I was aware of this eating insect/bug narrative through the promotion of Nicole Kidman “eating bugs” in 2021, an attempt to make eating bugs look attractive and to normalise this behaviour. That narrative has bubbled to the “in your face” surface now as highlighted in Episode 355 of The Highwire covering recent German Farmer Protests and connecting that to insects farming. This war against our food supply has been going on long before 2024.

Crafting the Narrative

Follow along the timeline from the bottom and notice the target market shifting, the groups who first get excited, the investors and more. It starts with “inspired” college roommates, investors are “attracted”, the “movement” has capital now to “market” and build, then the United Nations gets on board [allegedly].

It appears to have started in 2006 with the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation releasing a report titled Livestock’s Long Shadow which is being quoted that by 2050 Glgbal demand for meat will double, where “livestock production accounts already for 70% of all agricultural land”. Based on these trusted numbers alternative, sustainable protein sources have been pushed from January 2012 conference.

The “growing drive to bring insects into Western shopping baskets” took off in 2013 following FAO’s Edible Insects report . They are “rich in protein; environmentally friendly to harvest; sustainable; and, they’re already eaten, and enjoyed, in many other parts of the world.”

Setting the stage for the next superfood, packed with nutrition!: “‘Crickets are up to 70 per cent protein, which is three times the amount of protein found in beef. They’ve also got more iron than spinach, more calcium than milk, and the list keeps going. They are an incredible superfood.”

The Gateway Insect: “Crickets are the most widely cultivated insects for the human diet across the world and are considered the ‘gateway bug’ for people who choose to eat insects.”

Link to pages driving the “eat bugs” agenda:

• The Journal of Insects as Food and Feed (JIFF) launched May 2014 – READ
• First “Insects to feed the world” conference May 2014 – REF
• United Nations Food & Agriculture Organisation (FAO) – leads the global charge on edible insects – WEB
• International Platform of Insects for Food and Feed (IPIFF) circa 2014 – Promoting Insects for Human Consumption – HERE

Climate Change

The climate change agenda is driving the “eat bugs” agenda. What the media won’t tell you – HERE

This page is attempting to trace back where this climate-driven food agenda began, and how it has evolved. The timeline will be continuously updated as articles and links come to my attention.

Links in reverse chronological order

2024

April 22, 2024 – Nature: Revealed: the ten research papers that policy documents cite most – READ [to get ballpark date – as EAT don’t date their documents]

• EAT Forum: ‘Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT-Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems’, is now undisputedly one of the most influential scientific reports in the world. – READ

March 25, 2024 – Chief Nerd: Lab-Grown’ Meat Made Inside Bioreactors Is Now Being Tested at Restaurants in the U.S. – WATCH

January 2024 – EAT Forum: Economists calculate multi-trillion dollar opportunity to fix the broken global food system – READ, ARCHIVE,

• Food System Economics Commission | Global Policy Report: The Economics of the Food System Transformation – PDF, ARCHIVE, SOURCE
  • The Food System Economics Commission (FSEC) has brought together leading experts to develop a unique economic model that maps for the first time the impacts of two possible futures for the global food system: our Current Trends pathway, and the Food System Transformation pathway.
• Wellcome Trust and Lancet among the sponsors of this monstrosity, termed EAT – CREDIT
• EAT is a global, non-profit startup dedicated to transforming our global food system through sound science, impatient disruption and novel partnerships. – (2019) – ARCHIVE,
  • EAT is a non-profit founded by the Stordalen Foundation, Stockholm Resilience Centre and the Wellcome Trust to catalyze a food system transformation (Jan 17, 2019) – ARCHIVE, EAT-Lancet Commission – ARCHIVE
  • EAT is the science-based global platform for food system transformation. -(2024) READ

January 2024 – The Highwire Episode 355: UNREDACTED – WATCH, The Jaxen Report: Edible Insects in the context of Davos 2024 – EXCERPT

2024 – Sustainable Protein Sources (2nd Edition) – Advances for Healthier Tomorrow: Chapter 25 – Edible Insects: a Neglected and Promising Food Source – READ

• “The interest in insects as human food in the Western world is increasingly considered a viable alternative to other protein sources. In tropical countries, it is common practice and about 2000 insect species are eaten. Insects emit low levels of greenhouse gases, need little water, and require limited agricultural land.”

2023

December 1, 2023 – Brian Sussman Show – Ep 20 – Latest Climate Plan: “No Meat For You!” and more – WATCH

December 2023? – WHO Tedros – wants us to “transform food system” to combat “climate change” – TWEET

October 4, 2023 – Liberty & FinanceL Farms Being Shutdown; We Must Resist | Alex Newman – WATCH, READ

• The UN Master Plan for Humanity

September 25, 2023 – Epoch TV: No Farmers No Food: Will You Eat The Bugs? | Documentary – WATCH

July 13, 2023 – FreedomFest 2023 | Alex Newman: The Global War on Farmers and Push to “Eat The Bugs” – READ, TWEET, CREDIT

• Epoch Times: ‘No Farmers No Food’ Documentary Panel Discussion Held at FreedomFest – READ

July 9, 2023 – 41st Annual Meeting of Doctors for Disaster Preparedness: Let Them Eat Bugs – Debbie Bacigalupi – WATCH

2022

October 19, 2022 – Daily Mail: Aldi considers selling edible INSECTS to help families through the cost-of-living crisis – READ, Summit News – CREDIT

• Butget supermarket Aldi in the UK is considering stocking ‘edible’ bugs and providing recipe kits for parents to prepare worms and crickets for their hungry children, to solve “poverty”. Bugs are “known” to be “a cheap and sustainable form of protein”.
• The supermarket is also involved with a TV game show in which insect ‘farmers’ will pitch the bugs as the ‘next big thing’
• Yum Bug founders Aaron Thomas and Leo Taylor, both 28, are competing against other start-ups to get their product on the supermarket’s shelves

September 2, 2022 – The Guardian: UK urges hunger-stricken African nations to farm insects – READ

July 20, 2022 – Rebel News: Elites want us to eat bugs: Montrealers take a taste test – READ

• A new ideology that governments want to indoctrinate citizens with is one claiming that if we want to save the planet, we will have to turn to alternative sources of protein. Alternative sources such as insects, of course.

July 16, 2022 – WEF: You Will Eat Bugs, and You Will Be Happy – WATCH

June 27, 2022 – London Free Press: By Jiminy! Feds put $8.5M into London cricket farm – Aspire cricket manufacturing farm – READ

• $8.5 million of taxpayer money will go toward construction costs and technology — artificial intelligence specifically — that will monitor the billions of crickets about to be turned into food. The facility starts in a few days.
  • byproducts will be sold back to area farmers as fertilizer
• Mohammed Ashour, co-founder and chief executive of Aspire Foods, an idea that began nine years ago (2013) as a project with four other McGill University students who, in essence, want to solve the problem of world hunger.
  • 5 MBA students from McGill University “entered the world’s largest and most prestigious social enterprise competition” the 2013 Challenge The Global Food Crisis, which they won the Clinton Global Initiative Hult Prize in 2013 – About –REF

May 30, 2022 – Daily Mail: Would you eat bug bolognese? Primary school children in Wales could be offered EDIBLE INSECTS including mealworms and crickets as scientists urge the next generation to embrace eco-friendly meat substitutes – READ

May 26, 2022 – Canadian Manufacturing: Aspire Food Group completes production of manufacturing facility in London, Ontario – to produce 9000 metric tons of crickets every year for human and pet consumption – READ, CREDIT

• Aspire: A world transformed by insect technology – WEB, “Crickets are nature’s superfood ingredient for healthier, happier pets” – READ
• Eventually, 13 million kilograms of crickets will be processed annually in London. – REF

February 9, 2022 – WEF | Climate Change | Davos 2022 Agenda: 5 reasons why eating insects could reduce climate change – “Before you say “yuck,” hear us out.” – READ, You will Eat Bugs – WATCH

1. Edible insects can produce equivalent amounts of quality protein when compared to animals – not all but, crickets, certain ant species and mealworms are known to be protein and calorie dense stars in the the insect-consumption world.
2. Insects require less care and upkeep than livestock – they use less resources, less than plants!! [Plants use CO2 and produce oxygen – it appears they want to take our plants too!]
3. We’re actually running out of protein – The demand for protein will exceed our ability to procure it with10 bn people by 2050 [Well if the taking land, well yes!]
4. Insects are part of a virtuous eco-cycle – circular agriculture – feed microlivestock landfill waste!
5. . You can start small and work your way up – consume animals raised on insects!

January 14, 2022 – Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems: Review: Insects—A Source of Safe and Sustainable Food?— “Jein” (Yes and No) – Grabowski et al – READ, some definitions

• “The role of the consumer is the final factor that justifies the idea of producing insect-based foodstuffs or not…the effort in producing it is futile when the consumer simply does not eat it”

2021

December 30, 2021 – Summit News: Vanderbilt University Professor Argues That We All Need To Eat BUGS – “Black soldier fly larvae, in particular, hold promise.”, follow the EU example – READ

October 22, 2021 – PHYS: Eating the right insects can provide nutrition, and might be good for the planet – READ

• According to UN FAO “Some 2 billion people around the world already eat insects to supplement their diet”
• A January 2021 study in Critical Reviews in Food Science Nutrition said edible insects may have “high superior health benefits”

July 12, 2021 – WEF: Why we need to give insects the role they deserve in our food systems – READ

May 9, 2021 – The Guardian: If we want to save the planet, the future of food is insects – READ

• Ref the EAT-Lancet Commission report (see Jan 2019)

April 9, 2021 – FAO: Food safety aspects of edible insects outlined in new publication – READ, ARCHIVE,

• Looking at edible insects from a food safety perspective – Challenges and opportunities for the sector – REPORT
  • “FINANCIAL INVESTMENTS: Despite growing interest in the sector, procuring investments can be difficult for start-up companies owing to unclear regulations about the production and commercializationof insects as food and feed. This may also have implications on the advancement of research and development in the field.”
  • “overcoming food neophobia among some consumers, especially in the Western countries, is a challenge for the edible insects sector”

May 11, 2021 – Wired: The Cicadas Are Coming. Let’s Eat Them! – Why not embrace Brood X as the free-range, sustainable source of protein that it truly is? – READ, The Hartman Group – CREDIT

• Edible insects have been a part of rich culinary traditions around the world for years, from Mexico’s crunchy chapulines to beondegi, Korea’s silkworm pupae street food
• Market researchers predict the global edible insect market will reach $4.63 billion by 2027, with North America as the fastest-growing sector – ARCHIVE, now Edible Insects Market Worth $9.60 Billion by 2030 – READ

January 14, 2021 – Summit News: EU’s food safety agency Gives Go-ahead For Eating WORMS – “Allergic reactions are likely to occur”. – ARCHIVE, Mealworm consideration – ARCHIVES

January 2021 – Edible Insects Market by Product (Whole Insect, Insect Powder, Insect Meal, Insect Oil) Insect Type (Crickets, Black Soldier Fly, Mealworms), Application (Animal Feed, Protein Bar and Shakes, Bakery, Confectionery, Beverages) – Global Forecast to 2027 by Meticulous Market Research Pvt. Ltd- READ, CREDIT

• Market researchers predict the global edible insect market will reach $4.63 billion by 2027, with North America as the fastest-growing sector – ARCHIVE, Updated Jun 2022 – Edible Insects Market Worth $9.60 Billion by 2030 – READ
• Based on insect type, the crickets segment is expected to dominate the edible insects market during the forecast period of 2020-2027 (In terms of value) – REF

2020

December 22, 2020 – IOP Science | Environ. Res. Lett. : A review of edible insect industrialization: scales of production and implications for sustainability – Wade et al – READ

• “Edible insects have emerged in the past decade as a sustainable alternative to agro-industrial production systems and livestock-based diets.” [see below what has driven this!]

December 17, 2020 – FAO releases a comprehensive guide to sustainable cricket farming – READ, PDF

September 9, 2020 – Runtastic: Eating Insects Might Be Your New Favorite Source of Protein – READ, the WEF refered to this blog post as a “study”- HERE, the blog links to Sep 2015 paper – HERE

• With over 2,100 types of edible insects to choose from
• The WEF want you to know that insects offer between 9.96-35.2 g of protein/100g c.f 16.8-20.6 g/100g for meat. They forgot to state “per edible protein”, and that insects vary.

May 13, 2020 – Euractiv: Insect-based feedstuffs hold ‘enormous potential’ for EU sustainability goals – Farm to Fork strategy “will support the creation of “sustainable and novel feed materials and food,” listing insects as one such potential innovation….“To reduce the environmental and climate impact of animal production,…” – READ

• 2022 Food Safety: Farm to Fork strategy – for a fair, healthy and environmentally-friendly food system – at the heart of the Green New Deal- ARCHIVE

April 3, 2020 – Guardian: Edible insects set to be approved by EU in ‘breakthrough moment’ – READ

• EU’s European Food Safety Authority is expected by the insect industry to endorse whole or ground mealworms, lesser mealworms, locusts, crickets and grasshoppers as being safe for human consumption.

February 18, 2020 – Hartman Group: The Big Bet on Bugs. Providing Palatable Alternative Proteins for Consumers – READ

• Food manufacturers are betting that new protein sources are likely to become increasingly attractive alternatives as more consumers are making a conscious decision to eat less meat [Thus any threat to dis-belief of the climate narrative threatens bug investments]

January 5, 2021 – Critical Reviews in Food Science Nutrition: Potential health benefits of edible insects – Nowakowski et al – READ, CREDIT

• “Edible insects may have superior health benefits due to their high levels of vitamin B₁₂, iron, zinc, fiber, essential amino acids, omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids, and antioxidants.”

2019

October 15, 2019 – The Hartman Group | Research: From Lab-Grown Meat to Insects: Are Consumers Ready to Rethink Protein? – READ

• A wide range of protein possibilities are emerging, including those in the increasingly popular plant-based category but also those that are genetically modified, derived from cell-cultured meats, or derived from insects
  • Food & Technology 2019: From Plant-Based to Lab-Grown – REPORT “As more consumers than ever question the health, ethical, and environmental implications of animal products…”

September 12, 2019 – WEF: A psychologist explains why we find some food disgusting – and why it matters – Insects and lab grown meat ” is a promising area for social marketing.” – READ

August 21, 2019 – World Economic Forum: This London insect farm is changing the way we eat | Pioneers for Our Planet – WATCH

• A company called Entocycle feeds brewery waste and old coffee grains to fly larvae to create a form of animal feed that doesn’t harm the environment. “Insects are nature’s perfect upcycling machines,” says founder Keiran Whitaker. “They create organic natural protein that we can feed to animals – and eventually humans.”

July 8, 2019 – PLOS one : A parasitological evaluation of edible insects and their role in the transmission of parasitic diseases to humans and animals – READ, CREDIT

June 28, 2019 – The Coversation: Eating insects is good for you — and the planet! – READ

• UN FAO: How to Feed the World in 2050 – PDF

June 2019 – ARUP Report “The Future of Urban Consumption in a 1.5°C World’ – READ, PDF, C40 – READ, The Highwire Ep 357 – EXCERPT, European Farmers are protesting in 2024, moving global – TIMELINE

• Expose News: By 2030 you will not eat meat and you will be allowed only three items of new clothing a year, report says – CREDIT,
• Ambitious target is ZERO meat and milk consumption per day, yet you will still get 2,500kcal/day!

May 5, 2019 – Wired: Save the Lemurs! Eat the Crickets! -To take pressure off endangered lemurs, researchers are encouraging the people of Madagascar to embrace bugs as a source of protein. – READ Lab grown food revolution

January 16, 2019 – The Lancet | Commissions from the Lancet journals: Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT–Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems – READ, The Guardian – CREDIT, EAT–Lancet Commission web – ARCHIVE

• The EAT–Lancet Commission is the first full scientific review of what constitutes a healthy diet from a sustainable food system,… Sponsored by the Wellcome Trust!
• EAT Forum: The EAT-Lancet Commission on Food, Planet, Health – Can we feed a future population of 10 billion people a healthy diet within planetary boundaries? – ARCHIVE
• Jan 16, 2019 – The Lancet: Report Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT–Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems (Walter Willett et al.) – READ
• The EAT-Lancet Commission Summary Report – “Transformation to healthy diets by 2050 will require substantial dietary shifts…”- READ, PDF

2018

January 29, 2018 – Time: No One Elegantly Devours a Four-Course Meal of Bugs Like Nicole Kidman – READ, In a Vanity Fair video, Kidman reveals that her “hidden talent is eating microlivestock,” i.e. Nicole Kidman Eats Bugs – WATCH

2017

April 1, 2017 – Wageninger University: List of edible insects of the world – READ, PDF

2016

November 10, 2016 – WEF: What will we eat in 2030? “or new alternatives (soya products, or perhaps insects or artificial meat)” – ARCHIVE

April 8, 2016 – The Guardian: The worm has turned: how British insect farms could spawn a food revolution – “With meat prices expected to soar, agricultural entrepreneurs believe invertebrate livestock can provide the protein we need. But will the mainstream ever be ready to eat mealworms?” – READ

July 2016 – North American Coalition for Insect Agriculture (NACIA) is formed in 2016 when 50 stakeholders in the insects for food and feed industry met at the Eating Insects Detroit Conference – READ, REF

• Initially North American Edible Insect Coalition (NAEIC) – heads the “BugAg” movement. The mission of the North American Coalition for Insect Agriculture is to encourage positive use of farmed insects in North America.

May 26-28, 2016 – Eating Insects Conference at Wayne State University in Detroit – the first conference dedicated solely to exploring the culture of edible insects to be held in the U.S – READ, REF

April 27, 2016 – PROteINSECT Final Conference: Insects as a Sustainable Source of Protein – Feed for the Future – Brussels. An EU funded FP7 project. (Grant #312084) , coordinated by Fera Science Ltd in the United Kingdom – AGENDA, READ, White Paper – PDF

• PROteINSECT – enabling the exploitation of insects as a sustainable source of protein for animal feed and human nutrition – READ,
  • WHITE PAPER: Insect Protein: Feed for the Future – Addressing the need for feeds of the future today – PDF
• Fera Science Press Release: Insects no more risky than other proteins as animal feed – ARCHIVE
• Maggots raised on animal manure could provide a sustainable alternative to animal feed – READ

March 7, 2016 – Wired: You’ll Eat Bugs. These Investors Are Betting Millions on It – 3 years ago (2013) two college room mates (Greg Sewitz and Gabi Lewis) ordered 2 boxes of live crickets for their pet but instead made protein bars! – READ, ARCHIVE

• Investors: “…one deep-pocketed group is taking the pair quite seriously. Today Sewitz and Lewis’ company, Exo Protien, announced it has raised $4 million in a series A round of funding led by Accel Foods with participation by investors like Collaborative Fund.
• “…the United Nations says insects could play a crucial role in feeding a growing global population without wrecking the environment”

2015

September 16, 2015 – European Journal of Clinical Nutrition: Are edible insects more or less ‘healthy’ than commonly consumed meats? A comparison using two nutrient profiling models developed to combat over- and undernutrition by Raye et al – READ, Indirectly referenced by WEF (point 1) – HERE

• “The results presented here are the first systematic comparison of the nutritional composition of insects and meat, and their relative healthiness according to contemporary nutrient profiling models.”
• “Insect nutritional composition is highly diverse in comparison with commonly consumed meats. The food category ‘insects’ contains some foods that could potentially exacerbate diet-related public health problems related to over-nutrition, but may be effective in combating under-nutrition.”

July 7, 2015 – Financial Times – Edible insect farms strive for scale – READ, REF,

• Next Millennium Farms (now Entomo Farms) is one of a number of bug farms that have sprung into being to supply food brands and chefs with insects to bake into protein bars, biscuits and other bug delicacies.
• A revision to the EU’s Novel Foods Regulation, due this year, puts edible bug farmers in the right place at the right time.

June 2015 – EU: Updating rules on novel foods to keep up with scientific advances – new category for insects proposed – PDF

March 26, 2015 – Documentary: America’s Shrinking Farms – TRAILER, ARCHIVE, “That Will Change Your Views on the Future of Food” – READ, UN FAO – CREDIT

March 20, 2015 – EcoWatch “Transforming Green” via UN FAO: Are insects the next climate-friendly superfood? – READ, ARCHIVE, SOURCE

• “Demand for food-grade insects is growing rapidly,” says the website for Tiny Farms, a Silicon Valley-based start-up “pioneering the industry production of insects.”…Currently, it admits, edible insects are a niche products with the cost of a pound of cricket flour ranging from $25-$45. But it says that’s due to lack of scale and it hopes to change that”
• “More than 30 companies are already using cricket flour in their products such as cookies and energy bars. [and you didn’t know it!] And while eating insects is common in Latin America, southeast Asia and parts of Africa because they’re a cheaply available commodity,” in the US its not.
• The same day “Obama Signs Executive Order to Cut Government Greenhouse Gas Emissions by 40 Percent by 2025 – READ, REF

March 18, 2015 – Food Navigator: Tiny Farms: Edible insects are a novelty today, but they’ll be mainstream tomorrow – ARCHIVE cricket flour producers are popping up everywhere.

February 24, 2015 – Lux Research: Alternative Proteins to Claim a Third of the Market by 2054 – “insects, algae, and synthetic biology sources may make up over 50% of the alternative protein market by 2054” – ARCHIVE

• “Shifts in supply and demand of protein for human consumption will drive the rise of alternative proteins to 307 million MT by 2054, initiating significant changes in the food and agriculture landscape.” [what will drive that “demand”?]

