, with 3-year time operational objectives. – REF

April 21, 2010 – UNited Nations: Hanoi Declaration Sets Global Framework for Avian Influenza, Pandemic Readiness, Proposes National Steps to Detect Animal-Human Transmission, Control Outbreaks – READ

March 16 -17, 2010 – Shifting from Emergency Response to Prevention of Pandemic Disease Threats at Source, Chatham HouseREF, no archive – HERE

2009

October 22, 2009 – One World – One Health: Brazil 2009

2008

October 2008 – 6th International Ministerial Conference on Avian and Pandemic Influenza at Sharm-el-Sheikh – READOne Health becomes a political reality and a recommended approach

  • “In 2008, the three major international organizations charged with animal health and human health—FAO, OIE and WHO—collaborated with UNICEF, the UN System for Influenza Coordinator, and the World Bank to develop a joint strategic framework in response to the evolving risk of emerging and re-emerging infectious diseases.
  • The document communicating this framework, ‘Contributing to One World, One Health—A Strategic Framework for Reducing Risks of Infectious Diseases at the Animal-Human-Ecosystems Interface,’ was officially released” – ARCHIVE
    • The ‘One World, One Health’ concept, which establishes a more interdisciplinary and cross-sectoral approach to preventing epidemic or epizootic disease and for maintaining ecosystem integrity, is a trademark of the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS).REF

June 9, 2008 – PRESS RELEASE: Wildlife Conservation Society Announces One World One Health Research Projects Funded by Cargill a global food company – PDF, CREDIT

  • “The Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS), a non-governmental organization based in the United States with offices in Brazil, announced that five projects will receive financial support during the first year of the One World-One Health (OWOH) program in Brazil.”

2007

December 2007 – International Ministerial Conference on Avian and Pandemic Influenza (IMCAPI) of New Delhi – REF

  • Promoting One Health could be the natural extension of the Global Response to Avian Influenza (GRAI).” it is set in stone the next year!

October 2-4, 2007 – Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS): One World-One Health: Brazil 2007 Symposium- Healthy Ecosystems, Livestock and Human Livelihoods: An Innovative Public-Private PartnershipARCHIVE, Agenda – ARCHIVE

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is one-health-links.jpg

Welcome by Robert Cook – source
And this is how “conservations” gets involved in human health – SLIDE

  • Building upon the successful model of our previous One World – One Health symposia in New York, Bangkok and Beijing, we are now introducing this multidisciplinary approach to health and livelihoods to Brazil.
    • William Karesh, linking disease to population, land, conservation.
    • One World – One Health – One Surveillance System (aka ProMED mail) – READ, SLIDES
      • Program for Monitoring Emerging Diseases (ProMED) is the global electronic reporting system for outbreaks of emerging infectious diseases & toxins. It is a program of the International Society for Infectious DiseasesARCHIVE, History ISID – READ
      • ProMED and One Health today – HERE

2005

November 30, 2005 – The Lancet: Potential of cooperation between human and animal health to strengthen health systems – Zinsstag et al – READ

  • The WHO ministerial summit held in Mexico City, Mexico, on Nov 16–20, 2004, recognised the pivotal role of strengthened health systems in achieving the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) in an equity-effective manner
  • US epidemiologist Calvin Schwabe coined the term “one medicine”, to focus attention on the similarity between human and veterinary health interests – Historical roots of the “one medicine”

2005 – WCS: Conservation and Development Interventions at the Wildlife/Livestock Interface: Implications for Wildlife, Livestock and Human Health – by Osofsky, Karesh et al – READ

2004

November 17-25, 2004 – 3rd Session the World Conservation Congress, Bangkok, Thailand – ARCHIVE, REF, CREDIT

  • RESWCC3.011: Addressing the linkages between conservation, human and animal health, and security – Reclassified as a resolution 2004 – PDF

November 15, 2004 – Thialand Workshop prior to World Conservation Congress: Beyond Zoonoses: One World – One Health, The Threat of Emerging Diseases to Human Security and Conservation, and the Implications for Public Policy – ARCHIVE, Presentations – ARCHIVE

  • “Monkey pox,” “SARS,” “Ebola” and “avian influenza” are now household words.
  • The “workshop organized by the Wildlife Conservation Society, the IUCN Commission on Environmental Law, the IUCN Veterinary Specialist Group, the IUCN Commission on Environmental, Economic and Social Policy, the International Institute for Sustainable Development, the Center for Environmental Legal Studies of Pace University School of Law, and Asia – Pacific Centre for Environmental Law at the National University of Singapore, and the U.S. Centers for Disease Control

September 29, 2004 – One World, One Health: Building Interdisciplinary Bridges to Health in a “Globalized World” – READ, READ, CREDIT

September 29, 2004 – One World One Health: Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS): One World, One Health: Building Interdisciplinary Bridges to Health in a Globalized World – Symposium organised by WCS, hosted by The Rockefeller University, Caspary Auditorium – ARCHIVE, TIMELINE by Robert A. Cook, William B. Karesh, and Steven A. Osofsky of the Wildlife Conservation Society, Bronx, New York, USA, – Manhattan Principles

One World One Health – 2024 logo –source
  • Represented by the World Health Organization(WHO); the UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO); the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC); the United States Geological Survey National Wildlife Health Center; the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA); the Canadian Cooperative Wildlife Health Centre; the Laboratoire Nationale de Sante Publique of Brazzaville, Republic of Congo; the IUCN Commission on Environmental Law; and the Wildlife Conservation Society and more
  • Health experts from around the world met … for a symposium focused on the current and potential movements of diseases among human, domestic animal, and wildlife populations…[The] assembled expert panelists delineated priorities for an international, interdisciplinary approach for combating threats to the health of life on Earth
  • The product—called the “Manhattan Principles” by the organizers of the “One World, One Health” event, lists 12 recommendations for world’s leaders, civil society, the global health community and institutions of science for establishing a more holistic approach to preventing epidemic / epizootic disease and for maintaining ecosystem integrity for the benefit of humans, their domesticated animals, and the foundational biodiversity that supports us all. – READ
  • “The key theme of this conference was that given the dire urgency of the environmental and biological threats we faced, all major “One Health” decisions would need to be made by a panel of multidisciplinary experts.” – REF
  • The 12 Manhattan Principles – As defined during the meeting titled Building Interdisciplinary Bridges to Health in a “Globalized World” held in 2004 – READ

2003

September 14-15, 2003 – WCS: IUCN 2003 World Parks Congress AHEAD Launch Forum | Durban, South Africa – “Southern and East African Experts Panel on Designing Successful Conservation and Development Interventions at the Wildlife/Livestock Interface: Implications for Wildlife, Livestock, and Human Health”READ, ARCHIVE, ARCHIVE, Briefing Booklet – ARCHIVE

  • The Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS), IUCN Veterinary Specialist Group (VSG), and other partners helped to start the initiative is called AHEAD – Animal Health for the Environment And Development, in recognition of the importance of animal health to both conservation and development interests. …”Around the world, domestic and wild animals are coming into ever-more-intimate contact… without adequate scientific knowledge and planning, the consequences can be detrimental on one or both sides of the proverbial fence. But armed with the tools that the health sciences provide, conservation and development objectives have a much greater chance of being realized – particularly at the critical wildlife/livestock intersection, where conservation and agricultural interests meet head-on.” – REF [a prelude to One Health]
  • “To date, neither the nongovernmental organizations nor the aid community nor academia have holistically addressed the landscape-level nexus represented by the triangle of wildlife health, domestic animal health, and human health.
  • AHEAD publications – ARCHIVES
  • IUCN Occasional Paper No. 30 – Conservation and Development Interventions at the Wildlife/Livestock Interface: Implications for Wildlife, Livestock and Human Health – by Osofsky, Karesh et al – READ
    • Introduction “Looking AHEAD While Looking Back” by Osofsky – PDF, SOURCE
    • “As socioeconomic progress demands sustained improvements in health for people, their domestic animals, and the environment, we hope we’ve been successful in drawing attention to the need to move towards a “one health” perspective – an approach that was the foundation of our discussions in Durban, and a theme pervading this Proceedings.”

2002

December 7, 2002 – First archive page of the Wildlife Conservation Society’s Field Veterinary Program (VFP): Said to be the architects of Global Approach to Health – ARCHIVE

October 25, 2002 – National Geographic News: Human “Footprint” Seen on 83 Percent of Earth’s Land – READ, WCS Human Footprint Map – READ

September/October 2002 – Foreign Affairs magazine | Volume 81, Number 5: The Future of Conservation – A New Conservation Agenda is needed – By Dr. Steven Sanderson, President of the Wildlife Conservation Society – READ, SOURCE

  • Setting the justification for conservation (specifically Wildlife Conservation Society) to develop and lead a new global agenda. [Find an “unmet need” and exploit it – see Sept 2003 the “triangle of wildlife health, domestic animal health, and human health.

2001

January 24, 2001 – Steven E. Sanderson, a political scientits, is named President and CEO of The Wildlife Conservation Society – READ Sanderson is highly involved in the creating of One Health.

1994

1994 – The Program for Monitoring Emerging Diseases (ProMED) is a program of the International Society for Infectious Diseases (ISID), it was launched in 1994 as an Internet service to identify unusual health events related to emerging and re-emerging infectious diseases and toxins affecting humans, animals and plants – REF, it becomes part of One Health disease surveillance program.

  • International Congress on Infectious Diseases (ICID) was established in 1983 as a scientific assembly for the exchange of research and clinical information in infectious diseases, and in 1986 it merged with The International Federation on Infectious and Parasitic Diseases (IFIPD) and became the Society- READ
  • ISID journal began ~1996 – ISSUES

1989

1989 – The WCS Field Veterinary Program (FVP), established in 1989 – REF

1966

Under the leadership of William Conway as General Director of the WCS in 1966 and then President in 1992 the field conservation programs expanded throughout the world – REF

1895

The Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS) traces its origin to April 26,1895 when New York State chartered the New York Zoological Society. WCS is based at the Bronx Zoo! – REF

The post One World, One Health Agenda first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
Edible Insects (and Lab Grown Meat) https://totalityofevidence.com/edible-insects/ Tue, 23 Jan 2024 07:56:57 +0000 https://totalityofevidence.com/?p=44199 The Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations for a world without hunger (FAO) class Edible Insects as a “protein with a lighter environmental footprint”. I was aware of this eating insect/bug narrative through the promotion of Nicole Kidman…

The post Edible Insects (and Lab Grown Meat) first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

]]>
The Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations for a world without hunger (FAO) class Edible Insects as a “protein with a lighter environmental footprint”.

I was aware of this eating insect/bug narrative through the promotion of Nicole Kidman “eating bugs” in 2021, an attempt to make eating bugs look attractive and to normalise this behaviour. That narrative has bubbled to the “in your face” surface now as highlighted in Episode 355 of The Highwire covering recent German Farmer Protests and connecting that to insects farming. This war against our food supply has been going on long before 2024.

Crafting the Narrative

Follow along the timeline from the bottom and notice the target market shifting, the groups who first get excited, the investors and more. It starts with “inspired” college roommates, investors are “attracted”, the “movement” has capital now to “market” and build, then the United Nations gets on board [allegedly].

It appears to have started in 2006 with the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation releasing a report titled Livestock’s Long Shadow which is being quoted that by 2050 Glgbal demand for meat will double, where “livestock production accounts already for 70% of all agricultural land”. Based on these trusted numbers alternative, sustainable protein sources have been pushed from January 2012 conference.

The “growing drive to bring insects into Western shopping baskets” took off in 2013 following FAO’s Edible Insects report . They are “rich in protein; environmentally friendly to harvest; sustainable; and, they’re already eaten, and enjoyed, in many other parts of the world.”

Setting the stage for the next superfood, packed with nutrition!: “‘Crickets are up to 70 per cent protein, which is three times the amount of protein found in beef. They’ve also got more iron than spinach, more calcium than milk, and the list keeps going. They are an incredible superfood.”

The Gateway Insect: “Crickets are the most widely cultivated insects for the human diet across the world and are considered the ‘gateway bug’ for people who choose to eat insects.”

Link to pages driving the “eat bugs” agenda:

  • The Journal of Insects as Food and Feed (JIFF) launched May 2014 – READ
  • First “Insects to feed the world” conference May 2014 – REF
  • United Nations Food & Agriculture Organisation (FAO) – leads the global charge on edible insects – WEB
  • International Platform of Insects for Food and Feed (IPIFF) circa 2014 – Promoting Insects for Human Consumption – HERE

Climate Change

The climate change agenda is driving the “eat bugs” agenda. What the media won’t tell you – HERE


ToE Substack Jan 26, 2024 – READ

This page is attempting to trace back where this climate-driven food agenda began, and how it has evolved. The timeline will be continuously updated as articles and links come to my attention.