February 15, 2015 – TEDxYoungstown: Alternative Protein | Kevin Bachhuber founder of Big Cricket Farms, the first urban edible insect farm in the US – WATCH, ARCHIVE

2014

December 10, 2014 – Consumer Reoprts: Cricket-flour protein bars pass the taste test – Consumer Reports’ experts munched on snack bars and cookies – READ, CREDIT

• Protein products aimed at people interested in a paleo diet or weight loss in general are becoming increasingly popular, and cricket flour is seen as an environmentally efficient way of getting that nutrient in your diet”
• “These critters are raised on domestic cricket farms, where they are fed a grain-based diet. They’re dried or roasted and then milled into a fine flour. About 40 crickets are packed into an average snack bar.”
• “Cricket-flour goodies attracted plenty of attention at the recent Natural Products Expo in Baltimore, where manufacturers claimed they are making an investment in the environment because the insects don’t require much land or water—certainly much less than cattle, for example.”

August 20, 2014 – Washington Post: Gateway bug: How crickets could hook America on eating insects – ARCHIVE

June 24, 2014 – Practical Ethics: Should Vegetarians Consider Eating Insects? – READ

• “In the last few years, there has been a push from various bodies—including the UN—to get Western countries to adopt eating insects as an alternative to meat. They are: rich in protein; environmentally friendly to harvest; sustainable; and, they’re already eaten, and enjoyed, in many other parts of the world.”

May 14-17, 2014 – FAO: 1st International Conference “Insects to feed the world” at Wageningen University in the Netherlands – A whole new sector in animal livestock – READ, WATCH, Conference report – PDF, READ

• Summary Reoprt – “The overall objective of the conference was to lay the foundations for continued dialogue, further research, evidence-based policy making and investments to promote the use of insects as human food and as animal feed in the context of food and feed security”. – PDF

• The first international conference on insects for food and feed brought over 450 participants from 45 countries together to discuss about the state of the art in research, business and policy making in this new developing sector.
• “Today more than 20,000 cricket farmers are registered in Thailand alone” Patrick Durst, FAO
• A new Journal of Insects as Food and Feed (JIFF) by Wageningen Academic Publishers was also launched – READ, First edition – HERE
  • Foreword: Why a Journal of Insects as Food and Feed? – READ

March 17, 2014 – Wired: Out in the Open: Raise Your Own Edible Insects With This Free Kit – cockroaches, crickets, mealworms and silkworms – a “new and growing community of people who treat insects as food” known as entomophagy – READ

• Daniel Imrie-Situnayake and Tiny Farms have created what they call Open Bug Farm — a high-tech kit for raising your own edible insects.
  • In 2016 Mark Zuckerberg’s sister Arielle at a veture capital firm invested in Tiny Farms – READ

January 23, 2014 – US Patent 2014/0020630: METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR BREEDING FLYING INSECTS (Filed Jul 18, 2012) – PDF, CREDIT

2013

September 2013 – EcoWatch “Transforming Green” news began – A “cutting-edge news service”… “EcoWatch became a Certified B Corporation and joined more than 900 companies that leverage the power of business to solve social and environmental problems.” – ARCHIVE

May 14, 2013 – NPR | The Salt: Maybe It’s Time To Swap Burgers For Bugs, Says U.N. – READ

• The Food and Agriculture Organization has been pondering bugs as a protein source since 2003, but in the new report, the agency argues that insects might be essential to feeding a planet of 7 billion people.
• FAO says the future is bright for edible insects. “Although it will require considerable convincing to reverse [feelings of disgust], it is not an impossible feat,”

May 13, 2013 – BBC: UN Report urges people to eat insects to fight world hunger – READ

May 13, 2013 – Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations | FAO Forestry Paper 171: Edible insects: Future prospects for food and feed security – Report – ARCHIVE, (also see Jan 2012) The Highwire Ep 355 – CREDIT, Refered to as a “Landmark” report – REF

• Agenda to get Western nations to switch over to consuming insects – propaganda campaign to make this happen COMMUNICATIONS: “Western societies require tailored media communication strategies and educational programmes that address the disgust factor. Influencing the public at large as well as policymakers and investors in the food and feed sectors by providing validated information on the potential of insects as food and feed sources can help to push insects higher on political, investment and research agendas worldwide.” pg xv
• “The Way Forward” – “Recent developments in research and development show edible insects to be a promising alternative for the conventional production of meat, either for direct human consumption or for indirect use as feedstock. Nevertheless, a tremendous amount of work still needs to be done by a wide range of stakeholders over many years to fully realize the potential that insects offer for food and feed security.” – PDF
• The roadmap drawn up during the Expert Consultation Meeting on Assessing the Potential of Insects as Food and Feed in Assuring Food Security in Rome in January 23-25, 2012 – the tasks tha lay ahead

May 13, 2013 – FAO PRESS RELEASE: Forest products critical to fight hunger – including insects – New study highlights role of insects for food and feed consumption. – READ

• FAO’s research, done in partnership with Wageningen University in the Netherlands
• The Barriers:
  • “legislation in most industrialized nations forbids the actual feeding of waste materials and slurry or swill to animals, even though this would be the material that insects normally feed on. Further research would be necessary, especially as regards the raising of insects on waste streams. But it is widely understood by scientists that insects are so biologically different from mammals that it is highly unlikely that insect diseases could be transmitted to humans.”
  • Regulations often also bar using insects in food for human consumption
  • “The private sector is ready to invest in insect farming. We have huge opportunities before us,” said Paul Vantomme, one of the authors of the report. “But until there is clarity in the legal sphere, no major business is going to take the risk to invest funds when the laws remains unclear or actually hinders development of this new sector,”

May 13-15, 2013 – International Conference on Forests for Food Security and Nutrition in Rome – READ, Opening Remerks – PDF

• FAO launched their new study on Edible Insects – (see above)
• “It is estimated that insects form part of the traditional diets of at least 2 billion people. Insect gathering and farming can offer employment and cash income, for now mostly at the household level but also potentially in industrial operations.”

May 8, 2013 – Jason Drew and AgriProtein Team Wins United Nations Award for Innovation for Africa – nutrient recycling – a method that uses waste and fly larvae to produce natural animal feed – READ [The prelude to human insect farming?]

May 2013 – UN FAO – Edible Forest Insects – ARCHIVE

May 2013 – UN FAP -REPORT: Six-legged livestock: Edible insect farming, collection and marketing in Thailand – ARCHIVE

• Eating and selling edible insects are common activities in Thialand either farmed or harvested in the wild. Cricket farming was introduced >15 years ago (c. 1996). “However, information remains scant on their current stauts and on production, technology development, market channels and business ventures as well as future opportuinties.
• Crickets and Palm weevil larvae are farmed. “Currently there are approximately 20,000 farms operating 217,529 rearing pens. Total production over the last six years (1996-2011) has averaged around 7,500 tonnes per year”

April 24, 2013 – Wellcome Collection: Insects Au Gratin- Explore the future of food, debate the consumption of insects as a potential alternative to traditional livestock, and watch a live 3D food-printing demo. – READ

• There’s a “growing drive to bring insects into Western shopping baskets” [This is before the FAO report launch!]

2013 – Clinton Global Initiative | The Hutt Prize Solving “The global food crisis” challenge – ARCHIVE, Won by McGill Univertity students for Aspire cricket farming.

2013 – International Platform of Insects for Food and Feed (IPIFF) is a non-profit organisation founded in 2013 which represents the interests interests of private players in the insect industry associated to this organisation. In order “to help the insect industry prosper in Europe and worldwide” – ARCHIVE, READ, IPIFF today – HERE

2012

2012 – Tiny Farms, an edible insect company, was founded in 2012 to address a growing and evolving global market in entomophagy; the human consumption of insects. Promoting Entoculture is the intersection of bugs, food and farming – ARCHIVE

• “Insect production is more energy, space and time efficient than traditional agriculture, making it ideal for a world where more than half the population live in cities.”
• entomophagy movemement is a revolution in food production

August 28, 2012 – NPR | The Salt:Grow Your Own Locust Kit Could Someday Help Feed African Refugees – two industrial engineering students want to use insects as emergency food – READ, Design award – ARCHIVE, WATCH

• The product is still in the preliminary stages of development, but from what we can tell, it’s the first of its kind [the begnining/inspiration for benchtop, household tiny farms?]

May 9, 2012 – Incredible Edible Bugs – there is a movement is afoot to encourage insect eating – video 1 – ARCHIVE

January 2012 – Research Gate: Assessing the Potential of Insects as Food and Feed in assuring Food Security SUMMARY REPORT – Conference: FAO Expert Consultation on Assessing the potential of Insects for Food SecurityAt: FAO, Rome, Italy – READ

January 23-25, 2012 – United Nations: Expert Consultation Meeting on Assessing the Potential of Insects as Food and Feed in Assuring Food Security in Rome – READ, REF, Report source – ARCHIVE [Its as though they planned where we are in 2024!]

• Towards a global conference on Edible Insects as Food and Feed (2014) – REF

“Assessing the Potential of Insects as Food and Feed in assuring Food Security” Action Plan: – REF, READ

• Further document the nutritional values of insects in order to promote insects more efficiently as a healthy food source.
• Investigate the sustainability and quantify the environmental impacts of harvesting and farming insects compared with traditional farming and livestock-raising practices.
• Clarify and augment the socio-economic benefits that insect gathering and farming can offer, with a focus on improving the food security of the poorest of society. [then move to all Western society]
• Develop a clear and comprehensive legal framework at the (inter-)national level that can pave the way for more investment, leading towards the full development (from the household scale to the industrial scale) of production and trade in insect products for food and feed internationally.

2011

April 4, 2011 – FAO: FAO’s role in the development of edible insect programmes in collaboration with the Wageningen University- READ, READ, Videos – ARCHIVE

2007

December 2007- Edible Unique – shop online for unique edibles such as insects and other bush tucker – ARCHIVE, c.f. Dec 2015 – ARCHIVE

2006

2006 – United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation together with The Livestock, Environment & Development (LEAD) Initiative: LIVESTOCK’S LONG SHADOW: environmental issues and options – REPORT, CREDIT

• “The contribution by livestock and especially cattle to environmental problems is on a massive scale and should be addressed with urgency according to FAO’s report Livestock’s Long Shadow. Global demand for livestock products will more than double during the next 50 years (from 229 million tonnes in 1999/2001 to 465 million tonnes by 2050), and livestock production accounts already for 70% of all agricultural land. The livestock sector is an important contributor to greenhouse gas emissions such as CO₂, CH₄ and N₂O.”
• Globally the livestock sector is “one of the largest sources of greenhouse gases and one of the leading causal factors in the loss of biodiversity” …The livestock sector is also a primary player in the agricultural economy, a major provider of livelihoods for the poor and a major determinant of human diet and health. Hence its environmental role needs to be seen in the context of its many different functions…” pg 267
• – FAO 2014 believe Edible insects are a Protein with a lighter environmental footprint – REF

2003

2003 – NPR: “The Food and Agriculture Organization has been pondering bugs as a protein source since 2003” – REF

1997

1997 – Ecology of Food and Nutrition, 36: 347–366: The importance of edible insects in the nutrition and economy of people of the rural areas of Mexico – Ramos Elorduy, J.

• “In Mexico, the protein content of 78 evaluated species ranged from 15 percent to 81 percent of dry matter and protein digestibility ranged from 76 percent to 98 percent” – pg 70 REF

1996

1996 – Approximate time insect farming was introduced to Thailand, though eating insecst is a historic tradition, the farming isn’t – REF

1992

June 3,1992 – UNCED Earth Summit (Agenda 21) – “sustainable development” becomes the driving force for future global policy and funding. – TIMELINE

1988

1988 – The First International Congress of Ethnobiology was held in Belém, Brazil in 1988 – READ, History – READ, forging interdisciplinary boundaries of anthropology, botany, zoology, archaeology, pharmacology, geography, sociology, linguistics and related fields.

• Presentation: Edible insects: barbarism or solution to the hunger problem? by Ramos Elorduy, J
  (In D.A. Posey & W.L. Overal, eds. Ethnobiology: implications and applications. Proceedings of the First International Congress of Ethnobiology, pp. 151–158. Bélem, Brazil, Museu Paraense Emílio Goeldi.) – REF

1983

December 19, 1983 – UN establishes a “governing council” that would become known as the “Brndland Commission” – “Process of preparation of the Environmental Perspective to the Year 2000 and Beyond” – TIMELINE

• UNEP recommended the UN establishment of a “Special Commission” to “make available a report on environment and the global problamatique to the year 2000 and beyond, including proposed strategies for sustainable development”. Gro Harlem Brundtland was appointed as Chair
• In 1987 the commission published their report titled Our Common Future, where they cemented the term “sustainable development”.   This document formed the basis for the 1992 first UN Earth Summit (UNCED).

1976

May 31 – June 11, 1976 – UN Habitat I conference – Vancouver Declaration on Human Settlements – READ, TIMELINE

• The Declaration provided the first definition of ‘adequate shelter’ and recommendations for each country to achieve it. Population, land use and resources officially become a “concern”.

The post Edible Insects (and Lab Grown Meat) first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

Following Elon Musk’s purchase of Twitter in October 2022, “free speech” has (mostly) been returned to that platform, and many “bots” have been deleted, allowing the wider public to only now beginning to hear narratives that were censored, ridiculed and “debunked” previously.

Mainstream media air select “authority” voices deemed as “experts”, who repeat, over and over the same narratives without bringing the receipts, the data, they just spouting mantras – “safe & effective”, “misinformation” etc.

If a media host is able, and dares to bring in a counter-narrative voice they risk the threat of being ousted. Tucker Carlson served as a prime example of that! So where can we the people hear both sides of “The Science” at the same time….a live air debate?

Let these “experts” show their TRUE level of knowledge in a public debate

If these mainstream authority “expert” talking heads are truly knowledgable in their field they should hold up well in a public debate. But if they are simply spouting narratives that are not actually backed by actual evidence, then you’d suspect they’d scramble and bring up excuses not to debate.

Debate challenges have gone out and the public are eager to hear, and there is huge pools of money to be made by charities of their choice.

This page will captures, as best as possible, the timeline of public debate challenges, the challenges response and if a debate actually happens.

Some of the debate challenges you’ll find below:

• Del Bigtree challenges Neil DeGrasse Tyson to a debate on “the science” – DONE April 6, 2023
• Joe Rogan challenged Dr Peter Hotez to debate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on vaccines
• Steve Kirsch challenged Dr Paul Offit to debate him on vaccines and autism
• Dr James Lyons-Weiler challenges Professor Martin Kulldorff on vaccines and autism
• Steve Kirsch challenged Professor Vinay Prasad to debate qualified scientists who disagree with him on HCQ and Ivermectin for COVID-19

Not all are backed by monetary bets, but it is strongly suggested that the charities will go without millions!

Links in reverse chronological order

This page is continuously updated

2024

Febraury 9, 2024 – Illusion of Consensus: Vaccine Death Debate – Steve Kirsch vs Kevin Bass – (behind paywall) – into – WATCH

2023

August 16, 2023 – INVITATION: ROUND 2 OF THE DEBATE ON COVID Phillip Altman responds live to Dr. Dan (cardiologist) – READ,

August 8, 2023 – Cafe Locked Out Podcasts: Australia’s Inaugural Covid Debate between Doctors. Cafe Locked Out Special – WATCH, CREDIT

• Dr. William Bay (a suspended medical practitioner) debates cardiologist Dr Dan

June 28, 2023 – Steve Kirsch Substack: Will UCSF Professor Vinay Prasad “walk the talk” by agreeing to debate qualified scientists who disagree with him?

• “But I disagree with him on his views on ivermectin and HCQ as being effective COVID treatments and whether vaccines can trigger autism.” writes Kirsch

June 27, 2023 – Steve Kirsch Substack: James Lyons-Weiler challenges Professor Martin Kulldorff on vaccines and autism – private email between JLW and MK. Quoted with permission – READ

June 27, 2023 – Steve Kirsch Substack: Paul Offit is trying to gaslight you. Here are the facts. – Paul Offit wrote a Substack article in response to the RFK Jr. Rogan interview. I was not impressed. Not one bit. Here’s the counterpoint to what he wrote that everyone should know. – READ

• Dr Offit wrote recent Substack to respond to RFK jr from 20 years ago! – READ
• Kirsch includes responses from Aaron Siri – TWEET, & Dr James Lyons-Weiler – TWEET, SUBSTACK
• Steve Kirsch has asked Offit if he would debate Robert F, Kennedy Jr. on Joe Rogan’s podcast on the same terms as the Dr Peter Hotez offer – TWEET, Offit’s substack comments – HERE & HERE

June 23, 2023 – Steve Kirsch Substack: My written debate with Jonathan Howard MD on COVID vaccines for kids – He will only debate things he’s written articles about. OK, let’s start with his article which makes the ridiculous claim that “The vaccine …[is] far safer than the virus for children.” – READ

• My written debate with Jonathan Howard MD on whether vaccines cause autism – READ

June 18, 2023 – Chief Nerd: The Peter Hotez vs. RFK Jr Charity Debate Pot Is Now Over $1.52 MILLION!! – TWEET

• Elon Musk has entered the chat – TWEET
• Patrick Bet-David weighs in with a long – TWEET
• Kanekoa The Great reminds us that @JoeRogan grills Dr. Peter Hotez for exclusively promoting vaccines while disregarding exercise, vitamins, and a healthy diet all which boosts the immune system! – TWEET
  Mar 2019 JRE Ep #1261 Hotez interview LISTEN, Dr Kory – TWEET
• Matt Orfalea’s montage of Hotez “The Great Double-Talking Vaccine Scientist” – WATCH

June 18, 2023 – Joe Rogan challenges Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD to debate Robert F. Kennedy Jr – offers $100K to charity of his choice – TWEET, Follow up TWEET

June 17, 2023 – Prof Peter Hotez tweets Vice article – TWEET, ARCHIVE

June 16, 2023 – Vice | Anna Merlan: Spotify Has Stopped Even Sort of Trying to Stem Joe Rogan’s Vaccine Misinformation – As a recent conversation between the podcast host and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. makes clear – READ, ARCHIVE, [The “dogshit” article with Dr Peter Hotez tweeted]

June 15, 2023 – Joe Rogan Experience Episode #1999 – Robert F. Kennedy Jr. – LISTEN

April 6, 2023 – The Highwire Episode 314: WHEN TWO UNIVERSES COLLIDE – FULL, Del Bigtree debates Neil DeGrasse Tyson – WATCH

• The call for a debate went out in Episode 202 – WATCH

February 2, 2023 – The Highwire Episode 305: GAIN OF DYSFUNCTION – FULL, Featuring Del Bigtree’s debut with Ask Dr Drew – WATCH

• January 31, 2023 – Ask Dr Drew episode: Why They Lied: Del Bigtree Exposes Fauci, mRNA, EUA & The COVID Catastrophe Cover-Up – WATCH

2020

July 23, 2020 – Kennedy Jr. vs Dershowitz: Heated vaccine debate between Robert Kennedy Jr. and Alan Dershowitz moderated by Patrick Bet-David – WATCH

May 21, 2020 – The Highwire Ep 164: DEBATING CORONA-PHOBIA – FULL,

• Del Bigtree Debates Constitutional Lawyer Alan Dershowitz – after Dershowitz strongly stated earlier in the week “if you refuse to be vaccinated, the state has the power to literally take you to a doctor’s office and plunge a needle into your arm.” – WATCH, deleted from YouTube

2018

May 10, 2018 – The Highwire Ep 58 – Dr Andy Wakefield vs Brian Deer [journalist]: The Real Fraud Revealed – WATCH, deleted from YouTube, Episode Re-Aired December 27, 2018 – The Highwire Ep 91 – WATCH, Dr Wakefield – HERE

The post Let the Public Health Debate Challenge Begin first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

Dr. Risch received his MD degree from the University of California San Diego and PhD from the University of Chicago. After serving as a postdoctoral fellow in epidemiology at the University of Washington, Dr. Risch was a faculty member in epidemiology and biostatistics at the University of Toronto before coming to Yale. REF

• Dr Risch articles on Brownstone Institute – HERE
• Yale Profile – HERE, ARCHIVE
• Early Covid Care Expert – Harvey Risch, MD, PhD, FACE – BIO
• Early Covid Care are tracking Dr Risch videos – HERE, Articles – HERE

Harvey Risch on

• Twitter – HERE,
• Telegram – HERE

Dr Risch links in reverse chronological order

2024

April 6, 2024 – David Gornoski: The Science: Yale’s Prof. Harvey Risch Surveys Wreckage of Pandemic Policies – WATCH, TWEET

• “a conversation on how the COVID vaccines originated from bioweapons research, the truth behind Event 201, the “bird flu pandemic,” the failures of COVID protocols, the future of medical freedom, recommended dietary changes, and more.”

April 1, 2024 – Peter Navarro’s Substack: CDC Demonstrates Failure of Public Health Management of the COVID-19 Pandemic by Harvey Risch – READ

• As Peter Navarro spends time incacerated (for doing his job), his substack is being managed by others.
  March 19, 2024 – Dr. Peter Navarro Responds To Biden Admin’s Political Persecution Shortly Before Reporting To Miami Prison – WATCH

March 20, 2024 – IPAK-EDU Director’s Science Webinar – “A Conversation on Evidence-Based Medicine” with Harvey Risch – WATCH

February 26, 2024 – Sen. Ron Johnson’s Roundtable Discussion: “Federal Health Agencies and the COVID Cartel: What Are They Hiding?” – PRESS, 4 hours- WATCH, BACKUP, Dr Harvey Risch – EXCERPT

• We know the initial “coronavirus” cases in the Fall of 2019, paralleled the Wuhan Subway Line 2 – EXCERPT
  • [Sasha Latypova suggests toxic agents are traditionally released via subways!?- EXCERPT)

2023

October 17, 2023 – Club Grubbery: Graham and John discuss with Dr Harvey Risch the truth of the jabs… – WATCH

September 25, 2023 – Daily Clout w/ Dr Wolf: Legendary Epidemiologist Dr. Harvey Risch on Turbo-Cancers – WATCH

September 20, 2023 – Daily Clout/Wellness Company – Top Doctor [Risch] Explains Why “Turbo Cancer” Rates Are Likely to Get Even Worse – READ

“We know that the COVID vaccines have done various degrees of damage to the immune system in a fraction of people who’ve taken them,…And that damage could be anywhere from getting COVID more often, getting other infectious diseases, and perhaps it may also be cancer in the longer term,…”

Dr Risch

September 11, 2023 – American Thought Leaders: Dr. Harvey Risch: Rise in Aggressive ‘Turbo Cancers’–And Especially Among Younger People – WATCH

August 18, 2023 – Just The News: Dr. Harvey Risch shares the findings from his research paper on COVID vaccine deaths – WATCH, Americans with more COVID booster vaccines are more likely to catch the virus – WATCH, new rising COVID variant FL.1.5.1, whose most susceptible, and how Americans should prepare their immune systems ahead of flu season – WATCH

July 9, 2021 – America out Loud w/ Dr Harvey Risch: Does the Institution of Public Health Have Any Moral Justifications? interview with Dr David Martin – LISTEN

July 7, 2023 – War Room Battleground EP 328: Dr. Risch: Medical Journals Blindly Believe Government Findings While Ignore Independent Reports – WATCH, FULL, Daily Sceptic – READ, Substack – READ, for more links see Autopsy page – HERE

• The Lancet took down pre-print publication – A Systematic Review of Autopsy Findings in Deaths After COVID-19 Vaccination by Hulscher et al. New location – HERE

March 22, 2022 – Daily Clout | Dr Naomi Wolf: Renowned Epidemiologist Explains Systemic Health Care Corruption, Announces Solution w/ Dr Harvey Risch – WATCH

March 9, 2023 – American Thought Leaders: Dr. Harvey Risch: Fake Studies, Cherry-Picked Data, and Big Pharma’s Stranglehold on Medicine – LISTEN

March 8, 2023 – Just The News: Dr. Risch: Fauci kept people in the dark to hide COVID’s origin – WATCH, referencing hearing – HERE

February 27, 2023 – Just the News: Top epidemiologist blasts feds’ continued obsession with ineffective masks in COVID fight – “The irrationality of this is just not explainable,” Dr. Harvey Risch – WATCH

January 25, 2023 – Bannons War Room Ep 2471: Harvey Risch: The Mainstream Media Are Pushing A Very Dangerous Message – EXCERPT, FULL

January 25, 2023 – Bannons War Room Ep 2470: Dr. Harvey Risch Explains Critical Failures in Covid Booster Awaiting FDA Vote – EXCERPT, FULL

January 9, 2023 – CHD | The Defender: Science vs Plausibility With Harvey A Risch, M.D., Ph.D – WATCH, BACKUP, ‘Theories Are Not Science’ – READ. Clout Hub – READ

2022

December 8, 2022 – Bannons War Room Ep 2359: Harvey Risch: Ages 64 And Below Made Up Less Than 2% Of The Total COVID Infections – WATCH, FULL

They’re doing this [vaccine approval in ages down to 6 month old] because they have an agenda, not because these things offer any benefit for their supposed usage, that agenda is nefarious…the vaccination program is… not about helping public health

Dr Harvey Risch

[they] sentence…300,000, 500,000 people to death from the infection because they couldn’t get treated because of the suppression of these [effective early] treatments

Dr Harvey Risch

Nobodies pushing counter evidence, they pushing counter opinions!
[That’s not science!]

Dr Harvey Risch

December 7, 2022 – Senator Ron Johnson’s Round Table in Washington DC – Expert forum on COVID-19 Vaccines – filmed by The Highwire – Dr Harvey Risch – EXCERPT, FULL, RUMBLE, The highlights of all guests – WATCH

A pandemic with relatively low mortality is not managed by counting the cases, it’s managed by preventing hospitalisation and mortality.

Dr Harvey Risch

• Graph shows the distribution of mortality (prior to Omicron) by age group, which shows almost no mortality in the youngest age groups 64 years or less. The mortality that exists in the young age groups is due to chronic conditions such as obesity, diabetes, chronic heart disease, chronic kidney disease, the immuno-compromised. Even in the older aged groups the mortality is amongst those people who have multiple chronic conditions.

When you have such low or non-existing mortality in these low age-groups the potential serious adverse effects of the vaccine will surmount the non-existent mortality in these age groups.

…all these approvals for these vaccines that have pushed their way down into these low age groups had no reason to be there in the first place because there was no mortality that they were trying to prevent.

We already know the vaccines don’t prevent spread, as the CDC said on August 11th, they don’t prevent transmission, so the only point of them is for personal protection as treatment if one wants to choose that, and yet there’s no reason to choose that when the mortality from the infection is orders of magnitudes less than from the vaccine.

Dr Harvey Risch

December 2, 2022 – Just The News: Dr. Harvey Risch on the multitude of Covid claims made by the government that turned out to be false. – WATCH, Regulatory agencies are acting like the PR department for Big Pharma – WATCH

“When you play fast and loose with statistics, trying to be plausible, that’s not science.”

Dr Risch

November 26, 2022 – Brownstone Institute | Harvey Risch: Plausibility But Not Science Has Dominated Public Discussions of the Covid Pandemic – READ

November 23, 2022 – Ask Dr Drew with Dr Kelly Victory: mRNA Adverse Reaction Data SUPPRESSED by CDC w/ Dr Harvey Risch – WATCH

• Dr Risch is concerned about mRNA vaccines and “major suppression of information about adverse events by FDA, CDC, governments in general.”

October 24-25, 2022 – Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine in Oxford: “The lack of scientific freedom: causes, consequences and cures”: Presentation by Harvey Risch – Mass messaging of plausibility instead of scientific evidence – SCHEDULE

October 16, 2022 – Just the News: Dr. Harvey Risch: CDC has ‘officially backtracked’ on COVID vaccines – LISTEN

October 16, 2022 – WMD: Dr. Harvey Risch: Health establishment censors us because ‘they’ve lost the argument’ – WATCH, Government has no legal ground for COVID vaccine mandates – EXCERPT,

• CDC itself acknowledged in August 2022 that any protection against infection and transmission is only “transient.” –CDC

“All of this censorship, all of these claims of misinformation, disinformation, is purely a statement of: We cannot fight on the playing field of ideas, of argument. We do not have the ability to fight back against those positions, and so we are using the tool of censorship instead,”

September 24, 2022 – Ask Dr Drew Show: Masks Like a Chain Link Fence to Block Mosquitoes – Epidemiologist Dr. Harvey Risch – WATCH

September 23, 2022 – CHD | ‘Friday Roundtable’ Episode 26: With Peter A. McCullough, MD, MPH + Harvey Risch, MD, PhD – WATCH, READ

September 19, 2022 – The New American: Dr. Harvey Risch: No Compelling Government Interest in Covid Vaccinations – WATCH

September 15, 2022 – Steve Deace Show: A New Plan to Circumvent the Modern Medical Establishment | Guest: Dr. Harvey Risch – WATCH

• Dr Risch shares the new effort he and other high-profile doctors are putting together to help individuals circumvent the modern medical establishment and free doctors to do what they believe will help their patients

September 13, 2022 – Ask Dr. Drew: Major Suppression” Of Adverse Events By CDC: Dr. Harvey Risch & Dr. Kelly Victory – FULL, WATCH, Chief Nerd – re vaccine safety and recent Israeli adverse event study and leaked video – EXCERPT
[if you need historical CONTEXT]

“Not only have we seen major suppression of information about adverse events by FDA, CDC, governments in general, but this isn’t new.…

There are all these games, that get played, to hide the adverse events of these vaccines, it’s not just in covid, it’s pre-dated that...

This kind of malfeasance seems to be traditional for vaccines and makes you wonder why the government is doing this, all governments not just ours, are suppressing information about vaccine adverse events and what the implications are of that.”

Dr Risch

September 11, 2022 – Viva Frei Live!: Interview with Dr Harvey Risch – WATCH

August 22, 2022 – Bannons War Room: Dr. Harvey Risch: Dr. Fauci is Dodging Responsibility after ‘Draconian Lockdowns’ Destroyed America – WATCH

August 20, 2020: Dr Risch Retiring – Laura Ingraham stated Dr Harvey Risch is retiring from Yale this weekend – August 20, 2022 – WATCH

August 18, 2022 – Bannons War Rooom: Dr. Harvey Risch Discusses Trivial Self-Report Released By CDC Riddled With Errors In Logic – WATCH

August 18, 2022 – Brownstone Institute: CDC’s Ludicrous Makeover – READ

July 16, 2022 – American Thought Leaders: Negative Vaccine Efficacy – Dr. Harvey Risch: Why Are Vaccinated People Getting COVID at Higher Rates Than the Unvaccinated? –TEASER, WATCH

July 7, 2022 – Dr. Naomi Wolf’s “The Bodies of Others” book event in Brooklyn, New York, Dr. Paul Elias Alexander introduces Dr. Harvey Risch – WATCH

July 2, 2022 – Brownstone Institute: In Memory of Dr. Vladimir Zev Zelenko by Harvey Risch – READ

June 16, 2022 – Just The News: Dr. Harvey Risch: Monkeypox is NOT something that general public life is at risk for at all – WATCH

June 1, 2022 – Bannons War Room: pisode 1,897 – Dr. Risch Explains The Crisis Of our Time; Pandemics, Big Tech, And Your Life – FULL, Pandemic Deep-Dive w/ Harvey Risch, MD, PhD – WATCH

May 27, 2022 – Fox News: Laura Ingraham: Dr. Peter McCullough and Dr. Harvey Risch discuss monkeypox, Dr Risch saying it’s a “nothing burger” and the only risk is in those heavily vaccinated – EXCERPT, overlayed with Dr Peter Hotez – EXCERPT

May 16, 2022 – They’re still coming after your kids: Dr. Harvey Risch speaks against covid vaccines in children – WATCH, SOURCE

April 19, 2021 – Bannons War Room: It’s apparent Dr. Fauci has another agenda other than public health, Dr. Risch says – WATCH

March 25, 2022 – The Canadian Political Powershift: C.P.U. PowerShift Lawyer, Daniel Freiheit with Our Lead Medical Expert, Dr. Harvey Risch and Nicole – WATCH

March 7, 2022 – Ron DeSantis: Dr. Harvey Risch: Closing the Curtain on COVID Theater – “It’s interesting that there’s been a lot of misdirection from what we’ve seen,” – WATCH

February 2, 2022 – Connecticut State Representative Kimberly Fiorello in discussion with a leading expert in the field of epidemiology Dr. Harvey A. Risch – WATCH

January 24, 2022 – Senatory Ron Johnsons COVID-19: A Second Opinion – round table – Harvey Risch – WATCH, All speakers – WATCH

January 23, 2022 – Brownstone Institute: The Emergency Must Be Ended, Now by Risch, Bhattacharya and Alexander – READ

2021

December 29, 2021 – Bannons War Room: Episode 1,520 – Dr. Harvey Risch: The Coming Of Herd Immunity; The Defense Of Judeo-Christian Ethos – WATCH

November 30, 2021 – Epoch Times | American Thought Leaders with Jan Jekielek: COVID Taboos – Dr. Harvey Risch: Hydroxychloroquine, Ivermectin, and Other Therapeutics Highly Effective in Early COVID Treatment – TEASER, WATCH, Why doctors are frightened – TEASER

November 30, 2021 – Brownstone Institute: Covid-19 Vaccine Mandates Fail the Jacobson Test – READ

October 25, 2021 – Fox News: Dr. Harvey Risch says he would rather home school his kids than vaccinate them – EXCERPT

October 13, 2021 – The Pulse of Israel: Vaccine Mandates and Much Much More with Yale Epidemiologist Dr. Harvey Risch – WATCH

October 6, 2021 – Why Are the “Experts” Denying Natural Immunity – Peter McCullough, MD, MPH and Harvey Risch, MD, PhD speak with Laura Ingraham about the importance of post-COVID-infection immunity in ending the pandemic. – WATCH

September 9, 2021 – Media Matters for America: Fox guest says “natural immunity,” not vaccination, is “the only way we will get out of this whole COVID pandemic” – Dr. Harvey Risch: “The vaccinated people create the variants” – WATCH & READ

October 25, 2021 – Mark Levin: Yale Epidemiology Professor Dr. Harvey Risch says he would pull a healthy child out of public school and homeschool before he gave them this vaccine. – WATCH, ARTICLE, Uncover DC – READ

August 24, 2021: Doctor Talks Panel 3 of 3: Top Canadian Doctors Talking Vaccines – Dr Byram Bridle, Dr Bonnie Mallard, and Dr Harvey Risch to provide an update on the controversial subject of “ Co\/id Inoculations” in Canada – WATCH

August 12, 2021 – Daily Clout: Dr Naomi Wolf talks with Dr Harvey Risch, Dr Howard Tenenbaum and Dr Paul Alexander about the COVID-19 pandemic – WATCH

July 26, 2021 – Fox News | The Ingraham Angle: Vaccine Hesitancy, Early Treatment, and Natural Immunity – Dr. Harvey Risch talks about natural immunity, including the role of B and T cells – WATCH, BACKUP

July 5, 2021 – The Federalist: How College COVID Vaccine Mandates Put Students In Danger co-authored by Aaron Kheriaty, along with Risch, McCullough et al – ARCHIVE

June 24, 2021 – The Donlon Report: Dr. Joseph Ladapo and Dr. Harvey Risch join the Donlon Report to talk about lack of discussion of risks associated with COVID-19 vaccines – @35:17 WATCH

June 24, 2021 – IHU Mediterrannee in Marseille” Dr. Harvey Risch, MD, PhD, Professor of Epidemiology Yale University speaks about hydroxychloroquine – WATCH

June 17, 2021 – Early Covid Care: Hydroxychloroquine in Early Treatment of High-Risk COVID-19 Outpatients: Efficacy and Safety Evidence by Harvey Risch – PDF, CREDIT

• “Every one of the now 10 studies of high-risk outpatient hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) use has shown risk reduction for hospitalization or mortality. Meta-analysis demonstrates 44% reduction in hospitalization, and 75% reduction in mortality.”

June 16, 2021 – Dr. Harvey Risch talks with author John Leake about how hydroxychloroquine was fraudulently misrepresented and suppressed – WATCH

May 13, 2021: Doctor Talks Part 4: Dr Harvey Risch Talks Lockdowns, Immunity & Herd Immunity – WATCH

April 24, 2021 – Covid Call to Humanity: Yale dean upholds academic freedom despite widespread criticism against Dr. Harvey Risch – READ

April 19, 2021 – Bannons War Room: Dr. Harvey Risch: 60% of New Covid Patients Have Been Vaccinated – WATCH, Life Site News – READ, Gateway Pundit – READ

February 3, 2021 – Fox News | The Ingraham Angle: The medical establishment’s war on COVID therapeutics – WATCH

2020

Dec 14, 2020 – Fox News | The Ingraham Angle: Harvey Risch and Ramin Oskoui: Mainstream Medicine’s COVID Quackery Killed 300,000 in the U.S.- U.S. mainstream medicine’s COVID “therapeutic nihilism:” stay inside your home and don’t leave unless you can’t breath. Oskoui responds to Friedman. – WATCH

November 2, 2020 – American Journal of Epidemiology: Early Outpatient Treatment of Symptomatic, High-Risk COVID-19 Patients That Should Be Ramped Up Immediately as Key to the Pandemic Crisis – Harvey A Risch – READ

October 20, 2020 – Fox News | The Ingraham Angle: Dr. Harvey Risch and Dr. Ramin Oskoui (cardiologist) – Lower Death Rates, Weakening Virus (Attenuation), Fear Mongering, and Suppressed Proven and Safe Cheap Therapies – WATCH, BACKUP

October 19, 2020 – Washington Examiner | Opinion: FDA obstruction: Patients die, while Trump gets the blame by Harvey Risch – READ

• “In reality, these charges [blaming Trump] are driven by craven politics and Big Pharma conflicts of interest. They divert attention from the FDA’s despicable efforts to block access to effective and inexpensive generic medications. Foremost among these is hydroxychloroquine.”
• “Dr. Risch estimates that over 100,000 American deaths might have been prevented with widespread access to hydroxychloroquine.” – REF

August 24, 2020 – The New American: Yale Epidemiologist Harvey Risch: Lives Lost Due to Fauci/FDA Opposition to LIfe-saving Treatments – READ, Palmer Foundation – READ, World Tribune – READ

August 23, 2020 – Fox News: Yale Epidemiologist: Dr. Fauci & FDA Have Caused the ‘Deaths of Hundreds of Thousands of Americans’ – Mark Levin Interviews Dr. Harvey A Risch about HCQ, FDA, and Dr. Fauci – WATCH, ARCHIVE, BACKUP, YouTube deleted the video

There’s been a massive disinformation campaign, that stretches from the government to the media that’s either suppressing this message or its countering it with a false message…I am an expert in the science and I can tell you the science is all one-sided, in fact, the science is so one-sided in supporting this result that its stronger than anything else I’ve ever studied in my entire career. The evidence in favour of hydroxychloroquine benefit, in high-risk patients, treated early as outpatients is stronger than anything else I’ve ever studies. So scientifically there’s no question what so ever”

Dr Risch

• Dr. Fauci and FDA Have Caused the ‘Deaths of Hundreds of Thousands of Americans’ that Could Have been Saved by hydroxychloroquine

August 6, 2020 – Mediaite: Dr. Fauci Sides with CNN’s John Berman Over Pro-Hydroxychloroquine Yale Doc: Nearly Every ‘Competent’ Scientist Agrees [the smear campaign] – READ

“White House infectious disease honcho Dr. Anthony Fauci firmly rejected Yale epidemiologist Dr. Harvey Risch’s criticisms of randomized placebo-controlled studies of hydroxychloroquine…”

August 3, 2020 – Fox News: ‘Don’t speak for me’: Yale doctor battles CNN anchor over effectiveness of hydroxychloroquine – “you have to study the right people” – WATCH & READ

July 28, 2020 – Dennis Prager Interviews Epidemiologist, Dr. Harvey Risch (HCQ) on blocked therapeutics – LISTEN, BACKUP, ORIGINAL

July 23, 2020 – Newsweek: The Key to Defeating COVID-19 Already Exists. We Need to Start Using It | Opinion by Harvey A Risch – READ, Sen Johnson – TWEET

• “Physicians who have been using these medications in the face of widespread skepticism have been truly heroic. They have done what the science shows is best for their patients, often at great personal risk. I myself know of two doctors who have saved the lives of hundreds of patients with these medications, but are now fighting state medical boards to save their licenses and reputations. The cases against them are completely without scientific merit.”

July 23, 2020 – Fox News | The Ingraham Angle: CNN anchor accused of ‘ludicrous’ claim about hydroxychloroquine by Yale epidemiology professor – WATCH

July 20, 2020 – Fox News | Laura Ingraham: Dr. Harvey Risch on the war against hydroxychloroquine – “it’s a political drug now, not a medical drug…we’re fighting a propaganda war against the medical facts” – WATCH, OTHER, WATCH2, TRANSCRIPT

June 4, 2020 – Fox News | The Ingraham Angle: Controversial hydroxychloroquine research under scrutiny as experts raise ‘serious scientific questions’ – WATCH

May 27, 2020 (Peer reviewed November 2, 2020) – American Journal of Epidemiology 189 (11): 1218–26: “Early Outpatient Treatment of Symptomatic, High-Risk COVID-19 Patients That Should Be Ramped Up Immediately as Key to the Pandemic Crisis.” – Harvey A Risch – READ, ARTICLE

The post Dr Harvey Risch first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

Dr Richard Urso is a board certified Ophthalmologist who graduated top of his class and he has been practicing medicine since 1988. Former Chief of Orbital Oncology at UT MD Anderson Cancer Center. He is a drug design and treatment specialist and the former chief of orbital oncology at University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center. Sole inventor of FDA approved wound healing drug. Co-founder of Global COVID Summit.

Dr Urso is a member of America’s Frontline Doctors and in 2021 he co-founded the International Alliance of Physicians and Medical Scientists, who are the organisers of the Global COVID Summit events.

Social links: Twitter

It [the pandemic] was a lie from the very beginning. We had treatment from Day one!!!