Links in reverse chronological order

2024

April 22, 2024 – Nature: Revealed: the ten research papers that policy documents cite most – READ [to get ballpark date – as EAT don’t date their documents]

  • EAT Forum: ‘Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT-Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems’, is now undisputedly one of the most influential scientific reports in the world. – READ

    March 25, 2024 – Chief Nerd: Lab-Grown’ Meat Made Inside Bioreactors Is Now Being Tested at Restaurants in the U.S. – WATCH

    January 2024 – EAT Forum: Economists calculate multi-trillion dollar opportunity to fix the broken global food system – READ, ARCHIVE,

    • Food System Economics Commission | Global Policy Report: The Economics of the Food System TransformationPDF, ARCHIVE, SOURCE
      • The Food System Economics Commission (FSEC) has brought together leading experts to develop a unique economic model that maps for the first time the impacts of two possible futures for the global food system: our Current Trends pathway, and the Food System Transformation pathway.
    • Wellcome Trust and Lancet among the sponsors of this monstrosity, termed EAT – CREDIT
    • EAT is a global, non-profit startup dedicated to transforming our global food system through sound science, impatient disruption and novel partnerships. – (2019) – ARCHIVE,
      • EAT is a non-profit founded by the Stordalen Foundation, Stockholm Resilience Centre and the Wellcome Trust to catalyze a food system transformation (Jan 17, 2019) – ARCHIVE, EAT-Lancet Commission – ARCHIVE
      • EAT is the science-based global platform for food system transformation. -(2024) READ

    January 2024 – The Highwire Episode 355: UNREDACTED – WATCH, The Jaxen Report: Edible Insects in the context of Davos 2024 – EXCERPT

    2024 – Sustainable Protein Sources (2nd Edition) – Advances for Healthier Tomorrow: Chapter 25 – Edible Insects: a Neglected and Promising Food Source – READ

    • “The interest in insects as human food in the Western world is increasingly considered a viable alternative to other protein sources. In tropical countries, it is common practice and about 2000 insect species are eaten. Insects emit low levels of greenhouse gases, need little water, and require limited agricultural land.”

    2023

    December 1, 2023 – Brian Sussman Show – Ep 20 – Latest Climate Plan: “No Meat For You!” and more – WATCH

    December 2023? – WHO Tedros – wants us to “transform food system” to combat “climate change” – TWEET

    October 4, 2023 – Liberty & FinanceL Farms Being Shutdown; We Must Resist | Alex Newman – WATCH, READ

    • The UN Master Plan for Humanity

    September 25, 2023 – Epoch TV: No Farmers No Food: Will You Eat The Bugs? | Documentary – WATCH

    July 13, 2023 – FreedomFest 2023 | Alex Newman: The Global War on Farmers and Push to “Eat The Bugs” – READ, TWEET, CREDIT

    • Epoch Times: ‘No Farmers No Food’ Documentary Panel Discussion Held at FreedomFest – READ

    July 9, 2023 – 41st Annual Meeting of Doctors for Disaster Preparedness: Let Them Eat Bugs – Debbie Bacigalupi – WATCH

    2022

    October 19, 2022 – Daily Mail: Aldi considers selling edible INSECTS to help families through the cost-of-living crisis – READ, Summit News – CREDIT

    • Butget supermarket Aldi in the UK is considering stocking ‘edible’ bugs and providing recipe kits for parents to prepare worms and crickets for their hungry children, to solve “poverty”. Bugs are “known” to be “a cheap and sustainable form of protein”.
    • The supermarket is also involved with a TV game show in which insect ‘farmers’ will pitch the bugs as the ‘next big thing’
    • Yum Bug founders Aaron Thomas and Leo Taylor, both 28, are competing against other start-ups to get their product on the supermarket’s shelves

    September 2, 2022 – The Guardian: UK urges hunger-stricken African nations to farm insects – READ

    July 20, 2022 – Rebel News: Elites want us to eat bugs: Montrealers take a taste test – READ

    • A new ideology that governments want to indoctrinate citizens with is one claiming that if we want to save the planet, we will have to turn to alternative sources of protein. Alternative sources such as insects, of course.

    July 16, 2022 – WEF: You Will Eat Bugs, and You Will Be Happy – WATCH

    June 27, 2022 – London Free Press: By Jiminy! Feds put $8.5M into London cricket farm – Aspire cricket manufacturing farm – READ

    • $8.5 million of taxpayer money will go toward construction costs and technology — artificial intelligence specifically — that will monitor the billions of crickets about to be turned into food. The facility starts in a few days.
      • byproducts will be sold back to area farmers as fertilizer
    • Mohammed Ashour, co-founder and chief executive of Aspire Foods, an idea that began nine years ago (2013) as a project with four other McGill University students who, in essence, want to solve the problem of world hunger.
      • 5 MBA students from McGill University “entered the world’s largest and most prestigious social enterprise competition” the 2013 Challenge The Global Food Crisis, which they won the Clinton Global Initiative Hult Prize in 2013 – About –REF

    May 30, 2022 – Daily Mail: Would you eat bug bolognese? Primary school children in Wales could be offered EDIBLE INSECTS including mealworms and crickets as scientists urge the next generation to embrace eco-friendly meat substitutes – READ

    May 26, 2022 – Canadian Manufacturing: Aspire Food Group completes production of manufacturing facility in London, Ontario – to produce 9000 metric tons of crickets every year for human and pet consumption – READ, CREDIT

    • Aspire: A world transformed by insect technology – WEB, “Crickets are nature’s superfood ingredient for healthier, happier pets” – READ
    • Eventually, 13 million kilograms of crickets will be processed annually in London. – REF

    February 9, 2022 – WEF | Climate Change | Davos 2022 Agenda: 5 reasons why eating insects could reduce climate change – “Before you say “yuck,” hear us out.” – READ, You will Eat Bugs – WATCH

    1. Edible insects can produce equivalent amounts of quality protein when compared to animals – not all but, crickets, certain ant species and mealworms are known to be protein and calorie dense stars in the the insect-consumption world.
    2. Insects require less care and upkeep than livestock – they use less resources, less than plants!! [Plants use CO2 and produce oxygen – it appears they want to take our plants too!]
    3. We’re actually running out of protein – The demand for protein will exceed our ability to procure it with10 bn people by 2050 [Well if the taking land, well yes!]
    4. Insects are part of a virtuous eco-cycle – circular agriculture – feed microlivestock landfill waste!
    5. . You can start small and work your way up – consume animals raised on insects!

    January 14, 2022 – Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems: Review: Insects—A Source of Safe and Sustainable Food?— “Jein” (Yes and No) – Grabowski et al – READ, some definitions

    • “The role of the consumer is the final factor that justifies the idea of producing insect-based foodstuffs or not…the effort in producing it is futile when the consumer simply does not eat it”

    2021

    December 30, 2021 – Summit News: Vanderbilt University Professor Argues That We All Need To Eat BUGS – “Black soldier fly larvae, in particular, hold promise.”, follow the EU example – READ

    October 22, 2021 – PHYS: Eating the right insects can provide nutrition, and might be good for the planet – READ

    • According to UN FAO “Some 2 billion people around the world already eat insects to supplement their diet”
    • A January 2021 study in Critical Reviews in Food Science Nutrition said edible insects may have “high superior health benefits”

    July 12, 2021 – WEF: Why we need to give insects the role they deserve in our food systems – READ

    May 9, 2021 – The Guardian: If we want to save the planet, the future of food is insects – READ

    • Ref the EAT-Lancet Commission report (see Jan 2019)

    April 9, 2021 – FAO: Food safety aspects of edible insects outlined in new publication – READ, ARCHIVE,

    • Looking at edible insects from a food safety perspective – Challenges and opportunities for the sector – REPORT
      • “FINANCIAL INVESTMENTS: Despite growing interest in the sector, procuring investments can be difficult for start-up companies owing to unclear regulations about the production and commercializationof insects as food and feed. This may also have implications on the advancement of research and development in the field.”
      • “overcoming food neophobia among some consumers, especially in the Western countries, is a challenge for the edible insects sector”
    United Nations Edible Insects report 2021 – source

    May 11, 2021 – Wired: The Cicadas Are Coming. Let’s Eat Them! – Why not embrace Brood X as the free-range, sustainable source of protein that it truly is? – READ, The Hartman Group – CREDIT

    • Edible insects have been a part of rich culinary traditions around the world for years, from Mexico’s crunchy chapulines to beondegi, Korea’s silkworm pupae street food
    • Market researchers predict the global edible insect market will reach $4.63 billion by 2027, with North America as the fastest-growing sector – ARCHIVE, now Edible Insects Market Worth $9.60 Billion by 2030 – READ

    January 14, 2021 – Summit News: EU’s food safety agency Gives Go-ahead For Eating WORMS – “Allergic reactions are likely to occur”.ARCHIVE, Mealworm consideration – ARCHIVES

    January 2021 – Edible Insects Market by Product (Whole Insect, Insect Powder, Insect Meal, Insect Oil) Insect Type (Crickets, Black Soldier Fly, Mealworms), Application (Animal Feed, Protein Bar and Shakes, Bakery, Confectionery, Beverages) – Global Forecast to 2027 by Meticulous Market Research Pvt. Ltd- READ, CREDIT

    • Market researchers predict the global edible insect market will reach $4.63 billion by 2027, with North America as the fastest-growing sector – ARCHIVE, Updated Jun 2022 – Edible Insects Market Worth $9.60 Billion by 2030READ
    • Based on insect type, the crickets segment is expected to dominate the edible insects market during the forecast period of 2020-2027 (In terms of value) – REF

    2020

    December 22, 2020 – IOP Science | Environ. Res. Lett. : A review of edible insect industrialization: scales of production and implications for sustainability – Wade et al – READ

    • “Edible insects have emerged in the past decade as a sustainable alternative to agro-industrial production systems and livestock-based diets.” [see below what has driven this!]

    December 17, 2020 – FAO releases a comprehensive guide to sustainable cricket farmingREAD, PDF

    September 9, 2020 – Runtastic: Eating Insects Might Be Your New Favorite Source of Protein – READ, the WEF refered to this blog post as a “study”- HERE, the blog links to Sep 2015 paper – HERE

    • With over 2,100 types of edible insects to choose from
    • The WEF want you to know that insects offer between 9.96-35.2 g of protein/100g c.f 16.8-20.6 g/100g for meat. They forgot to state “per edible protein”, and that insects vary.

    May 13, 2020 – Euractiv: Insect-based feedstuffs hold ‘enormous potential’ for EU sustainability goals – Farm to Fork strategy “will support the creation of “sustainable and novel feed materials and food,” listing insects as one such potential innovation….“To reduce the environmental and climate impact of animal production,…” – READ

    • 2022 Food Safety: Farm to Fork strategy – for a fair, healthy and environmentally-friendly food system – at the heart of the Green New Deal- ARCHIVE

    April 3, 2020 – Guardian: Edible insects set to be approved by EU in ‘breakthrough moment’ – READ

    • EU’s European Food Safety Authority is expected by the insect industry to endorse whole or ground mealworms, lesser mealworms, locusts, crickets and grasshoppers as being safe for human consumption.

    February 18, 2020 – Hartman Group: The Big Bet on Bugs. Providing Palatable Alternative Proteins for Consumers – READ

    • Food manufacturers are betting that new protein sources are likely to become increasingly attractive alternatives as more consumers are making a conscious decision to eat less meat [Thus any threat to dis-belief of the climate narrative threatens bug investments]

    January 5, 2021 – Critical Reviews in Food Science Nutrition: Potential health benefits of edible insects – Nowakowski et al – READ, CREDIT

    • “Edible insects may have superior health benefits due to their high levels of vitamin B12, iron, zinc, fiber, essential amino acids, omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids, and antioxidants.”

    2019

    October 15, 2019 – The Hartman Group | Research: From Lab-Grown Meat to Insects: Are Consumers Ready to Rethink Protein? – READ

    • A wide range of protein possibilities are emerging, including those in the increasingly popular plant-based category but also those that are genetically modified, derived from cell-cultured meats, or derived from insects
      • Food & Technology 2019: From Plant-Based to Lab-Grown – REPORT “As more consumers than ever question the health, ethical, and environmental implications of animal products…”
    Food proteins being explored – source

    September 12, 2019 – WEF: A psychologist explains why we find some food disgusting – and why it matters – Insects and lab grown meat ” is a promising area for social marketing.” – READ

    August 21, 2019 – World Economic Forum: This London insect farm is changing the way we eat | Pioneers for Our Planet – WATCH

    • A company called Entocycle feeds brewery waste and old coffee grains to fly larvae to create a form of animal feed that doesn’t harm the environment. “Insects are nature’s perfect upcycling machines,” says founder Keiran Whitaker. “They create organic natural protein that we can feed to animals – and eventually humans.”

    July 8, 2019 – PLOS one : A parasitological evaluation of edible insects and their role in the transmission of parasitic diseases to humans and animals – READ, CREDIT

    June 28, 2019 – The Coversation: Eating insects is good for you — and the planet! – READ

    • UN FAO: How to Feed the World in 2050 – PDF

    June 2019 – ARUP Report “The Future of Urban Consumption in a 1.5°C World’ – READ, PDF, C40 – READ, The Highwire Ep 357 – EXCERPT, European Farmers are protesting in 2024, moving global – TIMELINE

    • Expose News: By 2030 you will not eat meat and you will be allowed only three items of new clothing a year, report says – CREDIT,
    • Ambitious target is ZERO meat and milk consumption per day, yet you will still get 2,500kcal/day!