Dr Richard Urso

GLOBAL COVID SUMMIT – HERE

Interviews in reverse chronological order

2023

January 25, 2023 – Ask Dr Drew wit Dr Kelly Victory: mRNA Is “Natural Born Killer” Says Drug Inventor Dr. Richard Urso – WATCH, READ

January 21-22, 2023: Pandemic Strategies: Lessons and Consequences – International Conference in Stockholm – 15 leading doctors, researchers and lawyers from the US, Canada, UK, Germany, France, Belgium, Switzerland, Israel, Ukraine and Norway, along with 7 Swedes. – Multiple presenations – WATCH

2022

November 26, 2022 [?] – Vaccine Safety Research Foundation: VSRF Thanksgiving Marathon- Reel 2: Kelly Victory, Ryan Cole & Richard Urso – WATCH, FULL

November 26, 2022 [?] – Vaccine Safety Research Foundation: VSRF Thanksgiving Marathon- Reel 3: Christina Parks, Richard Urso, Angela Wulbrecht, & Lisa Laehy (interview with Steve Kirsch) – WATCH

October 22, 2022 – Florida Summit of COVID – “The future of medicine in post-COVID America” – Discussion with Dr Richard Urso, Dr Pierre Kory, Dr Dan Stock Dr Paul Marik, Dr Lynn Finn – WATCH

August 8, 2022 – A Better Way | Health Conference Ireland: Public Health in a Post Pandemic World with Dr Richard Urso – WATCH

August 3, 2022 – Bright Light News: [INTERVIEW] How Did 5 GTA Docs Die in 2 Weeks? Dr Richard Urso Interview – READ, WATCH

July 21, 2022 – Real America’s Voice: Did Biden’s Multiple Jabs Make Him More Susceptible To COVID? Doctor Richard Urso explains – WATCH

July 14, 2022 – The Highwire Ep 276 – MALONE, URSO, KORY: “STOP VACCINATING” – WATCH, FULL

July 4, 2022 – Global COVID summit – Warning signs of re-emerging cancers in vaccinated patients – We’re seeing a tremendous uptick in cancers. I’m having recurrences in people who were 10 years clear – WATCH

June 6, 2022 – World Council for Health: COVID-19 Vaccine Injury: Dr. Urso, Dr. Kory, Dr. Marik and James Wells – WATCH, Playing Russian Roulette – EXCERPT

Aggressive Cancers Resurfacing After a Decade: “This Is Almost Unheard of” – Dr. Richard Urso – EXCERPT

‘Vaccine in the Brain. Period’: We Must Oppose Anything and Everything With the mRNA Platform – EXCERPT

“Right now, there’s no way to create any kind of delivery package that’s controllable, so anytime you hear lipid nanoparticle, messenger RNA anything, you know you’re gonna vaccine in the brain. Period.”

Dr Urso

May 19, 2022 – Dr Richard Urso and Dr Ryan Cole lead the way to Tennessee recognizing Natural Immunity – Testimony from the Tennessee House Health Subcommittee urging them to recognize natural immunity from COVID. – WATCH

May 13, 2022 – MALONE, COLE, URSO: A DOCTORS ROUNDTABLE – WATCH

May 11, 2022 – HIGHLIGHTS: GLOBAL COVID SUMMIT – WATCH, Full – WATCH

The Global Covid Summit, comprising over 17,000 physicians and scientists, holds a press conference highlighting the Summit’s declaration to “Restore Scientific Integrity.”

May 9, 2022 – The Dr. Hotze Report – Dr. Richard Urso Recap – WATCH, EXCERPT

April 21, 2022 – American Thought Leaders – Dr Richard Urso – Big Pharma Makes Billions Rebranding Existing Drugs As New Products – (free sign up to watch) PART 2

April 21, 2022 – American Thought Leaders – Dr Richard Urso – Alarming Post-Booster Trends and the Censorship of Treatments for COVID-19 – (free sign up to watch) PART 1

April 10, 2022 – Dr. Richard Urso speaks in front of thousands of attendees at the ‘Defeat The Mandates’ Rally held at Grand Park in Los Angeles, CA – WATCH

January 28, 2022 – The New American with Dr. Richard Urso: COVID Vax Mandates Are A Scientific Fraud – WATCH

January 27, 2022 – The Highwire Episode 252: Chat with Dr Richard Urso “OVER 500,000 COVID DEATHS COULD HAVE BEEN PREVENTED” – WATCH, FULL

January 24, 2022 – Senator Ron Johnson’s Second Opinion roundtable discussion – Dr Urso – WATCH, FULL

2021

September 24, 2021 – Global Covid Summit: San Juan Summit: 8 Prominent Doctors and Scientists Engage in a Remarkable Exchange – WATCH & READ hosted by media startup Roundtable!

• forum about effective early treatment and evaluate the current one-size-fits-all approach to Covid treatment
• Digital Media and Bitcoin Pioneers Launch Roundtable – June 16, 2021 by Brock Pierce (et al?) – READ, REF

August 25, 2021 – Covexit: Dr. Richard Urso Comments on the Delta Variant and the Need to Constantly Adapt Protocols – WATCH

July 27, 2021 – Americas Frontline Doctors White Coat Summit – Presentation by Dr Urso – “What if I already had COVID?” – WATCH

May 23, 2021 – Covexit w/ Jean-Pierre K: The Dr Urso Interview – WATCH

January 31, 2021 – Dr Urso on ineffectiveness of masks – TWEET

2020

December 2, 2020 – America’s Frontline Doctors Whitecoat Summit II – Dr. Richard Urso Testing and Transmission Inaccuracies and evidence of Hydroxychloroquine efficacy. – WATCH

October 18, 2020 – America’s Frontline Doctors – Speech at the Capitol “we had treatment from day one” – WATCH

October 13, 2020 – Dr Urso @richardursomd – “Here’s a list of all the wonderful effects of long term use of HCQ – TWEET

The post Dr Richard Urso first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

Dr Gold led the first Frontline Doctors‘ White Coat Summit on Capitol Hill in Washington D.C. July 27, 2020. These American Physicians who are treating COVID-19 patients were speaking out about masks, opening up schools and a life-saving early treatment for the disease based on their first hand experience and the scientific literature.

Dr Gold was told that the AFLD press conference video was “the most viral video of all time”, which within 24 hours following this summit YouTube removed their videos and their website host Square removed their website, vimeo removed their video also. This is an example of the coordinated censorship of doctors that has cost lives.

Dr. Simone Gold was then fired from the hospital where she worked as an Emergency Physician because she appeared in “an embarrassing video” according to her employer- Tucker Carlson REPORT

Dr Gold continues to Fight for Freedom, Informed Consent and Human Rights and Fight Against Medical Discrimination.

The censored Press Conference that started her journey of censorship (July 27, 2020) – WATCH

Below are a few key links to Dr Simone Gold’s videos to highlight her story.

Official AFLD videos HERE, Summit videos – HERE,
Dr Gold on Rumble – HERE,
Twitter – HERE
Gettr – HERE

Videos in reverse chronological order

2024

June 28, 2024 – AFLDS: Dr Gold comments on SCOTUS Historic Fischer v. USA Ruling – WATCH, Dr Malone – CREDIT

2023

July 27, 2023 – America’s Frontline Doctors: White Coat Summit 2023: The Reckoning Part 1 – WATCH, Introduction: WATCH, Official website – HERE, Presentations – HERE

July 27, 2023 – America’s Frontline Doctors : White Coat Summit 2023 – The Reckoning – SCOTUS Press Conference – 3 year anniversary – WATCH,

• AFLD Press Release: Third Annual White Coat Summit: The Reckoning demands accountability for crimes against humanity – READ

July 24, 2023 – Bannons War Room: Dr. Gold: White Coat Summit Seeks To Shine Light On The Abuse Of Lockdowns And Experimental Vaccines – WATCH. 3 Year anniversary of white coat summit, time for accountability.

March 27, 2023 – AFLD Press Release: Feds for Medical Freedom v. Biden – Federal employees score a huge legal victory against Biden’s mandatory mRNA injections – READ, Dr Simone on OANN – WATCH [Promoting GoldCare.com]

March 31, 2023 – AFLD Press Release: Corrupt Lawyer Joey Gilbert Resigns in Disgrace from AFLDS Board to Avoid Further Legal Scrutiny – READ

February 3, 2023 – Reinette Senum Subatack: Kevin Jenkins Joins Reinette Senum, Taking on AFLDS Founder Dr. Simone Gold’s Conflation of Facts vs. Fiction – Abuse of donor money, obfuscating the truth, and twisting the record comes to the surface through the Arizona judge’s official findings of the recent America’s Frontline Doctors AZ court case. – READ & WATCH, TWEET [make up your own mind!]

January 30, 2023 – AFLD Press Release: Judge Exposes Deceptive and Retaliatory Acts by Rogue Board Members Gilbert and Mack – READ, Frontline Flash- TWEET

• “…sentiment from the Court further demonstrates the dishonesty of Gilbert and the defamation promoted on his behalf by sensationalist Stew Peters and suspicious actor Kevin Jenkins, responding to the Court’s statement by falsely claiming “Dr. Gold is fired from AFLDS”,…”

2022

December 28, 2022 – Just The News: Twitter files reveal US government censored COVID-19 data – Dr Simone Gold comments – WATCH, Twitter Files – HERE

“I had a sterling reputation right up until the government decided to hate me”

Dr Simone Gold

November 8, 2022 – Tucker Carlson Today interview with Dr Simone Gold – WATCH, EXCERPT

September 9, 2022 – Dr. Simone Gold has been released and has a message for you! “I’m Back” – TWEET, TWEET
Rep. Louie Gohmert greeted Dr. Gold as she embraced being free outside the prison and gifted the Frontline Doctor with an American flag that was flown over the U.S. Capitol. – TWEET

September 8, 2022 – Dr. Simone Gold Being Released Early From 60-Day Jail Sentence for Trespassing at Capitol on Jan. 6 – READ, READ, Epoch Times – READ, TWEET , “I’m Back” – WATCH
Medpage Today: “Disinformation physician complained of 8 days of solitary confinement for refusing COVID vaccine” – READ

July 26, 2022 – Face the Facts with April Moss: America’s Frontline Doctor Founder Dr. Simone Gold recounts her ridiculous court case, and plans for after serving her 60 day jail sentence – WATCH, BACKUP

July 2, 2022 – Dinesh D’Souza: Dr. Simone Gold Shares Her Unjust Sentence for Being Present on Jan. 6 – WATCH

June 16, 2022 – Dr Simone Gold who plead guilty to entering a restricted building on Jan 6, was sentenced today to 60 days prison and 1 year “probation”. Dr Gold was caught up in the momentum of the day, her planned speech was cancelled so she delivered it in the Capitol, she didn’t witness any violence. – WATCH, ARTICLE

April 11, 2022 – Laura-Lynn Tyler Thompson: Dr. Simone Gold: “Medical Tyranny Was The Mechanism to Usher in Tyranny” – WATCH

March 8, 2022 – Daystar TV: Dr. Simone Gold | Dr. Peter McCullough | Dr. Richard Bartlett – WATCH, ORIGINAL (estimated to have reached 1.7 billion views)

March 4, 2022 – Dr. Gold Speaks at Clay Clark’s ReAwaken Tour: Ohio – WATCH

2021

November 20, 2021 – We The Patriots USA: Vaccine Safety Awareness Marathon – 2021 – Part 14 – Simone Gold – WATCH

September 29, 2021 – Dr Ardis interviews Dr Gold – WATCH

September 24, 2021 – Patrick Byrne: Breaking: TOP Medical official in US ARMY provides affidavit re Covid-19 vaccines – WATCH

September 1, 2021 – Frontline Films presents: The Cost of Courage – Dr Gold – WATCH

August 9, 2021 – Dinesh D’Souza interview Dr Gold – WATCH

June 19, 2021 – German Corona Investigative Committee: Session 54 with Dr Simone Gold – WATCH, YouTube

June 3, 2021 – Defending the Republic use Dr Gold’s testimony: Nuremberg Code and experimenting of people without informed consent – WATCH

May 17, 2021 – Dr. Simone Gold: The Origins of COVID-19 (Words on Paper!) – WATCH

May 6, 2021 – The Uncensored Truth – The FBI arrested Dr Gold! – WATCH

April 29, 2021 – Church and State: With Dr. Simone Gold! Get the Truth on Covid, Vaccine injury numbers, & Israeli action – WATCH

April 21, 2021 – NTD: Dr. Simone Gold discusses the expression ‘follow the science’, as the science is unequivocal—that early treatment works, lockdowns don’t work, masks don’t work – WATCH

February 11, 2021 – Michelle Malkin interview: Stop Medical Discrimination – WATCH

January 29, 2021 – Dr Simone Gold – Censorship of HCQ cost lives – TWEET, ARCHIVE

January 26, 2021 – Dr. Simone Gold, “The Covid-19 Vaccine, Explained” – WATCH

January 3, 2021 – Day 205 of the Stand20: Dr Simone Gold – What you need to know about the current vaccines – WATCH, BACKUP, ORIGINAL, VIMEO

2020

December 17, 2020 – Dr Gold via Twitter: “America’s Frontline Doctors met at the CDC to make our message clear. Experimental vaccines should NEVER be mandated or forced by businesses or govt. This choice should always remain between a doctor and a patient.” – WATCH

December 17, 2020 – The Highwire: The Frontline fight against medical discrimination – WATCH

December 14, 2020 – Dr Gold: BREAKING: America’s Frontline Doctors are at the CDC in Atlanta to protest against forcing millions of Americans to take an experimental vaccine for Covid-19, a pathogen with a survival rate of 99.7% – TWEET

October 22, 2020 – The Highwire: The Frontline Doctor who went viral – WATCH, BACKUP,

August 2020 – Sebastian Gorka: HCQ, ‘Why Is This Generic Drug Controversial’?… Plus Masks, Civil Liberties – WATCH

August 1, 2020 – KUSI News: Dr Simone Gold Discusses Benefits Of HCQ After You Tube Censors Briefing – ARCHIVE

July 30, 2020 – Tucker Carlson : Doctor Simone Gold Fired from Hospital After Attending ‘White Coat Summit’ — Hires Atty Lin Wood – WATCH, BACKUP 1, BACKUP 2

July 28, 2020 – Technology Review: How covid-19 conspiracy videos keep getting millions of views – [for an alternate perspective!] – READ

July 28, 2020 – Huff Post: How Quack Doctors And Powerful GOP Operatives Spread Misinformation To Millions -[for an alternate perspective!] – READ

July 28, 2020 – Breitbart News: Dr. Simone Gold: Squarespace Shuts Down America’s Frontline Doctors Website – READ

July 28, 2020 – Breitbart News: Google Censors Breitbart YouTube Video of Doctors’ Capitol Hill Coronavirus Press Conference – WATCH Facebook spokesman we removed if as they were “sharing false information about cures and treatments for COVID-19” – TWEET

July 28, 2020 – Breitbart News: Watch Live: Silenced Frontline Doctors Hold Capitol Hill Press Conference to Challenge Big Tech – READ

July 28, 2020 – Breitbart: Watch Live: Silenced Frontline Doctors Hold Capitol Hill Press Conference to Challenge Big Tech – READ

July 27, 2020 – Breitbart: Facebook, Google/YouTube, Twitter Censor Viral Video of Doctors’ Capitol Hill Coronavirus Press Conference – READ

July 27, 2020 – America’s Frontline Doctors Summit- Session 2 – ARCHIVE, YouTube

The inaugural White Coat Summit is to empower Americans to stop living in fear – ARCHIVE

July 27, 2020 – Dr Simone speaks to citizen journalist at the first summit – regarding HCQ – WATCH

July 27, 2020 – America’s Frontline Doctors press conference that started her journey of censorship – WATCH, BACKUP, OTHER

“LIVE from the steps of the US Supreme Court. America’s Frontline Doctors – Physicians from around the country address the American people about Covid-19 and the importance of reopening schools and our society.” – YouTube

July 21, 2020 – Fleccas Talks: COVID numbers explained: ER doctor talks “cases” and calls for schools to be open ASAP – WATCH, ARCHIVE

July 21, 2020: Fleccas Talks: “It would change everything” – ER doctor calls for HCQ to be over the counter – WATCH, ARCHIVE

“Dr. Gold calls for the over the counter use of Hydroxychloroquine. She discusses how the drug is safe, how the drug is OTC in countries around the world, and she explains how making it OTC could change the entire course of the pandemic.”

June 2, 2020 – The Tea Party Second Opinion Project – WATCH

The post Dr Simone Gold first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

Dr Zelenko has been speaking out load and strong since March 21, 2020 when he made a video and sent a letter to President Trump informing him of his successful early treatment regime. [Archives]

The collection of videos below follows Dr Zelenko’s journey as he watched HCQ become vilified by the American media, health and regulatory agencies, how toxic doses were used in clinical trials on hospitalised patients to “prove” that it was toxic, and how HCQ was removed from his tool kit to treat patients so he found another solution. (HCQ Trial tracker)

I suspect one day his incredible story will be made into a movie.

Zelenko Freedom Foundation – HERE
Statement from Zelenko Labs – HERE
Gettr – HERE
Telegram – HERE
Truth Social – HERE
Gab – HERE
Twitter – HERE

Dr Vladimir Zelenko passed away June 30, 2022
My condolences to his family. He will be missed.
His memory and brave example will live on in the collection of his videos captured below.

How Dr Zelenko saved countless lives

Dr Zelenko video interviews in reverse chronological order

The Zelenko Report with Ann Vandersteel – find interviews on Rumble channel – HERE

2024

June 30, 2024 – Via @DschlopesIsBack: Tribute to Dr Zelenko 2 years after his passing – from an interview done by Mikki Willis – WATCH

2022

September 8 , 2022 – Bannons War Room: Dr. Robert Malone On Hydroxychloroquine Effectiveness When Used Early On – Acknowledgement of Dr Zelenko’s 2020 work – WATCH

July 16, 2022 – X22 Report: Kevin Jenkins – The Medical Industry Is Panicking, The Medical Industry The Way We Know It Is Over – Z-Freedom Foundation – WATCH

July 8, 2022 – Ann Vandersteel speaks to Steve Bannon re Zelenko Freedom Foundation, Dr. Zelenko’s Legacy Moving Forward – WATCH

July 1, 2022 – Dr Zelenko’s memory lives on:

“Dr. Ze’ev Zelenko saved my dad’s life in 2020, along with thousands of others. While battling cancer with only one lung, he offered my dad a robust at-home treatment with life-saving hydroxychloroquine free of charge along with regular appointments and check-ins, along with his only oxygen machine when stores had completely run out.” – GETTR

July 1, 2022 – Defending the Republic documentary tribute to Dr Zelenko – Released EXCERPT

July 1, 2022 – Epoch Times: Dr. Vladimir Zelenko, Early COVID Therapeutics Innovator, Dies at 48 – READ

July 1, 2022 – Twitter just banned the account for the Zelenko Freedom Foundation…without just cause…”this has to be the most vile, cold-hearted and spiteful example of their biased censorship to date” – READ, OTHER

June 30, 2022 – Dr Malone’s tribute to Dr Z (he was attacked mercilessly for the life-saving Zelenko protocol. He exposed Rick Bright ( BARDA) and Janet Woodcock (FDA) for removing access to HCQ, he was the first to challenge the administrative state. ) – WATCH

June 30, 2022 – Human Events: Dr. Vladimir Zelenko (1973-2022), Rest In Peace – Obituary – READ

June 30, 2022 – Dr. Vladimir ‘Zev’ Zelenko passes away – Rest in Peace Dr Zelenko – READ , OTHER, WATCH

• “Dr. Vladimir “Zev” Zelenko, the man who discovered and implemented the treatment for Covid-19 that over the past two years has been responsible for saving millions of lives worldwide, has passed away after a long battle with cancer.  He was 48.”
• “Up to the time of his death, Zev had overseen the treatment of approximately 7,500 patients using his protocol and experienced only three patient deaths.  The use of the Zelenko protocol has spread worldwide.”
• “Despite numerous studies over the past two years that have supported the effectiveness of his protocol, access to the treatment remains denied to significant portions of the population and is simply ignored by many physicians.”
• “Undeterred, Zev went in search of another method to treat patients that could circumvent government restrictions.  HE discovered that the natural supplement Quercetin could serve the same function as did HCQ in assisting zinc to attack the still developing virus inside the cell.  It was not as effective, but as Zev was fond of saying, “You don’t go to war with the army you wish you had.  You go to war with the army you’ve got.”  He discovery of Quercetin, which he likened to being a .22 caliber compared to HCQ’s .50 caliber ultimately led to the development of his Z-Stack supplement.”

Memoriam can be given in Zev’s name to the Zelenko Freedom Foundation at www.zfreedomfoundation.com
Co-chair of foundation Ann Vandersteel – GETTR

Obituary – READ

June 30, 2022 – It’s “touch and go” for Dr Z’s life – Global prayers are needed now – GETTR, 2, Telegram updates by Daniel – HERE

June 28, 2022 – Dr Zelenko went into ICU to treat the tumor – Updates from Anne Vandersteel – GETTR, 2, 3
Daniel has access to Dr Zelenko’s account to share updates – PROOF

June 16, 2022 – Stew Peters: A Hero’s Legacy: Dr. Zelenko Faces Death, Launches Zelenko Freedom Foundation To Save Lives – WATCH, the Zelenko Freedom Foundation with Anne Vandersteel – GETTR

“I started the Zelenko Freedom Foundation, because I’m dying..it seems“

Dr Zelenko

June 14, 2022 – Dr. Zelenko really needs prayer and healing right now. The most recent update on his health today looks very bad but he has always been a fighter and a warrior! Please keep this truly wonderful man in your thoughts and prayers. – GETTR

June 3, 2022 – IMPORTANT Message From Famous Covid Doctor | Dr. Zev Zelenko “my cancer has progressed” – WATCH – [May 26, 2022 – The 5 Docs mention Dr Z – WATCH]

May 3, 2022 – Dr Zelenko Special message recorded before his passing – WATCH

April 19, 2022 – Message from Dr Z: A Roadblock to Dehumanization: Dr. Zelenko Weighs in on the Federal Mask Mandate Ruling – WATCH

April 10, 2022 – Massage from frontline doctors to Dr Zelenko for healing – GETTR

April 1, 2022 – Dr Z provides an update on his health situation – READ

March 25, 2022 – Ask Dr Drew: Dr. Vladimir Zelenko 2022 Update: “We Could Have Ended COVID Long Ago” – WATCH, LISTEN

March 25, 2022 – Dr Bryan Ardis Show: Full Interview! Dr. Zelenko has a warning about Big Pharma’s threat to doctors speaking the TRUTH! (Patents, HCQ, Remdesivir, Ralph Baric) – WATCH, EXCERPT, READ

• Evidence COVID “Weapon of Mass Murder” Came From Illegal Virus Research – EXCERPT

March 31, 2022 – LETTER – “failure to treat” with early treatments will now be considered “wanton disregard” – READ

March 9, 2022 – Mark Crispin Miller and Dr. Zelenko talk about the psychopaths who brought us the “vaccines,” and then “Ukraine” – READ,

• R&B Weekly Seminar: R&B Medical Fellowship (Jerusalem War Crimes Trials/Episode #25 — Tuesday, March 8th, 2022). Fellowship Chairman and Host: Dr. Vladimir Zelenko. Guest Speaker: Professor Mark Crispin Miller – WATCH

February 23, 2022 – Mel K speaks with Dr Z – Saving Humanity & Health Sovereignty – WATCH

February 14, 2022 – The JD Rucker Show: Dr. Vladimir Zelenko Deciphers the Transhumanist Goals of Schwab and Gates -“Around halfway into the interview, I asked Dr. Zelenko to describe the endgame.” – WATCH

February 11, 2022 – Interview with Patriot Streetfighter – WATCH

February 8, 2022 – WND – “We could have ended this pandemic long ago” – WATCH

January 22, 2022 – The Dr Ardis Show: Dr Z reveals the truth about COVID-19 variants – WATCH

January 8, 2022 – X22 Report: Dr Zelenko – Big Pharma hid the cures from the people – WATCH

2021

December 28, 2021 – Z-Stack Protocol: Dr Zelenko: The Gun & The Bullet, Breaking Down The Protocol And Immune Support – WATCH

December 27, 2021 – NerveCenter hosts Ron Watkins with Dr Z: How to Thwart Totalitarian Tyranny – LISTEN

December 24, 2021 – Dr Zelenko speaks with a panel of Australian doctors and politicians – WATCH

December 1, 2021 – Mel K speaks with Dr Z – The truth about COVID and solutions for health – WATCH

November 24, 2021 – AFLD Frontline News: Zelenko Protocol discoverer calls COVID-19 ‘bioweapon’, vaccine ‘poison’ – READ

November 24, 2021 – Frontline News – Dr Zelenko in letter to editor answers attack on COVID shot cautiousness – READ

November 24, 2021 – AFLD Frontline News: Dr. Vladimir Zelenko nominated for Nobel Peace Prize – READ

November 21, 2021 – The Gateway Pundit asks questions of Dr Zelenko – WATCH

November 8, 2021 – SGT Report: Zelenko: ‘Devout pagans, Satanists, and traitors’ – WATCH

October 29, 2021 – German Corona Investigation Committee – Session 62 with Dr Zelenko – WATCH

October 1, 2021 – Tracy Beanz from UncoverDC interviews Dr Z – LISTEN

September 21, 2021 – Dr Z receives daily death threats for speaking out – WATCH

September 7, 2021 – The Highwire: Dr Zelenko’s warning for Israel – WATCH

September 2, 2021 – Interview with Australia’s Craig Kelly – WATCH

September 2, 2021 – Zelenko discusses with Stew Peters the COVID Genocide “Very Nefarious, Sinister Purpose” – WATCH

September 2, 2021 – Dr Zelenko exposes how Dr Rick Bright’s (BARDA) Very Bad move sabotaged early Covid treatment killing masses – WATCH

August 14, 2021 – With Stew Peters, Dr Zelenko exposes “Global Genocidal Event” – WATCH

August 5, 2021 – Dr. Zelenko speaks to a Rabbinical court in Jerusalem – WATCH, READ

July 19, 2021 – Voice of Emet: (Third) Interview with Dr. Zelenko with the Latest about Covid-19 and the Shot – WATCH, READ, CHANNEL

July 15, 2021 – Back with Dr Mercola – WATCH

July 7, 2021 – Dr. Vladimir Zelenko talks with author John Leake about treating his patients for Covid-19 – WATCH, BACKUP

July 2021 – Interview with Dr. Mercola – Our Current Situation and Treatments for “The Jabbed” – WATCH

June 3, 2021 – Interview with Jenna Ellis: “What is called ‘gain-of-function’ is a very deliberate term to mislead the public” – WATCH

June 2, 2021 – Message from Dr Zelenko: Global Divine Great Reset – WATCH

May 13, 2021 – Freedom, Great Reset and Democracy. Interview with Rabbi Avi Schwartz – WATCH

May 10, 2021 – Zelenko talks about his protocol that saved members of his New York community – WATCH

May 5, 2021 – One America News – Dr Zelenko shares patient’s “Vaccine Regret” – WATCH

May 3, 2021 – Jean-Pierre Kickens from COVEXIT 2nd interview with Dr Zelenko – WATCH

April 23, 2021 – Dr Peter Breggin interviews Dr Zelenko – WATCH

March 4, 2021 – Interview with Dr Breggin discussing the Zelenko treatment protocol – WATCH

February 1, 2021 – Dr Z shares his medical opinion about the vaccines – WATCH

January 28, 2021 – Dr Breggin interviews Dr Zelenko again – WATCH

January 6, 2021 – Interview on The Highwire – WATCH @9:30

January 5, 2021 – New Book of Daniel #52: Some don’t want us to know about safe pre-hospital treatments for Covid – WATCH

January 4, 2021 – UncoverDC: Some don’t want us to know about safe pre-hospital treatments for Covid – featuring Ep 52 The new book of Daniel podcast interview with Dr Zelenko – READ & WATCH

2020

December 27, 2020 – Red Dawn News interview with Dr. Zelenko – PART 1, PART 2

December 19, 2020 – Interview with John Mappin – WATCH

December 16, 2020 – The Highwire with Del Bigtree interviews Dr Zelenko re President’s treatment and his published data showing 84% reduction in hospitalisation for risk stratified patients – WATCH, BACKUP

December? 2020 – Wayne Allyn Root Show – PODCAST

November 23, 2020 – Zev Zelenko via Twitter – The Zelenko protocol “ZZ pandemic solution-END LOCKDOWNS, NO MASKS. Immediate economic reopening. Easily manage increased incidence COVID-19 with Zelenko Protocol Plus. END GOVERNMENT OBSTRUCTION of life saving medication and information. High risk patients must be prophylaxed and/or immediately tx: – TWEET, ARCHIVE

November 17, 2020 – Zelenko Early Treatment Study, the Role of Zinc, the Therapeutic Approach to COVID-19 in Germany – WATCH, BACKUP

October 30, 2020 – Dr. Zelenko’s talks about his research paper published on 26 October 2020 in The International Journal of Antimicrobial Agents – WATCH

October 6, 2020 – Dr Z has had Chemotherapy, and comments on censorship and on the treatment protocol used by POTUS – WATCH

September 29, 2020 – No one should be dying from COVID-19 – start treatment early – WATCH

September 11, 2020 – Comments on prophylaxis treatment and face marks. Pakistan village using Zelenko protocol – WATCH

September 4, 2020 – Dr Been Medical Lectures: Dr. Zelenko Discusses COVID-19 Outpatient Management with Dr Been – WATCH, FACEBOOK

September 3, 2020 – Dr. Zelenko interview by Simone Smith of the Toronto Carribean News – WATCH

August 26, 2020 – Global suppression of the Zelenko Protocol – WATCH

August 16, 2020 – Protocol incorporates Quercetin for low-risk patients – WATCH

August 12, 2020 – Zelenko comments on Henry Ford Health denied the use of HCQ – WATCH

August 10, 2020 – Zelenko protocol adds in ivermectin and anti-coagulants – WATCH

August 9, 2020 – Quercetin is introduced as HCQ replacement, Influenza and HCQ and petition – WATCH

August 6, 2020 – FDA EUA update and research on HCQ – WATCH

August 4, 2020 – Dr. Zelenko interviewed by Debbie Aldrich on the war against hydroxychloroquine – WATCH

July 30, 2020 – Dr Zelenko and Dr Richard Bartlett speak with Australian Jewish Association on COVID-19 early treatment – WATCH

July 21, 2020 – Dr Z about to go in for open heart surgery – WATCH

July 16, 2020 – Dr Z on The Highwire with Del Bigtree – HCQ deniers are “guilt of mass murder” – WATCH

July 15, 2020 – Dr Zelenko wrote another letter to President Trump regarding his treatment success – LINK, WATCH

July 10, 2020 – World leaders are aware of Dr Zelenko’s paper – WATCH

July 8, 2020 – Jean-Pierre Kickens from COVEXIT 1st interview with Dr Zelenko – WATCH

July 3, 2020 – Rabbi Aryeh Katzin Channel: Dr. Zelenko shares the good news that his first paper is now publicly available in Preprint- WATCH, LINK, PEER REVIEWED

July 2, 2020: Dose of Dr Drew: Dr. Vladimir Zelenko Treats Covid-19 With Hydroxychloroquine & Zinc – ARCHIVE, YouTube, READ

July 2, 2020 – Rudy Guillani sits down with Dr Zelenko to discuss his patients 99.3% survival rate from COVID-19 – WATCH

June 21, 2020 – Zelenko comments on revocation of HCQ EUA by FDA – WATCH

June 4, 2020 – CNN:”Hydroxychloroquine was indispensable in Guayaquil,” says former mayor – READ, “Dr Zelenko saved Ecuador” – TWEET

Translated: The former mayor of Guayaquil Jaime Nebot was in En Diálogo with Longobardi and spoke about how indispensable the use of hydroxychloroquine was in that Ecuadorian city. He also said that so far the results after the crisis have been very good.

June 9, 2020 – Dr Zelenko on the 2 rectacted HCQ papers (Lancet & NEJM) – ARCHIVE, WATCH

May 28, 2020 – The politics of censorship – WATCH

May 22, 2020- Israel National News: Dr. Zelenko promises: Use of hydroxychloroquine with Zinc ‘will end coronavirus plague’ – In interview with Arutz Sheva, Dr. Zelenko says treatment with hydroxychloroquine and Zinc within first 5 days reduces death rates by 85% – WATCH & READ

May 21, 2020 – Dr Vladimir Zalenko is closing his Kiryas Yoel office after 20 years – WATCH, Times of Israel – READ

May 19, 2020 – President Trump acknowledges in Press Conference receipt of Dr Zelenko’s letter – WATCH, ARCHIVE

May 17, 2020 – Reduce HCQ dose when used with zinc – PART 1, PART 2

May 12, 2020 – Zelenko: dealing with second wave – WATCH

May 3, 2020 – Protocol being used in Honduras, Brazil, Ukraine, Israel, Italy, Turkey, Iran – WATCH

May 1, 2020 – WoP: Justice Dept. scrutinizes White House-connected doctor linked to disputed coronavirus treatment – READ, NY Times – ARCHIVE

April 30, 2020 – Zelenko responds to Veteran Affairs (VA) study on HCQ – WATCH

April 24, 2020 – WoP: FDA warns about hydroxychloroquine dangers, citing serious heart issues, including death – ARCHIVE

April 19, 2020 – Zelenko provides a clinical update – WATCH

March 28, 2020 – Dr Zelenko’s first bombshell interview with Rudy Giuliani – WATCH

March 28, 2020 – Tech StartUps: Dr. Vladimir Zelenko has now treated 699 coronavirus patients with 100% success using Hydroxychloroquine Sulfate, Zinc and Z-Pak [UPDATES] – READ, The Highwire – CREDIT

March 25, 2020 – Tech StartUps: Doctor Vladimir Zelenko: I treated 350 coronavirus patients with 100% success using Hydroxychloroquine Sulfate – READ

March 23, 2020 – Dr Zelenko writes an open letter: “To all medical professionals around the world” & CC’d President Trump and Mark Medows – LINK, ARCHIVE

March 20, 2020 – Dr Zelenko’s sends a video message to President Trump – WATCH

The post Dr Vladimir Zelenko first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

Repurposing known, cheap, off-patent drugs, singularly or in combinations, has been much of their focus.  Drugs with already know side-effect and toxicity profiles.  Drugs that are cheap, because the are off-patent, and have no “commercial value”.  Drugs that when they tried them, have literally been life saving and prevented the need for tens of thousands of hospitalisations, which was the whole purpose of the March 2020 global lockdowns – flatten the curve!

Health authorities designed clinical trials to assess the “potential” of therapeutics in hospitalised patients only, they used doses that exceeded known toxic levels, and they didn’t do combination drug therapies! At least this is true for HCQ in the first 9 months of the pandemic.

Later in the pandemic, they carried out a few outpatient treatment trials again not in combination, just single drugs.  Though the Oxford randomised budesonide study they had to cut short, because the treatment was so successful, they couldn’t ethically keep it from the control group. The same is true for ivermectin.

Early treatments have been largely ignored, why?

Early treatment options have seemingly been ignored by the “health authorities”, and poorly challenged by the main stream media.  There has been a strong push from the start of the pandemic that a vaccine will be the only solution!

The information about early treatment options is available, you just need to know where to look as it has been suppressed by Big Tech and the media.   Unknown “fact checkers” deemed it dis-information.  Judge for yourself.  Take the time to investigate yourself.

December 17, 2020 – Leon Klein: AFFORDABLE AND EFFECTIVE EARLY TREATMENTS – A summary overview – WATCH

Multidrug-therapy for high-risk patients has resulted in 85% reductions in COVID-19 hospitalization and death*.

*McCullough PA, Alexander PE, Armstrong R, et al. Multifaceted highly targeted sequential multidrug treatment of early ambulatory high-risk SARS-CoV-2 infection (COVID-19). Rev Cardiovasc Med (2020) 21:517–530. doi:10.31083/j.rcm.2020.04.264.  Link to paper here.

Treatment resources

There are many websites that are aggregating trial results, protocols and testimony from front line doctors and scientific specialists.  As we find these links we’ll add them to this page.

The Science data – C19 early – COVID-19 early treatment: real-time analysis – HERE

COVID-19 Protocols:

C19 Protocols website contains links to:

• Early Treatment Protocols,
• Prevention Protocols,
• Long-haul COVID-19 Protocols,
• Scientific studies and more

The above site is complied by front line doctors, those who are actually treating patients.

Early COVID Care – HERE,

FLCCC i-CARE early treatment protocols – HERE

WHO: Therapeutics and COVID-19: living guideline – April 2022 – ARCHIVE

Treatment Summaries

• Multi-drug approach – video and paper
• Budesonide
• Hydroxychloroquine
• Ivermectin
• Vitamin C and video and link and resource
• Vitamin D
• CDS , Preparation, Clinical trial here  Published here

Studies demonstrating the efficacy of COVID-19 treatments – Evidence by drug group @ early COVID care – HERE

Protocols Links

In no particular order

Prevention Protocols

Treatment Protocols

America’s Frontline Doctors – videos

Medicine (un)censored by James Todaro MD

Zelenko prophylaxis protocol

COVID-19 How can I cure thee? Let me count the ways  by Dr Thomas Levy

Official treatment guidelines

May 27, 2020 – WHO Intrim Guidance: Clinical management of COVID-19 – READ, ARCHIVES

Other Treatment Options

2023

July 29, 2023 – Courageous Discourse Substack: The Clear Benefits of Nasal Hygiene an interview with Mr. Nathan Jones, CEO of XLEAR nasal spray – WATCH & READ

• “Decades ago, Nate’s father, Dr. Alonzo Jones, began an exhaustive study of the benefits of oral and nasal hygiene for preventing upper respiratory tract infections. Nate found his father’s research so compelling that he formulated a nasal spray based on Dr. Jones’s findings”
• “…multiple lab tests confirmed that a minor component of XLEAR nasal spray—i.e., its grapefruit seed extract preservative—destroys SARS-CoV-2“
• “…the Federal Trade Commission prohibited every company in the nasal hygiene space from making any claims about the benefit of their products in preventing SARS-CoV-2 infection, reducing its severity, or reducing its transmissibility.”…”in spite of numerous peer-reviewed studies in the medical literature showing that viricidal nasal rinses can indeed reduce the duration and severity of the illness” – inorder to get EUA on mRNA jabs!
  • FTC sued XLEAR in court – READ, the fight is ongoing.

July 27, 2023 – Meryl Nass Substack: Treating COVID-19 in 2023 and update ivermecting and hydroxychloroquine – READ, i-CARE protocols – HERE

2022

August 2, 2022 – Journal of Pharmacy & Pharmacology Research: The Problem of Home Therapy during COVID-19 Pandemic in Italy: Government Guidelines versus Freedom of Cure? – Fazio et al – READ, PDF
Working group concluded there was obstruction to home-based therapies for COVID-19. – GETTR

July 20, 2022 – Dr Paul Alexander Substack: Nitric Oxide Nasal Spray (NONS) lowers Covid viral load by 94 per cent in 24 hours: Lancet study; Nitric Oxide blocks entry into nasal passage, kills the virus and stops its replication – READ

April 22, 2022 – WHO: Therapeutics and COVID-19: living guideline – ARCHIVE, Gilead press release – READ

• Early treatment with remdesivir recommended but at no time should hydroxychloroquine be used.

April 14, 2022 – Steve Kirsch Substack: These people deserve the credit for the deaths of nearly a million Americans – Introducing the members of the NIH COVID-19 Treatment Guidelines committee. – “if there are 100 trials and 90% of the trials were positive and 10% were neutral, should the NIH recommend the drug?” – READ

2020

December 30, 2020 – Reviews in Cardiovascular Medicine: Multifaceted highly targeted sequential multidrug treatment of early ambulatory high-risk SARS-CoV-2 infection (COVID-19) by McCullough et al – ARCHIVE, READ

October 11, 2020 – Association of American Physicians and Surgeons: Ambulatory Treatment of COVID-19 – WATCH, PAPER, SLIDES

August 26, 2020 – The Texan: Dallas Cardiologist Offers Guidance on Early Treatment of COVID-19 – To provide guidance to doctors about early treatment of coronavirus, cardiologist Dr. Peter McCullough wrote an article that will soon be published in the American Journal of Medicine – READ, Dr Peter McCullough – MORE

March 17, 2020 – International Society for Orthomolecular Medicine (ISOM) recommends nutrition support for curing and treating new coronavirus infections – WATCH, READ

The post COVID-19 Early Treatment Protocols first appeared on Totality of Evidence.

[Sept 2024 – Note that this page was not started as a timeline, unlike other pages, so many of the pre 2023 data points are not complete but are still being populated. This Sept 9,2024 article HERE , provides an excellent summary of what happened with HCQ, along with comments by Dr Malone HERE]

So why is hydroxychloroquine suddenly “dangerous”?

Some facts to consider about HCQ:

• Chloroquine and HCQ are listed as an essential medicine by the WHO.
• HCQ is relatively less “toxic” than Chloroquine when you look at the potential side effect profile.
• The patents for both Chloroquine and it’s derivative HCQ have expired, which means they can be manufactured generically, which in turn means cheaply.
• Hydroxychloroquine has been on the FDA’s list of approved drugs since 1955
• In 2005 an in vitro study of Chloroquine on SARS virus showed prohibitive viral properties when used early.
  August 22, 2005 – Viroolgy Journal: Chloroquine is a potent inhibitor of SARS coronavirus infection and spread – Vincent et al – READ
• In malaria prone countries, HCQ can be bought over the counter – no doctor’s script necessary.  In CDC fact sheet they recommend purchase before and deems it safe for adults and children, except those prone to psoriasis.
• HCQ acts as an ionophore, meaning it opens up a transport channel for zinc to enter the cell and it is the zinc that stops viral replication.
• A 200mg oral dose of hydroxychloroquine has a half life of 537 hours or 22.4 days in blood, longer in plasma.
• Experts agree that “chloroquine has a small toxic to therapeutic margin“, meaning the right dose is effective, too high and it is toxic, even fatal.
• In Taiwan December 2020 a manufacturing plant that makes the precursor to HCQ was damaged, and in May 2020, possibly 2 other plants that also make or store magnesium stearate were also damaged.  Coincidence?
• Since 1968 very few deaths attributed to hydroxychloroquine

Fact, if an effective early treatment was “found” for COVID-19:

• The pandemic would be over
• States of Emergency would no longer be ‘justifiable’
• Experimental vaccine’s would not be necessary or justifiable
• Emergency Use Authorisation or Provisional Registrations of vaccines would need to be stopped
• Vaccine manufacturers would loose hundreds of billions of dollars in profits.

Other questions to consider:

• Is HCQ a potential, broadspectrum anti-viral, in particular when used in combination with zinc?
• If HCQ is safe for adults, children and pregnant women for weekly treatment for malaria, they why is the same/similar dose suddenly “dangerous” in the middle of a pandemic, as a demonstrated effective early treatment measure?
• Why did health authorities design clinical trials for HCQ in late stage, hospitalised patients only, and at rates in excess of that used by frontline doctors for early treatment?
• If a broad spectrum anti-viral medication was “discovered” what would this do to the profitability of the vaccine industry?
• What would happen to the childhood vaccination program?
• Do you think Big Pharma and it’s “soldiers” would do everything they can to stop such information from coming to light?
• What tools do Big Pharma have to control the narrative?  Media? Lobby groups? Health authorities? Grant funding? Medical journal funding?

These are all questions to ponder as you dive into this controversial topic.  The greater number of people who know this information, the quicker a corrections can be made – assuming they do something about it!

HCQ and COVID-19

As the COVID-19 pandemic took hold in early 2020, some key doctors highlighted the life saving benefits of the HCQ drug for treating the symptoms of COVID-19 as well as potentially reducing the replication of the disease agent SARS-CoV-2.