    May 5, 2019 – Wired: Save the Lemurs! Eat the Crickets! -To take pressure off endangered lemurs, researchers are encouraging the people of Madagascar to embrace bugs as a source of protein. – READ Lab grown food revolution

    January 16, 2019 – The Lancet | Commissions from the Lancet journals: Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT–Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systemsREAD, The Guardian – CREDIT, EAT–Lancet Commission web – ARCHIVE

    • The EAT–Lancet Commission is the first full scientific review of what constitutes a healthy diet from a sustainable food system,… Sponsored by the Wellcome Trust!
    • EAT Forum: The EAT-Lancet Commission on Food, Planet, Health – Can we feed a future population of 10 billion people a healthy diet within planetary boundaries? – ARCHIVE
    • Jan 16, 2019 – The Lancet: Report Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT–Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems (Walter Willett et al.) – READ
    • The EAT-Lancet Commission Summary Report – “Transformation to healthy diets by 2050 will require substantial dietary shifts…”- READ, PDF

    2018

    January 29, 2018 – Time: No One Elegantly Devours a Four-Course Meal of Bugs Like Nicole KidmanREAD, In a Vanity Fair video, Kidman reveals that her “hidden talent is eating microlivestock,” i.e. Nicole Kidman Eats Bugs – WATCH

    2017

    April 1, 2017 – Wageninger University: List of edible insects of the worldREAD, PDF

    2016

    November 10, 2016 – WEF: What will we eat in 2030? “or new alternatives (soya products, or perhaps insects or artificial meat)” – ARCHIVE

    April 8, 2016 – The Guardian: The worm has turned: how British insect farms could spawn a food revolution – “With meat prices expected to soar, agricultural entrepreneurs believe invertebrate livestock can provide the protein we need. But will the mainstream ever be ready to eat mealworms?” – READ

    July 2016 – North American Coalition for Insect Agriculture (NACIA) is formed in 2016 when 50 stakeholders in the insects for food and feed industry met at the Eating Insects Detroit Conference – READ, REF

    • Initially North American Edible Insect Coalition (NAEIC) – heads the “BugAg” movement. The mission of the North American Coalition for Insect Agriculture is to encourage positive use of farmed insects in North America.

    May 26-28, 2016 – Eating Insects Conference at Wayne State University in Detroit – the first conference dedicated solely to exploring the culture of edible insects to be held in the U.S – READ, REF

    April 27, 2016 – PROteINSECT Final Conference: Insects as a Sustainable Source of Protein – Feed for the Future – Brussels. An EU funded FP7 project. (Grant #312084) , coordinated by Fera Science Ltd in the United Kingdom – AGENDA, READ, White Paper – PDF

    • PROteINSECT – enabling the exploitation of insects as a sustainable source of protein for animal feed and human nutrition – READ,
      • WHITE PAPER: Insect Protein: Feed for the Future – Addressing the need for feeds of the future todayPDF
    • Fera Science Press Release: Insects no more risky than other proteins as animal feed – ARCHIVE
    • Maggots raised on animal manure could provide a sustainable alternative to animal feed – READ

    March 7, 2016 – Wired: You’ll Eat Bugs. These Investors Are Betting Millions on It – 3 years ago (2013) two college room mates (Greg Sewitz and Gabi Lewis) ordered 2 boxes of live crickets for their pet but instead made protein bars! – READ, ARCHIVE

    • Investors: “…one deep-pocketed group is taking the pair quite seriously. Today Sewitz and Lewis’ company, Exo Protien, announced it has raised $4 million in a series A round of funding led by Accel Foods with participation by investors like Collaborative Fund.
    • “…the United Nations says insects could play a crucial role in feeding a growing global population without wrecking the environment”

    2015

    September 16, 2015 – European Journal of Clinical Nutrition: Are edible insects more or less ‘healthy’ than commonly consumed meats? A comparison using two nutrient profiling models developed to combat over- and undernutrition by Raye et al – READ, Indirectly referenced by WEF (point 1) – HERE

    • “The results presented here are the first systematic comparison of the nutritional composition of insects and meat, and their relative healthiness according to contemporary nutrient profiling models.”
    • “Insect nutritional composition is highly diverse in comparison with commonly consumed meats. The food category ‘insects’ contains some foods that could potentially exacerbate diet-related public health problems related to over-nutrition, but may be effective in combating under-nutrition.”

    July 7, 2015 – Financial Times – Edible insect farms strive for scale – READ, REF,

    • Next Millennium Farms (now Entomo Farms) is one of a number of bug farms that have sprung into being to supply food brands and chefs with insects to bake into protein bars, biscuits and other bug delicacies.
    • A revision to the EU’s Novel Foods Regulation, due this year, puts edible bug farmers in the right place at the right time.

    June 2015 – EU: Updating rules on novel foods to keep up with scientific advances – new category for insects proposed – PDF

    March 26, 2015 – Documentary: America’s Shrinking FarmsTRAILER, ARCHIVE, “That Will Change Your Views on the Future of Food” – READ, UN FAO – CREDIT

    March 20, 2015 – EcoWatch “Transforming Green” via UN FAO: Are insects the next climate-friendly superfood?READ, ARCHIVE, SOURCE

    • “Demand for food-grade insects is growing rapidly,” says the website for Tiny Farms, a Silicon Valley-based start-up “pioneering the industry production of insects.”…Currently, it admits, edible insects are a niche products with the cost of a pound of cricket flour ranging from $25-$45. But it says that’s due to lack of scale and it hopes to change that”
    • “More than 30 companies are already using cricket flour in their products such as cookies and energy bars. [and you didn’t know it!] And while eating insects is common in Latin America, southeast Asia and parts of Africa because they’re a cheaply available commodity,” in the US its not.
    • The same day “Obama Signs Executive Order to Cut Government Greenhouse Gas Emissions by 40 Percent by 2025 – READ, REF

    March 18, 2015 – Food Navigator: Tiny Farms: Edible insects are a novelty today, but they’ll be mainstream tomorrow – ARCHIVE cricket flour producers are popping up everywhere.

    February 24, 2015 – Lux Research: Alternative Proteins to Claim a Third of the Market by 2054 – “insects, algae, and synthetic biology sources may make up over 50% of the alternative protein market by 2054” – ARCHIVE

    • “Shifts in supply and demand of protein for human consumption will drive the rise of alternative proteins to 307 million MT by 2054, initiating significant changes in the food and agriculture landscape.” [what will drive that “demand”?]

    February 15, 2015 – TEDxYoungstown: Alternative Protein | Kevin Bachhuber founder of Big Cricket Farms, the first urban edible insect farm in the US – WATCH, ARCHIVE

    2014

    December 10, 2014 – Consumer Reoprts: Cricket-flour protein bars pass the taste test – Consumer Reports’ experts munched on snack bars and cookies – READ, CREDIT

    • Protein products aimed at people interested in a paleo diet or weight loss in general are becoming increasingly popular, and cricket flour is seen as an environmentally efficient way of getting that nutrient in your diet”
    • “These critters are raised on domestic cricket farms, where they are fed a grain-based diet. They’re dried or roasted and then milled into a fine flour. About 40 crickets are packed into an average snack bar.”
    • “Cricket-flour goodies attracted plenty of attention at the recent Natural Products Expo in Baltimore, where manufacturers claimed they are making an investment in the environment because the insects don’t require much land or water—certainly much less than cattle, for example.”

    August 20, 2014 – Washington Post: Gateway bug: How crickets could hook America on eating insects – ARCHIVE

    June 24, 2014 – Practical Ethics: Should Vegetarians Consider Eating Insects? – READ

    • “In the last few years, there has been a push from various bodies—including the UN—to get Western countries to adopt eating insects as an alternative to meat. They are: rich in protein; environmentally friendly to harvest; sustainable; and, they’re already eaten, and enjoyed, in many other parts of the world.”

    May 14-17, 2014 – FAO: 1st International Conference “Insects to feed the world” at Wageningen University in the Netherlands – A whole new sector in animal livestock – READ, WATCH, Conference report – PDF, READ

    • Summary Reoprt – “The overall objective of the conference was to lay the foundations for continued dialogue, further research, evidence-based policy making and investments to promote the use of insects as human food and as animal feed in the context of food and feed security”. – PDF
    Conference logo – source
    • The first international conference on insects for food and feed brought over 450 participants from 45 countries together to discuss about the state of the art in research, business and policy making in this new developing sector.
    • Today more than 20,000 cricket farmers are registered in Thailand alone” Patrick Durst, FAO
    • A new Journal of Insects as Food and Feed (JIFF) by Wageningen Academic Publishers was also launched – READ, First edition – HERE
      • Foreword: Why a Journal of Insects as Food and Feed? – READ

    March 17, 2014 – Wired: Out in the Open: Raise Your Own Edible Insects With This Free Kit – cockroaches, crickets, mealworms and silkworms – a “new and growing community of people who treat insects as food” known as entomophagy – READ

    • Daniel Imrie-Situnayake and Tiny Farms have created what they call Open Bug Farm — a high-tech kit for raising your own edible insects.
      • In 2016 Mark Zuckerberg’s sister Arielle at a veture capital firm invested in Tiny Farms – READ

    January 23, 2014 – US Patent 2014/0020630: METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR BREEDING FLYING INSECTS (Filed Jul 18, 2012) – PDF, CREDIT

    2013

    September 2013 – EcoWatch “Transforming Green” news began – A “cutting-edge news service”… “EcoWatch became a Certified B Corporation and joined more than 900 companies that leverage the power of business to solve social and environmental problems.” – ARCHIVE

    May 14, 2013 – NPR | The Salt: Maybe It’s Time To Swap Burgers For Bugs, Says U.N. – READ

    • The Food and Agriculture Organization has been pondering bugs as a protein source since 2003, but in the new report, the agency argues that insects might be essential to feeding a planet of 7 billion people.
    • FAO says the future is bright for edible insects. “Although it will require considerable convincing to reverse [feelings of disgust], it is not an impossible feat,”

    May 13, 2013 – BBC: UN Report urges people to eat insects to fight world hunger – READ

    May 13, 2013 – Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations | FAO Forestry Paper 171: Edible insects: Future prospects for food and feed security – Report – ARCHIVE, (also see Jan 2012) The Highwire Ep 355 – CREDIT, Refered to as a “Landmark” report – REF

    • Agenda to get Western nations to switch over to consuming insects – propaganda campaign to make this happen COMMUNICATIONS: “Western societies require tailored media communication strategies and educational programmes that address the disgust factor. Influencing the public at large as well as policymakers and investors in the food and feed sectors by providing validated information on the potential of insects as food and feed sources can help to push insects higher on political, investment and research agendas worldwide.” pg xv
    • “The Way Forward” – “Recent developments in research and development show edible insects to be a promising alternative for the conventional production of meat, either for direct human consumption or for indirect use as feedstock. Nevertheless, a tremendous amount of work still needs to be done by a wide range of stakeholders over many years to fully realize the potential that insects offer for food and feed security.” – PDF
    • The roadmap drawn up during the Expert Consultation Meeting on Assessing the Potential of Insects as Food and Feed in Assuring Food Security in Rome in January 23-25, 2012 – the tasks tha lay ahead
    Edible Insects – United Nations report 2013, from Jan 2012 meeting in Rome – PDF, source

    May 13, 2013 – FAO PRESS RELEASE: Forest products critical to fight hunger – including insects – New study highlights role of insects for food and feed consumption. – READ

    • FAO’s research, done in partnership with Wageningen University in the Netherlands
    • The Barriers:
      • “legislation in most industrialized nations forbids the actual feeding of waste materials and slurry or swill to animals, even though this would be the material that insects normally feed on. Further research would be necessary, especially as regards the raising of insects on waste streams. But it is widely understood by scientists that insects are so biologically different from mammals that it is highly unlikely that insect diseases could be transmitted to humans.”
      • Regulations often also bar using insects in food for human consumption
      • “The private sector is ready to invest in insect farming. We have huge opportunities before us,” said Paul Vantomme, one of the authors of the report. “But until there is clarity in the legal sphere, no major business is going to take the risk to invest funds when the laws remains unclear or actually hinders development of this new sector,”

    May 13-15, 2013 – International Conference on Forests for Food Security and Nutrition in Rome – READ, Opening Remerks – PDF

    • FAO launched their new study on Edible Insects – (see above)
    • “It is estimated that insects form part of the traditional diets of at least 2 billion people. Insect gathering and farming can offer employment and cash income, for now mostly at the household level but also potentially in industrial operations.”
    Conference Objectives “threats and crisis” = climate change! –source

    May 8, 2013 – Jason Drew and AgriProtein Team Wins United Nations Award for Innovation for Africa – nutrient recycling – a method that uses waste and fly larvae to produce natural animal feed – READ [The prelude to human insect farming?]

    May 2013 – UN FAO – Edible Forest Insects – ARCHIVE

    May 2013 – UN FAP -REPORT: Six-legged livestock: Edible insect farming, collection and marketing in Thailand ARCHIVE

    • Eating and selling edible insects are common activities in Thialand either farmed or harvested in the wild. Cricket farming was introduced >15 years ago (c. 1996). “However, information remains scant on their current stauts and on production, technology development, market channels and business ventures as well as future opportuinties.
    • Crickets and Palm weevil larvae are farmed. “Currently there are approximately 20,000 farms operating 217,529 rearing pens. Total production over the last six years (1996-2011) has averaged around 7,500 tonnes per year”

    April 24, 2013 – Wellcome Collection: Insects Au Gratin- Explore the future of food, debate the consumption of insects as a potential alternative to traditional livestock, and watch a live 3D food-printing demo. – READ

    • There’s a “growing drive to bring insects into Western shopping baskets” [This is before the FAO report launch!]

    2013 – Clinton Global Initiative | The Hutt Prize Solving “The global food crisis” challenge – ARCHIVE, Won by McGill Univertity students for Aspire cricket farming.

    2013 – International Platform of Insects for Food and Feed (IPIFF) is a non-profit organisation founded in 2013 which represents the interests interests of private players in the insect industry associated to this organisation. In order “to help the insect industry prosper in Europe and worldwide” – ARCHIVE, READ, IPIFF today – HERE

    2012

    2012 – Tiny Farms, an edible insect company, was founded in 2012 to address a growing and evolving global market in entomophagy; the human consumption of insects. Promoting Entoculture is the intersection of bugs, food and farming – ARCHIVE

    • “Insect production is more energy, space and time efficient than traditional agriculture, making it ideal for a world where more than half the population live in cities.”
    • entomophagy movemement is a revolution in food production
    Open Bug Farm – ARCHIVE, source

    August 28, 2012 – NPR | The Salt:Grow Your Own Locust Kit Could Someday Help Feed African Refugees – two industrial engineering students want to use insects as emergency food – READ, Design award – ARCHIVE, WATCH

    • The product is still in the preliminary stages of development, but from what we can tell, it’s the first of its kind [the begnining/inspiration for benchtop, household tiny farms?]

    May 9, 2012 – Incredible Edible Bugs – there is a movement is afoot to encourage insect eating – video 1 – ARCHIVE

    January 2012 – Research Gate: Assessing the Potential of Insects as Food and Feed in assuring Food Security SUMMARY REPORT – Conference: FAO Expert Consultation on Assessing the potential of Insects for Food SecurityAt: FAO, Rome, Italy – READ

    January 23-25, 2012 – United Nations: Expert Consultation Meeting on Assessing the Potential of Insects as Food and Feed in Assuring Food Security in Rome – READ, REF, Report source – ARCHIVE [Its as though they planned where we are in 2024!]

    • Towards a global conference on Edible Insects as Food and Feed (2014) – REF

    “Assessing the Potential of Insects as Food and Feed in assuring Food Security” Action Plan: – REF, READ

    • Further document the nutritional values of insects in order to promote insects more efficiently as a healthy food source.
    • Investigate the sustainability and quantify the environmental impacts of harvesting and farming insects compared with traditional farming and livestock-raising practices.
    • Clarify and augment the socio-economic benefits that insect gathering and farming can offer, with a focus on improving the food security of the poorest of society. [then move to all Western society]
    • Develop a clear and comprehensive legal framework at the (inter-)national level that can pave the way for more investment, leading towards the full development (from the household scale to the industrial scale) of production and trade in insect products for food and feed internationally.
    United Nations FAO PLANNED to link eating insects to climate change from January 2012 – source

    2011

    April 4, 2011 – FAO: FAO’s role in the development of edible insect programmes in collaboration with the Wageningen University- READ, READ, Videos – ARCHIVE

    2007

    December 2007- Edible Unique – shop online for unique edibles such as insects and other bush tucker – ARCHIVE, c.f. Dec 2015 – ARCHIVE

    2006

    2006 – United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation together with The Livestock, Environment & Development (LEAD) Initiative: LIVESTOCK’S LONG SHADOW: environmental issues and options – REPORT, CREDIT

    • “The contribution by livestock and especially cattle to environmental problems is on a massive scale and should be addressed with urgency according to FAO’s report Livestock’s Long Shadow. Global demand for livestock products will more than double during the next 50 years (from 229 million tonnes in 1999/2001 to 465 million tonnes by 2050), and livestock production accounts already for 70% of all agricultural land. The livestock sector is an important contributor to greenhouse gas emissions such as CO2, CH4 and N2O.”
    • Globally the livestock sector is “one of the largest sources of greenhouse gases and one of the leading causal factors in the loss of biodiversity” …The livestock sector is also a primary player in the agricultural economy, a major provider of livelihoods for the poor and a major determinant of human diet and health. Hence its environmental role needs to be seen in the context of its many different functions…” pg 267
    • – FAO 2014 believe Edible insects are a Protein with a lighter environmental footprint – REF

    2003

    2003 – NPR: “The Food and Agriculture Organization has been pondering bugs as a protein source since 2003” – REF

    1997

    1997 – Ecology of Food and Nutrition, 36: 347–366: The importance of edible insects in the nutrition and economy of people of the rural areas of Mexico – Ramos Elorduy, J.

    • “In Mexico, the protein content of 78 evaluated species ranged from 15 percent to 81 percent of dry matter and protein digestibility ranged from 76 percent to 98 percent” – pg 70 REF

    1996

    1996 – Approximate time insect farming was introduced to Thailand, though eating insecst is a historic tradition, the farming isn’t – REF

    1992

    June 3,1992 – UNCED Earth Summit (Agenda 21) – “sustainable development” becomes the driving force for future global policy and funding. – TIMELINE

    1988

    1988 – The First International Congress of Ethnobiology was held in Belém, Brazil in 1988 – READ, History – READ, forging interdisciplinary boundaries of anthropology, botany, zoology, archaeology, pharmacology, geography, sociology, linguistics and related fields.

    • Presentation: Edible insects: barbarism or solution to the hunger problem? by Ramos Elorduy, J
      (In D.A. Posey & W.L. Overal, eds. Ethnobiology: implications and applications. Proceedings of the First International Congress of Ethnobiology, pp. 151–158. Bélem, Brazil, Museu Paraense Emílio Goeldi.) – REF

    1983

    December 19, 1983 – UN establishes a “governing council” that would become known as the “Brndland Commission” – “Process of preparation of the Environmental Perspective to the Year 2000 and Beyond” – TIMELINE

    • UNEP recommended the UN establishment of a “Special Commission” to “make available a report on environment and the global problamatique to the year 2000 and beyond, including proposed strategies for sustainable development”. Gro Harlem Brundtland was appointed as Chair
    • In 1987 the commission published their report titled Our Common Future, where they cemented the term “sustainable development”.   This document formed the basis for the 1992 first UN Earth Summit (UNCED).

    1976

    May 31 – June 11, 1976 – UN Habitat I conference – Vancouver Declaration on Human Settlements – READ, TIMELINE

    • The Declaration provided the first definition of ‘adequate shelter’ and recommendations for each country to achieve it. Population, land use and resources officially become a “concern”.

    The post Edible Insects (and Lab Grown Meat) first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

    ]]>
    COVID-19 Enquiries https://totalityofevidence.com/covid-19-enquiries/ Fri, 22 Sep 2023 23:38:33 +0000 https://totalityofevidence.com/?p=40255 COVID-19 official enquiries and court proceedings The pandemic response was devastating to health (both physical and mental) and the economies of the world. This page will attempt to capture headlines of the push for enquiries/inquiries or Royal Commissions into the…

    The post COVID-19 Enquiries first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

    ]]>
    COVID-19 official enquiries and court proceedings

    The pandemic response was devastating to health (both physical and mental) and the economies of the world. This page will attempt to capture headlines of the push for enquiries/inquiries or Royal Commissions into the COVID-19 response in countries around the world.

    Links in reverse chronological order

    Content will continuously be added

    2024

    May 3, 2024 – Raphael Lataster PhD: My 2nd win against COVID vaccine mandates! – READ, CREDIT

    February 27, 2024 – The Guardian: Covid vaccine mandate ‘unlawful’ for Queensland emergency services, court rules – READ, CREDIT

    February 8, 2024 – The Guardian: Clive Palmer claims ‘great victory’ in funding challenge to Queensland’s Covid vaccine mandate – READ, CREDIT

    2023

    October 26, 2023 – Senator Rennick: Australian Senate Estimates hearings with the Office of the Gene Technology Regulator (OGTR) – Pfizer confirms gene therapy & the Office of Gene Tech are still in denial- READ, WATCH, Arkmedic – READ, JikkyLeaks – TWEET

    • Because the mRNA vaccines were not manufactured in Australia the OGTR regulate the quality of the product, they handballed all oversight to the TGA – who are not expert in gene techology!

    If in deed the mRNA was being manufactured here [in Australia] and its correct that gene technology was used, the modification of the mRNA. Then under the Gene Technology Act an approval would have been required for that manufacturing step…the Gene Technology Act doesn’t reach into other countries”

    Dr Bhula – Gene Technology Regulator

    It quite obvious the law has been broken and people suffered as a consequence. Authorities need to be held to account.

    Senator Rennick

    August 9, 2023 – Raphael Lataster PhD: We won our COVID vaccine mandate case! MSM uninterested? – READ, CREDIT

    September 27, 2023 – IOTP | John Adams & Martin North: The Regime Covers Up Its Monstrous Crimes – following Victoria’s Dictator Dan’s surprise resignation – WATCH

    • Dictator Dan’s monstrous crimes and that of other State and Territory Premiers and Chief Ministers which were committed in 2020 and 2021 are being covered up by the COVID-19 inquiry announced last week by the Prime Minister Anthony Albanese. This inquiry has a limited scope and a rigged panel.
    • [John also reveal the new propaganda push on Australian children that is happening in Canberra at Questacon regarding gene editing. Social engineering, propaganda!- EXCERPT]

    September 22, 2023 – Ian Brighthome’s Substack: New Zealand First [Party] will be seeking a full scale Covid pandemic inquiry. Our Kiwi neighbours will get closer to the truth if Winston Peters has his way – READ

    September 21, 2023 – Sky News Australia: Anthony Albanese confirms independent inquiry into Australia’s response to COVID-19 to ‘ensure we are better prepared for future pandemics’ – READ

    September 21, 2023 – SBS News Australia: What the COVID-19 inquiry will (and won’t) examine, and why there’s ‘witch-hunt’ concern – READ

    • “It will not probe actions taken “unilaterally” by states and territories, meaning it may be unable to explore the necessity or process behind lockdowns or school and border closures.”
    • And mandated vaccination??? as these were all enforced under an “emergency direction” by each STATE!
    • “Opposition leader Peter Dutton criticised the government for not holding a royal commission and accused Albanese of breaking a promise to the Australian public.”

    September 21, 2023 – ABC News: Government launches inquiry into response to COVID-19 pandemic – but state and territory local lockdowns and border closures are likely to avoid scrutiny – READ

    • Inquiry given 12 months to compile report and it’s terms of reference discounts ‘unilateral’ state and territory COVID-19 measures – under the states “emergency powers”
    • It is a “whitewash” inquiry, protecting Labor states – REF

    September 21, 2023 – The Guardian: Covid-19 inquiry will exclude state and territory decisions, Anthony Albanese says – READ [The exact areas that needs investigating regarding their “coordinated”, “independent” emergency directions!]

    September 21, 2023 – ABC News Australia: IN FULL: Anthony Albanese announces inquiry into Australia’s COVID-19 response – WATCH

    • Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Health Minister Mark Butler announced the inquiry and its scope at a press conference in Adelaide
    • Department of Prime Minister & Cabinet: Commonwealth Government Covid-19 Response Inquiry terms of reference – READ, ARCHIVE

    September 21, 2023 – Prime Minister of Australia | Press Release: Improving future preparedness: Inquiry into the response to the Covid-19 pandemic – READ, ARCHIVE

    • The Government has appointed an independent panel to conduct the Inquiry:
      • Ms Robyn Kruk AO (NSW) – READ
      • Professor Catherine Bennett (Victoria) – READ
      • Dr Angela Jackson (Victoria) – READ
    • Note: On 8 December 2022, the Australian Government appointed Ms Robyn Kruk AO to lead review into health practitioner regulatory settings.
    • “Here are the six issues it [the 3 panel team] must probe ahead of the next bug killer” [seriously!] – REF
    • “In total, the [Australian] federal government spent $291 billion in direct economic support for the pandemic by May 2021, fuelling the Commonwealth’s debt level” – REF

    September 20, 2023 – The Guardian: Anthony Albanese expected to announce inquiry into Australia’s Covid response – reports- but the opposition says it won’t have enough powers – READ

    September 20, 2023 – Australian Financial Review: [3 person] Expert panel to lead COVID-19 inquiry, but no royal commission – READ

    June 21, 2023 – Sydney Moring Herald: Start COVID-19 inquiry now: PM faces demands for action on promise – READ

    • “Now’s the perfect time to take the politics out of it,..” AMA president Professor Steve Robson said
    • “The right-aligned Institute of Public Affairs has already proposed its own terms of reference for a royal commission into the country’s handling of the pandemic” – TOR – HERE

    June 6, 2023 – Reuters: Britain’s COVID inquiry into the handling of the pandemic – READ

    • “Britain is holding a public inquiry into the handling of the COVID-19 pandemic, and the government is already seeking legal action against it even before it has started hearing evidence.”
    • The inquiry was ordered by the government when Boris Johnson was prime minister in 2021, to look at how the COVID-19 pandemic was handled in Britain, and what mistakes were made.”…”The inquiry was formally set up in June 2022

    June 2, 2023 – Reuters: UK government [Sunak] refuses to hand over WhatsApp messages to COVID inquiry – READ

    June 1, 2023 – Reuters: Boris Johnson hands COVID-era WhatsApps to UK government amid inquiry row – READ

    May 3, 2023 – Reuters: UK government given more time to hand over Boris Johnson messages to COVID inquiry – READ

    2022

    November 5, 2022 – The Guardian: ‘Psychological injury’: NSW teacher wins compensation payout over handling of vaccine mandate – Lawyer for Diane Dawking says he has dozens more teachers interested in pursuing similar action – READ, CREDIT

    • “A Sydney teacher sacked for not complying with New South Wales’s vaccination rules has been awarded ongoing workers’ compensation payments of $1,378 a week after she suffered “psychological injury” in the way the mandate was enforced….”