We’ve capture their story here, along with the science and the mode of action this drug has against this virus.  We’ll also look at the focus of the clinical trials that the “expert medical authorities” conducted using HCQ, and how they determined that the drug failed to be beneficial and was deemed to be potentially dangerous.  There is so much to unravel for this drug and its controversy.

In the mean time if you want an excellent summary read this article from Jun 2020:  How a False Hydroxychloroquine Narrative Was Created

HCQ Timeline

In March 2020, Australia’s Clive Palmer through his foundation donated 32,900,000 doses of HCQ to the people of Australia, because of the positive information coming from independent doctors, virologists and scientists.

For an excellent timeline of event surrounding HCQ the Palmer Foundation website has been keeping track of since April 2020, below we’ll share our own discoveries of which there will be overlaps.  It appears the general public is not aware of much of this information.

This web page will be updated, it is set up to build the story in chronological order.

Scroll to the bottom of this page for the most recent videos

Dr Vladimir Zelenko’s Story

Zelenko “discovers” HCQ combination as an effective treatment for COVID-19

This story is a movie in the making.  Dr Vladimir Zelenko is a family doctor for around 30,000 residents in New York area.  He himself was suffering with cancer, undergoing treatment and surgery during the pandemic.  He claims to have never worn a mask while with his patients (many coming to him with COVID-19 symptoms) and he takes his prophylaxis treatment daily to protect himself against contracting the disease – by late 2020 he as yet hasn’t contracted COVID-19 but has assisted many hundreds of patients through the disease process, with only 2 hospitalisations, and 2 deaths, one with late stage cancer (as of end 2020).

It is highly recommended you listen to his story (below) yourself as he shares how he discovered HCQ + Zinc + Azithromycin combination for the treatment of his patients who came to him presenting with COVID-19 symptoms.  Listen to what he says and compare that to trials the “authorities” designed that  “proved” the drug to be “ineffective”.

Since the media won’t show you this, you’ll have to discover it for yourself.

Dr Zelenko share’s his treatment protocol for COVID-19

This video was first aired 2 July 2020 on The Highwire  which has since been deleted from YouTube.  Below is a part of this episode that features Dr Zelenko.

The Zelenko Protocol

Zelenco Protocol information with publication links and links to more videos

The Zelenko Protocol

Find the Zelenko Protocol here, the whole purpose is to prevent symptoms from escalating and preventing hospitalisation.

Dr Zelenko mentions virologist Professor Didier Raoult from France.  Over time as these two doctors communicated and they refined their treatment, Dr Raoult started to use zinc in combination, and thus decreased his dosage of hydroxychloroquine.

Watch Medcram episode 34 explaining the mechanisms of zinc with an ionophore such as choloroquine, referenced by Dr Z.

www.VladamirZelenkoMD.com

Dr Zelenko’s Letter to President Trump

In March 2020 Dr Zelenko wrote a letter to President Trump to inform him about his success with the hydroxychloroquine combination treatment protocol for the COVID-19 pandemic.  Just as an aside it was claimed by the media that Trump owned shares in Sanofi, one of the companies that makes the generic drug, but that was taken out of context and thus fake news.

Video has been removed:
President Trump On Using Dr. Vladimir Zelenko’s Hydroxychloroquine Protocol
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=92pDKwloEEk

What the media didn’t tell you

An informative interview with Dr Zelenko

Dr Zelenko’s interview with the Corona Investigation Committee July22, 2021 – Session 62

Interesting statement by Dr Zelenko: “I’ve noticed, what ever the FDA decides, the rest of the world follows”.   Why this is interesting is that our TGA does refer to international regulatory bodies to assist in making recommendations and decisions.

He talks about how HCQ went from being available to everyone under Executive Order to being thwarted by FDA/HHS EUA for use in hospital settings only – the one setting it was never going to work in based on existing experience!

“In America, any drug that’s FDA approved can be used off-label for any reason” stated Dr Zelenco (within registered dose rates)

Combination treatment has provided the best results

The combination of HCQ with Zinc, is more effective than either used alone.  Zinc needs an ionophore to help it get into the cells, once in there it works to block the replication of the virus by inhibiting an enzyme called RNA-dependent RNA polymerase also called RNA replicase (see video below).
In addition, HCQ has multiple modes of action (see Dr Shiva video below) but when used in combination with zinc there is a synergistic effect.  Zinc is the bullet, HCQ (an ionophore) is the gun or the delivery tool.

Alternative Ionophores

If HCQ is not available Quercetin and EGCG (green tea extract) are also efficient zinc ionophores as discussed by Dr Zelenko.  All the front line doctors have stated, you need to get in early, the moment symptoms appear.

How Zinc and an ionophore work together

The paper referenced in this video: “Zn(2+) inhibits coronavirus and arterivirus RNA polymerase activity in vitro and zinc ionophores block the replication of these viruses in cell culture”.

Early treatment is key to the success with HCQ

The medical establishment (clinical trials) and media choose ONLY TO FOCUS  on advanced disease (hospitalisation) where HCQ  has demonstrated to offers little if any benefit based on front line experience.  The trials are designed to fail from the outset – timing, dose, used alone, not in combination.  This is not conspiracy, this is fact.

Early treatment is where all the front line doctors are having success in preventing hospitalisation.  But strangely this information is being censored.

The health establishment are doing garbage science.

April 16, 2020 – Unbreaking Science with Dr James Lyons-Weiler: Coronavirus: Mortality Rates, Hidden Information, Witheld Drugs w/ Meryl Nass, MD – withholding hydroxychloroqine early treatment – WATCH

HCQ: How It Works, benefits and side effects

Dr Shiva extracts the information from the scientific literature

Multiple mechanisms of action of hydryoxychloroqine against coronavirus:

1. Inhibits virus entry into the cell by inhibiting the viral particle binding to ACE2 receptor, this leads to reduced viral entry into the cell (Vincent et. al. 2005 CDC)
2. Inhibits viral replication of RNA via inhibition of RdRP in coronavirus.
3. Inhibits viral assembly
4. Inhibits new particle transport out of the cell
5. It acts as an ionophore for zinc, allowing zinc access into the cell, which in turn stops viral replication.

(note: Remdezivir, which is still under patent and costs around USD $3000 per dose, only inhibits viral replication, meaning one mode of action)

Mode of Action and Side Effects of HCQ

Dr Zelenko discusses COVID-19 outpatient management with Dr Been

American Front Line Doctor’s Summit

The summit videos were deleted from YouTube and web host provide deleted their site within 24 hours!

Massive censorship of Frontline Doctors led by Dr Simone Gold, where she and many other front line professionals shared their experience and treatment success stories along with other literature based presentations to help get the word out about all things COVID-19 related.  Their YouTube video’s and website was taken down by the hosting company (Square.com) within 24 hours of the summit – unheard of censorship.

But they have a new site here.  With their COVID-19 treatment’s page here and video page here including their Summit on July 27, 2020 covering many topics including hydroxychloroquine.

Doctor’s experience with HCQ:

Dr Anthony Cardillo explains that in his ER, they’ve found that HCQ really only works in combination with zinc.

Dr Zelenko has published his studies to share with everyone.  This was on the original Frontline Doctors website

Dr Simone Gold – White Paper on HCQ

The heart of the “problem”

Cardiologist at Mayo Clinic in March 2020 claim QT issues with hydroxychloroquine.  Why wait for now to raise this issue, when the drug has been handed out effectively like candy for malaria prevention to adults and children? Why now?

Then comes the VA Study

On 21st April 2020, the paper titled “Outcomes of hydroxychloroquine usage in United States veterans hospitalized with Covid-19” was published.  This is refereed to as the VA Study.

The media then grabbed hold of it’s conclusions and began to shout higher mortality rates with hydroxychloroquine (1, 2) or Fox news claiming HCQ has no benefit.  Though what they don’t tell you is it is an observational study who’s conclusions have not been put into context.

That is HCQ was use on patients who’s immune system was already shot, they were hospitalised in ICU on ventilators, it was not a randomised trial, the study didn’t report the doses of the drugs used, plus 30% of the control group received a treatment that itself could help reduce mortality.  Plus one of the authors Scott Sutton received funding from the Remdezivir manufacture Gilead.  So a case of bad science, conflicts of interest and another attack on a drug that still has potential as an early treatment!

Then on 24th April 2020, the FDA cautioned the use of HCQ due to the risk of heart rhythm problems – but only for COVID-19 suspected patients, not for Lupus or RA or for malaria treatment!

French virologist, Dr Didier Raoult responds to the flawed VA study here.

Del Bigtree unpacks the FDA and the two factions of the HCQ

(that YouTube deleted)

Laura Ingram on US Fox News reports on this VA study

Dr Raoult’s study

Dr Patrice Harris the President of the American Medical Association claimed on CNN in April 2020 that there was no evidence to support the use of hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19.  Understanding at this time, the front line doctors were successfully accumulating thousands of case studies, they’re using rates that are commonly used for malaria, they’re using it at the first sign of symptoms for at risk patients, and they are successfully preventing patients from having to go to hospital.

Fraudulent Peer Reviewed Lancet Study

Published on 22nd May 2020, the Lancet published a damning paper looking at 96,000 patients, and concluding the HCQ group were dying at high rates and with more heart related complications! –

The “…study did not examine the QT interval but instead directly analysed the risk of clinically significant ventricular arrythmias. We showed an independent association of the use of either hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine with the occurrence of de-novo ventricular arrhythmias. We also note that the hazard of de-novo ventricular arrhythmias increased when the drugs were used in combination with a macrolide” [such as azithromyicin].

On 25 May 2020, this lancet study gave justification for the World Health Organisation to temporarily pause it’s SOLIDARTY trials on HCQ.  A fraudulent, supposedly peer reviewed study caused the WHO, in the middle of a pandemic, to stop trials because of the heart problems supposedly caused by hydroxychloroquine.

But then two weeks later on the 4th June, 2020 after doctors and scientist started questioning this peer reviewed scientific paper it was retracted by The Lancet  and the US based company Surgisphere [1] that allegedly collected the data for this study from all over the world, including Australia, was completely fake!

WHO then resumed it’s study of HCQ.

Then on 15th June 2020 the FDA revokes the EUA for the use of HCQ and CQ to treat COVID-19 and referenced the already retracted lanced paper and refers to it as evidence for their decision!  So the FDA reference fraudulent science as evidence to not use a potentially life saving early treatment drug.

A second paper associated with Surgisphere has also been retracted from another peer review journal.

Australia’s TGA used Lancet study as a reason to restrict hydroxychloroquine in Australia

How much damage did these fraudulent study do to the HCQ treatment narrative?

Who else has lost faith in the “authorities”?

Clinical trials appear set-up to fail

Must read overview by Dr Meryl Ness “WHO and UK trials use potentially lethal hydroxychloroquine dose–according to WHO consultant” – HERE

August 13, 2020 – Unbreaking Science: Dr. Meryl Nass on lethal doses used in the HCQ trials – 2400 mg (2.4 mg) of HCQ is a lethal dose. So why did key studies of HCQ use 6 times the normal dose and when 35% increase mortality occur in hospitalized (late-stage) patients did the cease the trial instead of reduce the dose? – WATCH

All HCQ clinical trials designed by “medical experts” focused on late stage COVID-19, contrary to what was experienced in the field.

The key to HCQ’s success is treating the patient early and using the drug in low dose, with zinc.  Yet the international “safety and efficacy” clinical trails were designed to use the drug as a stand alone (without zinc), and in exceedingly high doses plus only in hospitalised patients.  In this setting the virus has finished its replication, and the symptoms have escalated, beyond what the drug could hope to benefit. This is contrary to the way the front line doctors are using the drug, and are achieving a high degree of success.

This is shown when you read the paper from the RECOVERY trial published November 2020 where it states in the discussion “Hydroxychloroquine has been proposed as a treatment for Covid-19 largely on the basis of its in vitro SARS-CoV-2 antiviral activity and on data from observational studies reporting effective reduction in viral loads.”

If these health officials that designed the large scale international clinical trials heard the doctors in the field they would know that the antiviral affects of HCQ have been shown not to be enough when used alone, that it is when used with zinc that the best results are had.

Its almost as though the trials were designed to fail!

The dose rate between therapeutically effective and that of being toxic, is small for chloroquine, and likely too hydroxychloroquine.  In the frail and already sick and weakened hospitalised COVID-19 patients, how would these trial doses of HCQ make them fair?

This graph below shows the relative dose of HCQ between various treatments up to 10 days of use based on the table above.   As you can see the early treatment protocol dosage is within the common Malaria and Arthritis treatment rates, where as two of the trials conducted in sick hospitalised patients were at toxic and possibly lethal doses!

HCQ Key clinical trials list:

• WHO – SOLIDARITY trial protocol
  Published – interim
• Oxford University – the RECOVERY trial
  Published here
• NIH – ORCHID study
  Published here
• Henry Ford Health System HCQ study
  Published here

Compare this to early treatment protocol doses

•  Zelenko Protocol, Out-patient (not hospital) for only moderate to high risk patients – combination treatment zinc, azitromycin + HCC
  (200mg x twice daily for 5-7 days = 400mg in first 24 hrs, cummulative 2000mg – 2800mg in 5 to 7 days respectively, max 400mg/day)

These studies above have been highlighted because these are what the Australian Therapeutic Goods Administration specifically referred to when they claimed the data shows “ no more effective than standard care in treating patients with COVID-19″.  Standard care should start at the GP’s office and not in hospital!  HCQ has performed poorly in clinical trials because it was used too late, in high doses and alone, not as a combination drug treatment.

Further still, based on these late stage clinical trials, the health officials and regulatory agencies deemed all use of HCQ ineffective and potentially dangerous!
If an early treatment was found the pandemic would be over and a vaccine would not be necessary, or at least mandating couldn’t be justified.

Australia’s TGA’s position on HCQ

The TGA claim use restrictions due to supply issues, yet the Palmer Foundation stocked us up in April 2020 with nearly 33 million doses, on top of what we already had in stock.

24 March 2020 – New restrictions on prescribing hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19

26 August 2020 – Amendments to the new restrictions on prescribing hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19

In this amemdment the National COVID-19 Clinical Evidence Taskforce  (NCCET) recommended against the use of hydroxychloroquine for the treatment of COVID-19.

Their media release states: “Taskforce Executive Director, Associate Professor Julian Elliott said the evidence indicates that hydroxychloroquine is potentially harmful and no more effective than standard care in treating patients with COVID-19.”  further “The pooled results show the drug does not reduce mortality, or shorten the amount of time a sick person spends in hospital. It also exposes them to side effects including cardiactoxicity.”

We are more than a year into this pandemic and they have not completed an early combination treatment study with HCQ, zinc and azithromycin or similar broad spectrum antibiotic.  “There are ongoing prevention trials investigating the use of hydroxychloroquine to reduce the risk of contracting COVID-19″ and they’ll get back to us.  Will they be in combination, and why so long?

Update: Dr Fauci’s emails have been sourced under FOI request

Dr Anthony Fauci, head of US NIAID in late May 2021 had about 3,200 of his January to June 2020 emails released under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), and they reveal much about what he knew.

On February 29, 2020 he was copied in on a high priority email to the vice president regarding the potential use of the cheap drug hydroxychloroquine to prophylax high risk patients.  The email even quoted the safe use rate of up to 6.5 mg/kg, a rate which Fauci’s NIH clinical trials exceeded, they used a one-dose-fits-all rate, but more importantly they used it in hospitalised patients when it was too late to be effective, and they knew it.

This is important for Australia, because our TGA referenced Fauci’s NIH ORCHID study as a “supporting” reason for them to make a blanket statement to NOT recommend hydroxychloroquine here in Australia even for it’s demonstrated benefit of early use with zinc.

Read Fauci’s email from February 2020

Articles and websites relating to HCQ

Medical Misinformation, Part 1: Hydroxychloroquine, 30 April 2020

NY Doctor Proved Everyone Wrong About Hydroxychloroquine – article by State of the Nation, a retrospective look at Dr Zelenko’s plea for truth

Tracking: HCQ studies for COVID-19: Real-time meta analysis for 245 studies and counting, and CV19-HCQ

WHO SOLIDARITY and UK RECOVERY trials use potentially lethal hydroxychloroquine dose, article by Meryl Nass, MD

COVID-19 and Coronavirus Resource Center

Countries in RED: DO NOT use or have LIMITED use of HCQ

More from Dr Zelenko and other doctors on HCQ

For the record.

April 2021 Part 1 of 4

Part 2 of 4
Part 3 of 4
Part 4 of 4

Interview with Dr Mercola

July 16, 2021

Dr Zelenko Interviewed by the Corona Investigation Committee

July 22, 2021

https://youtube.com/watch?v=XO4BmDEE8zw%3Fstart%3D18252

Corona Investigation committee interview – Session 62 Watch @4:45:50

Dr Zelenko nominated for the Presidential Medal of Freedom & Nobel Prize

August 2021

August 14, 2021 – Stew Peters: Dr. Zev Zelenko SLAYS Globalists, Exposes “Global Genocidal Event” – WATCH,

September 2, 2021 – Stew Peters: Dr. Zev Zelenko COVID Genocide “Very Nefarious, Sinister Purpose” WATCH

Dr Zelenko exposes how Dr Rick Bright (BARDA) sabotaged early COVID-19 treatment with HCQ, killing masses

September 2021 – Dr Zelenko exposes how Dr Rick Bright’s Very Bad move sabotaged early Covid treatment killing masses – WATCH

Hydroxychloroquine data points in reverse chronological order

Note this timeline is not complete and only started in this format approx 202. It continues to be updated.

2024

September 24, 2024 – PLOS Medicine: Evaluation of hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine for the prevention of COVID-19 (COPCOV): A double-blind, randomised, placebo-controlled trial – Schilling et al – READ, Craig Kelly – CREDIT, University of Oxford ClinicalTrials.gov NCT04303507

• “In this large placebo-controlled, double-blind randomised trial, HCQ and CQ were safe and well tolerated in COVID-19 chemoprevention, and there was evidence of moderate protective benefit in a meta-analysis including this trial and similar RCTs. ….. they [Hydroxychloroquine & Chloroquine] could have been deployed with benefit earlier, and they might have value in future pandemics…

September 9, 2024 – Brownstone Institute: Trump’s 63 Million Doses of Hydroxychloroquine Could Have Been Great for America by David Gortler, Pharm. D – READ

• Dr Robert Malone: What Happened to Trump’s 63 Million Doses of Hydroxychloroquine? – CREDIT

June 4, 2024 – Gateway Pundit: KILLER FAUCI: On March 16, 2020, Dr. Fauci Received Email Cheering Hydroxychloroquine Treatment of COVID in China – 4 Days Later He Publicly Rebuked President Trump at WH Presser For Suggesting It a Valid COVID Treatment – READ

March 31, 2024 – Meryl Nass: “How a false hydroxychloroquine narrative was created, and more”–republishing because we must never forget this evidence of a terrible crime – our-de-force paper on the 50+ ways HCQ was suppressed during 2020 – READ

March 26, 2024 – Broken Truth: Didier Raoult Francesoir Interview – Woodcock and Q Fever Treatment – WATCH, An explosive interview with Dr Didier Raoult reveals a possible motive behind the FDA acting commissioner’s refusal to discuss Coxiella Burnetti. READ

February 20, 2024 – Broken Truth presents documentary: Epidemic of Fraud – the coverup story of hydroxychloroquine – WATCH, READ, Press READ

February 2024 – Biomedicine & Pharmacotherapy: Deaths induced by compassionate use of hydroxychloroquine during the first COVID-19 wave: an estimate by Pradelle et al – READ

• The Latest Attempts to Discredit Hydroxychloroquine as a Treatment for COVID-19 – READ

I challenge the authors of this study to send me 1 out of the supposed 17000 people who died from HCQ…

We are all tired of Egocentric maniacs running our lives and allowing articles like this one with a conclusion that says “ Although our “estimates are limited by their imprecision” Who in their right mind published a conclusion like this? I give this paper a ZERO.