    October 12, 2022 – Institute of Public Affairs: Draft Terms Of Reference For A Royal Commission Into The Covid-19 Response – READ, Archive PDF

    August 17, 2022 – Australia’s COVID Inquiry 2.0 lead by Senator Malcolm Roberts – a cross-party, non-parliamentary inquiry – READ, WATCH, CREDIT

    • to “interrogate breaches of the doctor-patient relationship and the regulatory capture of Australia’s health and drug regulators.”

    June 28, 2022 – BBC: Covid: Terms of inquiry into UK pandemic response finalisedREAD

    • Boris Johnson has announced the launch of the Covid public inquiry and finalised its terms of reference.
    • In December 2021 Boris Johnson appointed Baroness Hallett to chair the inquiry

    March 23, 2022 – Senator Malcolm Roberts: Australia COVID Under Question: A cross-party inquiry – Full days’ proceedings – READ & WATCH, Introduction – WATCH

    A few of the Speakers:

    • Context and Data:
      • Brook Jackson
        Dr Peter Parry
        Dr Pierre Kory
        Suzie Pollock
        Dr Philip Altman
        Mary-Jane Stevens
        Alan Dana
    • Pfizer & The Vaccines
      • Christine Dolan
        Warner Mendenhall
        Dr James Rowe
        Senator Gerard Rennick
        Dr Robert Brennan

    January 21, 2022 – Euractiv: Irish government plans public inquiry into handling of pandemic – READ

    I would prefer to call it an evaluation of how the country managed COVID-19

    Micheál Martin, Taoiseach

    January 2022 – Election Campaign promises of Labor’s Anthony Albanese: Albanese promised in January 2022, ahead of the federal election, to hold a “royal commission or some form of inquiry” into the country’s handling of COVID-19 – REF, & May 2022 REF

    • During the election campaign in May [2022], Albanese told reporters: “I support looking at it through a measure like a royal commission. We haven’t finalised what the structure would be.”

    2021

    December 15, 2021 – BBC: Ex-High Court judge Baroness Hallett to chair Covid inquiry – appointed by Boris Johnson – READ

    • The inquiry, whose full remit has not yet been revealed, will get under way next spring.
    • Scotland plans to start its own inquiry into the pandemic later 2021

    April 2021 – Institute for Governement Analysis Report: The coronavirus inquiry – The case for an investigation of government actions during the Covid-19 pandemicPDF, BBC IfG “think tank” – CREDIT

    • “The inquiry needs to focus first on establishing the exact state of knowledge of ministers and officials when significant decisions were made…Only then can it fairly consider the reasonableness of those decisions and make recommendations about how the government needs to change as a result.” – REF

    The post COVID-19 Enquiries first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

    ]]>
    Biden Impeachment Inquiry https://totalityofevidence.com/biden-impeachment-inquiry/ Sat, 16 Sep 2023 00:10:44 +0000 https://totalityofevidence.com/?p=40068 This timeline page is a continuation of Hunter Biden’s Laptop from Hell PAGE (as that was getting too long) What has this got to do with a pandemic? Joe Biden become “President” of the United States in the middle of…

    The post Biden Impeachment Inquiry first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

    ]]>
    This timeline page is a continuation of Hunter Biden’s Laptop from Hell PAGE (as that was getting too long)

    What has this got to do with a pandemic?

    Joe Biden become “President” of the United States in the middle of the COVID-19 pandemic, where he rarely exited “his basement” to campaign, new election procedures were “allowed”, it took days to “count” votes in strategic swing states resulting in Biden “winning” by the most votes in US history – 81 million votes!

    The greater American public were not aware that the FBI had Hunter Biden’s laptop from December 9, 2019, yet come October 2020, 51 “Intelligence” officials seeded the media to call the laptop Russian disinformation – that was just the start of the public servants running cover for the Biden’s.

    Fast forward to September 2023, following laptop revelations, subpoenas and whistleblowers…

    On September 12, 2023 speaker Kevin McCarthy announced (under pressure) the launch of a formal impeachment inquiry into President Joe Biden, where Reps. Jim Jordan, James Comey and Jason Smith will lead the probe into Joe’s business dealings involving Hunter Biden. What this does is turbocharge “congressional power to acquire documents and testimony about Biden’s role in his family’s foreign business dealings while he was vice president.”

    Joe Biden claimed he was never involved with Hunter’s (multi-million dollar) foreign business dealings.

    10% for the Big Guy”
    “50% for Pops

    Hunter Biden’s Laptop communications, (Rep. Jim Jordan)

    The links below continue from the September 12, 2023 impeachment inquiry announcement, they may also include some backstory, and a continuation of the Hunter saga.

    • Hunter Biden’s Laptop, Labs and Lies (1988- Sept. 2023) – HERE
    • Oversight committee: Biden Family Investigation – Key Evidence – HERE, YouTube – CHANNEL
    • The Bidens’ Influence Peddling Timeline – HERE
    • Marco Polo – Biden laptop reports – HERE
    Official Biden Family Investigation – HERE, ARCHIVES

    Don’t forget Biden issued more executive orders and actions in the first 3 weeks of his presidency than any president in U.S. history, overturning President Trump’s work. How many of these favour Big Pharma, China ect and not America? List of 69 EOs: Breitbart- READ, ABC- READ. Just a few from first few day in office January 20, 2021:

    • Jan 20: Staying in World Health Organization – ARCHIVE
    • Jan 20: Rejoining Paris Climate Agreement – ARCHIVE
    • Jan 20: COVID-19 relief proposal of $1.9 trillion, when $1 trillion approved funds under Trump still waiting to be spent! – ARCHIVE
    • Jan 20: Ending Trump’s travel bans on terror-prone countries – ARCHIVE
    • Jan 20: Federal Mask Mandate (which he violated the same day) – ARCHIVE

    “Biden family” links in reverse chronological order

    Links are continuously being added, though not complete!

    2025

    January 31, 2025 – The Daily Wire: EXCLUSIVE: Trump Bans Intel Officials Who Pushed Russian Disinfo Hoax From Federal Buildings – White House expands executive order [EO14152] to bar former officials including John Bolton, Leon Panetta from entering secure government property – READ

    • Gateway Pundit: Deep State Crackdown: 50 Ex-Intelligence Operatives, Including Brennan, Bolton, and Clapper, Banned from U.S. Facilities by Trump Administration Due to National Security Concerns – CREDIT
    • Several of the 51 were CIA Contractors when they signed the letter with fictional statements which “broached the 18USC1001 statute on False Statements by Federal Officials” – REF

    January 30, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: MIC DROP: Tulsi Gabbard Drops Truth Bomb on Deep State Corruption — Exposes 51 Intel Officials, Hillary Clinton, and the Democrat Party in Scorching Opening Statement – READ

    Title I of FISA was used illegally to obtain a warrant to spy on Trump campaign advisor Carter Page, using a Clinton-Biden campaign-funded false dossier as their so-called evidence. Biden campaign advisor Tony Blinken was the impetus for the “51 former senior intelligence officials’ letter,” dismissing Hunter Biden’s laptop as disinformation and specifically intended to help Biden win the election.”

    Tulsi Gabbard

    January 24, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: “If They Weren’t the Crime Family, Why Do They Need Pardons?” – Speaker Johnson to Investigate Biden Family Pardons (VIDEO) – READ,

    • “The Biden Crime Family is real and Joe Biden proved that when he preemptively pardoned members of his family who participated in his influence-peddling scheme.
    • House Speaker Mike Johnson said Republican lawmakers are going to investigate Joe Biden’s family pardons….After pardoning his son Hunter, Joe Biden issued preemptive pardons to five members of his family: Sister Valerie Biden, her husband John Owens, brother Jim Biden, brother Frank Biden, sister-in-law Sara Biden.
    • House Oversight Chairman James Comer previously identified the NINE Bidens who were implicated in the corruption.”

    January 22, 2025 – President Trump on Hannity – Trump Issues a Warning to Joe Biden: “He Didn’t Give Himself a Pardon” – READ, WATCH

    January 20, 2025 – Washington Examiner: The Biden Crime Family cashes out after 52 years of trading on the family name – READ

    • “As a parting gift to his grifting kinsmen, Joe Biden exited his historical disgrace of a presidency by granting an eleventh-hour categorical pardon to his siblings, Jim Biden, Frank Biden, and Val Biden Owens, and their spouses for any and all nonviolent crimes “they may have committed or taken part in” during the decade-plus since January 1, 2014. Only the “full and unconditional” pardons the former president issued to his son Hunter and then to former National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Director Anthony Fauci were more sweeping.”
    • …Biden issued 8,064 acts of presidential pardon or clemency during his four long years, more than any other president since Jimmy Carter, who pardoned hundreds of thousands of draft dodgers in the wake of the Vietnam War.”
    Joe biden pardons compared to previous presidents
    Joe Biden’s Pardon numbers compared to previous Presidents – The Highwire – source

    January 20, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: Justice! President Trump Revokes Security Clearances of ALL 51 ‘Spies Who Lied’ and Former NSA Advisor John Bolton – READ, READ, EO – READ

    • “The order highlights the 51 former intel officials who coordinated with the Biden campaign to suggest that the Hunter Biden laptop was “a part of a Russian disinformation campaign.””

    January 20, 2025 – TRUMP WHITE HOUSE: Executive Order: “Holding Former Government Officials Accountable For Election Interference and Improper Disclosure of Sensitive Governmental Information.” – READ

    • “The signatories willfully weaponized the gravitas of the Intelligence Community to manipulate the political process and undermine our democratic institutions.”

    January 20, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: BREAKING: Joe Biden Pardons MULTIPLE Family Members in Shocking Abuse of Power – READ In the final moments he held office.

    January 20, 2025 – Gateway Pundit: BREAKING: Joe Biden [preemptively] Pardons Tony Fauci, Loser Mark Milley, and Entire J6 Select Committee of Liars in Final Act Against America – READ, ABC News- READ, CNN – READ

    2024

    December 7, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Joe Biden Pardons Son Hunter – But What About the Other Eight Family Members Caught Up in Family’s Criminal Enterprise? – READ

    December 7, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: WATCH: ESPN’s Stephen A. Smith SLAMS Biden’s Claims That Hunter Was “Singled Out” by Political Opponents: “Wait a Minute. What Have You All Been Doing With Donald Trump All of These Years?” – READ

    • “Joe Biden claimed that Hunter was being persecuted by “political opponents” and that he “was singled out”–by Biden’s own Department of Justice–“only because he is my son.””
    • The sweeping pardon denies prosecution for any crime he may have committed. This includes the cocaine found in the White House, any financial crimes, and the Biden family’s influence peddling that Hunter was involved in since he joined Ukraine energy firm Burisma’s board of directors in 2014….Hunter is now exempt from prosecution for emails where he shared classified information with Ukrainian business partners like Burisma board members. He will also not be prosecuted for taking a gift of diamonds from China, likely in exchange for classified information.”

    December 2, 2024 – NY Post: Why Biden’s pardon is one of the most controversial in history to his son Hunter Biden — and critics say it serves to also cover up the president’s involvement in his family’s foreign dealings.”

    • “…one of the most sweeping pardons in recent history…and critics say it serves to also cover up the president’s involvement in his family’s foreign dealings.
    • “Biden, 82, pardoned his disgraced 54-year-old son on Sunday on the basis that Hunter was “treated differently” by his own Justice Department. “

    December 1, 2024 – The Gateway Pundit: Breaking: Joe Biden Pardons Son Hunter Biden in Gun and Tax Cases–And Any Federal Crimes From 2014 Through 2024READ, White House Statement from President Biden – READ, ARCHIVE

    • On December 1, 2024 President Joe Biden Pardoned his Son Hunter Biden for any crimes he may have committed from 2014 to 2024 – reversing his claim he would not pardon his son. Joe Biden lied to the public.
      • Independent: In June 2024 “The president previously ruled out a pardon for his son, and he vowed to ‘accept the outcome’ after a verdict” – READ

    “Be It Known, That This Day, I, Joseph R. Biden, Jr., President of the United States, Pursuant to My Powers Under Article II, Section 2, Clause 1, of the Constitution, Have Granted Unto

    ROBERT HUNTER BIDEN

    A Full and Unconditional Pardon

    Joseph R. Biden, Jr. EXCERPT

    • NY Post: Joe Biden pardons son Hunter in shocking reversal, claiming he was ‘unfairly prosecuted’ as lame-duck prez winds down term – READ
    • Karine Jean-Pierre GASLIGHTS the Public After Reporter Points Out Joe Biden Lied About a Hunter Pardon (AUDIO) – READ
    • Former Biden White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki made some comments about the possibility of Joe Biden pardoning Hunter have come back to haunt her. (VIDEO) – READ, CREDIT
    • “Absolute Sh*t Bag” – Venice Beach Landlord Claims Hunter Biden Owes Him $300,000+ in Back Pay Rent, Says He Tried to Pay Rent with “Art Made From His Own Feces” – READ
    • Joe Biden discussed pardoning his son Hunter 6 months ago while he was publicly claiming he would not issue Hunter a pardon or commute his sentences. – READ
    • Bannons War Room – WATCH, Steve Bannon comments – EXCERPT
    • ABC – READ, NY Times – READ, BBC – READ, USA Today – READ,
    • NY Post: Donald Trump hints at mass pardons for Jan. 6 defendants after Biden pardons son Hunter – READ

    November 6, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: ON DAY ONE: President Trump Should Revoke the Security Clearances of the 51 Dishonorable Former Intel Officials Who Lied About Hunter Biden’s Laptop and Knew It Was a Lie All Along READ

    September 27, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: REPORT: Hunter Biden to Undergo Seven Hour Psych Exam to Prove He Was ‘Emotionally Damaged’ by Corruption Allegations in Patrick Byrne Defamation Trial – READ

    • “It remains a possibility that Hunter may end up fighting these cases from a jail cell. He is scheduled for sentencing in December for both of his convictions and could face up to 17 years in prison.”

    September 21, 2024 – Bannons War Room: Garrett Ziegler Exposes Democrats For “Changing History” With Revised Retelling Of Hunter Biden’s Shakedown – WATCH

    • Robert Goueia Esq.: The Diddy-Biden-Epstein Connections and More with Garrett Ziegler – WATCH, Marco Polo – SOURCE

    September 8, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Tom Cotton Exposes CNN’s 2020 Election Interference on Hunter Biden Laptop Cover-Up by Dozens of Intel Officials, Including Dana Bash’s Ex-Husband, Live on Air – READ, WATCH

    September 6, 2024 – Fine Point – The Biden ‘Guilty’ Escape Plan (Pardon for Hunter?) – With Garrett Ziegler, 9/6/24 – WATCH, Marco Polo – SOURCE

    September 5, 2024 – Bannons War Room: Mike Davis: Joe Biden Will Pardon Hunter Biden After Hunter’s Offered Plea Deal (also “Get Trump” election interference overview) – EXCERPT, WATCH,

    “Joe Biden will absolutely either pardon, or comute the sentence for Hunter Biden before he leaves office…he’s done everything he can to protect his son Hunter, and it’s not because he’s a loving father, it’s because Hunter is the Bag Man for the Biden Crime Family”

    “…money from China into Joe Biden’s bank account, that is absolute corruotion….there is just overwhelming evidence of tens of millions of dollars of foreign corruption going to the Bidens.”

    Mike Davis

    • NY Post: “…he’s betting it all on pardon from dad”- READ,
    • BBC – “Hunter Biden’s father, US President Joe Biden, has the power to pardon him for his two federal convictions.” – READ
    • June 6, 2024 – Politico: Biden says he won’t pardon son Hunter – READ, CNN – READ, BBC – READ

    September 5, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Joe Biden Pardon Incoming… Hunter Biden Tries to Change His Plea to Guilty in Federal Tax Case at the Last Minute to Avoid Trial… DEVELOPING – READ (Overview of case)

    • “In December [2023] Hunter Biden was hit with a 9-count indictment filed in the Central District of California: Tax evasion, failure to file/pay taxes, and false/fraudulent tax return. …The charges were handed down by Special Counsel David Weiss after a sweetheart plea deal on tax charges fell apart last summer.”
    • Hunter …knows his father will issue a pardon

    September 5, 2024 – NY Post: Hunter Biden enters shock guilty plea in $1.4M tax evasion case, first son facing up to 17 years in prison… – READ, ABC Aust – READ, AP- READ, CNN – READ, BBC – READ, Gateway Pundit – READ, NYTimes – READ,

    • “…in order to avoid yet another embarrassing trial that would’ve centered on his penchant for strippers, pornography, luxury hotels and exotic cars.”
    • This was “the day that an agonizing weekslong trial was supposed to begin” at Los Angeles federal courthouse
    • He pleaded guilty to all nine counts “entering a so-called Alford plea, acknowledging there was enough evidence to convict him even as he expressed innocence toward the same charges.”..sentencing for December 16, 2024
    Hunter avoiding tiral after prosecutors filed “road map” glossary to trial exhibits – source, CREDIT
    • “Hunter Biden will get a pardon and documents exposing Joe Biden’s international influence-peddling scheme will be suppressed.” – REF

    September 4, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Hard-Hitting New Documentary: ‘Hunter’s Laptop—Requiem for Ukraine’ READ, Premier’s Sept 5, 2024 – Trailer – WATCH, Laptop film – OFFICIAL, ARCHIVE

    • The documentary “delves into the scandal surrounding Hunter Biden’s infamous laptop, exploring the broader implications of political corruption, media manipulation, and international intrigue. The film begins with President Joe Biden’s inauguration and swiftly shifts focus to the controversial events leading up to and following the discovery of the laptop.”

    August 26, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Biden Returns to Delaware After Weeklong California Vacation – Then Takes Another NINE-DAY Vacation in Rehoboth Beach – Taxpayers Spend Millions to Ferry Biden Family Around on Endless Vacations – READ

    • “Biden has spent more than 40% of his presidency on vacation with no visitor logs.”
    • Who’s running the country if the “President” is continuously on vacation?

    August 20, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Trump-Appointed Judge Smacks Down Hunter Biden’s Bid to Dismiss Federal Tax Indictment – READ

    August 2, 2024 – Newsweek: Hunter Biden Gun Case Sentencing Will Be After Election Day – scheduled Nov 13, 2024 – READ, Gateway Pundit: Hunter Biden to be Sentenced One Week After Election, Faces Up to 25 Years in Prison – READ

    July 30, 2024 – War Room: EXC: Hunter Biden’s Bio Firm Partnered With Ukraine Lab On Bird Flu Research Funded By Fauci, Pentagon. – Natalie Winters – READ, WATCH

    • Metabiota is part of “portfolio” on Rosemont Seneca Technology Partners (RSTP) website – ARCHIVE
    • Metabiota “– a San Francisco-based company that purported to detect, track, and analyze emerging infectious diseases before being acquired [October 17, 2022] by a Cameroon-based non-profit” – called Health and Development in Action (HEADA).
    • PolitiFact: The facts behind the Russian, right-wing narratives claiming Hunter Biden funded biolabs in Ukraine – READ!
      • “Metabiota separately received money from the Pentagon’s Defense Threat Reduction Agency [DTRA] for subcontracted work related to the biological research labs in Ukraine. That work involved helping to train and otherwise support scientists at those facilities.”

    July 21, 2024 – Joe Biden drops out of presidential race – TIMELINE

    June 27, 2024 – Live: Trump and Biden Presidential Debate – WATCH, Gutfeld – WATCH, CNN rules – READ, ARCHIVE

    June 26, 2024 – Gateway Pundit – Biden Campaign officially refused to drug test Joe Biden ahead of Thursday (June 27, 2024) night’s highly anticipated presidential debate between Trump and Biden – READ,

    • No Photos, Videos or Sightings of Biden During Week of Debate Prep at Camp David – READ
    • CNN with Speaker Johnson re the coming debate and refrrence to “cocaine” – WATCH, EXCERPT
    • JD Vance: “we have no idea what kind of medication they’re going to give to Joe Biden.” – TWEET

    June 26, 2024 – Judicial Watch Press Release: FOIA Lawsuit Emails Show CIA Rushed Approval of Infamous Hunter Laptop Letter by 51 Former Intel Officials Before Election – READ, Gateway Pundit – READ

    • Following failed response by Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) to FOIA request, on June 23, 2023 Judicial Watch sued and finally received 8 pages of records from the CIA “showing Mike Morell, former acting CIA director under President Obama, requesting CIA permission to publish a letter by former intelligence community leaders stating that they believed the laptop emails exposing Hunter Biden’s connections to Ukraine were Russian disinformation. Morrell’s request for prepublication review was approved in just six hours by the CIA.”
    • ““This is a rush job, as it needs to get out as soon as possible,” Morell wrote in an email on Monday, October 19, 2020, at 6:36 a.m., to the CIA’s Publications Classification Review Board (PCRB) with a copy to Marc Polymeropoulos, a former CIA senior intelligence officer”

    “These documents are astounding. That the CIA would turn around a campaign document like this for Joe Biden’s team in six hours is insane news,” … “This seems to be demonstrable campaign interference by the CIA, and that should be alarming to all Americans.” 

    Tom Fitton, President of Judicial Watch
    • Judicial Watch has multiple federal lawsuits focused on Biden family corruption (listed in press release)

    June 26, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Rep Anna Paulina Luna Lowers The Boom on Merrick Garland — Warns He Has Until Friday Morning To Turn Over Tapes Or Be Taken Into Custody – ” the double standard that exists within the justice system” – READ, @RepLuna “Its simple..” – TWEET

    • Merrick Garland -“Barack Obama’s failed Supreme Court Justice nominee and America’s most crooked ever Attorney General.”
    • On February 27, 2024 the Oversight Committee and House Judiciary, sent a subpoena to Attorney General Garland to turn over the Hur-Biden tapes, “of which we received no response”
    • “Investigations are part of our legislative process, and people who interfere with these processes should be held accountable.”

    June 25, 2024 – Axios: Hunter Biden”suspended immediately from the practice of law” in D.C. – after the President’s son was convicted earlier this month of three federal gun charges – READ, ARCHIVE, CNN – READ, The Hill – READ

    June 21, 2024 – Press Release – Judicial Watch Asks Federal Court to Order Release of the Audio of President Biden’s Interview with Special Counsel Hur – READ

    • “The Biden Justice Department, in seeking to keep the audio recordings secret, asked the court to ignore precedent and rewrite FOIA law. The Biden agency: demands that a law enforcement/executive privilege exemption be rewritten to help Joe Biden; wants to change FOIA law to protect (after 50 years of being a politician) President Joe Biden’s privacy in his voice. ; and seeks to potentially end FOIA with a new argument that the possible “AI” alteration of the Hur recordings is reason to keep …the recordings and any government record a secret from the public.”
    • The question is “Hur’s conclusion that President Biden should not be prosecuted for his mishandling of classified records”…” supported by the evidence”?

    June 13, 2024 – National Pulse: Biden’s ‘Transparent’ DOJ Redacted EVERY PAGE of Interview Transcript. – READ, WATCH, Gateway Pundit: Biden Stolen Classified Docs Scandal MUCH WORSE Than We Thought – READ

    • Heavily redacted transcript of Mark Zwonitzer’s interview with the FBI on July 31, 2023 – PDF
    • “Joe Biden knowingly shared highly classified information with him and took him to his Wilmington garage where classified materials were stored in boxes”
    • Zwonikzer “admitted he deleted the audio recordings of Biden interviews after Hur was appointed SC” – TWEET
    • “Zwonitzer testified about how Joe Biden KNEW he wasn’t supposed to have the classified material in such an unsecure setting and needed to be “careful” in discussing classified material with Zwonitzer, who did not have a security clearance.” – REF
    • Bannons War Room: Joe Biden Shares Classified Information With Hunter’s Ghostwriter, Zwonitzer Escapes Charges – Garrett Ziegler – WATCH, Marco Polo – MORE,
      • Garrett Ziegler interview June 12, 2024 – Hunter Biden gun case, what he experienced in court, and what to expect in Hunter’s September tax evasion case – WATCH

    June 13, 2024 – National Pulse: BREAKING: Biden’s Ghostwriter, Mark Zwonitzer, Admits Deleting audio Evidence BECAUSE of Special Counsel Investigation – READ

    June 12, 2024 – AP: President Joe Biden’s son, Hunter Biden, is convicted of all 3 felonies in federal gun trial – READ

    June 12, 2024 – National Pulse: Biden’s AG Merrick Garland Held in Contempt of Congress, Argues ‘Executive Privilege.’ – READ

    • “House of Representatives voted 216 to 207 along party lines to hold Attorney General Merrick Garland in contempt of Congress over his refusal to provide the audio from President Joe Biden‘s interview with special counsel Robert Hur…”

    June 11, 2024 – Judicial Watch Statement on the Hunter Biden Verdict – guilty on three federal felony gun charges – READ

    June 10, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Hunter Biden Declines to Testify in Criminal Gun Trial – READ, Jurors began diliberations – READ

    June 9, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Maria Bartiromo grilled Oversight Chairman James Comer – “Where are the criminal referrals for Hunter Biden and James Biden over perjury, for lying to Congress? ” – WATCH & READ

    • “This was always about Joe Biden. We’re going to do everything we can to hold Hunter Biden and all the different shady associates accountable. This is just the beginning. But the next step will be accountability for Joe Biden….Everything that we refer to the Department of Justice is within the statute of limitations. In fact, there’s five years statute of limitations. So if Merrick Garland Department of Justice doesn’t take this up in an inappropriate manner, then the next administration and a new Attorney General certainly can. The investigation has already been done.”