Dr Sabine Hazen

January 16, 2024 – Meryl Nass Substack: Here is the evidence (from 2004-2014) that our governments tried to kill us by restricting HCQ. WHY? Hydroxychloroquine doesn’t kill people unless you overdose. But it does kill coronaviruses.
This is critically important evidence that our governments deliberately harmed us by suppressing this drug. – READ

January 4, 2024 – Politico: Hydroxychloroquine could have caused 17,000 deaths during Covid, study finds – ARCHIVE, CREDIT

• “Nearly 17,000 people may have died after taking hydroxycholoroquine during the first wave of Covid-19, according to a study by French researchers.” – [Another HCQ “study” retracted[
• RETRACTED Biomedicine & Pharmacotherapy: Deaths induced by compassionate use of hydroxychloroquine during the first COVID-19 wave: An estimate by Pradelle et al – READ, ARCHIVE, RETRACTED – READ

2023

December 15, 2023 – Bannons War Room: Episode 3251: Censorship In Peer Review Journals w/ Dr Steven Hatfill – a COVID-19 pandemic advisor to the Trump Administration – WATCH, EXCERPT

• December 2023 – Journal of American Physicians and Surgeions: The COVID Debacle: Merging Criminal Law and Medical Science for Accountability by Steven Hatfill – READ, PDF, EXCERPT
• Robert Kadlac helped acquire 62 million doses of hydroxychloroquine, FDA’s Janet Woodcock thwarted it’s use – EXCERPT
• mRNA vaccines should not have happened because there were safe early treatment options – EXCERPT

November 3, 2023 – Epoch Times: Hydroxychloroquine Associated With Lower COVID-19 Mortality: Study – The French study included 30,202 patients – READ, Vigilant Fox – CREDIT

• People who received hydroxychloroquine were less likely to die than those who did not – 0.8% vs 4.8%

“This study represents the largest single-center study evaluating HCQ-AZ in the treatment of COVID-19. Similarly, to other large observational studies, it concludes that HCQ would have saved lives,”

Dr. Didier Raoult

September 24, 2023 – Gateway Pundit: Mayo Clinic Website Now Says Hydroxychloroquine CAN Be Used to Treat COVID-19 Patients, Previously Claimed It Was Not Effective – READ

• May Sep 2023: “Hydroxychloroquine may be used to treat coronavirus (COVID-19) in certain hospitalized patients.” – ARCHIVE,
  • The webpage was deleted in 2 days – HERE, but has been live since 2014! – ARCHIVES

• Mayo Oct 2021: “Using this medicine alone or with other medicines (eg, azithromycin) may increase your risk of heart rhythm problems (eg, QT prolongation, ventricular fibrillation, ventricular tachycardia). Hydroxychloroquine should only be used for COVID-19 in a hospital or during clinical trials. Do not take any medicine that contains hydroxychloroquine unless prescribed by your doctor“.- ARCHIVE, Also READ

July 27, 2023 – Meryl Nass Substack: Treating COVID-19 in 2023 and update on HCQ & Ivermectin – READ

April 4, 2023 – Pre Print: Early Treatment with Hydroxychloroquine and Azithromycin: A ‘Real-Life’ Monocentric Retrospective Cohort Study of 30,423 COVID-19 Patients – Million & Didier Raoult et al – READ

• “retrospective study from France (30,000+ patients) has found that HCQ + Azithromycin was REDUCING DEATHS by 71% when given early and by 45% when given in hospital – before they banned it” CREDIT SpeedOfScience in comments

March 15, 2023 – United Australia Party (UAP) hosts Australian Covid Vaccines & Effects Tour – Clive Palmer introduction and speaks about his HCQ donation to Australia – WATCH, Palmer’s HCQ donation to Australia – TIMELINE

2022

2021

June 13, 2021 – Hydroxychloroquine: Just the facts and a Follow the Money investigation by Sharyl Attkisson – READ

• “…two new studies that show the inexpensive drug works. A new study in MedRxiv found that hydroxychloroquine and zinc increased Covid-19 survival by almost three times. And a recent study published in the Journal of The Association of Physicians of India also found hydroxychloroquine is an effective treatment for Covid-19.”

June 10, 2021 – The US Sun: Hydroxychloroquine drug touted by Trump as Covid treatment can increase survival rates by 200%, study finds – READ

June 10, 2021 – Fox News | Ingraham Angle: Ingraham: Fauci ‘routinely’ acted against science – “Study: 100K lives could have been saved” with using HCQ – WATCH, FULL

June 9, 2021 – The Washington Times: Follow the money: Big Pharma, Dr. Fauci and the death of hydroxychloroquine – The $2.45 million Gilead spent in the first quarter of 2020 lobbying the federal government was well spent – READ

• “HCQ is cheap (costing under $10 for the course of a COVID-19 treatment), well-understood by physicians having been prescribed for more than 80 years, and can be taken orally. Yet, Dr. Anthony Fauci and others at the National Health Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases preferred remdesivir, a proprietary, intravenous drug manufactured by Gilead Sciences, costing about $3,500 per treatment, with unknown side effects.”

June 1, 2021 – Fox News | The Ingraham Angle – Dr Stephen Smith, Fauci on variants nad Dr Scott Atlas – ARCHIVE, We could have saved 100K lives – EXCERPT

April 13, 2021 – Rounding the Earth w/ Mathew Crawford: How to Rig Research: Surgisphere Part I – READ

A lot of the observations that took Surgisphere down were me emailing other people, or writing in forums, under names other than my own.

Mathew Crawford – REF

February 26, 2021 – The Lancet: Hydroxychloroquine with or without azithromycin for treatment of early SARS-CoV-2 infection among high-risk outpatient adults: A randomized clinical trial – Johnson et al – READ [NO ZINC?, ], Clinical Trial # NCT04354428 – READ, trial HISTORY

• “The COVID-19 Early Treatment Study was funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (INV-017062) through the COVID-19 Therapeutics Accelerator….”
• “placebo” was vitamin C (1000mg/day1, then 500mg/day) and folic acid – so not inert placebo! -clinical trial – ARCHIVE
• HCQ 400 mg orally twice on Day 1 [800mg total], followed by 200 mg orally twice daily [400mg/day] ( for an additional 9 days

February 22, 2021 – The Guardian: Melbourne doctors under review for promoting discredited Covid treatment – Covid Medical Network doctors – READ,

• References peer reviewd paper in Reviews in Cardiovascular Medicine: Multifaceted highly targeted sequential multidrug treatment of early ambulatory high-risk SARS-CoV-2 infection (COVID-19) by McCullough et al – ARCHIVE, READ

2020

December 30, 2020 – Reviews in Cardiovascular Medicine: Multifaceted highly targeted sequential multidrug treatment of early ambulatory high-risk SARS-CoV-2 infection (COVID-19) by McCullough et al – ARCHIVE, READ (and image source)

December 20, 2020 – Taiwan News: Pharmaceutical factory on fire after explosion: 2 injured – makers of HCQ precursor – READ, worlds second largest HCQ supplier – SOURCE

• “Liberty Times reported that the factory produces hydroxychloroquine APIs, and is the world’s second largest HCQ raw material supplier.“

December 2020 – International Journal of Antimicrobial Agents: COVID-19 outpatients: early risk-stratified treatment with zinc plus low-dose hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin: a retrospective case series study – by Derwand, Zelenko et al – READ, TWEET

October 1, 2020 – The Scientist: The Surgisphere Scandal: What Went Wrong? – READ, CREDIT

August 30, 2020 – COVID-19 Real-Time Learning Network (sponsored by CDC grant): Hydroxychloroquine – information for doctors, links to “evidence” – ARCHIVE

• Explore the many references to clinical trials in HOSPITAL settings
• “One RCT suggests increased risk of QT prolongation among patients treated with HCQ+AZ compared to those not receiving HCQ” still hospitalised – July 23, 2020 – READ

July 2, 2020: Science: One U.K. trial is transforming COVID-19 treatment. Why haven’t others delivered more results? – trial design (hospital use in large doses) rules out HCQ by authorities – READ

June 17, 2020 – WHO: World Health Organization announces it was dropping hydroxychloroquine from the Solidarity trial – REF

• “Update (June 18): The World Health Organization announced yesterday that it was dropping hydroxychloroquine from the Solidarity trial after new data suggest the drug is ineffective as a COVID-19 treatment or prophylaxis.” – REF

June 17, 2020 – CNN: US stockpile stuck with 63 million doses of hydroxychloroquine …now that the US Food and Drug Administration has revoked permission for the drug to be distributed to treat coronavirus patients – READ, CREDIT

June 15, 2020 – CNN: FDA revokes authorization of drug Trump touted – ARCHIVE

• “Doctors can continue to legally prescribe the drugs off-label, as they can with any drug that’s approved for other conditions. The FDA’s emergency use authorization for hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine was narrow in scope, applying only to hospitalized Covid-19 patients and only to drugs donated to the Strategic National Stockpile.” !

June 15, 2020 – FDA: FDA cautions against use of hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine for COVID-19 outside of the hospital setting or a clinical trial due to risk of heart rhythm problems – Does not affect FDA-approved uses for malaria, lupus, and rheumatoid arthritis [!!!] – READ, CNN- CREDIT

• FDA July 1, 2020 Update: “A summary of the FDA review of safety issues with the use of hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine to treat hospitalized patients with COVID-19 is now available.” – PDF

June 15, 2020 – FDA LETTER from Denise M. Hinton, Chief Scientists FDA to Gary Disbrow, Deputy Assistant Secretary of BARDA – PDF, ARCHIVE, CNN – CREDIT

• This letter in response to BARDA requesting the FDA “revoke the Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) for emergency use of oral formulations of chloroquine phosphate (CQ) and hydroxychloroquine sulfate (HCQ) to be distributed from the Strategic National Stockpile (SNS) issued on March 28, 2020”
• Letter has “Attachment: Memorandum Explaining Basis for Revocation of Emergency Use Authorization for Emergency Use of Chloroquine Phosphate and Hydroxychloroquine Sulfate”

June 15, 2020 – FDA: Coronavirus (COVID-19) Update: FDA Revokes Emergency Use Authorization for Chloroquine and Hydroxychloroquine [but the product is still licensed!]- READ, ARCHIVE, FDA letter – PDF, Wired – ARTICLE

• “…the FDA determined that chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine are unlikely to be effective in treating COVID-19 for the authorized uses in the EUA.” – off-label use (which is legal) does not require EUA for a licensed product!
• “Additionally, in light of ongoing serious cardiac adverse events and other potential serious side effects, the known and potential benefits of chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine no longer outweigh the known and potential risks for the authorized use. This is the statutory standard for issuance of an EUA.”
• The Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) for HCQ was issued on March 28, 2020
• “Today’s request to revoke is based on new information, including clinical trial data results, that have led BARDA to conclude that this drug may not be effective to treat COVID-19 [Coronavirus Disease 2019] and that the drug’s potential benefits for such use do not outweigh its known and potential risks.”
• CNN: FDA revokes authorization of drug Trump touted – ARCHIVE

June 13, 2020 – The Lancet | Comment: Expression of concern: Hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine with or without a macrolide for treatment of COVID-19: a multinational registry analysis – by The Lancet Editors – READ

• To “alert readers to the fact that serious scientific questions have been brought to our attention. We will update this notice as soon as we have further information.”

June 8, 2020 – Science: Who’s to blame? These three scientists are at the heart of the Surgisphere COVID-19 scandal – Author partnership on coronavirus papers is “completely bizarre” and should have been a red flag, former journal editor says – READ (presents overview of authors) – Regading the RETRACTED Lancet Study

• Mehra “provided the kind of gravitas that can fast-track papers to leading journals.”
• Amit Patel (co-author) had introduced Mehra to Sapan Desai, a vascular surgeon and founder of Surgisphere, the tiny company that supplied the data.
• Mehra received compensation from Triple-Gene [3GTx.com], a gene therapy company Patel co-founded [and Clinical Director] to develop cardiovascular treatments.
  • “Triple-Gene LLC is a clinical stage cardiovascular gene therapy company and majority owned subsidiary of Precigen Inc. (NASDAQ: PGEN).” – REF

June 7, 2020 – STAT News: Researcher involved in retracted Lancet study has faculty appointment terminated, as details in scandal emerge – READ, Amit Patel – TWEET, The only author to be “punished” – CREDIT

• University of Utah has “mutually agreed” to terminate the [unpaid adjunct appointment with the Department of Biomedical Engineering] faculty appointment of Amit Patel,..who appears to have played a key role in involving a little-known company that has ignited a firestorm of controversy.”

June 5, 2020 – Oxford University RECOVERY Trial: PRESS Statement from the Chief Investigators of the Randomised Evaluation of COVid-19 thERapY (RECOVERY) Trial on hydroxychloroquine : No clinical benefit from use of hydroxychloroquine in hospitalised patients with COVID-19 – READ, This statement was used by WHO to help justify shutting down HCQ – CREDIT

• “‘On Thursday 4 June, in response to a request from the UK Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency (MHRA), the independent Data Monitoring Committee conducted a further review of the data. Last night, the Committee recommended the chief investigators review the unblinded data on the hydroxychloroquine arm of the trial.
• ‘We have concluded that there is no beneficial effect of hydroxychloroquine in patients hospitalised with COVID-19. We have therefore decided to stop enrolling participants to the hydroxychloroquine arm of the RECOVERY Trial with immediate effect. We are now releasing the preliminary results as they have important implications for patient care and public health. “
• Trial primary endpoint was 28-day mortality for hospitalised COVID-19 patients. “There was also no evidence of beneficial effects on hospital stay duration or other outcomes.”…‘These data convincingly rule out any meaningful mortality benefit of hydroxychloroquine in patients hospitalised with COVID-19″

‘Hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine have received a lot of attention and have been used very widely to treat COVID patients despite the absence of any good evidence. The RECOVERY Trial has shown that hydroxychloroquine is not an effective treatment in patients hospitalised with COVID-19. Although it is disappointing that this treatment has been shown to be ineffective, it does allow us to focus care and research on more promising drugs.” [remdesivir?]

Peter Horby, Professor of Emerging Infectious Diseases and Global Health in the Nuffield Department of Medicine, University of Oxford, and Chief Investigator for the RECOVERY HCQ trial

June 4, 2020 – MedScape: Two Journals Retract Studies on HCQ, Heart Disease in COVID-19 – READ, TIMELINE

• “The Lancet announced today [June 4, 2020] that it has retracted a highly cited study that suggested hydroxychloroquine may cause more harm than benefit in patients with COVID-19. Hours later, the New England Journal of Medicine announced that it had retracted a second article by some of the same authors, also on heart disease and COVID-19.”

June 4, 2020 – NY Times: Two Huge Covid-19 Studies Are Retracted After Scientists Sound Alarms -The reports, published in two leading journals, were retracted after authors could not verify an enormous database of medical records – READ (Hydroxychloroquine is not mentioned in the title, read down to find it!), Med City News – READ

• “Both studies were led by a professor at Harvard, and both depended on a huge international database of patient medical records that few experts had ever heard of.”
• “On Wednesday, after the journals [NEJM & The Lancet] noted concerns about the studies, the World Health Organization announced that it would resume trials of the medications”!

“It is now clear to me that in my hope to contribute to this research during a time of great need, I did not do enough to ensure that the data source was appropriate for this use…For that, and for all the disruptions — both directly and indirectly — I am truly sorry.”

Dr. Mandeep Mehra, lead author of the two studies, said in a statement to The New York Times.

June 4, 2020 – The Guardian: Surgisphere: governments and WHO changed Covid-19 policy based on suspect data from tiny US company – READ

• “Surgisphere, whose employees appear to include a sci-fi writer and adult content model, provided database behind Lancet and New England Journal of Medicine hydroxychloroquine studies”

June 4, 2020 – Med City News: Randomized trial shows hydroxychloroquine doesn’t prevent Covid-19 as questions arise about earlier study – A randomized, placebo-controlled trial published in NEJM found the malaria drug was not effective as a post-exposure prophylaxis against coronavirus disease. However, questions have arisen about data used in a large observational study about the drug published last month – READ

• Uni Minnesota trial “data showed that 11.8% of participants who received hydroxychloroquine developed Covid-19, compared with 14.3% who received a vitamin pill as a placebo….the result did not reach statistical significance…there is no way to rule out whether the result was due to chance alone.” Thus it was concluded no difference.
• Note COVID-19 was self reported by patient and not PCR confirmed [as far as I can tell] the trial objective was to “to prevent disease” i.e. any symptoms, not hospitalisation or death!
• “The study provides the most definitive evidence yet that hydroxychloroquine is not effective against Covid-19.”

June 3, 2020 – University of Minnesota: University of Minnesota Trial Shows Hydroxychloroquine Has No Benefit Over Placebo in Preventing COVID-19 – READ, ARCHIVE, CREDIT, Trial used by WHO to stop HCQ – REF

• June 3, 2020 – NEJM: A Randomized Trial of Hydroxychloroquine as Postexposure Prophylaxis for Covid-19 – Boulware et al – READ, Clinical Trial NCT04308668 – READ [No PCR confirmatory testing done, huge doses used]
  • “We conducted a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial across the United States and parts of Canada testing hydroxychloroquine as postexposure prophylaxis….We enrolled 821 asymptomatic participants”
  • Treatment dose “hydroxychloroquine (800 mg once, followed by 600 mg in 6 to 8 hours, then 600 mg daily for 4 additional days)” [High dose rate and without zinc, contrary to those finding success]. “The primary outcome was the incidence of either laboratory-confirmed Covid-19 or illness compatible with Covid-19 within 14 days.”
  • “The incidence of new illness compatible with Covid-19 did not differ significantly between participants…” [So they DIDN’T PCR test to confirm that an “illness” was COVID-19???] BUT
• “40% of trial participants taking hydroxychloroquine developed non-serious side effects — predominantly nausea, upset stomach or diarrhea.” [Maybe because to the excessive dosage they prescribed!! Normal dose 200-400mg/day, they gave a huge dose of 1400mg on day 1, and 3 times normal daily dose (200mg) on days 2-5]
• “However, the trial [even with excessive doses] found no serious side effects or cardiac complications from taking hydroxychloroquine”
• The WHO use this Boulware et al study to further justify dropping HCQ from their clinical trials because” the study found “the drug did not prevent people exposed to SARS-CoV-2 from becoming sick” [yet the study looked at COVID-19 (self assessed symptoms) not SARS-CoV-2 (the virus, which would require PCR confirmatory testing)] – The Scientist – REF

May 30, 2020 – The Scientist: Disputed Hydroxychloroquine Study Brings Scrutiny to Surgisphere – READ, CREDIT

• “Scientists have raised questions about the dataset published in The Lancet last week that triggered the suspension of clinical trials around the world—and about Surgisphere Corporation, the company behind the study.”

May 28, 2020 – The Guaridan: Questions raised over hydroxychloroquine study which caused WHO to halt trials for Covid-19 – Exclusive: Australian researchers query origin of data used for Lancet study, but stress there is no evidence drug is a safe or effective treatment – READ

May 28, 2020 – Zenodo: An open letter to Mehra et al and The Lancet (Richard Horton (editor) – Concerns regarding the statistical analysis and data integrity – by James Watson on behalf of 201 signatories – READ, PDF, CREDIT

• “This impact has led many researchers around the world to scrutinize in detail the [Lancet] publication in question. This scrutiny has raised both methodological and data integrity concerns.” – 10 concerns listed

May 27, 2020 – CNN: Fauci: Science shows hydroxychloroquine is not effective as a coronavirus treatment – ARCHIVE

“The scientific data is really quite evident now about the lack of efficacy for it,”…[ there’s likelihood of] “adverse events with regard to cardiovascular.”

Dr Anthony Fauci told CNN’s Jim Sciutto on “Newsroom”

• “Fauci.. is the first Trump administration official to say the drug is not effective in treating the virus based on scientific data.” [in hospitalised patients, not where the drug is being used by frontline doctors!]

May 27, 2020 – CNN: France halts use of hydroxychloroquine on Covid-19 patients – READ

• “French Health Ministry revoked its authorization for the drug to be given to those with coronavirus…suggest a link between the use of hydroxychloroquine and “cardiac toxicity,” particularly when used in combination with the azithromycin…”
• “Some context: The announcement comes after the World Health Organization (WHO) on Monday said it had temporarily halted the study of hydroxychloroquine as a potential Covid-19 treatment in its Solidarity Trial, due to safety concerns” [Based on The Lancet, soon-after RETRACTED fraudulent paper]

Our data has very convincingly shown that across the world in a real-world population that this drug combination, whichever way you slice it or dice it, does not show any evidence of benefit, and in fact is immutably showing a signal of grave harm

Dr. Mandeep Mehra, CNN passed this off as a direct quote – REF, more powerful than that quoted by TIME –HERE (See May 22, 2020)

May 27, 2020 – The Scientist: WHO Halts Hydroxychloroquine Testing Over Safety Concerns – based on The Lancet study – READ,

May 26, 2020 – The Guardian: Australian hydroxychloroquine trial to treat Covid-19 under review after WHO safety concern – READ

• “The AustralaSian Covid-19 trial (Ascot) has been recruiting patients in more than 70 hospitals in every state and territory, and 11 hospitals in New Zealand.”
• “Meanwhile, the Therapeutic Goods Administration granted former federal politician Clive Palmer a contract to import 1m doses of the drug [hydroxychloroquine] to add to the national medical stockpile.”

May 26, 2020 – The Guaridian: WHO halts hydroxychloroquine trial for coronavirus amid safety fears- READ

May 25, 2020 – Medical News: Zero benefit of Hydroxychloroquine or Chloroquine in COVID-19, says extensive study – READ

May 25, 2020 – CNN: WHO temporarily pauses hydroxychloroquine study due to safety concerns – READ

• WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said during a media briefing in Geneva – the decision was made after The Lancet observational study was published where the “authors reported that among patients receiving the drug, when used alone or with a macrolide, they estimated a higher mortality rate”

May 25, 2020 – WHO Director-General’s opening remarks at the media briefing on COVID-19 – 25 May 2020 – READ, ARCHIVE

• “The Executive Group has implemented a temporary pause of the hydroxychloroquine arm within the Solidarity Trial while the data is reviewed by the Data Safety Monitoring Board.”…”I wish to reiterate that these drugs [HCQ & CQ] are accepted as generally safe for use in patients with autoimmune diseases or malaria”

May 22, 2020 – CNN: Sales of drug touted by Trump have been soaring – READ,

• “Amid the growing public attention on the medication, its sales doubled from March 2019 to more than $50 million in March [2020]”
• Following FDA’s “caution”…more than 830,000 prescriptions for the drug were filled for the generic and name-brand version of the drug, Plaquenil, in March – up from roughly 460,000 prescriptions written during the same time last year….The IQVIA data did not yet include April figures and did not capture prescriptions administered to patients in nursing homes through long-term care pharmacies or at hospitals.”
• FDA aware of reports of “serious heart-related adverse events and death in patients with COVID-19” taking HCQ or CQ. [Why are all the arthritis (adults and children up to 400mg/day) and malaria (400mg/week) patients taking the drug on a daily basis, not suffring the same alleged concern?]

May 22, 2020 – Forbes: All The Times Trump Has Promoted Hydroxychloroquine – A TIMELINE- (NOTE this article references The Lancet study, but they’ve not updated their article since then to reflect the The Lancet RETRACTED that fraudulent paper) – READ, ARCHIVE

May 22, 2020 – Time Magazine: Large Study Finds No Benefit — and Potential Harm — in Using Hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19 – ARCHIVE, MD Edge – READ,

• “…scientists in the U.S. and Switzerland report on an analysis of more than 96,000 people hospitalized with confirmed COVID-19 in 671 hospitals on six continents. Nearly 15,000 patients were treated…”
• ““However we sliced and diced the data, the results were identical,” says Dr. Mandeep Mehra, chair of cardiovascular medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital and professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School, who led the study. “There was no evidence of benefit, and a consistent signal of harm — and in particular, harm linked to heart rhythm disturbances.”…“Why would you risk harm when there is so much consistent data showing lack of benefit [with hydroxychloroquine]?”
• “In fact, as the evidence continues to suggest that hydroxychloroquine may not provide much benefit, and instead might increase the risk of harm to the heart, Mehra says doctors may shift from considering hydroxychloroquine to other drugs being studied as COVID-19 treatments, like remdesivir. Studies indicate that remdesivir, an antiviral that has not yet been approved to treat any disease, may help people with COVID-19 to recover faster..”

May 22, 2020 – The Lancet: Hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine with or without a macrolide for treatment of COVID-19: a multinational registry analysis by Prof Mandeep Mehra (Brigham and Women’s Hospital & Harvard), Sapan Desai (founder and chief executive of Surgisphere Corporation, Chicago, IL, USA) et al – ARCHIVE, now RETRACTED – READ, Brigham’s PRESS RELEASE – READ

“However we sliced and diced the data, the results were identical,… “There was no evidence of benefit, and a consistent signal of harm — and in particular, harm linked to heart rhythm disturbances.””

Dr. Mandeep Mehra, chair of cardiovascular medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital and professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School, who led the study

• “The data [a mammoth private database of patient medical records] came from a company called Surgisphere, which claims to have granular patient-level information shared by 1,200 hospitals and health facilities on six continents.” – REF
• “Critics were quick to point out anomalies in both pieces of research, including implausible findings that should have been detected during the peer review process — like the registry’s apparent inclusion of a large number of Covid-19 cases very early on in the pandemic, even in Africa, where few hospitals have electronic health records….Many researchers were astonished to find out that such a database could exist, or that the gathering and analysis of tens of thousands of medical records on multiple continents could have been carried out so quickly.” – REF
• “Dr. Desai vigorously defended the Surgisphere database, saying that he was “all for transparency” but was bound to secrecy by contractual agreements with the hundreds of hospitals that are his clients, and therefore could not show anyone the raw data from his registry..”…”until February, [2020, Desai] worked as a vascular surgeon at Northwest Community Hospital in Arlington Heights, Ill.” – REF
• June 8, 2020 – Science: Who’s to blame? These three scientists are at the heart of the Surgisphere COVID-19 scandal -Author partnership on coronavirus papers is “completely bizarre” and should have been a red flag, former journal editor says – READ

May 19, 2020 – FDA: Pharmacovigilance Memorandum for Hydroxychloroquine and Chloroquine for All adverse events in the setting of COVID-19 from the FDA Adverse Event Reporting System (FAERS) – PDF, an “uncharacteristically brief 15-page safety review memorandum of HCQ” – CREDIT

• Brownstone: “a methodologically questionable report criticizing HCQ’s safety. The FDA’s narrative was based on preliminary and time-compartmentalized findings, and not a reflection of historical safety or based on the appropriate clinical use of HCQ dosing, prescribing, timing, and duration. The FDA then seemed to label its findings as conclusive, figuratively slamming the door shut on the consideration of new findings.” – REF
• “According to its uncharacteristically brief 15-page safety review memorandum of HCQ published on May 19, 2020, the FDA considered data from the National Poison Data System (NPDS) which means it seems to have included the use of non-pharmaceutical-grade and/or self-administered HCQ and/or overdose data in its clinical evaluation. “
• “…Table 6 only contained around 256 applicable adverse event reports [possibly associated with HCQ/CQ] over a five-month period in the entire world when administered for Covid-19″ With doses “anywhere from 2x to 6x the recommended maximum maintenance dose of HCQ for any clinical indication per FDA and manufacturer’s dosing recommendations.” Also “it did not appear to investigate or report patient weights”
• “92 of the 109 serious cardiac cases (84%) reported concomitant use of at least one other medication that prolongs the QT interval.”…”In other words, the FDA included well-known, clinically unsound, long-established, drug-drug interactions, contraindicated uses, and/or prescribing errors in denigrating HCQ’s safety.”
• And so many more oversights by this FDA’s report – REF

May 19, 2020 – CNN: Trump says he is taking hydroxychloroquine though health experts question its effectiveness – ARCHIVE

• Trump consulted his Whitehouse doctor
• “The admission was a dramatic development in Trump’s attempts to promote hydroxychloroquine as a treatment for coronavirus, which began earlier in the outbreak and has been met with resistance from medical professionals”

May 18, 2020 – Med City News: Report: VA still using hydroxychloroquine for Covid-19; mounting data indicate no effect …Meanwhile, two large studies from hospitals in the New York City area indicated that the drug did not improve rates of mortality among hospitalized patient – READ

May 16, 2020 – AP: VA says it won’t stop use of unproven drug on vets for now – READ, CREDIT

May 14, 2020 – The Guardian: Drug imported for Covid-19 trials won’t be given to Australians who need it for other conditions – Clive Palmer bought millions of doses of hydroxychloroquine – READ, Palmer Foundation – READ

• 33 million doses of hydroxichloroquine imported by Palmer and made freely available to Australias national stockpile – TIMELINE
• Clive Palmer’s donation – WATCH, he tells his story 2024 – WATCH

May 11, 2020 – Politico: Hydroxychloroquine shows no benefit against coronavirus in N.Y. study – READ, CNN – ARCHIVE, The JAMA STUDY

• “University at Albany looked at 1,438 patients with coronavirus who were admitted to 25 New York City area hospitals.” [Not pre-hospitalisation!]
• HCQ+azithromycin “…the patients who took the drug combination were more than twice as likely to suffer cardiac arrest during the course of the study. Heart issues are a known side effect of hydroxychloroquine.”

May 11, 2020 – JAMA: Association of Treatment With Hydroxychloroquine or Azithromycin With In-Hospital Mortality in Patients With COVID-19 in New York State by Rosenberg et al – PAPER, READ

May 7, 2020 – NEJM: Observational Study of Hydroxychloroquine in Hospitalized Patients with Covid-19 – Geleris et al – READ, Large study finds no benefit from hydroxychloroquine in Covid-19- CREDIT

• Study in New York-Presbyterian Hospital—Columbia University Irving Medical Center, – Of 1446 consecutive patients, 70 patients were intubated, died, or discharged within 24 hours after presentation and were excluded from the analysis.
• Hydroxychloroquine dose – 600mg twice on day 1 (total 1200mg), then 400 mg daily for a median of 5 days. Started 24-48 hrs upon admittance to hospital. “Hydroxychloroquine-treated patients were more severely ill at baseline than those who did not receive hydroxychloroquine”

May 6, 2020 – Med City News: The eye-popping allegations in ousted BARDA Director Rick Bright’s whistleblower complaint – READ

• “In the complaint, Bright alleges that he faced retaliation after resisting efforts to promote broad use of hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine on the basis of their safety problems and lack of scientific support for such use…”
• April 23, 2020 – Ex-BARDA director says he was ousted for questioning hydroxychloroquine for Covid-19 – READ

May 5, 2020 – Washington Post: Ousted vaccine official alleges he was demoted for prioritizing ‘science and safety’ – Rick Bright says in a whistleblower complaint that he resisted pressure from HHS leaders to make ‘potentially harmful’ antimalarial drugs more widely available – READ, COMPLAINT

• Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority (BARDA) Director Rick Bright alleged he was demoted due to his resistance to Trump’s promotion of the unproven drug

May 1, 2020 – FDA issued EUA for the patented, more expensive competitor drug remdesivir – REF

April 30, 2020 – The Highwire Ep 161: CORONAVIRUS: A NATION DIVIDED – segment on Chloroquine vs. Remdesivir – WATCH, FULL

April 28, 2020 – James Todaro MD on Twitter: The Italian Society of Rheumatology studied 65,000 patients on longterm hydroxychloroquine for RA and Lupus. – Only 20 patients tested positive for COVID-19, No ICU, no deaths – This is a 90% reduction in infection rate compared to the rest of Italy – No Archive, READ, Gateway Pundit – READ The Highwire – WATCH

April 28, 2020 The Italian – ARTICLE

• “primary care doctors and general practitioners contacted during this research, many have admitted – under their breath – to use the drug [hydroxychloroquine] as a “prophylaxis”, …Health professionals who are in close contact with contagious patients take the drug in advance, precisely to decrease the probability of contracting the infection.”
• Italian Society of Rheumatology (SIR) questioned 1,200 rheumatologists throughout Italy to collect statistics on infections. Out of 65,000 chronic rheumatoid patients (Lupus and Rheumatoid Arthritis), who systematically take Plaquenil / hydroxychloroquine, only 20 patients tested positive for the virus. Nobody died, nobody is in intensive care, according to the data collected so far.

April 28, 2020 – Fox News: Ingraham Angle: Infectious disease expert slams study that panned hydroxychloroquine as COVID-19 treatment: ‘It’s a sham‘ – WATCH

• Dr. Stephen Smith – the study published last week indicating the antimalarial drug hydroxychloroquine showed no benefit [and potentially harmful] for coronavirus patients in U.S. veterans hospitals was a “sham.” [the VA STUDY]
• A New study by French doctor Didier Raoult show correct way to use HCQ

April 24, 2020 – PRESS RELEASE: FDA cautions against use of hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine for COVID-19 outside of the hospital setting or a clinical trail due to risk of heart rhythm problems – Does not affect FDA-approved used for malaria, lupus and rheumatoid arthritis – READ, ARCHIVE, The Highwire – WATCH

April 22, 2020 – Fox News: COVID-19 treatment hydroxychloroquine showed no benefit, more deaths in VA virus study – READ (see paper below)

April 21, 2020 – University of Melbourne: Clinical trial into two potential COVID-19 treatments commences – AustralaSian COVID-19 Trial (ASCOT) – READ, CREDIT

• “Laboratory tests have shown that lopinavir/ritonavir, which is currently used to treat HIV, and hydroxychloroquine, used to treat arthritis and prevent and treat malaria, can stop SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, in its tracks.”
• “A clinical trial aimed at testing the effectiveness and safety of two existing drugs in patients hospitalised with COVID-19 has opened at the first site, the Royal Melbourne Hospital.
• “The aim of ASCOT is to test whether using these drugs will prevent patients deteriorating to the point of needing a ventilator in the intensive care unit (ICU),” said Associate Professor Steven Tong

April 21, 2020 – PrePrint : Outcomes of hydroxychloroquine usage in United States veterans hospitalized with Covid-19 by Magagnoli et al – READ, PDF , The Highwire – WATCH

• This was NOT a randomised study, and had other flaws such administering the drug to only the severely ill and those ventilated – too late to be effective, yet they concluded it increased mortality!
• The dosages for either drug are NOT even listed!
• 31% of the “control” group received azithromycin!
• Dr Stephen Smith calls this study “a sham”!
• Pharma-backed mainstream media picked up on this studies “conclusions” and used it to disqualify HCQ as a treatment, and the unsuspecting public, and healthcare community simply believe them

April 17, 2020 – Int J of Antimicrobial Agents: Can post-exposure prophylaxis for COVID-19 be considered as one of outbreak response strategies in long-term care hospitals? by Lee et al – READ
Post-exposure prophylaxis using hydroxychloroquine was provided to 211 persons, Disease development was successfully prevented without severe adverse events.

April 2, 2020 – Fox News | Ingraham Angle: Dr. Stephen Smith on effectiveness of hydroxychloroquine: ‘I think this is the beginning of the end of the pandemic’ – WATCH

March 31, 2020 – Washington Post: FDA authorizes widespread use of unproven drugs to treat coronavirus, saying possible benefit outweighs risk – READ

March 30, 2020: KHN: FDA Approves Emergency Use Of Malaria Drug Trump Touted Despite Scant Evidence That It Works – READ, and this on March 27 – HERE

March 29, 2020 – HHS: HHS accepts donations of medicine to Strategic National Stockpile as possible treatments for COVID-19 patients – 30 million doses of hydroxychloroquine sulfate donated by Sandoz and and one million doses donated by Bayer Pharmaceuticals – ARCHIVE

March 28, 2020 – The Register: Remember that clinical trial, promoted by President Trump, of a possible COVID-19 cure? So, so, so many questions… – Scientists pull coronavirus treatment study apart after rushed publication – ARCHIVE

March 28, 2020 – LA Times: Doctors and experts warn of the risks of using malaria drugs to treat COVID-19 – heart rhythm QT interval – READ, what is QT interval – READ

• “An article published this week in the Mayo Clinic Proceedings warns that both drugs could prompt dangerous and potentially deadly heart arrhythmias in the 3 million people worldwide who have a congenital cardiac condition — called long QT syndrome — that can cause the heart to beat erratically and lead to sudden death.” – Mayo Clinic preprint – PDF, Long QT syndrome – READ
• [Yet it’s ok to take for malaria!]

March 27, 2020 – Gateway Pundit: HUGE! Second French Study by Dr. Raoult finds Hydroxychloroquine and Azithromycin Helped EVERY PATIENT in Study Group of 80 Minus One – READ

March 27, 2020 – Fox News | The Ingraham Angle: Dr. Stephen Smith on effectiveness of hydroxychloroquine: ‘I think this is the beginning of the end of the pandemic’ – with Dr. Stephen Smith & Dr. Amesh Adalja – TRANSCRIPT

March 26, 2020: Newsday: Cuomo limits prescriptions for two drugs to active virus cases – READ, Dr Oz lift ban – READ

• An executive order issued by Gov. Andrew Cuomo limits prescriptions of hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine to only COVID-19 patients in state-approved clinical trials…

March 25, 2020 – Tech Startups: Doctor Vladimir Zelenko: I treated 350 coronavirus patients with 100% success using Hydroxychloroquine Sulfate – READ, Mar. 28, 2020 that number rose to 699 – READ

March 24, 2020 – FDA Drug Safety Communication on Hydroxychloroquine begins – READ

• FDA cautions against use of hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine for COVID-19 outside of the hospital setting or a clinical trial due to risk of heart rhythm problems – PDF

March 24, 2020 – NBC News: Man dies after taking chloroquine in an attempt to prevent coronavirus – A husband and wife in Arizona took chloroquine phosphate, an ingredient of fish parasite killers rather than the anti-malaria medication, following the President’s recommendation. The man died soon after ingesting the toxic chemical. His spouse was left in a critical condition. – READ

March 24, 2020 – Time Magazine: President Trump Called Hydroxychloroquine a ‘Game Changer,’ But Experts Warn Against Self-Medicating With the Drug. Here’s What You Need to Know – ORIGINAL, READ, Article archives – HERE

• “For the past few weeks President Trump has continually expressed great confidence in the promise of a new COVID-19 therapy involving two drugs—azithromycin and hydroxychloroquine”…
• “But in those few days, a few people [2, husband and wife who took fish tank cleaner – not hydroxychloroquine] who began self medicating with the drugs in an effort to prevent COVID-19 [misleading] have died, and others have been hospitalized. These tragedies have raised questions about the safety of the drug combo [from fish tank cleaner!!!], and how valid they are as a possible solution to treating COVID-19.”

“What do you have to lose? Take it,” … “I really think they should take it. But it’s their choice. And it’s their doctor’s choice or the doctors in the hospital. But hydroxychloroquine. Try it, if you’d like.”

President Trump – White House briefing April 4, 2020 (Time article updated, but not acknowledged in date)

March 23, 2020 – Time Magazine: Arizona Man Dies After Taking Chemical in Coronavirus Treatment Touted by President Trump – ARCHIVE

• “A Phoenix-area man has died and his wife was in critical condition after the couple took chloroquine phosphate, an additive used to clean fish tanks…It’s unclear if the couple took it specifically because of COVID-19″,
• Now Banner Poison and Drug Information Center “is warning everyone to avoid self-medicating”

March 21, 2020 – President Trump on Twitter re HYDROXYCHLOROQUINE & AZITHROMYCIN – TWEET, ARCHIVE

March 20, 2020 – AP FACT CHECK: Trump falsely claims drug approval for virus – READ

• “Technically, doctors can already prescribe the drug to patients with COVID-19, a practice known as off-label prescribing.”
• “Drug trials typically require hundreds or thousands of patients and, even when accelerated, take weeks or months to complete”
  • [This is deceptive, as HCQ has already gone through those safety trials before registration, and has an established 60 year risk profile for the doses used by the frontline doctors, so such huge trials “safety” trials are not required and is misleading to state this]
• “no FDA-approved therapeutics or drugs to treat, cure or prevent COVID-19”
• [Note during the pandemic the media the word “approved” instead of the correct phrase “Emeregency Use Authroised” – yet they attack Trump for saying apporved for and EUA “indication” approval – The drug is already registered – but BARDA got in and killed that EUA – WATCH]

March 20, 2020 – NBC News: Trump, promoting unproven drug treatments, insults NBC reporter at coronavirus briefing – READ

March 20, 2020 – ABC News: Chloroquine, an old malaria drug, may help treat novel coronavirus, doctors say – READ

• FDA approves compassionate use of chloroquine – President Donald Trump held a teleconference with state governors on Thursday at FEMA headquarters and discussed possible treatments for coronavirus.
• “The way that it worked against SARS was by preventing of the attachment of the virus to the cells. Chloroquine interfered with the attachment to that receptor on the cell membrane surface,” Horovitz said. “So it’s disrupting a lock and key kind of mechanism of attachment.”

March 20, 2020 – International Journal of Antimicrobial Agents: Hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin as a treatment of COVID-19: results of an open-label non-randomized clinical trial by Gautret and Didier Raoult et al – READ, Preprint – READ

• “However, [this] study was too small to be of significance, and there was no control group of patients to compare the outcome of the drugs.” – REF [reminder the FDA/ACIP considered 8 mice enough to justify injecting an experimental “vaccine”]

March 19, 2020 – President Trump mentions chloroquine/hydroxychloroquine as a potential treatment for COVID-19 based on feedback he had received from doctors using it on the frontline – WATCH,
Tony Fauci said “no” to being effective for COVID-19! – READ

March 18, 2020 – Cell Discovery: Hydroxychloroquine, a less toxic derivative of chloroquine, is effective in inhibiting SARS-CoV-2 infection in vitro – Liu et al – READ

March 11, 2020 – MedCram: Coronavirus Epidemic Update 34: US Cases Surge, Chloroquine & Zinc Treatment Combo, Italy Lockdown – WATCH, Korea using HCQ – EXCERPT

March 10, 2020 – J Critical Care: A systematic review on the efficacy and safety of chloroquine for the treatment of COVID-19 – Cortegiani et al – READ

• “There are more than 20 ongoing clinical trials in China and more scheduled to start in England, Thailand, South Korea and the United States” – REF

February 18, 2020 – Clinical Trials Arena: Coronavirus: Chloroquine yields positive data in covid-19 trial – Early data from clinical trials being performed in China has revealed that chloroquine phosphate could help treat the new coronavirus disease, Covid-19 – READ, WATCH

• Chloroquine was selected after screening thousands of existing drugs

February 11, 2020 (received as preprint) – International Journal of Antimicrobial Agents: Chloroquine for the 2019 novel coronavirus SARS-CoV-2 – Colson, Didier Raoult et al – READ, READ

2017

2019 – CDC: Medicines for the Prevention of Malaria While Traveling – Hydroxychloroquine (Plaquenil) – Brochure – PDF

• CDC promotes use of Hydroxychloroquine as safe and “a relatively well tolerated medicine.”
• The CDC in referencing the long-term use of HCQ for chronic disease treatments states “HCQ can be prescribed to adults and children of all ages. It can also be safely taken by pregnant women and nursing mothers.”

2014

October 1, 2014 – PLOS: Chloroquine is a zinc ionophore – Xue et al – READ, WATCH

2003

November 2003 – The Lancet | Infectious Disease: Effects of chloroquine on viral infections: an old drug against today’s diseases – Savarino et al – READ, CREDIT

• Chloroquine is a 9-aminoquinoline known since 1934…”Chloroquine/hydroxychloroquie can impair the replication of several viruses by interacting with the endosome-mediated viral entry or the late stages of replication of enveloped viruses”
• “Chloroquine has been shown to inhibit different viruses requiring a pH-dependent step for entry”
  • 2021- “Influenza hemagglutinin (HA) is a viral membrane bound protein that plays a critical role in the viral life cycle by mediating entry into target cells” – PAPER
  • May 2023 – pH-dependent endocytosis mechanisms for influenza A and SARS-coronavirus – PAPER
• “ Of particular interest for human pathology is the report that chloroquine inhibits uncoating of the hepatitis A virus, thus blocking its entire replication cycle”

October 30, 2003 – Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy : Effect of zinc salts on respiratory syncytial virus replication by Suara et al – READ, The Highwire – CREDIT

1994

1994 – BOOK: Vaccines and world health : science, policy, and practice by Faul F. Basch (1994) – (Borrow online) – READ, Credit Dr Judy Wilyman – Vaccination – HERE

• “The Effect of Infection-Controlling Drugs on the Immune Response to Vaccines” – Chloroquine can inhibit the antibody production to vaccine antigens! – READ

The post Hydroxychloroquine first appeared on Totality of Evidence.