    June 8, 2024 – Bannons War Room Episode 3671: Suffering The Consequences And Taking Back The Constitution – WATCH

    • Bill McGinley Reveals the History Of Biden’s Billionaire Dark Money – EXCERPT
    • The Biden Campaign Is Outsourcing Its Dirty Work To DNC And Dark Money Groups – EXCERPT

    June 7, 2024 – Judicial Watch: Justice Department Admits Transcript of Biden Interview Is Inaccurate – READ

    • “The White House admitted to a federal court that the transcript of President Joe Biden’s testimony to Special Counsel Robert Hur is not accurate. It is missing “filler words (such as ‘um’ or ‘uh’)” and words that “may have been repeated when spoken (such as ‘I, I’ or ‘and, and’)” which were sometimes “only listed a single time in the transcripts.””

    June 7, 2024 – Bannons War Room: John Solomon On FBI Protecting Biden Family -“They Sat Silent And That Silence Was Complicity In An Effort To Hijack The Election” – WATCH

    June 4, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Prosecutors Destroy Hunter Biden in Opening Statement, Tell Court He Bought a Gun While ‘Smoking Crack Every 15 Minutes’ – READ

    June 4, 2024: USA Today: Hunter Biden’s laptop could be used as evidence in federal gun charges trialREAD, NY Times – READ, ABC News – READ, Prosecutors introduce infamous laptop as evidence – READ

    • “President Joe Biden’s son is on trial for three felony gun charges over whether he lied about being addicted to drugs when he bought a gun in 2018.”

    June 4, 2024 – LIVE: Hunter Biden’s Criminal Gun Charge Trial Starts (outside) – WATCH

    May 31, 2023 – NY Post: Hunter Biden joins dad Joe on Air Force One — one day after Trump conviction and 3 days before own trial – READ

    May 22, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: House Ways and Means Committee Document Dump: Encrypted Message Sent by Hunter Biden to CEO of CCP-Linked CEFC Conglomerate, Setting Up a Meeting with Joe Biden in Dec. 2017 – READ, New York Post by Miranda Devine – READ

    • House Ways and Means Chairman Jason Smith (R-MO) on Wednesday 22nd accused Hunter Biden of lying under oath during his closed-door deposition before Congress in February 2024 about his family’s international influence-peddling scheme, new documents provided by a whistleblower prove
    • “IRS whistleblowers Gary Shapley and Joe Ziegler delivered 100 pages of new bombshell evidence showing Hunter lied repeatedly to investigators in his sworn congressional testimony in February, prompting House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Jason Smith to raise the prospect of perjury charges against the first son.” – REF Documents – READ
    • Hunter had been messaging his Chinese business associate, CEFC employee Raymond Zhao, not just on July 30, 2017 while sitting next to his “father”, but for months, so not the “wrong Zhao”
    • An “encrypted message, believed to be sent by Hunter to Liu Yadong, CEO of CEFC Global Strategic Holdings, setting up a meeting with Joe Biden in December 2017”- Miranda Devine – TWEET

    May 24, 2024 – NY Post: Hunter Biden gun trial jurors can see laptop evidence of illegal drug use, judge rules in blow to first son – READ

    May 22, 2024 – NY Post: House committee votes to release evidence that Hunter Biden ‘indisputably’ lied under oath to Congress – READ

    May 16, 2024 – National Pulse: Biden Invokes Executive Privilege to BLOCK Audio of His Special Counsel Testimony Being Released – READ

    • “This move occurred after the House Oversight Committee began proceedings to hold Attorney General Merrick Garland responsible for his refusal to produce the recording, despite a final warning issued in April compelling him to honor a subpoena.”

    March 20, 2024 – Bannons War Room: Episode 3477: Chaos In Hunter Biden Hearing; Softness Of Comer – with Bobulinski textimony excerpts – WATCH

    March 6, 2024 – Tucker Carslon Uncensored Ep. 79 – Dr Keith Ablow is a psychiatrist who spent years on Fox News. He also treated Hunter Biden. Armed agents raided his office, took his patient records as well as Hunter’s laptop, and never charged him with a crime. What was this about? He talks about it for the first time – WATCH

    February 29, 2024 – House Committee on Oversight & Accountability: Oversight and Judiciary Committees Release Hunter Biden Transcript of closed-door deposition – READ, 227 pg transcript – PDF,

    • Jesse Waters comments – WATCH, CNN – READ, Washinton Examiner takaways – READ

    February 21, 2024 – House Oversight Committee: Joe Biden Met Nearly Every Foreign Associate Funneling His Family Millions – READ

    February 15, 2024 – National Pulse: BOMBSHELL: Biden Lawyers Pressured DOJ to Cover Up ‘Failing Memory’ Report – READ

    February 13, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: DOJ Releases Photos From Hunter Biden’s iPhone Showing Crack Cocaine, Drug Paraphernalia – READ, Fox News – READ

    • The news comes as Hunter is charged with lying about his drug use on a federal form – he answered “No” to drug use.

    February 13, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: CNN is promoting the journalist Natasha Bertrand, who wrote the 2020 Politico report on intel officials who called the Hunter Biden laptop Russian disinformation and “funneled the Russia Collusion lie (hoax) into print” – READ, TWEET, TWEET [The same day investigative journalists get laid off – READ]

    February 13, 2024 – NY Post: Ex-Biden biz associate says China successfully sought to infiltrate and compromise WH, Biden ‘enabled’ CCP-linked transactions – READ, Washington Post – READ, Fox News – READ

    • For nearly four years, I have tried to tell the American people the truth about serious corruption at the very top of their government,” Bobulinski said in opening statements to House members from both sides of the political aisle in the closed-door session.

    The Biden family business was Joe Biden, period,…It is clear to me that Joe Biden was ‘the Brand’ being sold by the Biden family.

    …Joe Biden was aware of the CEFC transaction, enabled it, and had a constitutional responsibility and obligation to the American people to shut it down before it began,

    Bobulinski alleged

    February 13, 2024 – CNN: Former Biden family business associate recycles unproven allegations to House panels – Bobulinksi “levied critical but unproven allegations against President Joe Biden in a closed-door House interview” – READ,

    February 13, 2024 – Daily Mail: Joe Biden was ‘the enabler’ for foreign deals with China and others testifies Hunter’s ex-business partner Tony Bobulinski: He sold ‘his brand’ while being ‘buffered’ by a ‘complex scheme’ to maintain –READ, BACKUP, ABC – READ

    February 13, 2024 – Daily Mail: Read Tony Bobulinski’s blistering impeachment testimony: ‘The Biden family business was Joe Biden, period’ – READ

    • February 13, 2024 Opening Statement by Mr. Anthony BobulinskiREAD, ARCHIVE

    February 11, 2024 – NY Post | Miranda Devine: Bidens should fear Tony Bobulinski — the most deadly impeachment witness with a patriotic family history – in closed-door interview on Tue Feb 13. – READ, Just The News – READ

    • Reminder Oct 22, 2020 – Tony Bobulinski Statement on Hunter Biden – WATCH

    February 10, 2024 – Gateway Pundit – Hillary Clinton Says Biden’s Age ‘ is Legitimate Issue’ and People in White House Talk About Biden’s Old Age Behind the Scenes – READ, WATCH [What about Dementia not Age?!]

    • …it’s a legitimate issue for Trump who’s only 3 years younger” deflects Clinton, she think’s Joe Biden should continue to get out and campaign in the 2024 election. Biden’s taking questions (not from the media Alex Wagner slips out!)

    February 10, 2024 – National Pulse: New York Times: Jill Biden ‘Is Shielding Her Husband.’ – READ

    February 9, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Ghostwriter Deleted Biden Audio Files After Learning About Special Counsel Hur’s Investigation Into Stolen Classified Documents – READ

    • “According to Robert Hur, In 2017, Joe Biden read aloud classified passages about meetings in the Situation Room to his ghostwriter “verbatim on at least three occasions” – and Biden still wasn’t charged.”
    • Contrast to “In June Jack Smith indicted Trump on 37 federal counts for storing classified documents at his Mar-a-Lago residence.”

    February 9, 2024 – Bannons War Room Episode 3379: Meltdown Over Biden’s Mental Acuity – WATCH

    February 8, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: 25TH AMENDMENT: People Are Starting to Say it’s Time for Biden to be Removed From Office – READ

    February 8, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Here Are the Photos of [Vice President] Joe Biden’s Classified Documents Scattered All Over the Place – Still No Charges – PHOTOS

    • Contrast to Trump charges – TWEET
    • June 10, 2023 – ABC: President Trump indictment photos show boxes of documents stored at Mar-a-Lago [basement] – READ, Indictment – READ

    February 8, 2024 – Bannons War Room Episode 3378: Biden Willfully Kept Documents – WATCH, Kash Patel comments – EXCERPT

    Ladies and Gentlemen, pull out your diary and mark this day down…

    Steve Bannon

    February 8, 2020 – National Pulse: ABOVE THE LAW: Special Counsel Probe Says Biden ‘Willfully Retained Classified Material’, No Charges Brought Because Joe’s an ‘Elderly Man With Poor Memory’ Who a Jury Wouldn’t Convict – READ, Raheem Kassam comments on the War Room – EXCERPT

    • The refusal to prosecute Biden due to his age and poor cognitive function flies in the face of the persistent establishment talking points that “no one is above the law.”!

    February 8, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: BREAKING: Special Counsel Report Shows Joe Biden Couldn’t Remember When He Was VP “When did I stop being Vice President?”…Couldn’t Remember When His Son Beau Died – READ

    • The Justice Department defended not bringing charges against Biden because he’s a “sympathetic, well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory.”

    February 8, 2024 – Washington Post: Special counsel: No charges for Biden in classified documents probe – Evidence of willful mishandling of classified papers, but not enough to win a conviction, special counsel says in report – READ, CREDIT

    • “Joe Biden carelessly handled classified materials found at his home and former office and shared government secrets with his ghostwriter, but prosecutors decided no chargeable crime was committed, according to a long-awaited special counsel report released Thursday” Feb 8, 2024.

    February 8, 2024 – The White House Press Conference: President Biden Delivers Remarks – WATCH

    I’m was pleased to see he reached a firm conclusion that no charges should be brought against me in this case

    …My memory is fine

    President Biden
    • Note the report “concluded that Biden was mentally unfit to stand trial for “willfully” retaining classified documents from his time as Vice President.” – REF
    • National Pulse: Biden Insists He *Is* Fit for Prosecution, Before Claiming Mexico Borders Gaza – READ

    February 8, 2024 – Dept of Justice Special Council Report by Robert Hur: Report on the Investigation into unauthorized removal, retention, and disclosure of classified documents discovered at locations including the Penn Biden Center and the Delaware private residence of President Joseph R. Biden. Jr. (submitted Feb 5, 2024) – PDF, ARCHIVE

    • A 345-page report on Biden’s stolen classified documents investigation.

    January 10, 2023 – Epoch Times: Congress Takes Step to Hold Hunter Biden in Contempt – READ

    • Two U.S. House of Representatives panels voted to approve the reports and resolutions, which state that Hunter Biden, 53, violated federal law by refusing to appear for a deposition behind closed doors.

    January 10, 2024 – Newsmax: Hunter gave middle finger to Republican house by defying a subpoena to turn up to testify behind closed doors – WATCH, Jim Jordan comments – WATCH

    January 9, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: Another Biden Scandal: Democrat Donors – Including Hunter’s Lawyer Kevin Morris – Bought Hunter Biden’s Garbage Artwork – which sold for $75,000 to $500,000 – READ

    • One of Hunter’s artwork buyers got a favor from the Biden White House!…Los Angeles real estate investor and major Democrat donor, Elizabeth Hirsh Naftali, was appointed by Joe Biden to a prestigious position as Commission for the Preservation of America’s Heritage Abroad.
    • Hunter Biden’s lawyer Kevin Morris, who already paid off Hunter’s delinquent taxes, bought 11 works of Hunter’s art for $875,000

    2023

    December 13, 2023 – Bannons War Room Episode 3245: Supreme Court Hears J6 Case; House Opens Biden Impeachment Inquiry WATCH

    November 16, 2023 – Gateway Pundit: Speaker Johnson Says Impeachment Inquiry “Already Shown Corrupt Conduct” of Biden Crime Family, Calls for Key Witnesses to Testify Under Oath – READ

    • This is the first time subpoenas have been issued for testimony, previous were for bank records

    November 2, 2023 – House Oversight Committee: Chairman Comer Reveals How Joe Biden Received Laundered China Money – WATCH

    October 20, 2023 – Oversight Committee: Comer Releases Evidence of Direct Payment to Joe Biden – READ, WATCH, Comer on Newsmax – WATCH, NY Post – READ

    • “”the committee obtained bank records revealing a $200,000 direct payment from James and Sara Biden to Joe Biden in the form of a personal check.” dated March 1, 2015″On March 1, 2018, Americore wired a $200,000 loan into James and Sara Biden’s personal bank account – not their business bank account. On the same day, James Biden wrote a $200,000 check from this same personal bank account to Joe Biden…”
    • Their investigation began with by subpeonaring bank records of their closed shell companies, then followed the money from China to the Bidens’

    October 4, 2023 – Fox News | ‘Outnumbered’ panel: Hunter Biden gets ‘laughable’ probation conditionsWATCH

    October 4, 2023 – National Pulse: “President Joe Biden’s son Hunter has pleaded not guilty to three felony gun charges, potentially leading to a highly public trial while his father is in the midst of a reelection campaign’ – READ

    • ABC News: “The charges were originally part of a plea deal that fell apart in July”. Appearing in the same federal courthouse in Delaware – READ
    • “After entering his plea, Abbe Lowell, an attorney for Biden, signaled his intention to file a motion to dismiss the government’s case…Judge Christopher Burke set a Nov. 3 deadline for the parties to file motions.”

    October 3, 2023 – Daily Mail: EXCLUSIVE: Hunter Biden was suspected of hiring prostitutes from ‘Eastern European sex trafficking ring’ during drug binges and falsifying checks to pay the women, Treasury documents reveal – READ, Post Millennial – READ

    September 28, 2023 – Committee on Oversight and Accountability: The Basis for an Impeachment Inquiry of President Joseph R. Biden, Jr. – READ, WATCH

    September 28, 2023 – Fox News: ‘Joe Biden has been lying the whole time’: Ned Ryun, while Democrats keep pleading there is no evidence! – WATCH

    • The $260K money wires from China took place a few months after Biden declared his running for President 2020 – “which strikes me as extremely interesting timing to be getting this money” states Ryun
    • December 2018 – Jim Biden text’s Hunter”“We as usual just need several months of his [Joe’s] help for this to work.” – TWEET, Exhibit 402 WhatsApp message – PDF

    September 28, 2023 – Overshight Committee: Newly released emails and documents show that Delaware Assistant US Attorney Lesley Wolf DID NOT ALLOW AGENTS TO INVESTIGATE JOE BIDEN as part of a FARA probe” – TWEET

    September 27, 2023 – BPR: Bank records show Hunter Biden had two payments wired from China using Joe Biden’s home address – READ, TWEET

    • Oversight committee: CHINA WIRES LISTS JOE’S HOME AS BENEFICIARY ADDRESS: “A few months after Joe Biden announced his candidacy in 2019, information available to the Committee shows Hunter Biden received two wires from China for $250,000 and $10,000, including from Jonathan Li.” – TWEET

    September 27, 2023 – House Ways and Means Commisttee Gov | Press Release: Bombshell: Ways and Means Releases New Documents Revealing Hunter Biden Selling Access to White House, Investigators Blocked from Pursuing Evidence Related to President Biden – READ, Kanakoa – TWEET

    • “Despite never registering as foreign lobbyists, the Bidens received millions from oligarchs in Russia, China, and Ukraine by leveraging their connections with U.S. government officials, clearly violating the FARA.
    • These FARA violations are well-documented in emails, text messages, and primary source evidence found on Hunter Biden’s laptop, as outlined in the @MarcoPolo501c3 Report on the Biden Laptop.
    • Today’s revelation highlights the two-tiered justice system…”

    September 27, 2023 – NTD: LIVE: House Ways Committee GOP Hold Press Conference After Reviewing Hunter Biden’s New EvidenceWATCH,

    September 27, 2023 – Ways and Means Commitee | Press Conference: Chairman Jason Smith: “Significant” New Evidence in Hunter Biden Investigation to Be Reviewed in Executive Session – READ, WATCH, Forbes News: Rep. Jason Smith (R-MO) – WATCH

    Joe Biden is “The Brand”, the Asset – WATCH, Official – WATCH

    September 26, 2023 – Axios: Scoop: Biden team’s don’t-let-him-trip mission – READ, Jesse Watters: The puppet show is falling apart – 80 year old Biden’s tripping – WATCH

    September 26, 2023 – Committee on Oversight and Accountability: Comer Reveals Wires from China Have Joe Biden’s Wilmington Home as the Beneficiary Address – READ

    • “Bank records don’t lie but President Joe Biden does…”
    • “Evidence shows Joe Biden developed a familiar relationship with Jonathan Li during his vice presidency and prior to these payments to Hunter Biden….”...Jonathan Li and Hunter Biden developed a business relationship during Joe Biden’s vice presidency…etc

    September 25, 2023 – Committee on Oversight and Accountability: Comer Announces First Hearing on the President Joseph R. Biden, Jr. Impeachment Inquiry – READ

    • “House Committee on Oversight and Accountability Chairman James Comer (R-Ky.) today announced an upcoming hearing titled, “The Basis for an Impeachment Inquiry of President Joseph R. Biden, Jr.” The hearing will examine the value of an impeachment inquiry and present evidence House Republicans have uncovered to date regarding President Joe Biden’s knowledge of and role in his family’s domestic and international business practices.”

    September 18, 2023 – Gateway Pundit: Oversight Committee Issues Statement Following Hunter Biden’s Lawsuit Against the IRS: “Witness Intimidation Is Just Another Dirty Tactic by the Hunter Biden Legal Team” – READ, GOP Statement – TWEET

    September 18, 2023 – Gateway Pundit: Attorneys For IRS Whistleblower Gary Shapley Respond to Hunter Biden Lawsuit Against IRS – READ

    • “This suit against the IRS is just another frivolous smear by Biden family attorneys trying to turn people’s attention away from Hunter Biden’s own legal problems and intimidate any current and future whistleblowers…” statement from Gary Shapley’s legal team

    September 18, 2023 – Gateway Pundit: Hunter Biden Sues IRS After Whistleblowers Reveal He Was Given Sweetheart Deal for Not Paying Taxes on Millions in Illicit Business Deals – READ, Business Insider – READ

    September 18, 2023 – Fox News: Hunter Biden sues IRS over whistleblowers’ testimony – Hunter Biden’s lawsuit against the IRS whistleblowers who told Congress about his case, alleging the department unlawfully shared his private tax information – WATCH, MSNBC – WATCH,

    • Hannity: Hunter Biden’s story is falling apart – Hannity lists the questions that need answers – WATCH

    September 18, 2023 – AP News: Hunter Biden sues the IRS over tax disclosures after agent testimony before Congress – READ

    September 15, 2023 – NewsBusters: New York Times Smears Biden Impeachment Inquiry: It’s to ‘Appease Far-Right Lawmakers’ – READ

    September 15, 2023 – Your News: ‘Consistent With The 1023 Form’: Jim Jordan Lays Out Evidence Backing Biden Impeachment Inquiry – READ

    September 14, 2023 – NY Post: Hunter Biden indicted over lies about drug addiction while buying gun [timing!!] – READ, En-volve – READ

    • “Hunter Biden was indicted Thursday in Delaware by special counsel David Weiss on three counts related to lying about being addicted to crack cocaine when he bought a gun nearly five years ago…The charges carry a maximum sentence of 25 years in prison…

    September 14, 2023 – Daily Caller: Consistent With The 1023 Form’: Jim Jordan Lays Out Evidence Backing Impeachment Inquiry – WATCH

    September 14, 2023 – Daily Caller (Fox Biz): Rep. James Comer Reveals Next Step In Biden Bribery Probe – (revealing the powers granted by an impeachment enquiry)- WATCH

    • House oversight committee has learnt a lot since Biden investigation opened in January 2023
    • Impeachment Inquiry allows for now:
      • To force judge to rule quicker on accessing bank records of Hunter Biden and Jim Biden etc.
      • It trumps executive privilege of the Bidens
      • Allows them to get Grand Jury testimony – a precident established with Trumps impeachment inquiry
      • Money from China, Russia, Romaina, Ukraine to Shell Companies then to 9 different Biden bank accounts
      • Force agencies to turn over correspondence i.e. 5400 emails

    September 14, 2023 – Daily Caller: House Speaker Kevin McCarthy humiliated a congressional reporter from The Associated Press who falsely claimed the impeachment inquiry is “without evidence.” – WATCH

    September 13, 2023- NY Post: David Weiss ‘not the deciding person’ in Hunter Biden case –READ, Jim Jordan comments – WATCH

    • “Notes hand-written by IRS whistleblower Gary Shapley at an Oct. 7, 2022, meeting indicate Delaware US Attorney David Weiss said he was “not the deciding person” in the Hunter Biden tax fraud case.
    • “The document was released one day after House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) launched an impeachment inquiry into President Biden’s alleged role in his son Hunter and brother James Biden’s foreign business dealings.

    September 13, 2023 – Vigilant Fox: Kevin McCarthy Launches Formal Impeachment Inquiry Against Joe Biden – “Through our investigations, we have found that President Biden did lie to the American people about his own knowledge of his family’s foreign business dealings.” – WATCH & READ

    • Sen. John Kennedy – lists “what we know” – WATCH

    September 13, 2023 – Committee on Oversight and Accountability: 22 Examples of Evidence of Joe Biden’s Involvement in His Family’s Influence Peddling Schemes – READ

    September 12, 2023- NY Post: Why opening a Biden impeachment inquiry is a no-brainer …”For all the inevitable rage from the other side of the aisle, it’s a no-brainer.” – READ

    • In eight months, House GOP probes have proven that Joe was in close cahoots with Hunter’s enterprises: He broke bread with Hunter’s clients, jumped on calls with them, even wrote at least one college recommendation.

    September 12, 2023 – Breitbart News: White House Condemns Biden Impeachment Inquiry as Extreme, Unwarranted – READ, Next News Network – WATCH, Gateway Pundit- READ

    • Speaking in the U.S. Capitol Building, House Speaker Kevin McCarthy opened the inquiry on Tuesday (12th) by stating that House Republicans uncovered “serious and credible allegations” against President Biden of “abuse of power, obstruction, and corruption.” – McCarthy – WATCH, BACKUP
    • Rep. Matt Gaetz: “My goal is not to rattle Kevin McCarthy but to motivate him” – WATCH

    September 12, 2023 – NY Post: McCarthy directs House committees to open formal impeachment inquiry into Biden’s alleged involvement with Hunter business dealings – READ

    • “Based on the evidence, we support the opening of an impeachment inquiry into President Joe Biden….The American people demand and deserve answers, transparency, and accountability for this blatant abuse of public office”

    September 12, 2023 – Committee on Oversight and Accountability: Comer, Jordan, Smith Statement on Speaker McCarthy Opening an Impeachment Inquiry into President Biden – READ

    • Key Findings from IRS Whistleblowers – PDF

    September 12, 2023 – BREAKING: McCarthy Announces Formal Impeachment Inquiry into Biden – WATCH

    August 30, 2023 – NY Post | Miranda Devine: Americans are getting wise to Joe Biden’s corruption — despite his media gatekeepers – Almost half the country thinks Joe Biden is corrupt, according to a new YouGov poll – READ

    August 24, 2023 – Committee on Oversight and Accountability: Joe Biden Lied At Least 16 Times About His Family’s Business Schemes – READ

    June 22,2023 – IRS Whistleblowers: Smith: Testimony of IRS Employees Reveals Biden IRS, DOJ Interfered in Tax Investigation of Hunter Biden, Revealing Preferential Treatment for Wealthy and Politically Connected – READ

    January 12, 2023 – NY Post: Attorney General Merrick Garland names Robert Hur special counsel to probe Biden classified docs … to investigate a current or former president for potential misconduct related to classified information.” – READ

    • [Hur released his report Feb 8, 2024]

    January 12, 2023 – NY Post: A timeline of how the Biden classified documents scandal unfolded – READ

    January 9, 2023 – NY Post: Classified documents found at Biden’s namesake think tank – READ

    • Biden’s personal attorneys found classified documents from his time as vice president improperly stored in an office closet at his DC think-tank, the president himself stunned reporters Thursday by admitting that other sensitive papers were found in the garage of his Wilmington, Del. home — where he also keeps his classic Corvette. – REF

    2022

    November 17, 2022 – Committee on Oversight and Accountability: A President Compromised: The Biden Family Investigation – Interim Staff Report – PDF

    October 17, 2022 – Press Release : Cameroon-Based non profit HEADA acquires METABIOTA – READ
    Health and Development in Action (HEADA)

    2021

    January 20, 2021 – The White House (Unlisted!): The Inauguration of the 46th President of the United States – WATCH, ARCHIVES

    The most popular president in US history, 81 million votes!
    Is this why YouTube got rit of the down thumb counter?
    3 days after inauguration – source
    July 28, 2021 – 4.3K up, 51 thumbs down – source
    September 2023 still only 4.3K thumbs up after 2.06M views – LIVE

    2019

    October 9, 2019 – CNN: Joe Biden calls for Trump’s impeachment for first time – READ, ARCHIVE, CREDIT

    • “To preserve our Constitution, our democracy, our basic integrity, he should be impeached,” Biden said of President Trump
    • Trump admitted to discussing Biden and his son, Hunter, in his phone call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky – Trump released the transcript September 25, 2019

    September 25, 2019 – NY POst: Trump transcript: President discussed alleged Biden corruption with Ukraine leader – READ

    August 2, 2019, Chinese “Jonathan Li wired $250,000 with Joe Biden’s home listed on the wire.” – REF

    April 25, 2019 -CNN: Joe Biden announces he is running for president in 2020 – his 3rd attempt – READ

    April 25, 2019: Biden Official: Joe Biden For President: America Is An Idea – WATCH, ARCHIVE

    • “It’s time for respected leadership on the world stage—and dignified leadership at home. “
    Popularity – who won by the most votes in U.S. history! Oct 30, 2020 – source, It appears YouTube were controlling these numbers – ARCHIVES

    The post Biden Impeachment Inquiry first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

    ]]>